Asked by
To ask His Majesty’s Government, further to the Written Answer by
on 31 March
(HL6792), what progress has been made at the United Nations to
amend headlamp aiming criteria so as to reduce the risk of glare
from LED and other light sources.
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department for
Transport () (Con)
My Lords, the United Nations Economic Commission for Europe’s
road vehicle lighting expert group met at the end of April and
agreed changes to the headlamp aim requirements to reduce the
occurrence of glare. This includes the introduction of mandatory
automatic headlamp levelling systems for all types of headlamps
in new vehicles, most likely from 1 September 2027.
(Lab)
I thank the Minister for that Answer, which deals only with the
aiming of the lights and not the lights themselves, and for the
meeting that she had with me. However, the Department for
Transport seems to think that, because no deaths have been
recorded, there is not a problem. In fact, the College of
Optometrists reports that nearly all their members are seeing
patients presenting with what they think is a problem with the
eyes, to discover it is the lights from cars that are at fault
rather than their sight. Many people are in fact choosing not to
drive at night because of that. Since my last Oral Question, I
have heard from cyclists saying they have a problem, and from
motorcyclists who say that, when it is wet, there is a real
dazzle with the visors. There are three-quarters of a million
cars retrofitted with unregulated LED lights; that is a real road
safety issue. Could the Minister perhaps get the department on to
the front foot, to get some research done and get some action? We
should not wait for accidents and deaths before we do something
about this problem.
(Con)
I am delighted to let the noble Baroness know that the department
has already done research in this area. The 2018 research
concluded that overall there are no direct adverse health effects
from LED lights in normal use. However, the crux of all this—the
noble Baroness did point it out—is that there is no evidence of
any causal link at all to headlight glare causing accidents.
Glare is subjective; sometimes it can be caused by poor eye
health, which can be corrected in certain circumstances, but we
cannot eliminate glare altogether, because of course having
headlights pointing in the right direction is essential for road
safety.
(CB)
My Lords, can the noble Baroness tell us whether and how the
issue of headlamp glare is addressed as part of the MoT testing
process? I understand that many newer headlamps may not be
properly checked for aim during an MoT inspection because the
equipment used by MoT testing stations to accurately measure aim
does not work with the latest high-intensity headlamps. What
steps might the Government take to remedy this, or indeed to
include brightness as well as aim in the MoT testing
criteria?
(Con)
I will have to take that back to the department. It is not an
issue I have come across previously. Headlight aim and bulbs are
checked at the annual MoT test but, obviously, if there is not
the correct equipment to do that we need to do something about
it. Again, I will have to take that to the department; it is not
something that has previously been brought to my attention.
(Lab)
My Lords, if the Government intend to bring in some regulations
on glare, could it be extended to the glare from cycle
headlights? Some of them are very bright and dazzle you at night.
In this House many noble Lords talk about cycles with no lights,
which is just as dangerous, but perhaps she could just look at
the new lights that some cyclists use and check that they conform
as well.
(Con)
I am not aware that there are regulations around the use of
bright lights for cyclists. I agree that they could indeed cause
glare and be a road safety issue and, again, I will take that
back to the department.
(LD)
The noble Baroness is urging action by the Government on a road
safety issue, and another area where we need action is on
e-scooters. Research by the Parliamentary Advisory Council for
Transport Safety shows that between 2019 and 2021 we went from
zero accidents involving injury to roughly 1,400, and reports by
A&E services show that a disproportionate number involve head
injuries. We have been promised a major transport Bill for four
years now, so are we going to get that before the general
election? As we have illustrated this afternoon, there are a
number of road safety issues that need including in it. If not,
do we put it down as another broken government promise?
(Con)
The Government are of course looking very carefully at the
evidence around e-scooters, are considering policy, and will
bring proposals before Parliament when parliamentary time
allows.
The (CB)
My Lords, I also thank the Minister for seeing some of us about
these concerns. Can she say whether headlights causing glare
potentially have a disruptive effect on wildlife, including
mammals and bees, as is now being argued for
daylight-approximating LED street lighting in locations where
efforts are being made to reduce such lighting to enhance the
environment?
(Con)
I am not aware that there are specific concerns around wildlife
and headlights. There are certainly sometimes concerns about
where wildlife crosses a road very frequently, and there is a
road sign now available to warn drivers that this may be the
case. If the noble Earl has any evidence, I would be very happy
to see it.
Baroness Taylor of Stevenage (Lab)
My Lords, in the past decade the number of passenger cars
produced in the UK has declined from over 1.5 million to fewer
than 800,000. Growing the UK’s motor manufacturing industry would
not only provide a real boost to the economy and create jobs but
also allow the Government to support the production of
better-quality and well-regulated vehicles, including specifying
safety features such as headlamp criteria. What steps are the
Government taking to support the car manufacturing industry?
(Con)
Actually, what the Government are doing to support the car
manufacturing industry is working in lockstep with our colleagues
internationally. As the noble Baroness will know, many of the
regulations around type approval for cars come from this
international community—about 75%. The extent to which we are
able to work with our friends and neighbours in other countries
on road safety issues means that this provides the level playing
field that the UK automotive manufacturing sector needs.
(Con)
Does my noble friend agree that one of the curses of the age is
light pollution? It is very difficult to go anywhere and enjoy
natural evening light. While I accept the importance of safety
features on vehicles, can the Government also do something to
encourage developing more areas which are not polluted by
light?
(Con)
That is slightly beyond my brief but, from a transport and a car
perspective, one of the reasons why we have dipped headlights is
to prevent light pollution for other drivers and for pedestrians
et cetera using the roads
(LD)
My Lords, my noble friend specifically asked a question about
safety and e-scooters; I do not think it was dealt with in a way
that the House might want. The figures I have are 1,352
collisions—compared with 460 in 2020—1,434 people injured and 10
killed, all of whom were e-scooter riders. That is Department for
Transport information. Could the Minister answer the question
about what is being done to improve road safety for pedestrians,
cyclists and other road users?
(Con)
I am unable to say much more then I said before. I welcome the
stats that the noble Baroness gave the House. The Government are
also looking at the evidence that they are collating and are
considering policy. We will make a decision as to how we take
forward these new forms of transport in due course.