Asked by
To ask His Majesty’s Government what assessment they have made of
the balance between (1) the duty of local authorities under
section 122 of the Road Traffic Regulation Act 1984 to secure
expeditious, convenient and safe movement of vehicular traffic
and pedestrians, and (2) the imposition of low traffic
neighbourhoods and low emission zones.
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department for
Transport () (Con)
My Lords, the department has made no such assessment. It is for
local authorities to ensure they manage their roads in such a way
as to fulfil the duties placed on them. They have a wide range of
traffic management tools to support them in this.
(CB)
My Lords, I declare a type of interest in that I drive an
all-electric car and I have a clear conscience.
Does the Minister want people to return to work and productivity
to increase? I am urging the Government to stop any government
inducement to obstacles placed in the way of normal life in
pursuit of ideology and fines, not science. Studies prepared for
Oxford show that pollution is simply displaced from the centre
and the same amount goes to the ring road where poorer people
tend to live, and they are the ones punished by fines.
There are about 100 empty shops in Oxford. Businesses near the
low-traffic neighbourhoods are folding with great losses, and
they are often owned by ethnic minorities. There are tussles in
the streets over the barriers, ambulances take longer and the
once beautiful Broad Street is filled with industrial crates.
Working people are having great difficulties, the consultations
are ignored and the scientific evidence is withheld. Most
important of all, the traffic blockades discriminate—even the
blue badge is not exempt. Will the Government enforce the
protection of the rights of elderly, pregnant and disabled
people?
(Con)
There was a fair amount in that statement. The noble Baroness
mentioned Oxford, and it is important to understand that all the
issues she mentioned should be taken up with the local authority.
The Government have never been in control of local roads and are
not now. These issues are devolved to the local authority, and I
encourage her to raise those issues with her local council.
(Lab)
Speaking of convenience and safe movement of traffic, can the
Minister say what is happening with autonomous vehicles, be they
cars, lorries or buses, particularly with the trials going on in
this country and stretching right across Europe?
(Con)
The Government believe that there is a huge future for autonomous
vehicles, and we will bring forward legislation when
parliamentary time allows.
(LD)
My Lords, I am sure the Minister agrees that we must get this
right. The Transport for London web page tells us the details
about the scrappage scheme changes and the full eligibility
criteria for small and micro-businesses and charities. The new
grace period will be available on the discounts and exemptions
page at the end of this month, but the scheme is to be
implemented in August. Does the Minister think it is acceptable
that people struggling with rising costs should have only a few
weeks to find out if they are eligible?
(Con)
The scrappage scheme in London is of course under the remit of
the Mayor of London, and the Government have no recourse to have
any influence over it.
(Con)
My Lords, the noble Baroness, Lady Deech, raised an important
point. Would it not be sensible for the Government to have some
conversations with these local authorities? Oxford, with a bereft
high street, is not the Oxford most of us know and love, and it
is important that we get this thing in perspective. The
Government surely have an overall duty here.
(Con)
My Lords, one-way streets, traffic calming and pedestrianisation
have been used for decades. In some circumstances, they have been
put in and are not working, and in those cases it is for the
local authority to be held accountable by the local electorate.
The Government do, however, provide various bits of guidance,
both statutory and non-statutory, to assist local authorities to
come to the right decisions.
The Lord Speaker ()
My Lords, the noble Lord, , is participating
remotely.
(Lab) [V]
My Lords, on low-emission zones, can Ministers identify any
research showing that vehicles travelling over a given distance
at a constant 20 miles per hour in a low gear at high revs emit
less carbon monoxide than vehicles travelling at 30 miles per
hour in a higher gear at low revs? When I asked for the evidence
in 2021, this Minister gave the following answer:
“The Department does not have specific results for the situations
outlined”.
How can the public throughout the UK have confidence in a
speeding regime which lacks detailed assessment?
(Con)
It is up to local authorities to decide on local speed
restrictions, which they are encouraged to evaluate. As the noble
Lord will know, in most circumstances 30 miles per hour is the
limit, but some local authorities have chosen to make some
streets 20 miles per hour.
(Con)
The noble Baroness’s Question raises the important issue of the
safe movement of pedestrians. My noble friend the Minister may be
aware that the danger to disabled pedestrians posed by the
irresponsible use of e-bikes and e-scooters in the centre of
London’s low-emission zone was the focus of a recent Policy
Exchange paper, A Culture of Impunity, to which several noble
Lords contributed. Can my noble friend write to me with a formal
response to its recommendations and place a copy in the Library?
(Con)
I will certainly look into that, but I am not entirely sure that
I will be able to do as my noble friend asks. The safety of
people on our roads is critical, and one of the elements of
traffic management is the reduction in killed and seriously
injured people which I am sure all noble Lords would want to see.
It is not just about journey time changes but increasing the
number of people walking and cycling, and looking at modal shift
and levels of car ownership.
(Lab)
My Lords, I was brought up in Oxford. It was known then as the
“city of screeching tyres” and the college buildings were
blackened by pollution. Surely the best way to promote the city
is to continue with the huge environmental improvements that are
taking place there.
(Con)
As I said earlier, that is a matter for the council.
Baroness Taylor of Stevenage (Lab)
My Lords, local authorities are still having to rely on outdated
guidance from 2007 for the design and modification of residential
streets. In a debate in the other place in November last year,
Minister referred to the Department
of Transport publishing a revised version of the Manual for
Streets early in 2023. Can the Minister please give us update on
when we can expect that new manual?
(Con)
Yes, I can indeed. The Manual for Streets is an important
document on which we have engaged closely with stakeholders. That
engagement is still under way but I can commit to the noble
Baroness that the document will be published soon.
(Con)
My Lords, I declare an interest: I was invited to a speed
awareness course for travelling at 25 mph on Park Lane. Can my
noble friend explain how Park Lane, with three lanes and a bus
lane, can possibly be a 20 mph zone?
(Con)
It is a 20 mph zone because the Mayor of London has decided that
it should be.
(Lab)
My Lords, I am biased but the question from my noble friend
, on the emission
levels associated with a 20 mph limit and a 30 mph limit, was
splendid. I did not catch whether the Minister answered that
question, which is presumably a pretty precise one, on which
there can be scientific evidence. Can she try to answer it now?
(Con)
I am not aware of any research in that area but I will take that
question back to the department and write to the noble Lord.
(GP)
My Lords, I have enjoyed the Minister’s answers, batting away
some of the silly questions she has had from her own side. I just
wonder whether the explanation for shops shutting is not that
people are working from home now but simply the cost of living;
and perhaps people are not travelling as far and are shopping
locally.
(Con)
I reassure the noble Baroness that there are no silly questions
in your Lordships’ House. As I mentioned earlier, many of these
schemes are put in place to enable local economic growth. I
cannot conceive of my local town centre still having cars in it:
it is a hugely thriving town centre because it is pedestrianised.
However, what is really important is that local councils need to
get it right. If they do not get it right, they need to listen to
local communities and remove any interventions.