The Minister for Crime, Policing and Fire (Chris Philp) I beg to
move, That the Committee has considered the Draft, Police, Crime,
Sentencing and Courts Act 2022 (Extraction of information from
electronic devices) (Amendment of Schedule 3) Regulations 2023. It
is a pleasure, as always, to serve under your chairmanship, Mr
Vickers. In recent years, the extraction of information from
electronic devices has become a pivotal part of preventing,
detecting, investigating...Request free
trial
The Minister for Crime, Policing and Fire ()
I beg to move,
That the Committee has considered the Draft, Police, Crime,
Sentencing and Courts Act 2022 (Extraction of information from
electronic devices) (Amendment of Schedule 3) Regulations
2023.
It is a pleasure, as always, to serve under your chairmanship, Mr
Vickers. In recent years, the extraction of information from
electronic devices has become a pivotal part of preventing,
detecting, investigating and prosecuting crime. With around 90%
of all crime having a digital element, digital forensics has
become crucial in criminal investigations.
For that reason, the Home Office led on the introduction of the
extraction of information powers in the Police, Crime, Sentencing
and Courts Act 2022, which came into force in November last year.
Those powers established a statutory basis for extracting
information from electronic devices, ensuring that information is
extracted only for specific purposes, when necessary and
proportionate, and where relevant to a reasonable line of
inquiry.
In relation to victims and witnesses, there were various specific
safeguards to ensure that information is extracted only once an
individual has volunteered their device and agreed to the
extraction of information from it. Additional measures were
included to ensure that victims and witnesses are notified in
writing of what information is being sought and how it will be
used. They are also provided with various rights to refuse
permission, if appropriate.
Those powers can be exercised by the authorised persons named in
schedule 3 to the Act. The schedule is divided into three parts,
which set out the different purposes for which authorised persons
may exercise the powers. It is crucial that only authorised
persons can extract information for the purposes set out in the
schedule.
Those listed under part 1 of the schedule can exercise these
powers for the purposes set out in section 37 of the Act, which
concerns the investigation of crime, and for the purposes set out
in section 41, which concerns an investigation or inquest into a
person’s death. Those listed under part 2 may extract information
only for the purposes of section 37. Part 3 lists the authorised
persons who can extract the information only for the specific
purpose under section 37(1), which is preventing, detecting,
investigating or prosecuting a crime.
The draft regulations set out the requirement to move the Royal
Navy Police, the Royal Military Police and the Royal Air Force
Police from part 2 of schedule 3 to part 1 of schedule 3. That
means that those forces can extract information not just for the
purposes of section 37, but also for the purposes of section
41—supporting an investigation or inquest into a person’s death.
I am sure the Committee would agree that, where a person has died
in unexplained circumstances, it is crucial that the various
military police forces are able to investigate the death as
thoroughly as their civilian equivalents. That is what these
simple regulations aim to provide for.
(North East Bedfordshire)
(Con)
The Minister has given a very clear exposition, but it does
prompt a question as to why those police forces were not given
the powers in the original legislation passed in 2022 and why
there is a need for the change now.
In answer to my hon. Friend, I am afraid that I do not recall the
details of the debates at the time. I am not convinced that I was
a Minister at the time this went through the Bill Committee,
although I may have been—in fact, I may have been a Ministry of
Justice Minister, and a Home Office Minister may have taken this
through the Committee.
(Croydon Central) (Lab)
You were at Justice.
The shadow Minister seems to agree with my recollection. I
hesitate to delve into the history of this, but I think it is
clear that this simple move is sensible, and I hope it commands
the agreement of the whole Committee.
6.05pm
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Vickers. As
the Minister stated, this relatively straightforward statutory
instrument adds a new group of authorised persons—members of the
Royal Navy Police, Royal Military Police and Royal Air Force
Police—to part 1 of schedule 3 to the Police, Crime, Sentencing
and Courts Act. The Opposition will not vote against it
today.
The regulations give those authorised persons the power to
extract information from a device, when the user has died, for
the purpose of an investigation or inquest into the person’s
death, as well as for the purpose of investigating crime and
safeguarding others. When we debated the Police, Crime,
Sentencing and Courts Bill—the Minister is correct that he was
the Justice Minister and therefore debated some aspects of the
Bill and not others—we had extensive debates about the changes it
introduced, and Labour tabled several amendments that would have
placed new checks on the police powers to extract data from
electronic devices. We agreed with the direction of travel of the
Bill, but we were concerned about vulnerable people and about
those who do not want to hand over phones and the like because of
the intrusive nature of such searches.
We spent months urging the Government to protect victims,
particularly victims of rape and sexual abuse, from painful and
often unnecessary intrusion into their lives by the mining of
their phone data. In the end, the Government accepted some vital
changes that mean that the police officer or other authorised
person must “reasonably believe” that information stored on the
device is relevant to a “reasonable line of enquiry”. It took the
Government time to accept those amendments, but they did so in
the end.
In this case, of course, the situation is slightly different as
the owner of the device is deceased, but that person must still
be treated with respect and we have to ensure that we are not too
intrusive in how we mine people’s devices. I would like an
assurance from the Minister that information will be used
sensitively, because people deserve that even after they have
passed away.
Serious problems remain about the lack of resources available to
the police when it comes to carrying out data extraction from
electronic devices—in this case, when a user has died. We know
that there is a real problem with a lack of digital resources in
forces. Just last year, a report by His Majesty’s inspectorate of
constabulary and fire and rescue services found a raft of errors
in this area. The inspectorate found
“delays...so egregious that victims were being failed”,
and a system of digital forensic examination that was “slow” and
“ineffective”, and where
“the needs of victims were rarely taken into consideration”.
It noted that
“there are no set standards or oversight services”,
with victims let down by a postcode lottery.
At a time when most, if not quite all, crimes have some form of
digital footprint—the Minister gave us the stats—the delays,
oversights and lack of professionalism exposed by the
inspectorate are unacceptable.
If I can drag the hon. Lady back to the regulations we are
discussing today, they are about expanding the number of people
who can extract information from devices. She has listed a litany
of concerns, but can she answer the question that I put to the
Minister, as I think she was involved in the scrutiny of the
Bill? Why did Labour agree to this separation and why has she
changed her mind today?
I thank the hon. Gentleman for his intervention. I suspect that
it was an oversight in the legislative drafting that is being
rectified, and I would rather it was rectified than not. The
emphasis in our discussions on the Bill was on living people,
particularly rape victims, who were loth to give up their
electronic devices but who needed to. We needed to ensure that
the legislative framework was right for them so that they could
give up their devices in a way that they were prepared to and
that protected them. We did not have a debate about inquests or
about cases where people had passed away, but clearly that is
increasingly a consideration as digital devices are used more and
more.
Specifically on the Royal Military Police, the inspectorate
recommended in a separate investigation that a formal digital
investigation strategy should be introduced, because:
“RMP investigators don’t give enough consideration to how digital
investigation would help the specific cases they are working
on”.
That statement does not give me much confidence. I would like
some reassurance from the Minister that he has faith that
extending these powers to these forces will have tangible
positive impacts on inquests and on the investigation of crime.
Does he have evidence to suggest that the situation in the
military forces, covering the Army, Navy and RAF, is any better
than in the 43 territorial forces?
On recommendation 5 of the HMICFRS report, what progress has been
made on reviewing digital forensics budgets and funding? I note
that a formal consultation has not taken place, but the views of
three military forces were captured on why this amendment is
necessary; I do not know whether the Minister can share any of
those findings with us. I would be grateful if he indicated when
the code of practice for the extraction of information from
electronic devices is likely to be updated, and if he explained
how the forces that this statutory instrument relates to—the RAF
Police, Royal Military Police and Royal Navy Police—will be
trained to exercise their new powers, but we will not be
objecting to this legislation today.
6.11pm
There was quite a lot there that probably went a little beyond
the strict scope of the regulations, but I will try to answer
some of the hon. Lady’s questions. The Government accept the
point that digital evidence needs to be extracted from witnesses
and victims sensitively, only where necessary and in a carefully
managed way. There is evidence that it has been a been a barrier
to rape and serious sexual violence prosecutions and
investigations, in particular. We have tried to move things
forward since the debates that took place more than a year ago.
For example, with the commitment to get witnesses’ and victims’
phones back within 24 hours—particularly in the case of rape
victims—we have tried to remove that barrier.
The Government are working on the digital evidence programme,
which is designed to make sure that police forces have the
relevant capabilities. We have created a RASSO—rape and serious
sexual offences—technology partnership board to make sure that
the technology and extraction capability and approaches are as
good as they possibly can be.
In relation to investment, which the hon. Lady asked about, we
want to make sure that digital forensics have the investment and
the capabilities in place. We have invested in the creation of a
forensics capability network, sponsored by the Home Office, and
in the digital forensics programme, which is located in the
Police Digital Service, to support police forces through
automation, to better safeguard victims’ privacy and to make sure
that new technology is explored and taken up as quickly as it can
be. As the Royal Navy Police, Royal Military Police and Royal Air
Force Police take up these new powers, they will do so in the
same way as they already do with the section 37 powers, so the
various requirements around sensitivity and necessity apply.
Since we are clearly talking in this case about people who are
deceased, it is a slightly different set of considerations. None
the less, proper sensitivity needs to be displayed.
On the question about the code, we intend to update it in due
course. That will not be done immediately, but work is under way
to make sure that the code is updated so it is as effective as it
possibly can be. I should also add that in relation to rape and
serious sexual assault, which is one of the main areas of concern
here, there is a rape review taskforce chaired by the Justice
Secretary and attended by the Home Office, the Crown Prosecution
Service and the Attorney General’s Office. That rape review
steering group meets regularly to try to increase the number of
rape prosecutions, and a key element of it is considering
questions around digital forensics and things such as the 24-hour
commitment on getting a rape victim’s phone back to them. I
assure the Committee and the shadow Minister that these issues
are very much at the front of our minds on an ongoing basis,
particularly in the RASSO context.
I hope that addresses most, if not all, the questions that have
been asked, and I repeat my previous commendation of these
regulations to the Committee.
Question put and agreed to.
|