Violence in the West Bank
12:33:00
(Cynon Valley) (Lab)
(Urgent Question): To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign,
Commonwealth and Development Affairs if he will make a statement
on the violence in the west bank.
The Minister of State, Foreign, Commonwealth and Development
Office ()
The accelerating cycle of violence in the west bank risks another
round of bloodshed and the Government are doing everything
possible to urge the de-escalation of the situation. The latest
operation by the Israel Defence Forces in the Jenin refugee camp
in the northern west bank on Monday is the latest episode in a
conflict that has become more worrying as the year has
progressed. While the UK firmly supports Israel’s right to defend
itself and its citizens against terrorism, we urge the Israel
Defence Forces to demonstrate restraint, adhere to the principles
of international humanitarian law and prioritise the protection
of civilians.
While the security situation today remains fragile, the UK
welcomed Israeli and Palestinian engagement at meetings in Aqaba
on 26 February and Sharm El Sheik on 19 March. We are clear-eyed
that those meetings have not been a silver bullet, but they are
an open, meaningful channel of communication between senior
Israelis and Palestinians. At times of strife, this is important
in assisting de-escalation and reducing violence. We have
consistently engaged with both the Israelis and the Palestinians
to urge them to de-escalate tensions and to support efforts
towards renewed negotiations.
My right hon. Friend the Foreign Secretary spoke to the Israeli
Foreign Minister, Eli Cohen, on 26 June—when they discussed the
security situation in the west bank—having spoken to the
Palestinian Prime Minister, Mohammad Shtayyeh, on 16 June. I can
confirm that the Minister for the Middle East, Lord Ahmad, will
be discussing the evolving situation with the Israeli ambassador
later today, further to discussions in recent days. He also spoke
to the Palestinian Foreign Minister, Riyad al-Maliki, on 5 May.
Our ambassadors in Tel Aviv and Jerusalem regularly speak to both
the Israeli Government and the Palestinian Authority to urge
de-escalation and to make clear our expectation that all sides
avoid unilateral steps that move the parties further away from
dialogue.
Let me finally draw the House’s attention to the statement that
the Foreign Secretary made jointly with his Canadian and
Australian counterparts last Friday. The UK opposes Israel’s
announced proposal to expand settlements across the west bank,
and we ask Israel to halt and reverse its policy of supporting
settlement expansion. Settlements are not the only obstacle to
peace, but they are an important one, and our concerns about
these recent steps are clear. The lives lost in this wider
conflict are tragic. There is an urgent need for all parties to
avoid further escalation in the west bank and Gaza, now and in
the days ahead.
The past 24 hours have seen a horrifying military assault by the
Israel Defence Forces on the overcrowded refugee camp in Jenin.
The UN Refugee Agency says that about 15,000 people live in less
than half a square kilometre in the camp, yet we have all
witnessed on our screens the Israel Defence Forces launching air
attacks, including attacks from drones, and they have sent in
hundreds, if not thousands, of ground troops in the largest
military action in the west bank for 20 years. News agencies are
reporting 10 deaths of Palestinians, including three children,
and 100 Palestinians injured, while the Palestinian Red Crescent
says that it has evacuated 3,000 people. The UN’s Vanessa
Huguenin has said:
“We are alarmed at the scale of air and ground operations that
are taking place in Jenin”.
The World Health Organisation has said:
“First responders have been prevented from entering the refugee
camp”.
Meanwhile, the Palestinian Authority leadership has resolved to
“immediately petition the UN Security Council to implement
Resolution 2334 and the relevant resolutions on providing
international protection to the Palestinian people, stopping
unilateral measures, and imposing sanctions on the occupying
power.”
The UK currently holds the presidency of the UN Security Council
and is therefore responsible for guiding its response to requests
made by the Palestinian Authority. May I therefore ask the
following questions? What are the UK Government doing in their
capacity as President of the UN Security Council? How have they
responded at the UN to the Palestinian Authority’s call for
international protection? What has the Foreign Office said to its
Israeli counterpart about the Israel Defence Forces preventing
medical staff from accessing the Jenin refugee camp, or firing
tear gas into hospitals sheltering children and elderly
residents?
Finally, what steps will the Foreign Secretary take to review
whether the IDF have made any use of UK arms sold to Israel in
this attack? Will he immediately suspend all arms sales,
including surveillance technology, and will he ban collaboration
between the UK and Israel’s armed forces and military industries
as a result of this horrific attack on civilians?
I thank the hon. Lady for bringing the urgent question to the
House. This is a matter of deep concern to us all. We will
continue to urge the Israel Defence Forces to demonstrate
restraint in this operation so that all parties can try to avoid
further escalation in the west bank and Gaza. As I have said,
while the UK will always support Israel’s right to self-defence,
the protection of civilians, particularly children, must always
be prioritised, and we expect the armed forces’ conduct always to
be in line with international humanitarian law. We therefore call
on Israel to adhere to those principles of necessity and
proportionality while defending its legitimate security interest.
Mr Speaker
I call the Chair of the Foreign Affairs Committee.
(Rutland and Melton)
(Con)
We stand on the precipice of the Gaza crisis of 2023 and the
third intifada. Yesterday, an Israeli military incursion into the
Jenin refugee camp resulted in the deaths of more than 10
refugees. Hundreds were injured and, as the hon. Member for Cynon
Valley () says, the ensuing gun battle
has prevented civilians from getting the aid and medical care
they need. Today, five Israeli civilians were killed in a
terrorist car ramming and a stabbing, and we are in an endless
cycle of violence. We need a return to the diplomatic table.
Jordan and Egypt have been trying to facilitate that and stand
ready to continue to do so, but they must see meaningful efforts
to stand up for the agreements reached at previous meetings, such
as the one in Aqaba.
I therefore call on the Government to try to secure the
following. The Israelis must stop the expansion of illegal
settlements; we are seeing that continue and it must stop—they
agreed to do that at Aqaba. We must see Hamas end its terror
attacks on Israel. They are wrong—they are terror attacks—and
although we have no influence over Hamas, we must use our voice
to make it clear that it must immediately stop. As the UK, can we
urge our Israeli friends to show restraint? Can we appoint a
middle east peace process envoy who can be tasked with spending
their entire time working with our allies around the region to
de-escalate the situation? Our voice is unique and will be heard,
and we have a role to play in the peace process. Finally, will we
use our UN Security Council presidency? Through that role, we can
shed light on what is taking place.
I thank the Chair of the Foreign Affairs Committee for her
salient and wise comments, as always. May I reiterate that on
Friday the Foreign Secretary made a joint statement with the
Canadians and Australians to set out very clearly our opposition
to Israel’s announcement of the expansion of settlements across
the west bank? We are asking Israel to halt and reverse that
policy of settlement expansion with immediate effect.
More widely, of course, we recognise the very real security
challenges facing Israel and the Palestinian Authority and
condemn all terrorist groups planning and carrying out attacks,
but we mourn the loss of innocent lives. Indeed, the injuries to
civilians and particularly children are deeply concerning. We
will continue to speak and our colleagues are speaking to our
Israeli teams today about the urgent need for all parties to
de-escalate and prevent the further loss of civilian life.
(Caerphilly) (Lab)
We must all be extremely concerned about the situation in the
refugee camp in the city of Jenin, as well as the ongoing
deteriorating situation in the conflict as a whole. Israel has
the right to defend itself against militant groups, but that
right must be exercised proportionately and in line with
international law. I am therefore very concerned that reports
suggest there are significant civilian casualties in Jenin. I am
also aware that statements from the spokesman for the United
Nations Secretary-General suggest that this military operation
has not been conducted within the parameters of humanitarian law.
The Secretary-General is said to be “deeply concerned” about the
situation on the ground.
Likewise, I am extremely concerned about the breaking news of a
suspected car ramming in Tel Aviv, where latest reports suggest
that at least five people are injured. Can the Minister provide
an urgent update on the situation? We will always condemn acts of
terrorism, which only make peace harder to achieve.
On Jenin, I am concerned about reports that emergency health
teams have been prevented from entering Jenin to treat the
injured and to help people in general, and that two hospitals
have been damaged. The World Health Organisation has reported
that three children have recently been killed. I am sure that
everyone in the House will agree that it is truly appalling that
children—Palestinian and Israeli—continue to be the innocent
victims in this conflict. Does the Minister agree that all
civilian deaths must be thoroughly and impartially investigated
and that there must be meaningful accountability?
Let me be clear that the Opposition will continue to be strong
and consistent advocates of justice, human rights and
international law in this conflict. We also condemn the
unacceptable use of violence against civilians in all
circumstances. In our view, there will be a lasting peace only
when there is a negotiated diplomatic settlement to the
Israeli-Palestinian conflict. The only real solution will be a
settlement based on two states: a safe and secure Israel
alongside a viable and independent Palestinian state. We strongly
oppose actions that make this two-state solution harder to
achieve. So my fundamental question is: what of substance are the
Minister and the Government doing to bring this immediate
conflict to an end and to lay the foundations for a two-state
solution?
I do not have the latest information on the Tel Aviv attack, but
I understand that Hamas are claiming it as one of theirs. We
absolutely condemn Hamas’s use of indiscriminate violence and
attacks of this nature. There can never be any justification for
such acts of violence, and we will continue to call on Hamas and
other terrorist groups to permanently end their incitements
against Israel. Importantly, Ministers and our ambassadors will
continue to work very closely, today and in the days ahead, to
urge the de-escalation of the present situation in Jenin.
(Reigate) (Con)
Understanding that this comes in the context of, for years,
Israel building settlements that block the route to a settlement
of this dispute, and understanding that Israel is failing to show
restraint, failing to follow international humanitarian law and
failing to protect civilians, what are the Government actually
going to do?
As I say, the statement that the Foreign Secretary put out with
his Canadian and Australian counterparts last week set out a
clear message to the Israelis about stopping the settlement
expansion. We will continue to work with our friends and allies
to make that message clearly heard.
Mr Speaker
I call the SNP spokesperson.
(Inverness, Nairn, Badenoch
and Strathspey) (SNP)
Violence on all sides must be condemned. However, contrary to
what the Minister said, illegal settlements are a barrier to
peace, yet the UK Government continue to fail to take any
meaningful action towards preventing that. This violence
represents a serious escalation of tensions on the west bank. As
we have heard, Palestinians and Israelis have lost their lives.
What assessment has been made of the potential chain reaction of
violence that this could unleash?
It has been confirmed that thousands of people have been
displaced from the camp. What discussions has the Minister had
with international colleagues on how to minimise the suffering of
those refugees— civilians—who have now been displaced twice? This
morning, UN aid agencies voiced alarm at the scale of Israel’s
military operation in Jenin, reporting that water and energy
supplies have been damaged, so will the UK Government commit to
working with partners to provide additional humanitarian funding
to restore these vital supplies for people there?
The UK’s position is clear: settlements are illegal under
international law and they call into question Israel’s commitment
to the two-state solution. So we have urged Israel to halt that
settlement expansion, which is threatening the physical viability
of a Palestinian state. To the hon. Gentleman’s point, we are
working with our partners the United States, France, Germany and
Italy to strongly oppose these unilateral steps.
I am afraid that I do not have the latest information on
humanitarian funding, but our teams work very closely through the
United Nations Relief and Rehabilitation Administration and other
humanitarian organisations. I would be happy to ask the relevant
Minister to update the House later on what the latest commitments
are.
(Harrow East) (Con)
Clearly, this morning’s car ramming is only the most recent of
the terrorist attacks that have emanated from the city of Jenin.
So far, Operation House and Garden has resulted in the
destruction of three labs, hundreds of improvised explosive
devices and thousands of grenades. Underneath the mosque, there
were two tunnels with hundreds of weapons, and 120 people have
been arrested. Clearly, the terrorist activity is going to be
severely limited. Behind all this is the Islamic Revolutionary
Guard Corps, Hamas and the Jenin battalions. Does my right hon.
Friend agree with me that this is a proportionate attempt to
reduce terrorism against the state of Israel?
As I say, while the UK remains absolutely resolute in its
commitment to Israel’s security, and we condemn absolutely the
use of indiscriminate force by Hamas and other terrorist groups,
we call on all parties to maintain a proportionate balance, so
that we can de-escalate the existing situation and ensure that
civilians are not caught up in this any more.
(Manchester, Gorton) (Lab)
With water and electricity services in the Jenin refugee camp
damaged as a result of the violence, camp residents are unable to
move from their homes. Many are in urgent need of food, drinking
water and medical support, but the ambulances have been prevented
from reaching the wounded. Will the Secretary of State raise with
the Israeli authorities the issue of access for ambulances and
medical teams to the Jenin camp?
The FCDO Minister for the middle east, Lord Ahmad, will be
listening to the debate and will be able to give an update in the
other place later today about his ongoing discussions with
Israeli counterparts.
(West Bromwich East)
(Con)
Let us be clear: any loss of innocent civilian life is one too
many. But let us also be clear that the Palestinian Authority has
lost control over Jenin and it has become a safe haven for
terrorists. Terror groups have fortified the area with IEDs and
last week they fired rockets towards Israel from inside the camp.
Iran has also boasted about arming, training and funding the
Palestinian terror groups that operate there. Does the Minister
agree that it is in the interests of both the Palestinians and
the Israelis that terror groups cease these operations, which
only further destabilise the Palestinian Authority and the
region, with innocent people dying as a consequence?
We recognise the real security concerns facing Israel and the
Palestinian Authority while they try to deal with those terrorist
groups, and we condemn absolutely terrorist groups planning and
carrying out attacks. To my hon. Friend’s point on the loss of
innocent lives, every loss is one too many and there will also be
a serious number of injuries to civilians. We continue to be
deeply concerned by the cycle of violence in the west bank. The
urgent need for all parties to de-escalate to prevent that loss
of life remains critical.
(Orkney and Shetland)
(LD)
Unless and until we acknowledge our own role in this developing
tragedy, anything the Minister says at the Dispatch Box is
essentially going to be meaningless. The increase in violence by
the IDF and the expansion of settlement in the west bank happen
because we and other countries in the west do nothing to hold
Israel to account. So could the Minister tell us now: will she
commit to supporting an International Criminal Court
investigation into what is happening there? Will the Government
here now set a timetable for the recognition of the Palestinian
state?
This Government and Members on both sides of the House do not
waver from the two-state solution that we all wish to see. As I
have said, settlements are illegal under international law and we
will continue, alongside allies and partners, to make that point
clear. As for the ongoing activity today, I hope that Lord Ahmad
will be able to pick up on that later today as progress is made
with our counterparts in Israel.
(New Forest West) (Con)
But hasn’t our strategic partnership with Israel, announced in
this House, afforded us any leverage over Israeli policy in the
west bank?
Our strategic relationship with Israel is a strong and
long-standing one. We work with Israel in many areas, from
security to trade. It is an important partner. That does not
negate the fact that we want to see a de-escalation of the
current situation and to ensure that the loss of civilian lives
is minimised.
(Birmingham, Selly Oak)
(Lab)
I share the distress of others at the loss of civilian life.
Islamic Jihad has already claimed several of the dead as Islamic
Jihad fighters and, as we have heard, the Israelis say that the
camp was used as a hub for terrorist operations. Does the
Minister think any more can be done to prevent terrorists from
embedding themselves among civilians, particularly in places such
as refugee camps?
We recognise the security challenges that are faced and will
continue to be faced, not only by Israel and the Palestinian
Authority in this case, but elsewhere in the world, where
innocents living in refugee camps are used as a cover for
terrorists wishing to cause harm. We all have to continue to
tackle that not only in the west bank, but around the world.
Importantly, in this situation, we will all continue to urge
de-escalation to reduce the risk of any further civilian
casualties or loss of life.
(Sunderland Central)
(Lab)
This year has seen more Palestinians killed than in any other
year, more settlement starts announced than in any other year,
more demolitions in East Jerusalem than in any other year and
more violence in general. We are on the precipice of another
intifada. At the minute, it looks to me as though Israel is
acting with impunity and this is an all-out assault on
Palestinian life. So what actions will the Government
undertake—not just conversations—to bring this dreadful
escalation in violence to an end?
We are absolutely committed to working with all parties on the
challenges associated with demolitions so that people remain calm
and avoid provocation. But we are clear that in all but the most
exceptional of circumstances demolitions and forced evictions are
contrary to international humanitarian law. The practice causes
unnecessary suffering to Palestinians and is harmful to efforts
to promote peace. In particular, we are monitoring developments
at Masafer Yatta closely and we have made our views clear to the
Israeli Government on that matter.
(Edinburgh South West)
(SNP)
Constituents have written to me about their grave concerns for
the welfare of civilians and health workers in the Jenin camp.
They, like me, know that the Israeli army enjoys a climate of
impunity because the international community never holds Israel
to account for its actions. Israel continues to breach
international law, including the fourth Geneva convention. As we
have heard already today, settlements are war crimes under the
Rome statute. So my question for the Minister is: what specific
actions will the Government take to ensure that Israel adheres to
international law and that its leaders are held accountable for
its war crimes?
As I say, we have been clear on this. My colleague in the other
place will speak with the Israeli ambassador later today to
ensure that we put forward the UK view that de-escalation is
urgently required in this difficult situation and that we
continue to tackle the questions associated with illegal
settlements, which are contrary to humanitarian law.
(Hayes and Harlington)
(Lab)
When the Russians have bombed predominantly civilian areas,
resulting in the death of civilians, we have rightly condemned it
as a war crime. Why have the Government not condemned these
actions, which are resulting in the loss of civilian life, as a
war crime? Have the Government called in the Israeli ambassador
to remind her in the strongest terms possible of the legal
responsibility that Israel has to protect civilians?
The UK supports Israel’s right to defend itself and its citizens
against terrorist activities, but we are clearly urging the IDF
to demonstrate restraint in order to prioritise the protection of
civilians. As I say, Lord Ahmad will be speaking with the Israeli
ambassador later today.
(Central Ayrshire)
(SNP)
We all condemn attacks on civilians, regardless of which
community they are from. The actions of the IDF in Jenin are
indefensible and have resulted in 2023 being one of the most
lethal years for Palestinians. The UK has long claimed to support
a two-state solution, endorsed UN Security Council resolution
2334 and recognised that settlements are illegal under
international law. So after yesterday’s appalling move to block
action by citizens and public bodies to stop illegal occupation
and settlements, have UK Government policy changed?
As I say, this Government will continue to stress the importance
of the adherence to the principles of necessity and
proportionality when Israel defends its legitimate security
interests, as well as the importance of continuing to provide
appropriate protection to the Palestinian civilian population,
particularly children.
(Middlesbrough) (Lab)
At around 11.30 am yesterday, 17-year-old Majdi Younis Saud
Ararawi sustained a gunshot wound to the chest and Nouruddin
Husam Yousef Marshoud, who was just 15, was shot in the head by
Israeli occupation forces. Their names join a list of more than
30 Palestinian children killed by the Israeli regime since the
beginning of 2023. The ultimate cause of those senseless killings
is Israel’s brutal and illegal occupation of Palestine, which has
gone on for over half a century.
Given that last night the Government voted for legislation
banning peaceful means of protesting against this abomination,
and given Britain’s humanitarian and historic responsibilities to
the Palestinian people, what actions have the Government taken?
The Minister has ducked the question so far, but I will give her
another chance to answer. What action will the Government take to
ensure that Israel adheres to international law and its leaders
are held to account?
As I have said, we are engaging both with the Israelis and the
Palestinians to urge them to de-escalate those tensions. Lord
Ahmad will be speaking to the Israeli ambassador later,
highlighting and demanding that under international law access to
medical care and staff is allowed, so that those who are injured
in the Jenin refugee camp are able to receive the medical care
that they require.
(Hammersmith) (Lab)
The use of aerial bombardment and armoured assault by thousands
of troops in a refugee camp, familiar to the people of Gaza, is
now extended to the west bank. Alongside settlement expansion, it
is part of the annexation of the Occupied Palestinian Territories
by Israel’s far-right Government. Occupation is the cause and
context of these latest war crimes. Will the Government
acknowledge that and respond by recognising the state of
Palestine?
As I say, across this House we continue our long-standing
position of a two-state solution. We will continue to work with
partners across the world to find a solution that allows that to
happen. In the meantime, we are deeply troubled by the level of
violence and we continue to call on Israel, while defending
itself and its citizens, to demonstrate the restraint required to
ease the situation in Jenin today.
(Dwyfor Meirionnydd)
(PC)
My thoughts go out to the people affected by the horrific attacks
on the Jenin refugee camp. We must be clear that this is a
violation of international law and that the occupying forces, in
particular, have a responsibility to end the violence. I will
give a clear suggestion of a possible action: will the UK
Government send a clear message of condemnation by bringing to an
end the importation into the UK of goods that are produced in
those Israeli settlements that are deemed illegal under
international law?
As I say, we will continue to make calls on
Israel—[Interruption.] Goods made in the settlements are not
allowed to be imported, and that continues to be the case. We
continue to grow the work that we do on trade with Israel, the
Palestinian Authority and the OPTs, and I know the Department for
Business and Trade is focused on that development work.
(York Central)
(Lab/Co-op)
I do not think the Minister understands the power of office.
Today we have heard comments and some warm words, but we have
seen no action. The UK currently has the power of holding the
presidency of the United Nations Security Council, so will she
call the Security Council together to act now on the atrocities
that we have seen in Jenin? What other measures will she take to
stop further atrocities occurring?
As I say, we continue to work on the peaceful two-state solution.
Later today, Lord Ahmad will provide an update in the other place
on our continuing activities.
(Brentford and Isleworth)
(Lab)
This year has already been the deadliest for violence in the west
bank since 2005. What assessment has the Minister made of the
impact of rising Israeli violence against Palestinian civilians?
I will give her another chance: does she not agree that civilian
deaths should lead to investigations and accountability?
As I say, we continue to be deeply troubled by the high number of
Palestinian civilians who have been killed and injured, as the
hon. Lady highlights. While Israel has a legitimate right to
defend itself, it is important that Israeli forces exercise
maximum restraint, especially in the use of live fire, when
protecting that legitimate security interest.
Ms Anum Qaisar (Airdrie and Shotts) (SNP)
I draw attention to my entry in the Register of Members’
Financial Interests.
Peace is a word we often hear in relation to Israel and
Palestine, but how can peace be achieved when Palestinians are
subjected to systematic and deliberate oppression and
discrimination by Israeli authorities? The people in the Jenin
refugee camp have already fled their homes, and they have been
displaced yet again. Can the Minister set out what is being done
by the international community to help those who have now been
displaced twice? Will she condemn the denial to access medical
care for Palestinians in Jenin? And will she join me in calling
out Israel’s behaviour for what it is? As stated in a report by
Amnesty International, Israel is committing the crime of
“apartheid against Palestinians.”
As I say, Lord Ahmad will be speaking to the Israeli ambassador
later and will be making clear that we want to ensure that
medical supplies are able to get into refugee camps to provide
the care that is needed to those who are injured as a result of
the violence of the past few days.
(Feltham and Heston)
(Lab/Co-op)
Reports from Jenin are shocking, particularly reports that
medical teams are unable to get access to civilians in need. I
support what the Chair of the Foreign Affairs Committee, the hon.
Member for Rutland and Melton (), said about having steps
towards a solution and an ending of Israeli settlements. The
United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian
Affairs reports there have been at least 570 attacks by settlers
against Palestinians in the west bank this year, which is an
average of three attacks a day. What is the Minister doing, in
discussions with her counterparts, on tackling Israeli settler
violence, as well as on the issues faced because of new
Palestinian militant groups? Action is needed now to de-escalate
the situation, as well as looking again at the international
funding for the United Nations Relief and Works Agency, which is
vital to support Palestinian refugees.
As I say, we condemn settler violence in the strongest possible
terms and we urge the Israeli authorities to do what they can.
The Foreign Secretary’s statement, published with Australia and
Canada at the end of last week, highlighted the very clear demand
that the Government of Israel reverse their decision to approve
over 5,700 new settlement units in the west bank and change the
settlement approval process. We will continue to work with allies
to achieve that.
(Bedford) (Lab)
The escalation of violence in the west bank over the past year
and the killing of innocent civilians, including children in
recent days, is devastating. The two-state solution, which many
of us hope will bring peace and stability to the region, seems
further away than ever. What are the Government actively doing to
stop the killing of innocent people and to ensure that a
two-state settlement is still a diplomatic reality?
As I have said, we continue to work with partners and allies on
the two-state solution. Indeed, we call on all those caught up in
the violence today to show restraint and to de-escalate the
situation so that the violence can come to a halt and we can
ensure that those casualties are able to receive treatment.
(Easington) (Lab)
My good and hon. Friend the Member for Cynon Valley () was absolutely correct in her
remarks and I thank her for securing this urgent question. I
visited the refugee camp at Jenin in 2012 and saw some of the
clinics and schools; to say that the conditions were grim is an
understatement. What we have seen over the past day or two is an
attack by Israeli security forces on a refugee camp, using
missiles against children, parents, the elderly and the
vulnerable. This is not about Israel defending itself. Even the
White House has stated that it is tyranny. When will the UK
Government intervene not just with words to condemn those
actions, but with something in practical terms to support the
Palestinian people undergoing such appalling oppression?
The UK’s position on the middle east peace process is clear and
we will continue to support a negotiated settlement, which leads
to a safe and secure Israel living side by side with a viable and
sovereign Palestinian state, based on the 1967 borders. In the
short term, we are calling very firmly, as are all partners
around the world, on Israeli defence forces to show the required
level of restraint to ensure that the violence ceases in Jenin
refugee camp as soon as possible.
(City of Durham) (Lab)
I thank my hon. Friend the Member for Cynon Valley () for securing this urgent
question. It has been reported that medical teams have been
prevented from entering Jenin. Will the Minister condemn that now
from the Dispatch Box? Will she express to her counterpart that
Palestinians must have medical aid, and can she then return to
the House to update MPs on the medical situation?
As I have said, international humanitarian law requires access to
be made available for medical teams to treat those in need of
care, so we are urging Israel to allow that as soon as possible.
I know that my colleague, the Minister for the middle east, will
be raising that particularly urgently with the Israeli ambassador
when he speaks to her this afternoon. I will ensure that an
update is provided by the Department in due course.
(Bury South) (Lab)
The last time that we saw tensions rise like this, we experienced
a month of hate, with incidents of antisemitism rising to an
all-time high, and horror tropes on the streets of London. Does
the Minister agree that, while discussions are taking place to
de-escalate the situation, we all have a duty to temper our
language to make sure that Jewish residents, such as my
constituents, do not live in fear of abuse, graffiti, racist
convoys and, ultimately, violence. We all have a duty to try to
tackle this behaviour on the streets when we see it.
We all have a duty to ensure that antisemitic voices are not
allowed to cause distress or violence. We will continue to ensure
that those who feel anxious get the support they need. We provide
a great deal of support and are very proud of the work that the
Home Office does in support of many of our Jewish communities.
(Kilmarnock and Loudoun)
(SNP)
This year, we have seen a record number of settlement units
approved. The Israeli Finance Minister has instructed ministries
to prepare for an additional 500,000 settlers on the west bank.
We have seen 33 Palestinian children killed. While the Government
urge restraint and we get the same weak answers time and again
from the Dispatch Box, Israel is acting with impunity. I think
the Minister said it slightly wrong earlier on, but it seemed
that she was saying that trade with illegal settlements is now
deemed illegal by the UK Government. Is that the case?
Let me reiterate again that the UK position on settlements is
absolutely clear. Those settlements are illegal under
international law and, indeed, they call into question that
commitment to the two-state solution, to which the UK are
committed. We will continue to urge Israel to halt that and
ensure that the trade relationships that we have with Israel and
the Occupied Palestinian Territories can progress as they need
to.
(Luton South) (Lab)
Many of my Luton South constituents have been in touch to say how
distressed and angry they are about the increase in violence on
the west bank. Many have set out that the access to supplies,
clean water and powdered milk for children is at risk, so, beyond
conversations, can the Minister confirm that there will be
additional support for healthcare and medical organisations on
the ground so that they can help civilians?
Once my noble Friend Lord Ahmad has had discussions with the
Israeli ambassador, I will ensure that further information on how
we will continue to support UNRWA and other humanitarian groups
focuses in particular on this incident. I am afraid that I do not
have more information to hand at the moment.
(Carmarthen East and
Dinefwr) (Ind)
One eye witness in an interview with CNN has compared the impact
of the incursion with a natural disaster in terms of the
destruction of infrastructure, such as roads, water systems and
electricity. What role can the British Government play in helping
reconstruction to reduce further humanitarian suffering? Is it
the policy of the British Government that the state of Israel
should pay reparations for damage to civilian infrastructure in
the occupied territories as a result of military activity?
As I have said, we have seen the violent activity today on our
TVs and we call on the Israeli Defence Forces and the Israeli
Government to demonstrate the restraint that is required to
prioritise the protection of civilians and ensure that we can see
both medical support get into the Jenin camp and de-escalation of
the violence as soon as possible.
(Liverpool, West Derby)
(Lab)
I wish to pass on my thanks to my hon. Friend the Member for
Cynon Valley () for raising this issue today.
I will give the Minister one more chance before we end this
urgent question: can she set out with far, far greater clarity
than she has done so far what action the Government will take as
president of the UN Security Council to ensure that Israel
adheres to international law and that its leaders are held
accountable?
As I set out earlier this week, the Foreign Secretary spoke to
the Israeli Foreign Minister, Eli Cohen, on 26 June and to
Palestinian Prime Minister Shtayyeh on 16 June. Such
conversations are going on day after day. Lord Ahmad will be able
to give an update on his conversations later on in the day in the
other place.
(North Down) (Alliance)
Israel is clearly in breach of international humanitarian law as
well as multiple UN Security Council resolutions. The Minister
has ducked the very specific question on the Security Council on
multiple occasions. As president of the Security Council, the UK
has a particular power to convene the Security Council and,
indeed, the responsibility to do so. Can the Minister give us a
very clearcut answer: will the UK Government convene the Security
Council on this issue—yes or no?
As I have said, the Government continue not only to have close
discussions with the Israelis to try to ensure a de-escalation of
the violence that we are seeing today, but to work closely with
our allies and partners to ensure that we continue to support and
give the clear direction of international partners on the
question of the two-state solution.
(Strangford) (DUP)
I thank the Minister of State for her measured and careful
answers to the urgent question. It is important that her interest
in this matter is put on the record. Will she outline what
discussions have taken place with our Israeli allies to renew
peace talks, to allow both states to co-exist beside each other
without the tit-for-tat action that has become normalised and yet
is truly horrific and heartbreaking for all those who are losing
loved ones in this conflict?
I thank the hon. Gentleman for his question. He is right that,
when this violence occurs, the great tragedy is that civilians
are caught up in it, especially where the Israeli Defence Forces
are legitimately trying to defend themselves and, indeed,
Palestinians from the terrorist threat. The Foreign Secretary
continues to have a strong focus on this and we are working with
leaders and our allies around the world to try to find a
solution.
(Liverpool, Riverside)
(Lab)
The Minister mentioned that the Government have urged the Israeli
Defence Forces to demonstrate restraint and have urged
de-escalation to protect civilians, but actions speak louder than
words. Can the Minister say what it will take for the Government
to suspend arms sales to Israel until we can be sure that they
are not being used to violate international law and perpetrate
war crimes and human rights abuses? I would appreciate it if the
Minister could give a well-thought-out answer to the question,
instead of referring to pre-scripted notes in a folder.
I will continue to state the fact that these violent activities
are ongoing and colleagues are in discussions right now with
Israeli counterparts. I do not wish to disturb those discussions
in any way. I am here to update the House on as much as we know.
It is an ongoing situation, but I know that when my colleague
Lord Ahmad responds to an urgent question later in the day, he
will have more information to share in the other place.
(Leeds East) (Lab)
I have listened carefully to the Minister, but since 2015 the
Government have sold £500 million-worth of arms to Israel, and UK
arms have been implicated in previous atrocities against
Palestine. Can the Minister say categorically whether any of that
military equipment has been used in Israel’s assaults on the
Jenin refugee camp? Does not this attack again show why the
Government should suspend all arms sales to Israel until it
abides by international law?
The Government take our defence export responsibilities seriously
and we operate some of the most robust export controls in the
world. I reiterate, as colleagues have heard me say before in
previous roles, that all applications for export licences are
assessed on a case-by-case basis against strict criteria and we
will not issue a licence if there is a clear risk that equipment
might be used for internal repression. The Government will
continue to monitor closely the situation in Israel, Gaza and the
west bank and, if extant licences are found to be no longer
consistent with those criteria, those licences will be revoked.