Nick Fletcher (Don Valley) (Con) I beg to move, That this House has
considered e-petitions 585304 and 589716, relating to food
labelling and support for people with allergies. It is a pleasure
to serve under your chairmanship, Sir Graham. I thank the
petitioners for their campaign; I know that they are here today.
Together, the petitions have received over 33,000 signatures. The
first petition states: “The Government should appoint an Allergy
Tsar to act as a...Request free trial
(Don Valley) (Con)
I beg to move,
That this House has considered e-petitions 585304 and 589716,
relating to food labelling and support for people with
allergies.
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Sir Graham. I
thank the petitioners for their campaign; I know that they are
here today. Together, the petitions have received over 33,000
signatures. The first petition states:
“The Government should appoint an Allergy Tsar to act as a
champion for people with allergies to ensure they receive
appropriate support and joined up health care to prevent
avoidable deaths”.
The second petition, on Owen’s law, asks for a change in the law
around labelling in UK restaurants. It has three parts. First, it
asks that restaurants
“put all information about allergens in their food on the face of
the main menu so customers have full visibility on what they're
ordering.”
Secondly, it requires servers to
“initiate a discussion with customers about allergies on all
occasions”.
Finally, it states that there should be a register for all
anaphylaxis deaths.
Those are the petitions, and I will discuss why the petitioners
are asking for these measures. Sadly, they have suffered
unbearable losses. Natasha Ednan-Laperouse died in 2016 after
eating a baguette that did not have a complete list of
ingredients. The baguette contained sesame seeds, to which
Natasha was allergic. That caused her to suffer an allergic
reaction, which resulted in her death. She was only 15—so young.
Natasha’s parents Tanya and Nadim have already been successful in
their campaign for Natasha’s law, which enforces a requirement
for all pre-packed sandwiches to contain a list of ingredients
and which became law in October 2021.
The second petition was started by Owen Carey’s sister Emma. Owen
suffered from multiple allergies all his life and was used to
ordering meals for his restricted diet. In April 2017, he ordered
a chicken burger at a restaurant. He explained his allergies to
the server; with no other information available, he was assured
that he was safe. However, the chicken was marinated in
buttermilk, to which Owen was very allergic. He knew instantly
that something was wrong. He had a massive reaction and, after 45
minutes, collapsed and died. He died celebrating his 18th
birthday—again, so young. They were both young people with their
entire life ahead of them. We can all clearly see why Natasha and
Owen’s families want to stop anyone else going through this.
I spoke to the families of Natasha and Owen so that they could
explain to me in their own words exactly what they are trying to
achieve. I am grateful to them for that. It appears that both
petitions go hand in hand. The petitioners believe that if we had
a tsar, they would have a champion who could work with families
who have suffered bereavement and with charities that want to
help, along with frontline staff, proprietors, supply chain
businesses, the Food Standards Agency and all Government
Departments that share an interest. It is a straightforward
ask.
(Rutherglen and Hamilton
West) (Ind)
The FSA has highlighted the fact that while young people are more
likely to experience a food allergy, they are less likely to tell
a café or restaurant about it, especially if they have eaten
there before. Does the hon. Member agree that we must empower
young people to speak up about their allergies and make
businesses aware of the importance of proactively asking
customers about their potential allergies?
The hon. Member is exactly right. I was forwarded a list of many
people who have fallen foul of that, and they always seem to be
so young. I will definitely come on to what the hon. Member has
mentioned.
The second petition seems relatively simple, too. How difficult
can it be to put on a menu what allergens are in each piece of
food? In fact there is already a law requiring that, but it falls
short by requiring it “by any means”, which often means that
allergen information is missed by those who need it most. The
petitioners say that the law needs tightening up, but they are
flexible in their ask: they say that allergens must be stated on
the face of the menu, but that could be in paper format or
electronic. For a server to make sure that a discussion is had
seems another simple ask, and a list of the sad losses could be
dealt with through the coroner’s office.
But as with many things in life, it is not quite as simple as all
that. The industry is huge. Billions of pounds are spent each
year on food from outlets of varying sizes. We have all been to a
local caff or McDonald’s; some of us have been fortunate enough
to go to some rather expensive restaurants in hotels with
branches around the world. Then there are those in the middle,
the squeezed small and medium-sized enterprises. Therein lies the
problem: the variation among outlets and what and how they
serve.
Fast food chains give a specification to their suppliers of the
ingredients that their food is to contain, with no
variations—that is what they ask for and that is what they get.
But other outlets, big and small, often get swaps when they order
their ingredients, pretty much like when we get an online
supermarket delivery. A local caff may be able to cope with that,
with a good proprietor keeping a check on what they are sent and
very few menu changes throughout the year, if any. It may not be
too much of a problem for them, but the large restaurants and
some of the independents with fast-moving kitchens may
struggle.
We have all seen a chef with 40 covers to do bellowing in
someone’s ear, pots and pans everywhere, hot kitchens with hot
atmospheres, young people trying to learn their trade, and
impatient customers breathing down a server’s neck. These are
high-pressure situations, often in open kitchens, and these
people are all trying to make a living. Mistakes will happen.
Then there are menu changes. Many restaurants change their menu
frequently to add to the customer experience. They have to offer
a variety to keep it fresh, and hopefully in season too, but
every change brings a problem—another allergy list and another
place for an error to occur. It is not as easy as one first
thought.
Data from 2022 published by the FSA shows that when dealing with
a risk of food allergies, smaller manufacturers will focus on the
physical separation and secure storage of ingredients. In
comparison, medium-sized manufacturers will take further steps
such as cleaning between production runs and managing the
packaging, labels and transport of products. Does the hon. Member
agree that businesses of all sizes should have access to
personalised guidance on how they can improve their allergy
awareness in risk assessment?
I will be coming on to that point, but I believe that an allergy
tsar, which the first petition asks for, will be able to bring
those concerns together. That would help the industry
immensely.
There are companies out there such as Control Catering that want
to work with the Food Standards Agency and the industry to create
a single source of truth. They want to work with manufacturers so
that all data is seamlessly passed to the end user, the customer
or diner. The petitioners believe that that is a sensible idea,
as we have over 50,000 products across a huge supply chain going
to many different outlets and 60 million-plus people across this
land. The British Institute of Innkeeping and Hospitality
Allergen Support UK feel it is sensible, too, but apparently the
FSA is slow to respond when contacted about it. The industry
believes that unless we have a joined-up approach, we could end
up putting forward legislation that has the best intentions but
turns out to be completely unworkable. I know that there is much
more that the petitioners would have me say, but I must move on
in the hope that other MPs will add their thoughts on the
complexity of the issue.
The second part of Owen’s law would be for all servers to start a
discussion with customers about allergies so that customers do
not have to ask. My own experience is that that is happening
anyway. However, I am fortunate enough to be able to answer no,
so I am unsure how deep the conversation goes if the answer is
yes. Stakeholders feel that training is required for all servers,
but I understand that the industry suffers from a high turnover
of staff, so that is not an easy task.
(Ceredigion) (PC)
I am grateful to the hon. Member for introducing this important
debate. There is very often a high turnover of staff in the
hospitality trade, but does he agree that technology such as
electronic forms and QR codes might help? Even though staff
members might work in a restaurant for only a couple of months at
a time, such technology would enable them to quickly check when
asked what ingredients are in the food they are serving.
The hon. Member is right. As we move forward in the digital age,
we will be able to put options on menus that the server can
discuss with the diners and things like that. Maybe the
conversation should always be instigated, but if the answer is
yes and the server is not adequately trained, they should be
assisted by a person with higher authority or even the chef.
Again, that may be difficult to implement, but a conversation
must take place with an outcome that protects anyone who suffers
with allergies.
Before I move on from this point, though, let me say that I
believe that there is a responsibility on people who suffer with
allergies to make that known. They must play their part. I know
many are young, but I am a firm believer in personal
responsibility and we must give the catering industry a chance.
We must help it to help us if the system is not quite working as
it should. All of us who are fortunate enough not to suffer
should support those who do by being patient, by showing a caring
attitude when ordering our food with guests and, if it is our
child who suffers, maybe even by ordering what they order. That
would help our children and the restaurateur, and it would show
some skin in the game. If we want change, we should be prepared
to bear a little cost ourselves and to make ourselves a little
uncomfortable for the cause. The state cannot and should not be
the answer to everything. We should all play our part.
Finally, Owen’s law asks that we maintain a list of all people
who have died from anaphylactic shock. It would not necessarily
be for the public domain or even name where the tragedy occurred,
but it would be recorded to make the Government and all
stakeholders aware of the size of the problem and to aid work on
prevention as well as a cure. Professor Adam Fox believes that
there should also be a list of near misses. Near misses are
recorded in the construction industry; they should be recorded
here, too. If we know the size of the problem, it may focus our
attention on why there is a problem. Why are 40% of the
population suffering with some kind of allergy? To me, that is
the real question.
We can now see why the petitioners believe that the introduction
of a tsar could help with the second petition’s aim of
instigating Owen’s law. They believe that if we do nothing, we
will see more tragedies, and if the industry simply states, “All
our food may contain certain ingredients,” people with
hypersensitivity will stay away. Some stakeholders believe that
if we move too quickly with poor regulation, we will damage the
industry and no doubt close businesses. So do we do nothing?
Well, the petitioners and the industry at large agree that there
should be a change, and appointing a tsar who could lead on
solutions may just do that. It may help to bring forward
legislation or ideas that will not only save lives, but save an
industry that is battling on many fronts simply to stay afloat. I
look forward to listening to what colleagues and the Minister
have to say.
4.44pm
(Dagenham and Rainham) (Lab)
What we are talking about today matters a great deal to a great
many people. Millions across the country suffer from some
allergic condition: it is estimated that 44% of adults and 50% of
children in the UK have one or more allergic disorders. While the
prevalence, severity and complexity of allergies have increased
on a global scale over the past 60 years, UK rates are among the
highest in the world. There is a modern-day epidemic in allergy.
I therefore very much welcome both petitions: one to appoint an
allergy tsar as a champion for people living with allergies and
the other in support of Owen’s law, a change in the law around
allergy labelling in UK restaurants. I congratulate the
organisers. Literally tens of thousands of people are mobilising
and demanding a change both in public health and in corporate
responsibility for labelling policy.
Why do we need an allergy tsar? No single person has overall
responsibility for the wellbeing of allergy sufferers in the
Department of Health and Social Care, NHS England or anywhere
else in Government. There are no clear lines of accountability in
relation to the overall NHS provision of allergy care. An allergy
tsar would act as a champion for people living with allergies. As
the national lead, the tsar would ensure that adults and children
with allergies received appropriate support to prevent avoidable
death and ill health. The lack of a national lead has been raised
time and again by coroners at the inquests of those who have
tragically died following severe allergic reactions. The need for
an allergy tsar is supported by the National Allergy Strategy
Group and across the allergy community.
(Hammersmith) (Lab)
I pose this question because my hon. Friend is an expert in the
subject. There have been calls for a national allergy tsar for a
long time. Does he understand why the Government are resistant to
them?
I will come on to that point. There have been 20 years of reports
that agree about a common platform for policy change, and there
is a unanimity across the community. It is bewildering that over
the past 20 years, Governments have not responded in a proactive
way, although over the past 18 months there have been a few
changes, which I will come to later.
The need for an allergy tsar is supported by the National Allergy
Strategy Group. In addition, the Natasha Allergy Research
Foundation and the NASG are asking the Government to better
support people with allergies through, first, an expert advisory
group for allergy, which would actively support the growth and
delivery of high-quality, comprehensive and geographically
diverse allergy provision, and secondly a national allergy action
plan.
A lack of societal awareness around food allergies is dangerous.
For example, 600,000 people in the UK have coeliac disease, but
there is a misconception that people choose to eat gluten-free
food for its health and cosmetic benefits. Does the hon. Member
agree that more needs to be done to ensure that the UK public are
aware of the definition and dangers of different food
allergies?
I agree. I would suggest that that is part of the lack of an
overall strategy and of key responsibilities at national level
for making people aware about the differences and the public
health needs across all our communities in every constituency
that we represent here in Parliament.
The second part of the proposal is a national allergy action
plan, which would join up GP and hospital allergy services,
increase the number of specialist allergy clinics, train more
specialist allergy doctors and consultants and provide mandatory
training in allergies for all GPs. Owen Carey’s family want a
change in the law to compel restaurants to state the allergens in
their dishes, specifically on the face of main menus. That would
build on Natasha’s law, which dealt with the ingredients and
allergy listings on pre-packaged takeaway foods. Natasha’s law
left an uneven situation in which people who buy pre-packaged
foods have more protection than those who eat in restaurants,
which is what the family are keen to sort out.
The family are also campaigning for better training for waiting
staff, for more thorough and certified allergy and first-aid
training and, as we have heard, for the proper recording of and a
national register for anaphylaxis deaths. Those are all very
sensible suggestions. Businesses are also responding: in March
2023, the bosses of 11 leading UK businesses, including Tesco and
Sainsbury’s, called for clearer rules on food labelling following
recent tragic and preventable deaths.
As for the general context, the figures speak for themselves. One
third of the UK population, or 20 million people, are living with
an allergic condition, and 5 million have a condition severe
enough to require specialist care. Fatal and near-fatal reactions
have increased over recent years. There has been a 615% increase
in hospital admissions relating to allergic disease during the
past 20 years. More than 200,000 people require the prescription
of emergency adrenalin because of the severity of their allergic
condition. Each year, births add 43,000 new cases of child
allergy to the population in need. The figures are
extraordinary.
What is so frustrating—touching on what my hon. Friend the Member
for Hammersmith () raised a few minutes ago—is
that over the past two decades a series of reports have
consistently demonstrated the prevalence of allergic diseases,
the patient needs and the lack of UK service provision. The list
of reports includes two Royal College of Physicians reports, in
2003 and 2010, on allergy: the unmet need. We had the 2004 House
of Commons Health Committee report on the provision of allergy
services, as well as the 2007 House of Lords Science and
Technology Committee report on allergy. In autumn 2021, the
all-party parliamentary group on allergy and the National Allergy
Strategy Group published “Meeting the challenges of the National
Allergy Crisis”.
All the reports have consistently highlighted how allergy remains
poorly managed across the NHS because of a lack of training and
expertise. All have recommended significant improvement in
specialist services as well as improved knowledge and awareness
in primary care. They have all talked about a national allergy
action plan and the need for a national lead person responsible
for allergy services—an allergy tsar. Yet in truth, very little
has happened in 20 years. Change is long overdue.
Beyond the statistics, we are talking about a growing number of
people living with allergic disease. Their condition can have
significant and negative impacts on their lives and those of
their families. It is frightening and restrictive to live with a
condition that can cause a severe or life-threatening reaction at
any time.
The reports that I mentioned, spanning 20 years, have all agreed
on four key recommendations for change: a national plan for
allergy, which would involve making allergy a priority and
investing in a national plan led by a designated Department head,
a national tsar; specialist care, which would involve expanding
the specialist workforce as a priority; in primary care, ensuring
that all GPs and other healthcare professionals have knowledge of
allergic diseases; and, in terms of commissioning, ensuring that
local commissioners understand the allergy needs of their
population.
As I mentioned, I want to acknowledge some progress over the last
year. The previous care and mental health Minister—the right hon.
Member for Chichester (), who is now Secretary of
State for Education—demonstrated real commitment in this area,
and since 2021 we have established a work programme and an
ongoing dialogue between civil servants and representatives from
the NASG to support the development of a national plan. I hope
that that work continues. It should be the right of every allergy
sufferer to receive a quality standard of care, and every
sufferer should be able to be confident about the food that they
consume in restaurants, as is the case under the arrangements
that successfully operate in other countries, such as the Irish
Republic.
In December 2022, the Food Standards Agency executive said that
as a result of the need to respond to the deadline imposed by the
Retained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Bill, it had to delay its
planned work on Owen’s law. Supporting the petition this
afternoon will, we hope, put pressure on the Department for
Environment, Food and Rural Affairs to force the FSA to
prioritise its work on Owen’s law before another person dies
unnecessarily.
I congratulate all the organisers of both petitions and urge the
Government to respond favourably to them, because lives literally
depend on it. Government action is important, and I hope that the
Government can back both petitions this afternoon.
4.53pm
(Winchester) (Con)
It is good of you to call me so early, Sir Graham. I was really
keen to make a contribution to today’s important debate, the
subject of which was ably laid out by my hon. Friend the Member
for Don Valley (). Congratulations to the
many people who signed the first petition: 13,000, as my hon.
Friend said. I think the second highest number of people who
signed it live in the Winchester constituency, and I will explain
why that was the case.
This is a subject that I am interested in, not only because I
chair the House of Commons Health and Social Care Committee and
am a former Public Health Minister and who has sat many times in
the seat where the Minister is today, but because I am the
constituency MP of Emma, who is here today and whose lovely
brother Owen gives his name to part of today’s debate—one of the
petitions—and, of course, to the Owen’s law campaign. The House
will wish to note that I met up with Emma on Friday in Winchester
and heard a bit about her little brother, the tragic
circumstances in which he lost his life and the brilliant
campaign that she and the family have put together in his memory.
They have hotfooted it from Manchester, where they were on the
“BBC Breakfast” sofa this morning, so it is really great to have
them here in the Public Gallery today.
As I have said a number of times in this Chamber, the Health and
Social Care Committee recently launched a major new inquiry into
prevention of ill health. It is a subject that I am passionate
about, and it is one of my top priorities as Chair. Obviously,
prevention covers a huge range of topics, and that is one of the
reasons why we decided to theme the inquiry around 10 key
workstreams, which we will be exploring over the remainder of
this year and probably into next. A high number of the
submissions that we received to our initial call for evidence
were related to food. Although perhaps more obvious topics spring
to mind when talking about food and prevention, such as the
obesity agenda, it is important that we do not lose sight of how
crucial preventive work is when supporting people with food
allergies and intolerances. Today’s debate on the two e-petitions
perfectly illustrates that point.
Owen’s sad death at the age of just 18 gave rise to the campaign
for Owen’s law, and we have also heard about Natasha. These were
simply avoidable deaths. They really could have been prevented if
better information about allergens had been available. I agree
with the hon. Member for Dagenham and Rainham () about levelling that playing field—he put that very
well. To avoid other families suffering the same awful loss that
Owen and Natasha’s families have experienced, it is essential
that the Government look at what more can be done to pull
together all the work carried out over many years, to ensure that
people with allergies have the information they need to make
informed decisions about what they can and cannot eat.
I was encouraged to see in the Government’s response to the
petition on Owen’s law that the Food Standards Agency met the
Carey family to discuss their proposals, and that the agency
committed to working with the Department to consider how to
improve the provision of information to people with food
hypersensitivity. That response, however, was issued back in
2021, so I hope that the Minister will provide us with an update
on how that work is progressing.
Alongside improving the provision of information about allergens,
it is important, as we have heard, that research continues into
food allergies, so that there is an improved understanding of how
to prevent complications relating to those allergies in the
future. Ministers should look to the work proposed by Professor
Adam Fox at the British Society for Allergy and Clinical
Immunology. I was encouraged to see in the Government’s response
to the second e-petition that the National Institute for Health
and Care Research has allocated more than £2 million for research
into food allergies over the preceding five years. Again,
however, that response dates from 2021, so I hope we can have an
update today.
I understand that the Food Standards Agency will discuss the
changes proposed under Owen’s law at its June board meeting,
which is very good news. Will the Minister ensure that the
strength of feeling in the House today is fed to the FSA ahead of
that meeting? Specifically—and specifics are important here—we
are talking about regulation 5 of the Food Information
Regulations 2014, which simply obliges restaurants to provide
allergy information accurately “by any means”. That could mean
anything—it could mean just a passing verbal reference. In short,
the Owen’s law campaign wants to change the words “by any means”
and to oblige restaurants to write that vital information on the
menu. That is critical for the reasons we have discussed. Many
people do not want to discuss their allergies and personal health
circumstances when they are going for a birthday meal. That is
not unreasonable.
I trust the Minister will agree that it is essential we make
progress in this area, and do so fast. The hon. Member for
Dagenham and Rainham talked about the work that has gone on over
a decade or more. I say to the Minister that the bottom line is
that the music stops when they sit in that chair. I have been in
that chair, and it is a wonderful job—the best job in Government.
It gives the Minister a great opportunity. He must grab it. As we
have heard, the architecture for Owen’s law is already in place
in the Republic of Ireland, so will the Minister promise the
House that he will look at that example and learn from it?
We need to see changes in law, regulations, guidance and industry
practices, as well as in research into allergies. I will not
repeat every ask of the campaign, because my hon. Friend the
Member for Don Valley did that when opening the debate. We intend
to keep working until we get progress on this issue. I promise,
as Chair of the Health and Social Care Committee, that I will put
my weight behind the issue, and the Committee will look at
it.
Owen had a range of allergies and, although he was just 18, he
had become well versed in managing them. With school lunches,
trips and holidays, I heard they had to work so hard to manage
them. Owen did not have to die, but he did because he went out
for a meal to celebrate his 18th birthday. I asked his big sister
on Friday what she thought Owen would be doing today—he would be
23 years old. Emma said she thought he would be somewhere in
Wales—the family’s spiritual home—probably on the Gower beaches
where his brother Daniel, who is also here today, taught him to
surf. He was due to go to Swansea University, and Emma thinks he
most definitely would be working in something clever, probably
tech or computing, living an outdoors life to the fullest and
playing that guitar he loved so much. He cannot do any of that
now and that is a tragedy, but we can do something to ensure that
his death and Natasha’s were not in vain and to ensure that
others do not end up in the same position.
There is a saying that I often like to refer to in this place—I
used to have it on my desk when I had the Minister’s job—and that
is, “For a moment like this.” That sentence can be completed with
anything you like. For a moment like this, we are in
Parliament—please let us seize the opportunity.
5.01pm
(Chesham and Amersham) (LD)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Sir Graham. I
thank the hon. Member for Don Valley () for opening the debate and
all those who signed both petitions. I express my support for the
appointment of an allergy tsar to act as a champion for allergy
sufferers.
Last year, I was contacted by a then eight-year-old constituent
who shared with me the harrowing experience she had had following
an allergic reaction. She had been baking with her grandparents
and ended up consuming what doctors suspect might have been trace
amounts of either pistachio or cashew nut. The reaction led to
her being rushed to hospital in an ambulance terrified and, in
her own words, thinking she might die. Thankfully, my constituent
was able to receive treatment in time, but her parents have told
me how they have had to become food manufacturing detectives to
keep their daughter safe. They routinely contact food companies
directly to understand the company’s cross-contamination
policies, which then allows them to make informed decisions on
what food they give her. Surely, in today’s Britain, parents
should not have to play detective to keep their children
safe.
While there is a legal requirement to label products that contain
any of the 14 most common allergens, such a requirement is sadly
lacking when it comes to precautionary labelling on the risks of
cross-contamination. That means there remains significant
variation in whether and how food companies provide that
information. Some companies that clean machinery between
manufacturing different food products decide not to include
precautionary labelling at all, despite the risk of
cross-contamination from trace amounts of allergens. Where
companies do provide such information, the way in which it is
shared can vary drastically, including the location of labels on
the packaging and the phraseology used. This lack of consistency
can lead to confusion, as the Food Standards Agency identified in
its report published last summer. Most importantly, it can lead
to sufferers or their parents missing critical information that
could help them decide whether a particular food is safe.
My constituents have also raised with me the fact that where
there are warnings about nuts in particular, they are almost
always generic, with statements such as “This product may contain
nuts.” In some cases, where sufferers are allergic to some types
of nuts but not others, the lack of detail means that large
amounts of food products that otherwise might be suitable for
them are automatically ruled out. As the Food Standards Agency
report makes clear, this much-needed change is supported by
industry. It says that food businesses
“want a standardised approach, with clear requirements that
provide certainty and a level playing field, giving confidence
that their risk assessments protect consumers.”
I therefore urge the Government to appoint an allergy tsar and to
take action on precautionary labelling, to ensure that allergy
sufferers are able to make informed decisions about what they eat
and to reduce the risk that they will expose themselves to
potentially deadly allergens.
5.04pm
(South East Cornwall)
(Con)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Sir Graham. I
congratulate my hon. Friend the Member for Don Valley () on leading this debate.
Paul Carey, Owen’s dad, is my constituent. His son was lost when
he ate a burger that had been soaked in buttermilk, to which he
was highly allergic. Minister, I will be repeating what has been
said already, so that it hits home. Owen knew about his
allergies, and he explained them to the server, who did not know
that the burgers had been soaked in buttermilk. Owen died at the
London Eye, which is just over the river from Parliament. That is
why I think it is particularly brave for my constituent and his
family to come to this debate. I thank them for that, and I thank
them for their tireless campaigning to stop another parent going
through what they have gone through.
Many restaurants, including small outlets in my constituency,
already have allergy information on their menus. I thank them for
that. I call on other places to do the same now, before a change
in the law. Quite simply, it could save a customer’s life—a
customer who could come back time and again because they feel
confident in the information provided without having to ask for
it or to rely on a server who may not have the full information.
That works already. The Republic of Ireland implemented a change
to its law in 2014. The Food Standards Agency has already done a
fact-finding mission to better understand how that law works in
practice. It is doing a workshop next month to go through its
findings. It would not need to be a big change in legislation.
Food businesses already need to make allergy information
available. Putting it on the face of menus would stop those with
allergies having to ask for it.
I call on the Minister and the Government to make that a priority
and to make that change to the law now. I am sure the whole House
would back that minor change, which would incur very little cost
to the public purse. I also ask the Government to look at how the
training of service staff can be improved so that they ask
customers about allergies, and so that they know about allergens
and what to do if someone has an allergic reaction.
I have relations and members of staff who have allergies of one
sort or another. Minister, it is time we took action. I look to
the Minister in his reply to confirm that he will tell us when
his Department plans to implement Owen’s law.
5.08pm
(Hammersmith) (Lab)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Sir Graham, in
such an important debate. I will echo the Chair of the Health and
Social Care Committee, the hon. Member for Winchester (), and others. Through
relatively small changes to how the NHS is organised and to
legislation, this dramatic change would both improve and save the
lives of millions, so I hope we will hear something positive from
the Minister.
I also thank the hon. Member for Don Valley (), who opened the debate, for
his comments about Natasha Ednan-Laperouse and her family, and
for the sensitive and compassionate way in which he dealt with
that tragic death. Natasha’s family are my constituents, and we
have heard that Natasha died at the age of just 15 from eating an
inadequately labelled Pret a Manger sandwich.
The afternoon I spent with Nadim, Natasha’s father, will stay
with me for the rest of my life. He described his experience of
how she went from enjoying a happy holiday—getting ready to go
out, the excitement of getting ready to fly, taking the
precautions she normally did as someone who knew about her
allergies, in this case to sesame—to end in her awful death. I do
not want to draw that out today, though.
I am very pleased to see Natasha’s mother Tanya here today. I
feel huge sympathy and compassion for the family, but also huge
admiration for them and everything they have done to commemorate
Natasha’s life, going far beyond what many people have done to
ensure that the lives of others are improved. Not only have they
set up the Natasha Allergy Research Foundation, which we have
heard about, but they pioneered Natasha’s law, which came into
effect in 2021. It requires food businesses to include full
ingredient labelling on foods that are pre-packed for direct
sale. Natasha’s law filled an important gap in food legislation
and food safety, and Owen’s law would do exactly the same in
another respect. His family are here today, and I praise them for
having courage and pursuing this matter. I hope that because of
the efforts made by these families, we will see a positive
response.
Although we have taken those important steps forward, there is
still a lot of work to do, hence the petitions and the debates
today and last week in this Chamber. The petitions received a
very high number of signatures, and some of the highest numbers
were among my constituents. That shows how a case such as
Natasha’s can have a profound impact on not just a family, but a
whole community.
I am grateful to my hon. Friend the Member for Dagenham and
Rainham () for securing last week’s debate marking Allergy
Awareness Week and for his speech today. I looked carefully at
the Minister’s reply, which I will come back to in more detail in
a moment, from the debate last Thursday. I read nothing about
steps towards appointing an allergy tsar in that response, which
is unfortunate because that is something that the allergy
community tell us is needed to keep people safe and to keep
research moving forward.
As we heard in both debates, allergies in the UK are on the rise.
About one in three people have an allergy-related disorder, and
over the past 20 years there has been a more than 600% increase
in hospital admissions due to allergic diseases. It is not just
the numbers of allergy sufferers that are escalating, but the
severity of the symptoms. Over 200,000 people in the UK require
emergency adrenalin on prescription to manage their allergy.
The very real and ever-present risk of death from an allergic
reaction is an ongoing trauma for families and parents of young
children who have an allergy condition. As we have heard, about
50% of our child population now live with an allergic condition.
Many of our schools have rightly become nut-free zones, due to
the numbers of children who would be at risk if someone brought
in a nut-based food in their lunchbox. Children go to school with
medication bags including EpiPens and adrenaline, in case the
worst happens. We should not underestimate the distress and
anxiety that that can cause a child, who must learn from a very
early age the consequences that can come from eating the wrong
thing.
The weight of that on a child is really quite unfathomable, yet
we have nobody in the Department of Health and Social Care or NHS
England who is responsible for a strategy to tackle allergies. We
know that this is a growing problem and research is desperately
needed, but to ensure that allergic conditions get the focus they
need, someone must be appointed to champion the issue. Given the
current state of the NHS, we all understand that resources are
stretched, but if the Government committed to an allergy lead,
along with funding, they would allow someone to take ownership of
the matter and drive forward a strategy to improve the lives of
those with allergies.
If I may, I will give a brief, or at least recent, history and
timeline of the lack of progress made towards appointing an
allergy tsar. Back in January 2020, an inquest was held into the
death of another young person who tragically died as a
consequence of an allergy: Shante Turay-Thomas. Following the
inquest, Emma Turay, Shante’s mother, said:
“Nothing will ever bring our beautiful Shante back to us but what
has kept me going throughout this process is knowing that she
would want me to get answers and make sure the same thing doesn’t
happen to anyone else…The coroner highlighted the fact that no
one person in NHS England or the Department of Health is
responsible for allergies, and it is quite clear we need an
allergy tsar to co-ordinate and implement steps to prevent others
from suffering avoidable deaths like Shante’s.”
It is interesting that we still do not have access to a
compendium of prevention of future deaths reports. We rely on
individual reports, which are very important, but if coroners’
reports were better organised, this issue would have much greater
public attention. In Shante’s case, the coroner’s report
said:
“there is no person with named accountability for allergy
services and allergy provision at NHS England or the Department
of Health as a whole”.
The response from the then Minister for Social Care, the hon.
Member for Faversham and Mid Kent (), was:
“Although there is no single, named individual with oversight for
all aspects of allergy policy, individuals and teams work closely
together in the Department on all aspects of policy relating to
allergies.”
The inadequacy of that response led to the petitions being
launched and to the call by tens of thousands of people for the
Government to appoint an allergy tsar to act as a champion for
people with allergies and ensure they receive appropriate support
and joined-up healthcare, and so prevent avoidable death and ill
health.
In June 2022, following those events, the Natasha Allergy
Research Foundation met a new Health Minister, who showed an
interest and assured the foundation that meetings were ongoing
with the National Allergy Strategy Group and my hon. Friend the
Member for Dagenham and Rainham. Three months later, because of
the carousel of Prime Ministers turning, the Health Minister was
demoted to a different Department and the momentum was lost,
notwithstanding the fact that my hon. Friend the Member for
Nottingham North (), who was then the shadow
Health Minister, tabled an amendment to the Health and Care Bill
to create an allergy tsar. Although the Government refused to
accept the amendment, the then Health Minister promised to raise
the issue with NHS England.
There is a constant expectation that something is going to be
done, and then it is dashed, either because of inaction by a
particular Minister or because the Minister has simply moved on.
Time and again, progress has stalled because of the musical
chairs—the many Prime Ministers and the sacking, promotion and
demotion of Ministers—and the allergy community has been left
waiting patiently for the matter of an allergy tsar to be taken
seriously once more.
This reminds me of the long battles we fought to have inquiries
into Hillsborough and the contaminated blood scandal. Ministers
constantly promise things, or at least say they will look into
things, and then they move on and we are suddenly back to square
one. I hope the Minister will give us positive news today, not
just warm words, and that he will tell us about tangible steps he
will take to appoint a lead person for allergies as soon as
practicable.
I have not heard anybody coherently argue against the merits of
having an allergy tsar, which is why I posed the question I did
to my hon. Friend the Member for Dagenham and Rainham. An allergy
tsar would be dedicated to and focused on the development of
research into cures for allergies, and tasked with ensuring
specialist allergy clinics and services up and down the UK. They
would be a dedicated lead who works with the Government to
implement mandatory reporting on all anaphylaxis events presented
to hospital to support comprehensive investigations of fatal and
near-fatal anaphylaxis events, and a champion and advocate for
those who live with allergic conditions and need more specialist
practitioners in their corner.
There is a lot more that I could say, but I will concentrate on
two questions that I would like the Minister to answer. First, in
relation to the appointment of an allergy tsar, may I remind the
Minister what his colleague the Minister for Social Care said in
responding to the debate last Thursday? She said:
“There have been calls over recent years—I have heard them echoed
today—for stronger leadership on allergy. I am pleased to take
this opportunity to outline the allergy leadership that we
already have in place. In October 2022, Dr Claire Bethune was
appointed national speciality adviser for specialised immunology
and allergy. Dr Bethune chairs the NHS England clinical reference
group that provides clinical advice and leadership on the
specialised immunology services, and advises on how specialised
services can best be delivered.”—[Official Report, 11 May 2023;
Vol. 732, c. 264WH.]
That is not good enough. That is somebody who has a partial
role—a part-time role—who may well do a good job in their own
field, but who is not an allergy tsar. It is not a single person
who is taking overriding responsibility for allergy.
Let me briefly give a few reasons why an allergy tsar is
essential. The debate and the concern about the lack of a
national lead on allergy has been going on for 20 years. During
that time, clinical outcomes have barely improved, but the number
of hospitalisations has tripled. An adviser who specialises in
immunology and who simply chairs the existing clinical reference
group does not meet the requirements for a national allergy lead.
Allergy is currently managed by too many different professional
groups. The immunologists do not see it as a priority and are
more pathology-focused or laboratory-focused rather than
clinically focused. That means that different specialties manage
allergy disorders differently.
There is not a strong appreciation that allergy leads to severe
symptoms that sometimes lead to death, for example through
anaphylaxis or asthma. Allergy is too often trivialised and
passed down to primary care practitioners, who are inadequately
trained and over-committed in other areas. Allergy is equated
with mild disease, but even hay fever has a much greater impact
on those affected by it than is appreciated. It would be far
better to have a national lead who could also be a clinical lead
and who is an expert in managing allergic disease. Training in
clinical allergy is minimal, whether for specialist clinicians or
for primary care practitioners. We need special efforts to build
this specialty. Finally, deaths from anaphylaxis are appreciably
lower in those countries with a joined-up clinical allergy
service, and in such countries population knowledge about allergy
is more highly developed. The case for why we should have an
allergy tsar is overwhelming and I would like a clear answer from
the Minister today. I do not want a restatement of the current
position, because the current position is clearly inadequate.
The second question for the Minister is whether he or one of his
colleagues, ideally the Secretary of State, would meet the
Natasha Allergy Research Foundation and other interested and
expert parties. I ask for that meeting for three reasons. The
first is that people at the foundation have personal experience,
which to their great pain they have shared publicly, and they
have a great deal to offer to the Government and to the NHS in
explaining the needs of people with allergy.
The second reason is that the foundation and these other
organisations have expertise. I have already indicated that the
work done by the foundation since her death really puts the
Government to shame. It is not just about the passage of
Natasha’s law. The foundation also launched a £2.5 million
Natasha clinical trial across six British university hospital
sites, seeking to prove that everyday food products could be used
in NHS settings as a cheap alternative to expensive
pharmaceuticals, to provide oral immunotherapy treatment for
children and young people. It has also funded bursaries over four
years for students and healthcare professionals at the University
of Southampton on the internationally recognised allergy master’s
degree and PhD courses at this world-leading allergy research
centre. The foundation also organised the global allergy
symposium in September last year, which was hosted by the then
Prince of Wales, now King Charles, at Dumfries House in Scotland,
home of the Prince’s Foundation, to discuss allergy and the
environment, which was attended by 16 of the world’s leading
allergy scientists. That is the work of one family—one
foundation. What have the Government done during that time to
compare to it?
The third reason why a meeting is necessary is that we have
waited too long. I have talked about the musical chairs of
Ministers coming and going. The time is long overdue for a
Minister to sit down and talk seriously to the Natasha Allergy
Research Foundation and other interested parties, and to confront
the issue. I would love to hear the Minister say that the
Government are going forward with an allergy tsar. If he will not
say that, I ask him to say that he will sit down and seriously
listen in detail—he can do so far better than others in this room
can—to the reasons why an allergy tsar is needed. Lives have been
lost, and lives are at stake. As I said at the beginning of my
remarks, the Minister’s response today can make a huge difference
to how we go forward on the issue.
5.25pm
(Sheffield, Brightside and
Hillsborough) (Lab)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairpersonship, Sir Graham.
I thank the hon. Member for Don Valley () and the Petitions Committee
for bringing forward this vital debate. I pay tribute to Owen’s
and Natasha’s families and to all the people who have come to the
debate. I thank them for coming here, because I know how painful
it must be for them. I also thank the many thousands who signed
the petition.
Owen should have turned 24 last month. This should have been a
time of joy and celebration for him and his family. Instead,
because of a tragic and preventable failing, he died less than
300 metres from this building. Diagnosed with severe food
allergies at just six months, Owen was always careful to manage
his allergies and avoid triggering a reaction. On the day that
Owen passed, he took the time to inform the waiting staff of his
allergies, but because of a miscommunication the information was
not passed to the kitchen. That led to his consumption of a
chicken burger that had been marinated in buttermilk. Despite the
presence of one of the most common allergens, dairy, the
information was given only in the small print on the back of the
menu, not alongside the product listing. That is in line with
regulation 5 of the Food Information Regulations 2014, which
requires restaurants to collate allergen information but allows
the information to be delivered “by any means”. The regulations
do not go far enough to inform customers about what allergens
might be a part of their meal. Instead, the onus is unfairly
placed on those with allergies to inform their servers. That
cannot be right.
Since Owen’s untimely death, his family have campaigned
tirelessly for a common-sense change to the legislation, so that
it reads “on the face of a menu” instead of “by any means”. That
would be much like the vegan and VE vegetarian symbols displayed
alongside vegetarian and vegan products in restaurants. I praise
the restaurants that acted unilaterally to display allergen
information prominently on their menus. That is a straightforward
step that could save lives.
The number of people with allergies in the UK has steadily risen,
and an estimated one in three people are affected. Owen’s law
would benefit the millions of people in the UK who are allergic
to a food product or who care for someone who is. Those who
suffer with even a mild allergy know the detrimental impact that
it can have on their quality of life, the stress caused by social
interactions in unfamiliar places, the diligence it takes to
analyse everything that they purchase and consume, and the
constant worry that their allergy might progress and get worse
with little or no warning. It is no wonder that those who are
diagnosed with an allergy are more likely also to be diagnosed
with depression or anxiety.
At the inquest into Owen’s death, the coroner found that a lack
of data collection regarding anaphylactic reactions contributed
to a failure to learn from these tragedies. I am pleased that
some progress has been made on this front with the establishment
of the UK anaphylaxis registry in 2021, but we need to do more to
support people with allergies. The past 20 years have seen
minimal investment in NHS allergy services, and I support calls
for an allergy tsar to advocate on behalf of those with
allergies, alongside an increased number of allergen clinics. We
cannot eliminate allergens entirely, but one thing we can do is
advocate Owen’s law, which would build on Natasha’s law and
ensure that allergen information is displayed alongside food
products in restaurants so that the proper information is
provided in the most accessible manner.
I beg the Minister to ensure that action is taken. No one here
has disagreed today; everyone has been in favour of more
resources being deployed in this area and of having a tsar who
runs a proper strategy and has the proper financial resources to
research why so many people are allergic to various products. Let
us change the legislation. The Minister has the opportunity to
stop many more parents having to face the unthinkable and lose a
child or family member. These deaths can absolutely be avoided
with the right services and legislation in place.
5.30pm
(East Kilbride, Strathaven
and Lesmahagow) (SNP)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Sir Graham. I
congratulate the hon. Member for Don Valley (), who opened the debate on
behalf of the Petitions Committee. It is an extremely important
and very poignant debate for many here today and for people
across the United Kingdom who have been affected by allergies and
inadequate labelling and service provision, which have led to the
tragic deaths that have been relayed by Members today. I thank
the families for the work that they have done and will continue
to do in this space until the allergy tsar is appointed—a
proposal that has been supported by everybody who has spoken so
far.
The hon. Member set the scene perfectly. He asked for the allergy
tsar to be appointed to address the important issues that have
been raised, and he highlighted why it is so vital that menus are
explicit. The point was also made that although people can have a
discussion about their health-related issues at the dinner table,
it is perhaps something that not everybody feels comfortable
doing. That is exactly why it is so important that menus are
explicit and that the issue is taken forward with prominence.
The hon. Member spoke about the numbers of people affected and
why it is so important that we have accurate data, which includes
not only those who have been impacted, but the near miss cases.
Only with accurate data can we understand the scale of the issue
and the prevention measures that are needed. He highlighted some
of the difficulties for the trade in implementing the changes
needed, but, my goodness, when young people’s lives are at stake,
it is vital that those changes are made and that we work together
with industry to ensure that they happen.
I also thank the hon. Member for Dagenham and Rainham (), who highlighted that this is a corporate
responsibility across Government and that we have been waiting
for 20 years, which is far too long, with far too many lives lost
in the interim. We must make sure that the strategy comes
together, that the tsar is appointed and that Government
implement the policies that are so desperately needed.
The hon. Member for Winchester () said that Owen’s law has
already progressed in the Republic of Ireland. That is very
important because it shows that despite the difficulties outlined
at the start, this can be done and progress can be made. This
proposal therefore has to be implemented pragmatically. The hon.
Member for Chesham and Amersham () described her constituent’s
near miss case very eloquently, saying that that is why it is so
important that we have a standardised approach.
The hon. Member for South East Cornwall (Mrs Murray) spoke
eloquently on behalf of her constituents, as she continually does
in this House. She raised the case of Owen and spoke of the
support she has given to the family. She has also ensured that
constituents’ concerns are heard at the highest level. She called
it an absolute priority, and asked the Government for changes to
be made in law.
There were some very good interventions from the hon. Member for
Rutherglen and Hamilton West (), who is no longer in her
place, particularly about the Food Standards Agency having been
too slow to react. The hon. Member for Hammersmith () spoke at length,
reinforcing the need for the tsar to be put in place. His point
that the clinical outcomes have not improved was so important:
whatever has been done so far has perhaps made progress, but it
is just not enough and is not making a difference clinically. He
underlined the point that the current position is therefore
inadequate. Finally, the hon. Member for Sheffield, Brightside
and Hillsborough () said—this sums up the
debate—that common-sense changes are needed, that we must work
together and that no one has disagreed.
I would like to reinforce the asks that have been made of the
Minister. I also think that much more testing should be available
for allergies. I remember being tested, and the nurse saying to
me, “Do you have any allergies, Lisa?” I said no, and I was so
shocked when my arm started coming up with lots of little red
spots and I was told that indeed I had quite a few allergies. We
need to make sure that everybody can have that diagnosis and
testing so that there are not accidental cases in which people
may not even be aware that they have allergies.
As has been said, training for staff in the hospitality sector
and others is so vital in this case. The other thing that I am
very interested in is the digital, technological advancements
that we are making. I would like to hear from the Minister—he can
write to me if he does not have this information today; that
would be perfect—about the blockchain digital technology that I
have heard can be applied to food labelling and distribution.
That technological advancement might help us to move forward in
this case. Finally, I echo everybody’s words and call on the
Minister to please appoint an allergy tsar, because we will be
saving very many people’s lives.
5.37pm
(Denton and Reddish)
(Lab)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Sir Graham. I
am grateful to be responding to the debate on behalf of the
shadow Health and Social Care team this afternoon.
I thank the hon. Member for Don Valley () for his opening
contribution and the compelling way in which he put the case to
the House. I thank my hon. Friends the Members for Dagenham and
Rainham (), for Hammersmith () and for Sheffield,
Brightside and Hillsborough () for their contributions, as
well as the hon. Members for Winchester (), for South East Cornwall (Mrs
Murray) and for Chesham and Amersham (), and the hon. Member for East
Kilbride, Strathaven and Lesmahagow (Dr Cameron), who spoke for
the SNP.
I begin by recognising the courage of Tanya and Emma, who are
observing us from the Gallery. I know the etiquette is not to
refer to the Gallery, but as we have heard, Tanya’s 15-year-old
daughter Natasha died of anaphylaxis after unknowingly consuming
sesame in 2016, and Emma’s daughter Shante died after a severe
allergic reaction to hazelnut in September 2018. To both of you,
I say: I cannot even begin to comprehend the loss that you have
both suffered. We are incredibly grateful to be joined by you
today, and I pay tribute to the exceptional work that you are
doing via the Natasha Allergy Research Foundation. Thanks to the
efforts of yourselves and others, full ingredient and allergen
labelling on pre-packaged food for sale was introduced in October
2021—something that Members on all sides of the House agree is a
vital step in the right direction.
But as has been rightly pointed out, there is still a very long
way to go. The UK is now in the top three in the world for the
highest incidence of allergies, with hospital admissions for
food-induced anaphylaxis tripling over the last 20 years. The
largest increase has been seen in children under 15, among whom
there has been, on average, a 6.9% annual increase in admissions
with a serious allergic reaction. Across all allergy sufferers,
20% live with a severe, debilitating form of their condition. The
case for action could not be clearer.
We are here today to respond to two petitions. The first relates
to Owen’s law, named after Owen Carey, and I pay tribute to Tanya
and Emma. I also pay tribute to Paul, Emma and Owen’s family, who
are in the Public Gallery. As we have heard, Owen was an
18-year-old who tragically died after eating a chicken burger
marinated in buttermilk, to which he was allergic. Despite
checking the menu and making his allergies clear to the server,
Owen collapsed 45 minutes after his meal and could not be
resuscitated. I know that the Food Standards Agency is
considering what steps to take to increase the accuracy of
allergen information on non-pre-packed food, but I would be
grateful if the Minister provided an update on the development of
Owen’s law and on what recent discussions he has had with the FSA
on this vital issue.
The second petition calls for a specific allergy tsar, for which
Members of different parties, but particularly my hon. Friend the
Member for Hammersmith, have put the case so diligently. As the
coroner highlighted following Shante’s death in 2018,
“there is no person with named accountability for allergy
services and allergy provision at NHS England or the Department
of Health as a whole.”
That is unfathomable, and this runs the
“risk that future deaths will occur unless action is taken.”
That warning was repeated recently by the coroner Heidi Connor
following the death of Alexandra Briess in 2021. We have now had
two senior coroners making a similar recommendation to the
Government that someone —whether we want to call them a tsar, a
lead or just someone with named accountability—should be
appointed to take responsibility for allergy services in England.
I would therefore appreciate it if the Minister outlined what
assessment his Department has made or is making about introducing
an allergy lead within NHS England or the Department of Health
and Social Care, particularly in the light of the powerful
interventions that we have heard from patients, bereaved families
and coroners and in all the contributions to today’s debate.
The other point on which I would like to press the Minister is
NHS service provision. Failings in care for allergic disease have
been allowed to fester for far too long. My fear is that with the
NHS under increasing stress in terms of waiting times, waiting
lists and staff vacancies, the problem may well get worse, not
better. What steps is the Minister taking to address the acute
problems for allergy sufferers? The Natasha Allergy Research
Foundation says that with many GPs not receiving training in
allergies, with primary and secondary care services being
disjointed and with a shortage of allergy specialists across the
UK, there is a postcode lottery of care that is costing lives.
That is being compounded by a lack of information, with more than
half of integrated care boards not currently holding data
relating to allergy disease and treatment. That is not
acceptable. I hope the Minister agrees that we need rapid
progress in the delivery of allergy care and the monitoring of
prevalence and treatment.
Finally, on research, what steps are the Government taking to
support potentially game-changing treatments for many allergy
sufferers? I am sure that the Minister will agree that we want to
see a world in which allergy diseases are eradicated. Members
across the Chamber would greatly appreciate any update on
research in the field. We all want improvements in allergy care
and support for those living with allergic diseases. We owe it to
Tanya, Emma, Natasha, Shante, Owen, Alexandra and all the
families who have lost loved ones because of avoidable and
treatable allergic reactions. I sincerely hope that today’s
debate will instigate a step change and that together we can work
towards a future in which allergies are cured and those living
with allergic disease are properly supported.
5.45pm
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Health and Social
Care (Neil O’Brien)
I thank my hon. Friend the Member for Don Valley () for introducing this debate
and for doing an excellent job of setting out the issues, and I
thank all hon. Members who contributed. I found myself making
copious notes; there was a lot for me to take away and work on. I
also thank the thousands of individuals who signed the petitions
that triggered this debate, which show the strength of the desire
and the demand to improve treatment for those who suffer from
allergies. Above all, I thank the victims’ families and friends
who are here in the Public Gallery. I am terribly sorry for your
loss; it was awful to hear about. I pay tribute to you and thank
you on behalf of the Government for all the work that you have
already done to improve safety and make sure that others do not
suffer in the way you have suffered.
I will set out some of the work that is under way on different
aspects of the issue in the Department of Health and Social Care
and the Food Standards Agency. Food businesses are all under the
same legal obligation to provide information at the point of sale
indicating the presence of the 14 major allergens. Natasha’s law,
which the Government introduced in 2021, requires all pre-packed
direct-sale food such as grab-and-go sandwiches to have a label
that shows the ingredients and allergens. That is important in
helping people with allergies to feel confident that they are
choosing safe food.
There are about 2.6 million people with food hypersensitivities
in the UK. As hon. Members have pointed out, that number is
rising. It includes people with food allergies, intolerances and
conditions such as coeliac disease, which my mother suffers from,
so I have some sense of the challenges facing people with that
condition. The Food Standards Agency is working to address the
needs of those consumers so that they can make safe and informed
choices about the food they buy. For people with a potentially
life-threatening reaction to certain foods, that trust is much
more important.
The Carey family are already driving awareness on the issues that
people with life-threatening allergies face. The FSA has met the
Carey family several times in the past few years and it
recognises the positive impact that the Owen’s law campaign is
having. We need to consider changes to the law carefully to
ensure that there are better safety outcomes for allergen
sufferers and to avoid unintended consequences for consumers.
As hon. Members have mentioned, a workshop is taking place at the
start of June with the families and others to look at how we can
go further. To answer the question asked by my hon. Friend the
Member for Winchester (), the FSA team have been over
to Ireland to look at its law and study how it is working. I am
not in a position to make an announcement today, but I am struck
by the fact that everyone involved agrees that there is room to
do better. Nothing is off the table at this point.
There are a number of issues relating to improving labelling for
people with serious allergies. They are not arguments against
doing anything; they are just issues that we must grapple with as
we work out how to make progress. One is how we avoid potentially
dangerous out-of-date information on menus, particularly for
smaller restaurants, which change their ingredients more
frequently. We cannot have false reassurance. When I worked in a
Chinese restaurant, I was often sent out to a supermarket to find
ingredients on the day, and that would often change what was in
what we were serving up. Small businesses absolutely cannot have
out-of-date information on menus.
Will the Minister explain how some small outlets in my
constituency list the allergens on their menus when, as he says,
doing so is an obstacle?
Neil O’Brien
To reiterate what I said at the start of my remarks, I am
mentioning some of the issues that we have to solve, not
presenting them as insuperable obstacles to doing what a lot of
people are calling for.
Another challenge that we have to grapple with, and are grappling
with, is how to avoid some smaller businesses taking away a lot
of choices for people with allergies by simply labelling too many
items as containing allergens. Such businesses may have small
kitchens that work with lots of different products and multiple
allergens. We cannot take away lots of choices for people with
allergies; we want them to have the freedom of choice that
everyone expects to enjoy, but to have safety at the same
time.
Dr Cameron
The Minister is making some good points, but on his last point,
even if some outlets are being over-cautious, surely it is more
sensible to be over-cautious than to put people’s lives at
risk.
Neil O’Brien
That is a perfectly reasonable point. Of course, safety has to
come first; I am merely laying out some of the challenges that we
are grappling with as we think about Owen’s law and how we go
further.
Even as we work on these issues and think about how we go further
in providing information, we are getting on with improving
training and knowledge for people in the food industry. Since
September 2020, 380,000 people have signed up for allergy
training through the FSA, which is a huge improvement in the
provision of information and the correct treatment of people with
severe allergies. Over the past 22 years, the FSA has invested
about £22 million into researching these issues. Its scientific
and social research, which improves the understanding of the
views of those who are affected, of food businesses and of other
key stakeholders, underpins our approach. To underline what I
said a few moments ago, although I am not making an announcement
today, nothing is off the table. We continue to look at and work
on these issues at pace.
Let me turn to some other issues that have been raised in the
debate. We have heard the calls for an allergy tsar, a form of
leadership to advocate on behalf of those with serious allergies
and their families. We already have parts of that leadership role
in place, although, to address the point made by the hon. Member
for Hammersmith (), that responsibility is not
squarely on one individual’s shoulders. We will look closely at
the proposal and at how we get to a more joined-up approach. The
hon. Member asked directly whether I would meet with expert
groups and those representing families who have been affected.
The answer is yes, absolutely. I am extremely keen to meet and
learn from those who have done lots of work on the subject.
It is worth setting out a bit about how the current NHS England
operation works and what it is doing, although I recognise that
that operation is not what those who are campaigning for a single
joined-up tsar are asking for. In NHS England, there is a
clinical reference group chaired by the national specialty
adviser, Dr Claire Bethune. The group provides clinical advice
and leadership on specialised immunology and allergy services.
Its members include clinicians, commissioners, public health
experts and patient and public voice members to try to capture
the insights of those who are most affected by the issues. The
members use their combined knowledge and expertise to advise NHS
England on the optimal arrangements for the commissioning of
specialised services. That advice includes the development of
national standards in the form of service specifications and
policies. As hon. Members know, those are tremendously important
in defining what NHS services must be available.
The CRG is in the process of commencing a review of the current
service specification for specialised allergy services. The
output of that review will be an updated specification that makes
reference to up-to-date guidance and takes account of the very
latest evidence to clearly define the standards of care for
commissioned specialised services, including transition into
adult services.
The CRG is just one tool that we have at our disposal to address
the multifaceted challenges that people with allergies face.
Officials across Government are working with the National Allergy
Strategy Group to consider how we can work more effectively
together through things like an expert advisory group for
allergy. The arguments that I have heard today will strike a
chord with many people listening across the country. I am certain
that it is right that we continue the conversation about how to
work in a more joined-up way in future.
On ensuring that we have the right mix of staff to support people
with allergies, in recent years there has been a 100% fill rate
for doctors going into the two most relevant training pathways,
allergy and immunology. NHS England will continue to identify
priorities for investment in this space, in line with the
expressed service priorities of the NHS across all medical
specialties and the wider workforce. That work will be
complemented by the forthcoming long-term workforce plan that we
have commissioned NHS England to develop for the next 15 years,
which we have committed to publishing shortly. It will include
projections for the number of doctors, nurses and other
professionals that will be needed in five, 10 and 15 years’ time,
taking full account of improvements in productivity and the need
for particular specialisms and skilled people to deal with things
like immunology and allergy.
Most people with an allergy can be cared for in primary care
settings, with services planned and commissioned by their local
ICB. Specialised allergy services, however, are also provided for
patients with the most severe allergic conditions, or those who
have common allergic conditions for which conventional management
has failed or for whom specialised treatments are required. In
the current financial year, 2023-24, those services are jointly
commissioned by NHS England specialised commissioning integrated
care boards, in line with the published service
specification.
All patients have access to those specialised services.
Specialised services are required to be compliant with the
service specification, including the need to have physicians,
dieticians and nurses who are specially trained in allergy or
have had long specialist expertise in the practice of allergy
management and have up-to-date, continuing professional
experience. All that work is serving to improve the lives of
millions of people who have been affected to a greater or lesser
degree by allergy.
There is clearly much more that remains to be done. The
Government and those who have personal experience and great
expertise working together will be central to driving forward
continuing improvements, building on the work that has already
been done and the changes that have been made. In future, we want
to work closely with those who are most affected to improve the
care and service provision for those who have serious allergies,
so that they can live full, meaningful and safe lives.
5.57pm
I hope the petitioners believe that they have heard a good debate
today. We have heard an awful lot from people who understand this
subject. They all want to help to bring everything together and
ensure that the incidents and tragedies that have happened to the
petitioners do not happen again. It seems to me that there is a
lot of work going on, but in many cases it is siloed working, and
a tsar would be able to bring it together. We could pick up the
pace with that and prevent tragedies like those we have discussed
from happening again.
One of the easiest things that restaurants could do would be to
say that all their menus may contain something. Although that
would cover them in some ways, it would take choice away for a
lot of people. We need to get ahead of the issue. We need to look
at it and see what we can do so that there is as much choice for
everybody, and everybody can dine and eat safely. I believe that
a tsar is probably the best way forward to start with. I
appreciate the Minister acknowledging that there is an issue
there; he has made copious amounts of notes to take away and work
through with his Department.
I refer back to the part about personal responsibility. Obviously
there is still work to be done, so to ensure that tragedies do
not happen we must all work together to support and help
individuals who we know suffer and ensure that those questions
get asked if somebody forgets to say something. It is not
something that should be ridiculed; it is massively important to
people. We have a duty to look after everybody in society while
we get food labelling to the place where it should be. May I
finish by thanking the petitioners for all their work, hon.
Members for contributing—I appreciate it, and I am sure it is
appreciated by the petitioners—and the Minister for his
comments?
Question put and agreed to.
Resolved,
That this House has considered e-petitions 585304 and 589716,
relating to food labelling and support for people with allergies.
|