Asked by
To ask His Majesty’s Government what assessment they have made of
the impact of the Energy Profits Levy on energy companies.
The Parliamentary Secretary, HM Treasury () (Con)
The energy profits levy was introduced to respond to
extraordinary profits in the oil and gas sector and includes an
investment allowance to encourage companies to reinvest their
profits in the UK. It has raised £2.8 billion to date and is
expected to raise almost £26 billion by March 2028, in addition
to around £25 billion from the permanent regime over the same
period.
(Lab)
I thank the Minister for her response. We have all seen the
eye-watering profits of the oil and gas companies. The energy
profits levy does not treat all companies the same. Many of the
largest companies pay considerably less, with their profits and
extraction being largely outside the UK. This is not the same for
many of the smaller domestic UK producers. Moreso, the EPL has a
more favourable capital relief than the electricity generator
levy. How can the Government justify a levy that gives favourable
treatment to oil and gas companies over renewable developers?
(Con)
On the noble Lord’s first point, he is right that the energy
profits levy is applied to profits made in the UK or on the UK
continental shelf. That is in line with other profit-based taxes
on companies that operate in the UK and overseas. On the
difference between the energy profits levy and the electricity
generator levy, they are structured in completely different ways.
The headline rates of those two taxes are also completely
different. We have different programmes in place to ensure that
we incentivise continuing investment in our renewables, which is
why we have such a great track record on delivering renewable
energy in the UK.
(LD)
My Lords, one of the peculiarities between the energy profits
levy and the electricity generator levy is the huge difference in
tax relief—80% and 0% respectively, as the noble Lord, Lord
McNicol, alluded to. So why this preferential treatment for the
oil and gas sector? It is not as though we need new sources of
fossil fuels for domestic use—or are the IEA, the IPCC, the vast
bulk of UK scientists and the Government’s own net zero tsar,
, wrong on this?
(Con)
My Lords, I disagree with the noble Baroness that there is
preferential treatment for the oil and gas sector, which faces a
far higher tax rate based on the extraordinary profits it is
benefiting from. That is entirely appropriate. On the investment
incentive, we will continue to need oil and gas as we transition
to net zero. We need to encourage investment into UK oil and gas
fields to help meet that demand, and that is something the
Government will continue to do.
(Lab)
My Lords, in November 2022 the current Chancellor estimated that
the levy would raise £40 billion over six years. Six months
later, the Treasury’s estimate seems to have gone down to £28
billion. What is responsible for that? Is it by any chance the
OBR’s estimate of the increase in oil and gas expenditure by
these oil and gas companies, rather than renewables expenditure,
which they released alongside the Spring Budget, and the
consequential forecast increase in tax relief on those sectors’
windfall tax bills?
(Con)
My Lords, a number of factors affect predicted revenues from the
EPL, not least the high degree of volatility that we have seen in
commodity prices. I say to the noble Lord that, if we do not have
investment allowances in place and if we do not invest in the
future of this industry in the UK, there will be less revenue in
future coming from UK oil and gas fields to contribute to the
Exchequer and our priorities in future.
(Con)
My Lords, following that answer by the Minister, I completely
agree that we still need oil and gas as we transition to net
zero. We cannot have a modern digital economy with high-speed
electric rail running on solar and wind only, as the technology
stands. However, the issue with the levy is that there are
companies that are now saying they will pull investment from the
North Sea. So how do we encourage that investment, given that we
need it in the transition to net zero?
(Con)
My noble friend is right. That is why the Government have always
sought to deliver a balance between a fair return for the UK from
the use of its resources and providing the right conditions to
attract investment in the North Sea. That is why we have the
investment allowance in the EPL that provides an additional
incentive for companies to reinvest profits in the UK. On the
point about environmental impact, the level of tax relief
available for upstream decarbonisation expenditure was increased
from January this year to incentivise companies for the cleaner
production of oil and gas.
(Lab)
My Lords, the Government’s energy levy leaves billions in excess
profits on the table while many households struggle through an
unprecedented cost of living crisis. Only last week BP announced
quarterly profits of over £6 billion while Shell recorded a
quarterly profit increase of 22%, handing a further £5 billion to
shareholders and now allocating more to dividend payments alone
than to its entire investment in renewables. Given that, and with
households and small businesses facing sky-high energy bills, how
well does the Minister think the current levy is working?
(Con)
I welcome the noble Lord to the Front Bench. He referred to
figures that are the global profits of companies. As I have said
to his noble friend, the UK applies its windfall tax to UK
profits, and I think that is the Labour proposal also. Abolishing
the investment allowance would be counter-productive. As I have
said, the UK is still reliant on gas for its energy supply.
Reducing incentives to invest would lead to investors pulling out
of the UK, damaging the economy, causing job losses and leading
to lower future tax revenue—tax revenue that we have used to put
in place unprecedented cost of living support to families, which
is still going out to households at the moment, so that those who
are worried about their bills who are on low incomes and
means-tested benefits can look forward to more support coming
from the Government over the next year.
(Lab)
My Lords, while I am delighted that the Government took Labour’s
advice to introduce the windfall tax that has been mentioned,
there is no doubt that what is happening now, with the
profiteering coming from these energy giants, is insufficient and
is just not working. In fact, I would go as far as to say that it
is almost peanuts when you look at the profits that were
announced last week. So when will the Government fight back
against “greedflation” and bring in a windfall tax with real
teeth in it—something similar to what is happening across the
rest of Europe at the moment?
(Con)
I do not know whether referring to over £50 billion of tax take
as “peanuts” reflects the broader Labour Party’s attitude towards
public finances, but the Government consider that the measures we
have put in place are working well. We need to balance the
rightful approach of taxing the unexpected profits of these
companies while ensuring that we have investment incentives in
place that protect UK jobs and UK energy security.
(Con)
Does my noble friend have any figures for the amount of money
when profits are made that goes into pension funds and therefore
to people who are earning pensions?
(Con)
My noble friend makes an important point. Investors in these
companies can come from all sources, including pension funds. It
is right and proper that they think about the return they get
from their investments when making those decisions.
(CB)
My Lords, I declare my interests. May I take the Minister back to
her fundamental argument that the electricity generator levy,
which applies to renewable energy, is completely different from
the energy profits levy? She has argued strongly that the latter
needs the additional investment allowance to encourage investment
in oil and gas, but somehow the electricity generator levy does
not need that additional investment incentive. Is she absolutely
sure that that is true and is she in any way concerned about the
report that we may lose some offshore wind projects because of
it?
(Con)
The electricity generator levy reflects a historic approach to
how we pay for our electricity. New electricity contracts are
often done, for example, under the contracts for difference
process, which is not subject to this levy. We have also put in
place a wide range of other measures to support investment in
renewables. That is why we have such a great track record and why
I have every faith that we will meet our stretching targets on
decarbonisation in future.