Extracts from King's Speech debates in the Commons and Lords: Israel - Nov 7
Extracts from Commons debate on the King's Speech The Prime
Minister (Rishi Sunak):...Before we get into the traditional
debate, let me first address the situation in Israel and
Gaza. All of us in the House care deeply about the suffering of
innocent people and the scenes we have witnessed. We abhor the way
in which Hamas have used innocent Palestinians as human shields. It
is right that the United Kingdom is doubling our aid funding for
Palestinian civilians. We...Request free
trial
Extracts from Commons debate on the King's Speech
The Prime Minister (Rishi Sunak):...Before we get into the
traditional debate, let me first address the situation
in Israel and Gaza. All of
us in the House care deeply about the suffering of innocent
people and the scenes we have witnessed. We abhor the way in
which Hamas have used innocent Palestinians as human shields. It
is right that the United Kingdom is doubling our aid funding for
Palestinian civilians. We have been consistent throughout in our
calls for a humanitarian pause as soon as possible to get aid in
and hostages and foreign nationals out, but a unilateral and
unconditional ceasefire would simply allow Hamas to entrench
their position and continue their attacks against Israel Only last week,
Hamas reiterated their intentions, stating clearly:
Stephen Flynn (Aberdeen South) (SNP):...We
say that because these are our values. It is what we believe in.
We believe in peace, we believe in protecting civilians and we
believe in democracy. Of course, that view extends beyond just
Ukraine; it extends to the situation in Israel and Gaza, too. I
know I am at risk of repeating myself here—as indeed many of us
do in this Chamber from time to time—but it is important to
reiterate that all of us in this Chamber are united in our
unequivocal condemnation of what Hamas did exactly a month ago.
There can never be a justification for the senseless killing of
men, women and children in the way that that terrorist
organisation did. What we have seen off the back of that on our
streets is equally—not perhaps equally—concerning. We all have
grave concerns about the rise of antisemitism and the fear so
many people have walking the streets of these isles. I want to
send my heartfelt support to all those in the Jewish community
and to make it very clear—if, indeed, it ever needed to be
clear—that we all oppose antisemitism, no ifs and no buts.
Sir Peter Bottomley (Worthing West)
(Con):...Overhanging our debate is the misery and terror both
from the attack on Israel and the
Israelis, and from the conditions of people in Gaza. We need to
keep in mind that until Hamas releases hostages, until it can
honestly say that it will not repeat that kind of attack, and
until it recognises the state of Israel it will
be a continuing problem. We cannot close our eyes and say that an
instant, lasting ceasefire will solve all the problems. Ed Davey (Kingston and Surbiton) (LD):...Today’s Gracious Speech is overshadowed by horrifying events around the world, with the monstrous terrorist attacks by Hamas on Israel one month ago—more than 1,400 Israelis were slaughtered and hundreds were taken hostage, and they are in our thoughts today—and now the dire humanitarian situation in Gaza. Innocent Palestinians have been cut off from food, water and medicine. Their homes have been destroyed, and more than 10,000 have been killed...
Sammy Wilson (East Antrim) (DUP):...I want
to note three things about the Gracious Speech. First, there are
the things that I am glad about. I am glad that the Government
have once again restated their commitment to stand by those who
are under attack from tyrants and from terrorism, with their
commitment to Ukraine and their commitment to Israel both of which
are under huge pressure at present. Indeed, across the world
there appears to have been a tiring in support for the war in
Ukraine and for the Ukrainian Government as well as, almost
immediately, condemnation of the nation of Israel for standing up
and doing its duty by its citizens who were brutally murdered by
terrorists. Many people—some of them may be well-meaning, and
some may be simply reacting to the cruelty of war—are calling for
an immediate ceasefire. While the Government of Israel have their
citizens held captive and while Israel’s very existence is under
threat because of a huge terrorist army on its doorstep,
regardless of how strong the siren calls are from the UN, nations
across the world and all the non-governmental organisations, it
would be foolish to go for a ceasefire. Julie Elliott (Sunderland Central) (Lab):...Although I welcome some measures in the King’s Speech, I am extremely concerned about the fact that the Government have brought back the Economic Activities of Public Bodies (Overseas Matters) Bill, which is designed to put undue controls on public bodies and limit their ability to express their beliefs. This is a time when language and actions matter—we have heard a lot about the horror that is unfolding in the middle east; about the horror inflicted on Israeli citizens by Hamas; and about the tens of thousands of innocent Palestinians who have died in the horror unfolding in Gaza—and there has never been a more sensitive time in the middle east, so to introduce the Bill at this moment shows a lack of sensitivity by the Government. It is adding fuel to the fire, and it is not sensible to introduce it at this time... Theresa Villiers (Chipping Barnet) (Con):...The carry-over of the anti-boycott Bill is welcome. Singling out Israel for boycotts by councils is divisive and unjustified. The boycott, divestment and sanctions movement has driven increases in antisemitism, so I welcome the continuation of that Bill...
Ian Blackford (Ross, Skye and Lochaber)
(SNP)...Of course, much of the attention over the past few weeks
has rightly been on the appalling events that unfolded
in Israel on 7 October. It
is right that each and every one of us in this House should call
out that act of terrorism, that attack on the people
of Israel that took place,
and that slaughter of men, women and children. Yes, we call out
Hamas as the terrorist organisation it is, and yes, Hamas must be
destroyed—it must be defeated—but we also need to recognise that,
sadly, what we have seen over the past few weeks is the inhumane
slaughter not just of the Israelis, but of those who live in Gaza
and are casualties of a war that is not of their making. We must
remember the responsibility that we have, yes, to
support Israel but also, yes,
to support those who desire peace on the Palestinian side.
Stephen Doughty (Cardiff South and Penarth)
(Lab/Co-op):...I normally talk from the Opposition Front Bench on
international issues, but I want to reflect as a constituency MP
on some of the challenges facing the world at the moment. That is
important in a constituency such as mine, because of its nature
as a port and having had people come from all over the world for
over 150 years. What happens elsewhere in the
world—in Israel and Palestine,
Afghanistan, Sudan, Libya, the Sahel, south Asia, Yemen, Nigeria,
Syria and many, many other regions and countries—matters deeply
to my constituents. In the past weeks I have heard from
constituents about their anguish at the deaths, loss of civilian
life and destruction in Gaza, and their horror at the terrorism,
hostage taking and killing that Israel and its
citizens have had to endure. I have heard about the need to
ensure we protect civilians, aid workers, hospitals and schools;
to secure humanitarian pauses and get humanitarian aid in,
particularly into Gaza; and to move back to a pathway to peace
and a two-state solution, and to an adherence to international
law and international humanitarian law. I have also, with other
hon. Members and neighbours in Cardiff and the Vale of Glamorgan,
heard face to face from those who have families who are directly
affected in both Gaza and Israel—a genuine fear about what
divisions can mean for us in our communities.
Rachael Maskell (York Central)
(Lab/Co-op):...It is a real pleasure to follow the hon. Member
for North Dorset (Simon Hoare). In responding to the King’s
Speech I must open where His Majesty ended, reflecting on the
horrendous situation in Israel and Gaza. My
constituents have overwhelmingly expressed their call for an
immediate ceasefire across Israel and Gaza,
putting the humanitarian cause at the forefront of our response.
Our hearts are breaking for the hostages, the casualties and
their families caught up in this war. While I utterly condemn the
horrific violence perpetrated by Hamas, I cannot be silent about
the barbarity of the bombing in Gaza. As Israeli citizens are
suffering, the civilians of Gaza are suffering too. They have
neither perpetrated any violence nor have any means of defence.
Last night Antonio Guterres, the UN Secretary General, described
this as “a crisis of humanity” and said that Gaza was fast
becoming “a graveyard for children”. Over 4,100 innocent children
are dead. Every life is a precious gift and we carry a heavy
responsibility to do everything in our power to stop the
killing.
Gareth Thomas (Harrow West)
(Lab/Co-op):...The second issue I wish to focus on is the events
in the middle east. Like so many of my constituents over the past
month, and so many others in this House, I have watched the
unfolding crisis with increasing horror. I utterly condemn
Hamas’s appalling and ongoing terror attacks on Israel There can never
be any justification for the shocking attacks a month ago or the
continued holding of hostages. When an innocent is killed, it is
equally tragic, whether they are Palestinian or Israeli. We must
uphold the basic fundamental human rights of innocent
Palestinians too, caught in the crossfire between Hamas
and Israel International
law must be upheld. Vicky Ford (Chelmsford) (Con):...I do not think that I have seen global security in such a precarious state as it is today for many decades. Today marks one month since 7 October, when Hamas rewrote the definition of evil. Since that day, when so many Israelis lost their lives, we have seen the desperate loss of Palestinian civilian lives as well, and the dire humanitarian situation. The Prime Minister was right in everything he said today about the need of Israel to defend its citizens, the need for a pause in fighting—that is not in our hands to deliver, but in the hands of those who are fighting—the need for aid to flow, and the need to minimise civilian casualties...
Patrick Grady (Glasgow North)
(SNP):...Like other Members, the issue I have most heard about
from my Glasgow North constituents in recent weeks is the ongoing
conflict between Israel and Hamas, and
the need for an immediate ceasefire. I have received more than
700 such emails at the last count; many—if not most—are from
constituents reaching out for the first time, appalled, horrified
and sometimes even traumatised by what they are seeing on the
news, especially those who have friends and family in the region.
Thousands of completely innocent children have been killed—by
some counts, one child for every 10 minutes of the conflict so
far—and acts of what can only be described as collective
punishment are being inflicted on people in Gaza by the
Government of Israel Likewise, there
is no justification for the atrocities perpetrated by Hamas. Nor
is there any excuse for antisemitism in any form. At the end of
the day, a lasting settlement can only come about through
negotiation and a willingness to come to agreement.
Apsana Begum (Poplar and Limehouse) (Lab):
I am grateful for the opportunity to speak in this debate on the
Humble Address. People in my constituency are alarmed and
appalled at the disregard for Palestinian life that has been
demonstrated widely in the recent period. It is therefore very
concerning that the King’s Speech did not include a commitment to
securing a ceasefire on both sides in Gaza and the release of all
hostages, along with a condemnation of war crimes and crimes
against humanity. Catherine West (Hornsey and Wood Green) (Lab):...The theme of security came up in the King’s Speech, and I was pleased that the King mentioned the sensitive time that we are going through, as he has a record of interfaith work. One of the most helpful things I did during Prorogation was attend two synagogues in my constituency, where I took part in prayers for Israel I also attended the London Islamic Cultural Society mosque in my constituency, as well as the interfaith group that meets every couple of months in the constituency, usually to discuss interfaith work, but in the context of the unfolding tragedy in Israel and Gaza, to talk about how we as a community can respond to the horror of the attacks that Hamas perpetrated in the south of Israel on 7 October, a month ago today, and the feelings of despair and sadness experienced by families whose loved ones are still in tunnels somewhere in Gaza, as well as the terrible television coverage and newspaper reports of the situation in Gaza. I think the Financial Times reported a week ago that people in Gaza were running out of shrouds in which to wrap the fatalities, and were having to build mass graves, which is a terrible moment for any humanitarian organisation...
Anna McMorrin (Cardiff North) (Lab):...In
the conflict in Ukraine, we stand wholeheartedly with Ukraine
against Putin’s illegal invasion. Also, just one month ago,
Hamas’s horrific, brutal terror attacks on innocent Israelis and
Jews shocked me and all of us to our core. Like many, I am
horrified by the ongoing humanitarian catastrophe, violence and
devastation that is impacting many thousands of innocent
people—including women and children—in Gaza. Our priority must be
to protect innocent civilians, to ensure that food, water and
support reaches them, and to ensure that international law is
upheld. For context, OPEN HERE Extracts from Lords debate on the King's Speech Baroness Smith of Basildon (Lab): ...For many of our citizens, these are challenging and worrying times. Our previous debates were held against the backdrop of Putin’s invasion of Ukraine. While that terrible war continues and we remain steadfast in our commitment to and support for Ukraine, it has been forced off the headlines by the shocking events in the Middle East. Today is just a month since Hamas’s brutal attack on Israel with 1,400 people murdered and over 200 taken hostages. Their families still do not know their fate. The violence and suffering that has been unleashed is devastating. As the death toll in Gaza continues to rise, it is clear that humanitarian support is now essential to ensure that aid gets to those who desperately need it, and the hostages must be released... Lord Newby (LD):...The fourth is international affairs. International crises are often the great unpredictable disruptors that preoccupy our politics, and in this Parliament Ukraine and now Gaza have done so. We have supported the Government in their response to Ukraine, and on Gaza we agree that Israel has the clear right to defend itself against attack, but we are concerned about the impact of its response on the innocent citizens of Gaza. We call for a humanitarian ceasefire and the release of all the hostages and call on the Government to intensify their diplomatic efforts to bring these about... Lord True (Con):...We think also of the victims of the truly barbaric atrocities perpetrated by Hamas against Israel a month ago today in which at least 14 British nationals were killed, and for which there can be no justification whatever. The Government continue to support Israel’s right to defend itself in line with international humanitarian law. We must also support the Palestinian people and are doing so; they are victims of Hamas too. As the Prime Minister has said, there is no scenario where Hamas can be allowed to control Gaza again. We are working to support British nationals in Gaza and the wider region and to secure the safe return of hostages. We continue to work with international partners to prevent a destabilising regional escalation.... For context, OPEN HERE |