Moved by Baroness Brown of Cambridge That the Grand Committee takes
note of the Report from the Science and Technology Committee
Nature-based solutions for climate change: rhetoric or reality?
(2nd Report, Session 2021-22, HL Paper 147). Baroness Brown of
Cambridge (CB) My Lords, I start by declaring my interest as chair
of the adaptation committee of the Climate Change Committee. I am
delighted to introduce for debate this Science and Technology
Committee...Request free trial
Moved by
That the Grand Committee takes note of the Report from the
Science and Technology Committee Nature-based solutions for
climate change: rhetoric or reality? (2nd Report, Session
2021-22, HL Paper 147).
(CB)
My Lords, I start by declaring my interest as chair of the
adaptation committee of the Climate Change Committee.
I am delighted to introduce for debate this Science and
Technology Committee report on nature-based solutions for climate
change on behalf of my noble friend , the former chair of the
committee. I thank all the committee members who participated in
the report; our expert adviser, Professor , of the University of Aberdeen;
and particularly the committee staff at the time, George Webber,
Thomas Hornigold and Cerise Burnett-Stuart.
Nature-based solutions form a critical element of the
Government’s net-zero strategy. We will need the carbon
sequestration services of new forests and woodlands, restored
peatlands, and new wetlands and marine environments if we are to
take enough carbon dioxide out of the atmosphere to get us to
net-zero greenhouse gas emissions by 2050. We may also need to
grow significant new areas of bioenergy crops to enable us to
generate energy with carbon capture and storage, and to
contribute to decarbonising aviation through the production of
sustainable aviation fuels. All of that implies significant
change to the way in which we use land. The CCC estimates that
forest and woodland cover will need to increase from about 14%
today to 18% by 2050, supported by major changes to what and how
we farm. If we get it right, this will lead to healthier
diets.
Our inquiry was important, but it was also timely, because the
replacement of the common agricultural policy—following our
departure from the European Union—by the development and
introduction of the new environmental land management scheme is
the key opportunity to support farmers properly to deliver the
changes that we will need, while maintaining their livelihoods
and enhancing our precious countryside.
The inquiry considered how protecting, managing and restoring
natural ecosystems and agricultural land can reduce net
greenhouse gas emissions and provide co-benefits such as
adaptation to the changing climate, examining issues of both
science and policy. The inquiry ran from July 2021 to January
2022, and we heard from a wide range of witnesses, including
scientists with domain expertise on different types of
nature-based solutions. We heard from stakeholders such as the
National Farmers’ Union, the National Trust and the RSPB, as well
as government agencies, including Natural England, the Forestry
Commission and the Environment Agency, that deliver nature-based
solutions. We also heard from government witnesses including
civil servants, the Defra Chief Scientific Adviser, and the
Environment Minister at the time, the noble Lord, of Richmond Park.
Overall, we found that the Government have ambitious, even
laudable, plans for nature-based solutions. There are headline
commitments to plant 30,000 hectares of trees a year by 2025 and
to restore 280,000 hectares of peatland by 2050. These sit
alongside the ambitious reductions in land use emissions needed
to achieve net zero. The scale of this ambition to restore nature
is a major and essential component of reaching net zero, and
could provide significant co-benefits for biodiversity, human
health and well-being, and adaptation to climate change. We were
pleased to see the Government lobby for the inclusion of
nature-based solutions in the COP 26 decision text, as we advised
in a letter to the president of COP 26.
However, in our report we were sceptical and concerned about
whether the current level of policy support is sufficient to see
these plans realised. There are strong headwinds that need to be
overcome to deliver effective nature-based solutions. There are
scientific uncertainties around how much carbon these approaches
will sequester, and on what timescales. The Government have
neither assessed the skills gap nor provided sufficient training
to ensure that nature-based solutions can be deployed at
scale.
There remains huge uncertainty about the details of the policies
that are set to incentivise nature-based solutions, such as the
new environmental land management schemes. More funding is likely
to be required in key areas, from basic scientific research to
funding for public delivery bodies that will have to regulate and
support these projects. Many land managers feel disengaged and
uncertain about the changes they will need to make, but their
support is critical for these schemes to be delivered.
The Government are relying on private finance to help to fund
nature-based solutions by creating markets for carbon credits and
other ecosystem services that nature-based solutions can provide.
However, these markets exist only on a small scale at present,
and the regulatory infrastructure needed to ensure that they work
as intended and genuinely deliver carbon removal over time does
not yet exist.
Finally, we found that the Government have not said anywhere how
they will balance the many competing demands on UK land. The
committee was seeking evidence that the Government have a
coherent plan for meeting these demands; we did not hear it. In
short, although the Government’s ambitions for nature-based
solutions are admirable and we support them, our report found
that there is a clear and present danger that they will not be
achieved, and that this could undermine the target of net zero by
2050, as well as undermine the agricultural sector with a failed
transition.
Our committee made a number of recommendations to assist the
Government in delivering their ambitions. Among these, we wanted
the Government to invest further in researching the storage
potential of nature-based solutions, especially for soils and in
the marine environment. We recommended that the budgets of public
delivery bodies such as Natural England and the Environment
Agency be increased to be commensurate with the increased
workload of deploying nature-based solutions at the scale of the
government targets.
We asked the Government to provide urgent clarity on the nature
of environmental land management schemes and how they will
support nature-based solutions among their other objectives. We
recommended that communication with land managers be improved,
and the introduction of a dedicated advisory service for land
managers to help them to navigate ELMS.
We made a number of recommendations about private financing for
nature-based solutions, including that existing standards such as
the woodland and peatland codes incorporate additional value for
ecosystem services and co-benefits beyond carbon sequestration.
We asked for clearer regulatory standards for emerging carbon
markets and for the Government to create or sponsor an
independent central broker to allow stacked and blended finance
from the private and public sector and for a combination of
different projects.
Finally, as with much in climate change policy, we wanted to see
a plan that added up. Specifically, we wanted the Government to
develop an overall land use strategy that explained how
trade-offs in land use would be managed to deliver nature-based
solutions as well as other important targets.
The Government’s response to our report was generally positive,
and I warmly thank the Defra civil servants involved for their
detailed and helpful work. The response was characterised well by
our evidence session with the noble Lord, , who responded to most of
our lines of questioning by agreeing with the concerns and points
raised by the committee.
Among the concrete responses, we heard that the Government would
publish more detailed information on the environmental land
management scheme later in 2022. More detail has now been
published on the sustainable farming incentive, launching new
standards for payments, and further pilot projects for the
landscape recovery scheme will be awarded in the next two
years.
The Government said that Defra would conduct “spatially explicit
analysis” on land use to assess the level and type of changes in
land use in England indicated by government commitments, which
would help to manage trade-offs in land uses. They said that the
need for a land use strategy would be kept under review as work
progressed in 2022.
The Government committed to engaging with land managers but
stopped short of our recommendation to introduce a new advisory
service to help them navigate ELMS. Farmers are now referred to a
range of local organisations that can provide advice. However,
evidence from stakeholder groups such as the National Farmers’
Union suggests that farmers are still struggling with the details
of the schemes. The Government said they will work with
stakeholders to develop a
“more stable and comprehensive standards framework … later this
year”—
that is, in 2022, for carbon and other ecosystem services, to
“help ensure their use is beneficial for the climate, people, and
nature.”
Section 6.5.1 of Chris Skidmore’s excellent review, Mission Zero:
Independent Review of Net Zero, published this year, urges the
Government to set up a regulator for carbon credits and offsets,
and indeed repeats many of our recommendations in this area,
suggesting that the problems are not yet resolved.
A year has passed since we published our report on nature-based
solutions; we are a year closer to the net-zero target, and
nature needs time to act. Trees take 20 or 30 years to grow and
deliver their carbon sequestration potential, so action is
urgent; we have to act now, and we do not seem to have seen much
progress.
Let me illustrate my point with a few examples. In the
environmental land management scheme, only the sustainable
farming incentive has launched, which is the most basic payment
scheme and the closest to the previous area-based payments. Local
nature recovery and landscape recovery are still in pilot stages,
and the old scheme of countryside stewardship is still being
used. We hear that there are problems getting sufficient
enrolment in schemes. Only 2.4% of eligible farmers—2,000 out of
82,000—applied for the sustainable farming incentive, which was
intended to be the simplest ELMS and the one that most land
managers would apply to. The Government have had to boost the
payment rates to try to get more farmers to apply.
The House of Lords ad hoc Committee on Land Use in England, in
its final report, published in December 2022, echoes our
recommendations, saying:
“Create a Land Use Commission tasked with producing a land use
framework. The framework must consider several factors, including
food, nature, housing needs and the push for net zero.”
It continues by saying that we should
“provide immediate clarity on the Environmental Land Management
Schemes … programme, ending the uncertainty which is causing
serious problems for effective land use.”
We are hearing increased reports that the UK will miss its
tree-planting targets, and there are similar stories about
Scotland’s peat and the Scottish Government’s nature restoration
targets. The Government missed their legal deadline for setting
the first batch of targets under the Environment Act 2021, and
there are concerns that the post-Brexit sunsetting of regulations
will remove vital environmental regulations. These examples serve
to underline that much more action is needed, and it is needed
urgently.
To conclude, I ask the Minister to respond to the following
questions. What are the Government going to do to ensure that we
catch up with our tree-planting targets, given the shortage of
nurseries, plug plants, skilled people and the lack of a clear
land use strategy which addresses the trade-offs—for example,
between food and carbon sequestration? The current markets for
nature-based solutions have been described as the “wild west”,
given a lack of strong governance and standards. Greenwashing is
rife, while uncertainty about the level and consistency of
revenues of certain ecosystems services is undermining the
confidence of some investors. What discussions are the Government
having about a strong, independent co-ordinating body to
scrutinise and set national standards for nature-based solutions
in the UK? This is an area where UK action could show real
leadership and give confidence to corporates to fund these
critical developments.
As you might expect, we are very fond of numbers on the Science
and Technology Select Committee. We like sums that add up and
measures that can be quantified. How will the Government make the
numbers add up? The funding required for nature recovery in the
UK is estimated to be between £4 billion and £10 billion per
annum. Total government spending is about £650 million per annum,
with aspirations for private sector investment to match this. How
are we going to fill the gap?
Finally, after a catalogue of good intentions but missed targets
and deadlines, what are we going to do to instil a sense of
urgency and catch up with the delivery of this critical and
laudable ambition? I beg to move.
1.15pm
(CB)
My Lords, I thank the chair of the Science and Technology
Committee, the noble Baroness, Lady Brown, for leading this
debate. Her expertise in and knowledge of all areas of climate
change and the road to net zero are unsurpassed. Like her, I
thank the members of the committee, the committee staff and our
specialist adviser, Professor Pete Smith FRS, professor of soils
and global change at the University of Aberdeen. Due to Covid
restrictions, the whole inquiry was conducted virtually, and we
have yet to meet our specialist adviser—he certainly looked very
colourful on the images we saw—but we hope to meet him some
time.
The noble Baroness, Lady Brown, has so eloquently and effectively
covered the issues raised in our inquiry that I intend to confine
my comments to the contribution that better management of
peatlands in the UK can make to climate change and net zero.
The UK’s natural environment is degraded due to decades of
neglect and uncontrolled planning, and it has led to a decline in
biodiversity, resulting in the UK being the worst country in the
G7 and 12th in the world for biodiversity. There are many reasons
for the decline in biodiversity, but the State of Nature report
identified land use as the single biggest driver.
The International Union for Conservation of Nature estimates that
only 20% of UK peatland is in a near-natural state. A recent
assessment found that UK peatland is so degraded that it is
emitting more CO2 than it is sequestering. The UK is one of the
top 10 nations in the world for peatland area, accounting for 9%
to 15% of Europe’s peatland and around 13% of the world’s blanket
bog.
The partially decomposed organic matter of peatlands makes them
the most carbon-dense terrestrial systems on the planet, storing
approximately 550 gigatonnes of carbon, which is twice the amount
stored in the biomass of all vegetation in a far smaller land
area. When disturbed, it releases carbon. In a near-natural
state, UK peatland is estimated to hold 11,700 metric tonnes of
CO2. Although the precise figure is not known, there is consensus
that peatlands are the UK’s largest natural carbon stores,
holding 40% of UK soil carbon. Causes of degradation are drainage
for agriculture, forestry, air pollution, fires and extraction of
peat. Disturbing the peat releases carbon.
It is obvious that restoring peatland should be a matter of
urgency. Priorities for policy should be to protect intact
peatlands and to restore degraded peatlands. The Government’s
peatland code is a good initiative and could ensure good
practice.
I have the following questions for the Minister. First, lowland
peat used for agriculture accounts for 7% of UK peatland but is
responsible for 32% of all peatland emissions. Will the
Government commit to developing specific targets for lowland peat
in their net-zero strategy?
Secondly, planting trees on peaty soils results in carbon
emissions. The Forestry Commission’s current policy allows free
planting of trees on such soil types. Should the Government
require the Forestry Commission to keep its policy of planting
trees on peatland under review?
Thirdly, while the Government’s ambition to restore peatlands is
admirable, a skills shortage needs addressing —the noble
Baroness, Lady Brown, mentioned that several times. What plans do
the Government have to assess the skills needed and for the
provision of training of those undertaking peatland
restoration?
Fourthly, what plans do the Government have for long-term
monitoring of the Peatland Code to assess its success in
greenhouse gas reduction, carbon sequestration and enhanced
biodiversity status?
Fifthly, peatland restoration delivers a range of co-benefits.
Will the Government commit to establishing a research programme
to quantify the co-benefits of projects under the Peatland Code
and to ensuring that payments for other ecosystem services are
included within current and future carbon codes?
Restoration of peatlands should be a matter of urgency if the
Government are to meet their net-zero targets. If done
successfully, it will deliver more than carbon capture on the
road to net zero.
1.20pm
(Con)
My Lords, it is a pleasure to take part in this debate, as it was
to be a member of the inquiry into nature-based solutions. It is
a real pleasure to follow both the committee’s current chair and
its recent past chair. I do not know what this means for my
future preferment, but No. 3 is certainly a good place to be.
I will cover three areas and have three asks. Those areas are
trees, seas and bees. In our inquiry, we rightly spent a lot of
time on trees and woodland. Does my noble friend the Minister
agree that it is important to consider trees and woodland not
just at the beginning of their lifecycle—planting—important
though that is, but across the story of that most vital resource,
post harvest and right the way through its lifecycle? Would he
also comment on the current situation regarding planting trees on
peat and pseudo-peat boglands, and any current research on it? We
spent a lot of time on this in the committee and there seemed at
times to be some cloudy thinking around it.
We concluded that much more attention needs to be paid to the
potential role that the seas and oceans can play. A whole blue
marine programme fully to assess all the elements that the ocean
could contribute to nature-based solutions would make a great
deal of sense. Does my noble friend agree that a whole lot more
work still needs to be done? It is extraordinary that we have the
excellent “Blue Planet” on the TV but possibly not enough focus
on this area when it comes to nature-based solutions. Similarly,
does he agree that a lot of work could be done beyond what our
inquiry covered in partnership with the British Overseas
Territories, a number of whose environments could be particularly
beneficial for ocean-based, nature-based solutions?
Bees were not covered by our report, but it is a universal truth
that everything we can do in nature-based solutions must be good
for bees. As we know, what is good for the bees is good for us
all.
I turn to my asks. Does my noble friend the Minister agree that
not only do we need a universal, horizontal approach to
nature-based solutions but that it must go across all government
departments? For example, I and others put down amendments in
Committee and on Report of the UK Infrastructure Bank Bill to put
nature-based solutions in that Bill, to give them the necessary
level of importance in the potential investments that the UKIB
would make. The Government did not accept those amendments. Does
my noble friend regret that? Does he see that it would be
important and a positive force to move forward on that in
future?
My second ask echoes the comments of the noble Baroness, Lady
Brown, on ELMS. Does my noble friend the Minister agree that we
still need increased clarity and communication around ELMS? For a
lot of farmers and landowners, it seems clear that it is
difficult to see the wood for the ELMS.
Finally, as has already been mentioned by the noble Baroness,
Lady Brown, in a sense all of this goes to the critical
importance of a universal, coherent, connected land use strategy.
Does the Minister agree that we all need to focus more, and that
the Government need to put more effort into bringing this
about?
So much focus, attention and commentary is rightly around net
zero, but as our report demonstrates, net zero is an important
part but it is not the whole story. It has to be seen alongside
nature-based solutions because even if we reach net zero, we
still need, and should welcome, the benefits that nature-based
solutions should bring. When she sums up, will my noble friend
the Minister give full-throated support for everything that the
Government can, should and will do on nature-based solutions?
1.25pm
(Lab)
My Lords, it is a pleasure to follow the noble Lord. I add my
thanks to the noble Baroness, Lady Brown, the committee and the
staff for having produced the report we are debating today. I pay
tribute to the previous chair, the noble Lord, . I did not know until he spoke a
moment ago that this is a wholly Covid-based report. I think this
is the first debate I have taken part in that is based on a
Covid-only investigation.
It was only yesterday that the Lord Privy Seal came to the
Dispatch Box in the House and moved a Motion that will allow the
Government to take priority over business on Thursdays from now
until the end of Session —which is many months away—in order to
allow more time in part, he said, to enable debates to take place
on Select Committee reports because of the backlog that builds
up. That is true in this case, as it has been more than a year
since the report was published.
This Select Committee, which one day I hope to join, has produced
an interesting and worthwhile report, and I do not need to add
anything to the excellent introduction provided by the noble
Baroness, Lady Brown. More generally, I think it is important
that the House as a whole grasps that one of the committee’s most
important conclusions is that there remain “significant
scientific uncertainties” about not only the nature of this
report but in general. Life and science are full of uncertainty.
How much carbon is stored in habitats? We do not fully know. How
much can be sequestered by different habitats in future? We do
not fully know. For how long might carbon remain sequestered in
those habitats? We do not fully know. I agree with the previous
speaker, and add that there is still an enormous degree of
uncertainty about the role of the world’s oceans in carbon
sequestration, which is another point made by the committee.
Another key point was to question whether the Government have an
effective plan for resolving the
“many competing demands on the land”,
whether it is producing food or materials or providing space for
nature or housing, or, as the Government pledged earlier this
week, access to green space or blue water within 15 minutes of
where we live. I look forward to the Minister’s reply. I should
have added that I welcome the Minister to what may be his first
science debate, and I hope that there are many more. I look
forward to him saying a bit more about the “spatially explicit
analysis” which the Government have promised in their reply.
In this contribution, I want to convey the views of the Royal
Society of Biology and its science team. In the interests of
transparency, I ought to say that I worked for the Royal Society
of Biology for 10 years, and I look back on those years with
great fondness. I should add that I have been elected a
fellow.
I want to make six points, briefly. First, investing in the
workforce and technologies involved in creating and implementing
nature-based solutions is crucial to unlock the solutions needed
to achieve the Government’s environmental goals. The committee
recognises that the UK does not yet have the range of skills
required to deliver nature-based solutions at scale. Effective
training and recruitment can allow the development and capture of
a broad range of ideas, talents and experience, which can in turn
better implement the required solutions. There is a story in the
Times today reporting that citizen science is leading more people
to nature, and I hope that in future that feeds through to more
people taking an interest in this subject.
Secondly, increased investment in research and development is
vital to generate more efficient, effective and responsible
carbon sequestration techniques, the improvement of which is
vital in addressing the climate crisis. This investment should
also address funding discrepancies in areas such as research
funding opportunities and infrastructure development.
Thirdly, as recommended by the committee, it is crucial that the
Government’s plans for nature-based solutions, such as carbon
sequestration schemes, are considered in tandem with their other
environment-related polices, such as championing the 30 by 30
target and the commitment to halt and reverse biodiversity loss
as outlined in the Environmental Improvement Plan 2023. It was
only this week that the Minister came to the Dispatch Box to
answer questions about the EIP. Biodiversity loss is one of the
great themes of our century and a great deal depends on the COP
biodiversity conferences.
Fourthly, although initiatives such as increased tree planting
are positive, they should be implemented with due consideration
of the pre-existing habitat, such as avoiding planting on areas
such as peatlands and species-rich grasslands, with the aim of
maintaining and restoring the natural habitation of the UK
landscape. [Interruption.] I am sorry; I wondered what that noise
was. I now realise that it is me hitting the microphone.
This should include the types of environment and specific tree
species present as opposed to the sole objective of maximising
carbon sequestration. Failure to consider those in tandem with
the net-zero objectives will lead to a greater problem in the
long term, including further biodiversity loss.
Fifthly, as highlighted by the British Ecological Society, which
is a member organisation of the Royal Society of Biology, it is
important to understand that nature-based solutions are not the
only answer to solutions on climate change.
Sixthly, it is important that nature-based solutions are
implemented through effective public communication, dialogue and
incentives, and that a combination of public and private
investment will help to fund and facilitate nature-based
solutions provided that they are effectively regulated and
monitored. In short, we need more research; who would not say
that?
Finally, in the moments I have left I turn to something that
arose this week: the government reorganisation of the machinery
of government at the centre, which is an important thing for us
to touch on briefly today. The Prime Minister’s restructuring
will have a considerable effect on government activity, including
the subject that we are addressing today. I do not know whether
the Minister will be able to say anything about this, but I am
sure that anything he says will be very welcome and of
interest.
I take the view that the break-up of BEIS will not be mourned.
However, more importantly, the creation of the Department for
Science, Innovation and Technology could provide this Government,
and indeed any future Government, with a renewed sense of purpose
and focus on making the UK the science superpower that we all
hope to see. Of course, the change in the machinery of government
will also take time to bed in. I mention this, because I think
this committee might want to look that subject. It is certainly a
worthy subject for a future report and a debate, but that is for
another day.
In the meantime, I commend the committee’s report and I hope that
it will prove a real contribution to the future success of
nature-based solutions for climate change.
1.32pm
(LD)
My Lords, it is a pleasure to follow the noble Viscount. I must
compliment the noble Lord, , who so expertly chaired the
committee, on which I was privileged to serve, and produced such
a fantastic report. I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Brown, for
so comprehensively introducing the report; there is very little
left for us to say, especially on land use. I echo her thanks to
the clerk of the committee and the staff, and to the special
adviser, Professor Pete Smith.
Planet earth supports life above and below ground through the
intricate web of independence of all living species, flora and
fauna, in balance with the essential physical cycles of water,
carbon and nitrogen. The biggest takeaway for me from this report
is how woefully incomplete our understanding is of these forces
and how they interact with each other. For example, we are only
now beginning to understand the vital role of soil, be it
onshore, in ancient rainforests, tropical or temperate, in mixed
woodland, in peatlands, in grasslands or mangroves, or offshore.
For the first time, we are beginning to appreciate the
effectiveness of seagrass meadows, kelp forests, the seabed floor
and algae as essential carbon sinks.
This report makes many recommendations on how much better we
should be doing in understanding how to manage our land in the UK
to reduce emissions of greenhouse gases. I know that other noble
Lords will cover that aspect, so I will concentrate most of my
remarks on recommendations 6, 7, 8 and 9, which all relate to the
marine environment and the gaps in the evidence base about carbon
sequestration in marine habitats.
In the report, we recommend collaboration between Natural
England, the Crown Estate, the Marine Management Organisation,
academics and other relevant bodies, and we asked Defra to
support research on establishing the current and historical
extent of marine habitats, their carbon sequestration rates and
their long-term potential for carbon storage. In their response
to the report, the Government cite a slew of collaborative
efforts, and it is clear that in the run-up to COP 26 that was
indeed the case. I thank the Government for their work on raising
the profile of the marine environment. However, can the Minister
tell us in what way that momentum has been maintained since
November 2021?
Lastly on this issue, an important point was raised in
recommendation 9 about the effects of bottom trawling on the
decline of marine habitats. This was not addressed in the
Government’s response, so can the Minister update your Lordships
on research programmes by the MMO to look into this vital
issue?
We are at a crucial point when global emissions need to be
falling fast, yet they are in fact still rising and have not yet
peaked. To reduce or even stabilise concentrations of carbon
dioxide in the atmosphere, the world needs to reach net-zero
emissions. This requires fast reductions in further anthropogenic
emissions, and I hope that the creation of the new Department for
Energy Security and Net Zero will bring greater emphasis on
energy generation by renewables and end the preferential
treatment of oil and gas producers in the North Sea, so that we
can proceed with the phase-out of destructive greenhouse gases as
fast as possible.
However, it is increasingly being realised that a huge expansion
in global carbon removal capacity is required to deliver on
global climate goals, and time is of the essence. Novel
techniques such as carbon capture and storage; BECCS—bioenergy
with carbon capture and storage; direct air
capture and enhanced rock weathering do not yet deliver at
scale. Indeed, an Oxford University study found that all current
carbon removals —that is, 2 gigatonnes of carbon dioxide per
annum—come from conventional nature-based approaches, and
nature-based solutions remain far more cost-effective than
high-tech versions.
We are in such dire straits that it is essential that research
into the newer emerging carbon removal techniques continues
apace, but we must grasp what we know works today and protect
existing carbon sinks wherever we find them in order to minimise
emissions, such as from deforestation, and increase our efforts
to create more of the carbon sinks that we know work—for example,
planting the right trees in the right place—as fast as
possible.
That is where carbon offsets come in, because they are a way of
getting the trillions of pounds of investment that the World
Economic Forum says is needed to reduce emissions. However,
carbon offsetting schemes are open to abuse. The Climate Change
Committee has recommended putting stronger regulation, guidance
and standards in place to ensure that the purchase of carbon
credits is not used as a substitute for direct business emissions
reductions. This is the thrust of recommendation 39, which asks
BEIS, as was, to provide clarity about what companies must do to
claim net zero emissions.
The Government’s response, unfortunately, is not very
satisfactory. The Minister will know that I have my name to a
number of amendments to the Financial Services and Markets Bill
that are designed to deliver a functioning green taxonomy,
sustainable finance disclosures plans, mandatory transition plans
and clean supply chains from resources from deforestation, as an
example. That would give the UK the momentum it needs to become a
net-zero financial centre with reduced opportunities for
greenwashing.
In conclusion, the report emphasises the importance of
nature-based solutions in meeting our net-zero targets and points
a way forward for the UK to be at the forefront of this
opportunity. I recommend it to noble Lords.
1.39pm
(CB)
My Lords, it is my pleasure to take part in the debate this
afternoon, and I add my congratulations to the committee on such
an excellent and thorough report conducted in very difficult
circumstances. I particularly thank the noble Baroness, Lady
Brown, for her introduction and the noble Lord, , for his excellent chairing of
this inquiry.
The summary of this document is excellent; it is very clear. It
states that, although there are possible benefits from deploying
nature-based solutions in tackling our growing concentrations of
greenhouse gases in the atmosphere, there are significant
scientific uncertainties about how carbon is stored in habitats
now and how much will be sequestered in future. I will focus on
that uncertainty in the few minutes that I have today, because it
is fundamental to understanding how we can deploy capital into
nature-based solutions without jeopardising our efforts to
mitigate climate change.
I will explain why it is so important. Before Christmas, when the
UK’s first deep coal mine was approved, the Minister said that it
was going to be the world’s first carbon-neutral coal mine. The
cynicism of that statement beggars belief. Not only was the very
group that was supposed to be supplying the off-sets to the mine
saying, “Please don’t count on us. We don’t want to sell you
these credits. You’re going to damage our reputation”, but the
coal mine was counting its emissions only from processing the
coal, not from the actual content of coal being burnt.
I stress this, because it is wonderful to look at nature-based
solutions, and this is an admirable report, but, on the other
side of the ledger, if you sell a nature-based solution or a
carbon sink, in many cases you are allowing a carbon emission to
occur. They are totally different in their characteristics. It is
not true to say that a tonne is equal to a tonne. That was the
lie from the carbon market 20 years ago, and we know now that
that is not the case. We know that when you burn coal and release
into the atmosphere carbon that has been stored over millions of
years in the earth, it will stay there for approximately 1,000
years, with a very high degree of certainty that it will cause
impact. In fact, there is ever more evidence that it will cause
impact the longer we go on, because it is a cumulative problem:
these emissions build up over time. When we release tonnes now,
they are even more damaging, because the carrying capacity is
that much reduced.
Compare that certainty with the complete uncertainty of a
nature-based carbon store. There is simply no equivalent. The
report is excellent in pointing out that we need far more
research and investment in infrastructure, monitoring, reporting,
verification and regulation to make sure that this market does
not lock us into a self-defeating cycle whereby we rely on nature
to try to soak up the emissions from carbon dioxide but we allow
the fossil fuel emissions that are driving climate change to
continue, making our forests, land and soils that much more
unstable and that much less resilient and durable. We are
basically locking ourselves into a highly changeable system with
high degrees of uncertainty and using false equivalence to tell
ourselves this very seductive lie that we can carry on burning
fossil fuels.
The report is clear that this is not a “get out of jail free”
card and that it should be used only for residual emissions, but
nowhere have the Government defined what they are. There is
nothing here that points to the rules that need to be set that
state how these things can be used and what can be used to claim
against them. That is fundamental to this. We are in a brilliant
position in the UK to address this, because we have the world’s
best scientists located here, including atmospheric chemists. I
am delighted that we have an atmospheric scientist in our midst
today, Professor Ray Weiss from the University of California San
Diego, an atmospheric chemist of long standing, who understands
this far better than me. We have our own experts in this area,
and a tall-tower network of sensors and monitors that allow us to
know in great detail what is happening to our biosphere.
Those are the sorts of investments that we have to double down
on, and I hope that the UK will join up its thinking on how it
approaches the measurement of what is happening in the
atmosphere. Again, the report is excellent. It states that we
must have
“long-term research and monitoring … overseen by the relevant
departments”
that will allow us to see the fluxes on a range of different
sites around the country, so that we are not just using
inventories and guessing whether these actions are delivering a
carbon saving but measuring it, and over the long term, so that
we have certain sense of whether we are making progress.
We cannot allow this to continue as business as usual. We have
been trying to solve climate change for 30 years or longer and,
in that time, greenhouse gases in the atmosphere have simply got
ever higher. We cannot afford a misstep where we allow the fossil
fuel industry to make use of the seductive phrase “nature-based
solutions” to carry on with business as usual.
In conclusion, I ask the Minister to go back to the department
and ask how we are using the infrastructure that the UK already
has in its tall-tower monitoring system to backstop anything that
we do on the opening up of private finance and markets into this
area. We also have our public funding from ELMS and the reform of
the agricultural subsidies, which is a safe space in which to
look at, and experiment with, what works.
Let us do that first, get the groundwork done and be certain that
this works before we say that it is open season for the private
sector to use this and to develop a carbon market. I have studied
carbon markets for far too long, and every one that I have looked
at booms and busts, for good reason: this is difficult to do. So
let us not rush into it and allow this to be abused by those who
would seek to get off lightly from their contributions to climate
change. I am delighted that this debate has been kicked off, and
I again commend the report.
1.45pm
(Con)
My Lords, I declare my registered interests as a co-founder of a
natural capital trading platform—one of many seeking to address
some of the issues raised in this report—as a developer of
natural capital projects to sequester carbon, as an investor in
natural capital-related businesses, and as a land and forest
owner. I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Brown, and the committee
for this excellent report and debate.
I congratulate the Government on the Woodland Carbon Code and the
Peatland Code, which are world-leading certification standards.
The later edition of the woodland carbon guarantee scheme was a
masterstroke in creating confidence in future value. These
schemes are uniquely high quality in the strength of the data,
the strict qualification requirements and the conservative
assumptions. The world has very few reliable certification
standards. The Verra avoiding deforestation standard, REDD+, has
been attacked by the Guardian for its limited reliability. The
New Zealand scheme has led to the blanket planting of radiata
pine, although at least this is admissible in its emissions
trading scheme’s underpinning values. These codes already place
the UK in pole position in this emerging industry. Many of the
issues addressed in this excellent report are solvable by private
capital, with government support needed in critical areas. In
turn, that should lead to much lower financial calls on the
Government to enable these outcomes.
High-credibility standards, which private capital is willing to
invest in, are critical. The woodland and peatland carbon codes
are done, but we await the soil and blue carbon codes, as well as
helping to quantify the co-benefits. The crucial question of how
to measure and value these co-benefits is raised very effectively
in the report. For market acceptance, consistency with the
Integrity Council for the Voluntary Carbon Market’s principles
and assessment framework, due during Q1 2023, will be
necessary.
The second point where the industry needs government help is in
creating profit incentives. The Woodland Carbon Code and the
Peatland Code are voluntary standards with limited tangible
value. The industry needs improvement in the standing of these
units and to see the creation of market demand for other aspects
of natural capital, such as biodiversity, water management,
cultural heritage, education, public access and visual
impact.
We can bring down the cost and increase the transparency of
delivering nature outcomes over time by creating that profit
incentive, drawing entrepreneurial talent and capital. Even at
this early stage of development, and without clarity around
market structures, a plethora of start-up and established
companies is improving the cost-effective baselining, monitoring,
measuring, managing and analysing of these projects. Most of
these use innovative hardware and/or software to create scalable
and cost-deflationary solutions.
In ELMS, there is progress on many of these fronts, but three
questions are unanswered for landowners. First, do the resulting
goods belong to the landowner? When the Government fund actions
such as afforestation, peatland restoration or natural habitat
restoration, will these benefits belong to the Government or to
the landowner? Only one entity can claim them.
Secondly, will the additionality qualification remain intact,
even with government funding under ELMS? Expert buyers require
that the scheme has the additionality of the units they are
buying in order to go ahead. If the Government have financially
incentivised the scheme, additionality may be compromised.
Finally, will the tax treatment of these assets be disadvantaged
when focused on natural capital, rather than on agriculture or
forestry?
I turn to some of the specific points in the report. There is a
statement that commercial forestry carbon calculations are
dependent on the use of harvested wood, but that is not the case
under the Woodland Carbon Code. The code calculations assume that
commercial forestry is clearfelled at maturity and the carbon
lost, which means that only the average standing carbon over
multiple rotations is recognised. Productive forestry captures
carbon more rapidly than broadleaves and creates jobs for decades
into the future, but it is handicapped in carbon forecasts by
this clearfelling assumption. The primary use of hardwoods
remains firewood. Are the Government’s calculations based on the
code assumptions, or do they use a different methodology for
carbon capture within a new forest?
Different industries have different opportunities to eliminate
carbon, making a blanket 10% cap unreasonable. Usage
discrimination through market pricing that incorporates all
methodologies of reaching net zero is likely to provide the most
efficient solution for allocating these off-sets to the
appropriate sector. It is more than two years since the Taskforce
on Scaling Voluntary Carbon Markets issued its final report. Have
the Government considered its recommendations?
The report raises two other points that I will address briefly.
UK forestry standard schemes are handicapped by a limited menu of
tree species, as highlighted by the report; I believe there are
around 60, when there are 3,000 to 4,000 species globally. Our
narrow palette brings greater biological and climate risk, and
largely references species reintroduced since the last ice age. I
agree with the report that work needs to be done to extend
this.
In response to the comments on planting into 30 centimetres of
organic matter peat,, and I would like the Forestry Commission to
stipulate methods of planting depending on soil types and
conditions. Mounding is too widely used in the industry, and I
would like to see techniques that are less disruptive to soil
condition encouraged to minimise carbon emissions during planting
and establishment. I would also like the Forestry Commission to
look further at its yield class tables, which place caps at yield
class 24 on Sitka spruce, for example, which can achieve well
into the 30s. I believe that Ireland has already made that
step.
1.51pm
(Lab)
My Lords, as a member of the Science and Technology Committee, it
gives me great pleasure to support the excellent opening remarks
by our chair, the noble Baroness, Lady Brown of Cambridge. She
has chaired the committee with great skill and good humour, as
did the noble Lord, . Both handled our many
witnesses, including Ministers, with tact and diplomacy, as well
as firing penetrating questions when we needed to cut through to
hard evidence.
One of the problems in this inquiry was the evidence available in
quantifying the relative benefits of these approaches as against
others. It became clear that more research was needed to be able
confidently to assert that some solutions were more beneficial
than others and thus where the country needed to focus its
efforts. Others have mentioned research. Can the Minister tell us
whether the Government are satisfied that adequate resource is
being allocated for this essential research?
Our inquiry into nature-based solutions to climate change follows
a number of related inquiries seeking to understand the role that
different approaches and so-called solutions can play in
responding to the climate and biodiversity crises we face as a
society, as well as the UK’s path to net zero. A central issue
for all these inquiries has been quantifying and assessing the
UK’s skills gap, which must be bridged if we are to make any
serious progress to net zero. Indeed, we chose to highlight this
in one of our most recent reports. The deadline for the
Minister’s response is next Wednesday, so I hope the Minister
will gently remind his colleague . The new Department for
Science, Innovation and Technology will hopefully bring another
view in support of a STEM skills agenda into the Cabinet.
Even if we are confident about the way forward, do we have the
skills to be able to follow through? This has been an intractable
problem in the UK despite new policies being developed by every
Government ever since I became involved in the education and
skills area. We still have major challenges in developing in our
people the skills that will enable the country to grow the
economy in the way that we all want and need. I will focus my
brief remarks on this aspect of our report.
We recommended that, to match their ambitious targets, the
Government should establish equally ambitious skills and training
programmes for land managers, authorities developing local nature
recovery strategies and public delivery bodies. We also urged the
Government to expand urgently training in the very specific areas
where it was clear that there were gaps: surveying, monitoring
and verifying, carbon accountancy, forestry ecology, and planning
and carrying out nature-based solutions.
In their response to our report, the Government said that the
Green Jobs Taskforce had helped to inform the net-zero strategy
published in October 2021, yet this said nothing about these
specific skills. They also said that they had invested £80
million in the green recovery challenge fund during Covid and £10
million in the natural environment investment readiness fund, but
they did not address the committee’s recommendation that DfE and
BEIS must allocate some of their funding to specific schemes for
land managers and provide sufficient skilled personnel to meet
the Government’s ambitious targets. Is it surprising that I
remain concerned about the lack of urgency or even focus on this
issue?
Our witnesses reflected those concerns. Our report states:
“The support of local authorities for the Local Nature Recovery
Strategies will be essential, but the Association of Local
Government Ecologists noted that fewer than a third of local
authorities have ecological expertise. The Institute of Chartered
Foresters said that a skills gap in tree-planting could undermine
climate targets, and we heard from Professor Henderson that
forestry skills ‘have deteriorated in the country over recent
decades’. Richard Lindsay told us that, for the heavily emitting
lowland peats, ‘the hoped-for strategy/solution’ is ‘this new
concept of wetland farming’ but the skills required for that do
not exist. Professor Stead, Chief Scientific Adviser, Marine
Management Organisation, told us of marine nature-based solutions
for which ‘the training and capacity building is not at a mature
stage.’”
Our report notes that, when speaking for the Government,
“Lord Goldsmith of Richmond Park acknowledged the scale of the
skills challenge”,
saying that
“‘it would be wrong to pretend, at this stage, that the skills
that will be needed in the medium and long term have been fully
mapped out and identified, and that our workforce of the future,
based on where we are today, will be ready for that
challenge.’”
Despite the ongoing talks between Defra and the DfE to address
these skills gaps,
“he acknowledged that the urgency of the agricultural transition
leaves little time: ‘to hit the 2030 targets on biodiversity, we
cannot wait until 2028 to have people doing that work.’”
That seems to be the Government’s position: they have set targets
that they know they cannot meet. We have excellent further and
higher education bodies, as well as public delivery bodies such
as Natural England, that could fill that gap in training land
managers and others to implement nature-based solutions. Will the
Minister say why the Government are not harnessing this resource
urgently? What route do they see for providing training in the
timescales required for a transition over the next decade?
1.57pm
(CB)
My Lords, I join other noble Lords in thanking the noble
Baroness, Lady Brown of Cambridge, for the thoughtful way in
which she has introduced this report and my noble friend for the thoughtful, imaginative
and determined way in which he chaired your Lordships’ Science
and Technology Committee in undertaking this important
inquiry.
It is particularly appropriate that we take this debate a few
weeks after the Royal Society published its report
Multifunctional Landscapes: Informing a Long-Term Vision for
Managing the UK’s Land. It is an interesting and informative
report that identifies the opportunity for a data and
science-driven approach to ensuring that we understand the
capacity of UK land, the competing demands on it and how they
might be addressed. Of course, as we have heard from noble Lords’
contributions during this important debate, this is a critical
issue. Nature-based solutions are not a panacea for achieving net
zero and addressing the climate change challenge, but they offer
an important opportunity to make a fundamental contribution to
achieving those net-zero targets.
Do we really understand the nature base? Are we properly informed
about the sequestration capacity of different habitats? Do we
understand the impact that our adjacent land use behaviour in
total currently has on these different environments? Do we
understand how much carbon is already stored in these habitats?
Do we understand what behaviour and activity are doing to degrade
these habitats and subsequently release carbon? These are all
important issues that need to be informed through an appropriate
knowledge base, database and science base. Of course, the
technology for us to be able to do this in a systematic fashion
becomes increasingly available.
I should declare some specific interests in that I was a member
of your Lordships’ Science and Technology Committee and that I
serve as a member of the advisory board of the Royal Society and
chairman of the 1851 commission. In your Lordships’ report and in
that of the Royal Society, it is recognised that we need common
standards, an approach to appropriate metrics, a data standard,
methodology protocols and, potentially, the development of a
common evidence platform available to inform all land use in our
country. That would subsequently help us to understand where
nature-based solutions sit.
Beyond that, we need more fundamental research to characterise
those different habitats. Do we really understand the nature of
our forests? Do we really understand the interplay of the age
those forests’ different tree habitats, the broader biodiversity
attending the soil and the importance of the different species of
trees available in those habitats? Are we properly informed about
the true stored carbon content and the ultimate sequestration
capacity of peatlands and wetlands? What do we really understand
about the marine environment even in our own coastal waters? It
is a protected environment that we are proud of, but only 5% of
it bans trawling of the seabed. How can that be logical and why
is it tolerated? Do we have a science base that helps us properly
to understand the implications of that?
When we think about broader land use, are we conscious of the
impact of land use adjacent, for instance, to a protected marine
environment? What impact does land use for building and for other
purposes have on that environment, its biodiversity, its
potential destruction and therefore the erroneous assumptions
that we might make about that environment making an important
contribution to sequestration and ultimate storage of carbon?
Is the Minister content that His Majesty’s Government have a
proper, whole-government, holistic approach to establishing a
research and evidence base that helps us to best understand the
true potential and capacity of our nature base to provide
nature-based solutions for net zero and address the climate
challenge? In supporting the establishment of an appropriate
science evidence base, are we also cognisant of the opportunity
to drive innovation in this area—innovative technologies that
allow us to map these environments appropriately, bring those
data together and make them readily available for all who are
responsible for land management? Are we clear that that science
base will be used to develop government policy appropriately? We
pride ourselves on having an informed science base informing the
development of policy. Are we content that is happening with
regard to policy to drive the opportunities for nature-based
solutions?
2.03pm
(GP)
My Lords, I thank the committee for the opportunity to speak in
the gap, the noble Baroness, Lady Brown, for her excellent
introduction to this report, and the noble Lord, , for his chairmanship of the
Science and Technology Committee.
This valuable, forensic and detailed report identifies that in
this area of climate policy, as in most of them, the Government
have rhetoric but no plans for delivery—as the title suggests.
First, the report, says that
“the UK does not have the requisite skills to deliver … solutions
at scale”
and no plans to create them. Secondly,
“there is huge uncertainty about the details of policies that
will incentivise nature-based solutions”.
Thirdly,
“more funding is required in several key areas”.
However, I want to focus on one crucial sentence in the
report:
“Nature-based solutions are not a get out of jail free card.”
We have both to stop emitting greenhouse gases and to restore our
natural world. No trade-off is scientifically possible.
Offsetting is a con, a cheat, a fiction. I am building here on
the comments, in particular from the noble Baroness, Lady
Worthington, but also from the noble Viscount, Lord Stansgate,
and the noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan. One way of explaining this
is by looking at the difference between biology and geology.
First, as the report says, there is scientific uncertainty about
how much carbon is stored, and how it can be stored in different
habitats, and how long it will remain. The timescale of
ecosystems—of biology—is, if you are lucky, years, but it is
often months, days, or even minutes. A wildfire sweeps through a
forest—I grew up in Australia, and I have watched bushfires all
too close up—and, within a blink of an eye, a lot of the
so-called stored carbon is in the atmosphere.
By contrast, geological timescales run to hundreds of millions of
years. Up to around 400 million years ago, carbon dioxide levels
in the atmosphere were up to 6,000 parts per million. We are now
at less than a 10th of that, albeit 50% up from the level at the
start of the industrial revolution. Over hundreds of millions of
years, geological processes locked vast amounts of carbon
underground, mostly deep underground. It was never going to
emerge, at least on our human timescale—if you take a 24-hour
timescale, we as a species have been on this planet for just one
second—until we started to dig it up. The best possible carbon
capture and storage is to leave the coal in the hole, the gas in
the ground, the oil in the orb. That carbon capture and storage
is free, certain and essential.
Secondly, biological systems are living systems. They are
flexible, ever changing, adaptive, complex far beyond our current
understandings. Unlike claims still sometimes made, just dropping
a lot of organic matter into the soil—as good an idea as that is
for both biodiversity and food security—will not necessarily
increase soil carbon. To quote a recent journal article,
“Persistence of organic matter in the soil depends on chemical,
physical, environmental, and/or biological factors.”
It is complex.
The fact is that biology is not going to rescue us, which means
that we have to stop growing our economy. We have to operate
within the physical limits of this one fragile planet. We have to
rescue ourselves by transforming our economic and social system
from a way of life built on carbon emissions to one that will
stabilise this planet.
2.08pm
(LD)
My Lords, it is a pleasure to start the wind-up speeches in this
debate. I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Brown, and all involved
in producing this report. It was an honour and a pleasure to
serve on the committee. The evidence we heard was
compelling—sometimes shocking, in particular on
bottom-trawling—and the recommendations that we made are
important.
Our findings gave us much cause for concern. We heard about major
gaps in the research and data needed to give confidence to the
decisions and measures that we need to take to reduce emissions
and sequester more carbon in our land and marine environments.
For example, we wanted to see more on-farm trials and more
research on sequestration in marine environments. However, we
found that there is enormous potential in the UK to do better and
to take full advantage of the potential of nature-based solutions
to help us to reach net zero. While we wait for more evidence, it
should not stop us taking action; the precautionary principle
must apply.
We heard that we do not have enough people with the appropriate
skills and knowledge to do the science, design the programmes and
put them into practice. Neither is there a plan in place to
achieve the skilled workforce that we need in the numbers that we
need when we need them.
We heard about many problems related to farming and land use. The
various government land management schemes have been too late for
farmers and land managers to plan for the future of their
business, and there has too little information and help on
eligibility for and accessibility to the schemes, too little
advice for farmers and very serious issues for tenant farmers. We
heard that, although there is growing interest in investing in
natural assets and environment schemes, these need to be properly
regulated, on the one hand, and give greater certainty to
investors about returns on the other.
Finally, we heard that there is currently no effective plan to
resolve the competing demands on land. Indeed, a recent report
suggested that to honour all the demands on land, we would need
double the land mass we have.
Let me look at some of our recommendations, the Government’s
response and ask some questions. There are many players and
organisations involved in this massive mission. Two of the key
ones are Natural England and the Environment Agency. We
recommended that, given the growing demand for their services to
fulfil government policies, they need more funding. In response,
the Government tell us that they have given an uplift of £1.4
million to Defra over three years—less than £500,000 per year.
How much of that will go to those two agencies? They will need
more funding as the need for mitigation rises due to the
increased number of extreme weather events we are seeing. I refer
particularly to flood risk.
We asked for a coherent plan for skills training. The Government
established a task force whose work informed the net-zero
strategy of October 2021. We are told that there is £40 million
in the Green Recovery Challenge Fund, of which £10 million comes
from the nature recovery fund and £30 million from Nature for
Climate funding. There is also a £10 million in the Natural
Environment Investment Readiness Fund. All this has to be applied
for and is allocated competitively. I have three questions for
the Minister. How much of that will go into relevant skills
training? How much of it is new money? How are all the recipients
of these pots of money being co-ordinated to ensure that a
coherent plan for skills is developed and delivered?
We also recommended that a direct and independent expert advisory
service be created to assist farmers to apply for schemes, reduce
their emissions, produce food more efficiently and sustainably,
sequester more carbon in their soils and protect biodiversity.
The answer was another fund. It is the Future Farming Resilience
Fund of £9 million, and it goes to organisations that will give
free advice to farmers and support their transition towards net
zero. How will farmers themselves be involved in the design of
this support? Have they been asked if they want the workshops
which are to be funded? Given that all farms are different, would
they not find one-to-one advice more useful, based on information
about their particular land, soil and business plan? Although
land sparing such as tree planting can sequester more carbon,
there are many effective land-sharing approaches, such as
silvopasture and hedge planting. When can we expect to see the
results of the relevant research on these systems?
We also recommended that the Government should be clear about
what companies must do to claim that they are net zero. There
seems to be a lot of greenwashing about, but there must always be
additionality. Some companies claim that they have reduced the
emissions from how they produce their goods or deliver their
services but are allowed to ignore what happens to those goods
afterwards. I am thinking of plastic goods or fossil-fuel
producers such as coal mines. Offsets cannot be a substitute for
reducing emissions. When can we expect to see the strong
framework of standards and rules for investment in ecosystem
services promised in the Government’s response? When will we see
flexibility for aggregating multiple projects and combining
public and private funding?
Finally, two big things stand out for me. First, we recommended
that the Government produce a land use strategy. I accept that
that is very difficult, given the competing demands, but someone
has to do it and I should like to know from the Minister who that
will be and on what scientific and policy basis. Will the
Government be implementing the recommendation of the Committee on
Land Use in England to create a land use commission?
The other big thing was the issue of tenant farmers. So many
witnesses outlined the barriers to tenants participating in
schemes to reduce their emissions and increase biodiversity that
we became very concerned about their role in reaching net zero.
Rents are rising, as is the cost of inputs; the security of basic
payments is being withdrawn with too little certainty about what
is replacing them, and tenant farmers are being asked to deliver
more for the environment without impacting food security.
Tenant farmers are a large and important part of the farming
community, so the Government set up a working group, under our
committee colleague, the noble Baroness, Lady Rock, to review the
issues and make recommendations. I was surprised by some of the
figures on the very first page of her report. Sixty-four per cent
of the total farmable area in England is either wholly or partly
rented, a very large part of the whole. Secondly, the average
length of new farm business tenancies in 2021 was three years.
With a tenancy as short as that, how does anyone expect a tenant
to invest in the long-term health of his soil and the
productivity and biodiversity of his land?
The noble Baroness, Lady Rock, unfortunately is unable to speak
today. However, her report made many excellent recommendations
about how government schemes should be designed to make them
“tenant proof”, to involve tenant farmers and to enable both
tenants and landowners to benefit from schemes designed to fulfil
government’s environmental policies. Unless those things happen,
participation will be poor, farmers will go out of business and
government policies will not be achieved. Could the Minister
outline the Government’s response to the Rock report? The noble
Baroness asked for
“an open and collaborative approach between tenants and
landlords”.
This exists in some places, but by no means all. What can the
Government do to make schemes fair for all and encourage this
collaborative approach?
2.16pm
(Lab)
My Lords, it gives me great pleasure to contribute to this
excellent debate about this extremely timely and important
report. I join others in thanking the members of the Science and
Technology Committee for their contributions today and for all
the work that they have done over a significant time. I thank in
particular the former chair, the noble Lord, , and the noble Baroness, Lady
Brown, for her excellent introduction to the report.
Timing is everything in these debates, and it is particularly
worth noting that this report is being debated in a week when
Whitehall has seen a significant change in the arrangement of
departments. We hope that separating energy policy and net zero
from the former BEIS is a reflection of the Government’s
recognition of the urgency, expressed so much today, of this
agenda. I hope that the Minister will be able to indicate to us
that that message around urgency has been heard and how it will
translate into practice. What we need to hear is that the change
will lead to more policy output, but Defra’s recent suite of
environmental targets has given some of us the impression that
the Government do not fully appreciate the urgency of the matters
we are discussing today.
The contributions today have been striking, with the noble
Baronesses, Lady Brown and Lady Sheehan, each coming in on this
agenda. Of course, the discussion has focused inevitably on the
areas of uncertainty. I pay tribute to the comments made by the
noble Baroness, Lady Worthington, and my noble friend Lady
Warwick. There is little doubt that nature-based solutions are
recognised as having an important role to play in the transition
to a cleaner, greener future.
My noble friend Lady Warwick stressed, as have others, the
importance of the skills agenda. In so many of the areas that I
speak on, the skills shortages that this country is facing are
reaching crisis point. In acknowledging the lack of skills in
this area, I will pick a specific example. The Government
recently announced the Forestry Training Fund, offering free
training to those who want to move into the forestry industry. Of
course we welcome the initiative, but where is the follow-up? Why
has it taken so long for Ministers to bring it forward? How many
people do the Government expect to come forward, and do they
think that it will generate more interest than their failed Pick
for Britain campaign of several years ago?
We have discussed the other major concern about land use, an area
which the House explored at length during the passage of the
Environment Bill, with the Government unfortunately resisting
calls from my noble friend Lady Young of Old Scone for the
publication of a dedicated land use strategy. We will not scale
up nature-based solutions without buy-in from the private sector,
whether in the form of finance or delivery capacity. That is why,
during the Lords stages of the UK Infrastructure Bank Bill,
Labour supported an amendment to expand that legislation’s
definition of infrastructure to include nature-based solutions.
If the Government are so keen to ensure private sector
involvement in important projects, why did they overturn that
sensible amendment in the House of Commons?
Finally, the committee drew attention to the need for landowners
and farmers to have certainty about future funding arrangements,
including, as we have heard, through the Government’s ELMS. Could
we ask again—I hope we will get a response to the Minister—how
the Government aim to settle the important question from the
noble Baroness, Lady Brown, about competing demands on land use?
It is now several years since the Agriculture Act was passed and,
although there have been announcements on ELMS in recent weeks,
the process has been fraught with delays, miscommunications and
other difficulties.
We have so much consensus in this area. The questions that we are
all asking is why there is so much delay and why so much
opportunity is being missed. We understand the need for research
programmes. As we have highlighted today, the uncertainty is
there, and more research and more funding are required to make
sure that that takes place. We understand the need for extensive
consultation when so many key players are involved, but the clock
is ticking. Can I borrow the report’s excellent title and say
that we need to turn rhetoric into reality?
2.23pm
(Con)
My Lords, I declare my interests in farming and land management,
as set out in the register. I take this opportunity to
congratulate the noble Baroness, Lady Brown of Cambridge, on
securing this debate, and I thank all noble Lords for their
contributions. I welcome the opportunity to respond to the points
raised and to provide an update on the actions that have been
taken since the publication of the Science and Technology
Committee report. I agree at the outset with the noble Baroness,
Lady Blake of Leeds, and other noble Lords about the urgency and
extreme importance of tackling climate change.
As was acknowledged following the report’s publication in January
2022, the Government are grateful to the committee for the report
and pleased that our ambitious plans for nature-based solutions
have been recognised. Nature-based solutions are key to tackling
climate change and averting its impacts. They deliver multiple
benefits for climate, biodiversity, and people, and play a
critical role in our plans to tackle the interrelated climate and
biodiversity crises.
At the time of publication, the Government acknowledged the
challenges and risks raised by the committee and set out the
action being taken with our delivery partners to address these
issues. Following the important announcements in this area since
the publication of the report and in recent weeks, I welcome the
opportunity to provide an update on the key themes raised in the
report and in this debate.
First, I will provide an update on our overarching targets and
progress being made. We have stretching nature-based targets that
set out the Government’s strong ambition to protect and improve
our landscapes. We are working tirelessly to ensure that our
targets become a reality and that progress is being made.
Starting with forestry, the noble Baroness, Lady Brown, raised
the need for more action in this area. We have full confidence
that our targets are achievable and have increased tree planting
and woodland creation in England from 2,700 hectares in 2021-22
to now investing £750 million through our Nature for Climate
Fund, which will support England’s contribution to our UK-wide
target of planting 30,000 hectares of new woodland annually from
May 2024. Tree planting is a key priority in the environmental
land management schemes, which I will provide more detail on
shortly.
On support for nurseries, also raised by the noble Baroness, Lady
Brown, the Government committed in the England Trees Action Plan
2021 to 2024 to provide funding for UK public and private sector
nurseries and seed suppliers and to set up the sector capacity
project. In addition, £879,000 has been provided through the Tree
Production Innovation Fund to encourage the adoption of
innovative ways of working in the nursery sector. Last year, a
new tree production capital grant opened for applications,
providing capital support to nurseries and seed suppliers to
modernise facilities and improve the quantity, quality, diversity
and biosecurity of planting stock available for planting in
England.
The noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, raised the subject of tracking
marine biodiversity. In English waters, we have established a
network of marine protected areas across more than 35,000 square
miles. We have just created a new statutory target for 70% of
designated beaches in marine protected areas to be in a
favourable condition by 2042, with the remainder in recovering
condition and with an interim target of 48% of designated beaches
to be in favourable condition by 31 January 2028, in line with
the trajectory required to achieve the long-term target.
On peatland, we are delivering on our commitment to restore
280,000 hectares of peatland in England by 2050, which is
supported by funds such as the Nature for Climate Peatland Grant
Scheme and the new environmental land management schemes. Through
the development of the peat restoration road map, to be published
in 2024 by Natural England, we will be able to set out a
trajectory for restoration over the next 20 years.
The noble Lord, , raised the subject of lowland
peat used for agriculture. I thank him for highlighting this
important issue of peatland restoration and, in particular, for
highlighting the focus areas for the Government. In 2021, the
lowland agricultural peat task force commenced working with
stakeholders to deliver recommendations for a more sustainable
future for lowland peatland in England. Its aim is to identify
ways of extending the usable life of our agricultural peat soils
to preserve the carbon stored in them and to ensure that
profitable agriculture can continue for decades to come. The task
force will report to government in the summer.
To meet our global climate target under the Paris agreement and
our commitment to net zero, we need peatland restoration and
opportunities for woodland expansion to happen without one
compromising the other. Our commitments are reinforced in our
recently published Environmental Improvement Plan 2023, which is
delivery-focused and sets out the actions that will drive us
towards reaching our long-term goals. It includes stretching
interim targets to be achieved by the next review of the plan,
driving progress towards our new long-term targets as required by
the Environment Act 2021.
The noble Viscount, Lord Stansgate, raised the issue of skills
and research and development. Of course, action to meet our
headline targets must be underpinned by research and development
and the necessary skills to deliver, issues which the committee
report highlighted in detail.
The Government recognise the importance of investing in these
areas. In the net-zero strategy we committed to £75 million on
net zero-related research and development to inform our pathway
to 2037. Defra is involved with many research and development
projects to address evidence gaps and inform policy-making on
agroforestry, lowland peat and hedgerow planting. Projects cover
areas such as: understanding how climate stress will affect tree
species in the future; the £5.6 million Paludiculture Exploration
Fund, which looks at tackling barriers to developing that farming
practice as commercially viable; and further modelling to
estimate the potential benefits of hedgerow creation on carbon
storage and sequestration.
A focus of the committee was on the need to build a stronger
evidence base on blue carbon habitats in the UK, and a number of
actions are being taken in this area. The UK’s recently published
UK Net Zero Research and Innovation Framework identifies research
needs on coastal wetland habitats to support improved greenhouse
gas accounting and reporting as a priority. Research and
development was also raised by the noble Lord, .
On agroforestry, Defra is currently involved in several
agroforestry research projects that are looking at different
evidence gaps, including expanding agroforestry in an evidence
review and gap analysis to fill in key evidence requirements.
Furthermore, Farm Tree will develop decision-support tools for
integrating trees on agricultural land and Agroforestry Futures
will identify opportunities for, and barriers to, an expansion of
agroforestry into peri-urban areas and rural parts of the UK. The
Agroforestry Pollinator Plantations project aims to understand
how climate stress will affect tree species and which tree and
shrub species growing in the UK will be suitable for future
climates.
In the England Trees Action Plan, we committed to an ambitious
research and development programme which includes building more
evidence for the reintroduction of woodland species such as the
pine marten, supporting the development of innovative wood
products and building the evidence base on how best to protect
and enhance ancient woodlands.
Defra has committed £1.2 million from the net-zero research and
development allocation over the spending review period to further
build the blue carbon evidence base. My noble friend Lord Holmes
and the noble Baroness, Lady Worthington, asked about work on the
seas. In 2022, we established the UK Blue Carbon Evidence
Partnership, through which UK Administrations are working
together with BEIS, as it was, and Defra to address key research
questions related to blue carbon policy, advancing our commitment
to protect and restore these habitats to support them as
nature-based solutions. An initial aim of the partnership has
been to set out key research questions related to blue carbon by
producing an evidence needs statement, which will be published in
spring 2023.
The noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, raised the issue of bottom
trawling, which can cause carbon dioxide to be released from
sediments. However, the processes are complex and the impact of
trawling on carbon dioxide remains uncertain. That is why Defra
is actively progressing the evidence space to better understand
the resilience and recovery of sea biodiversity stores in
sediments in response to human practices and management
interventions.
The noble Baroness, Lady Warwick of Undercliffe, raised the issue
of skills and growing the workforce. This will be essential to
delivering on our targets. We are taking action across key
sectors, such as scoping out options for a research project on
peat-restoration sector capability. We continue to develop new
educational routes and career opportunities around skills in the
forestry sector. A new Forestry Commission development woodland
officer apprenticeship has been launched jointly with the
University of Cumbria and the Institute of Chartered Foresters.
It is the first time a degree-level forestry apprenticeship has
been offered in the UK. In addition, through the Forestry
Commission, we are supporting the Forestry Skills Forum in
refreshing its action plan for England, which will raise the
profile of forestry careers among school leavers and career
changers.
The noble Baronesses, Lady Warwick of Undercliffe and Lady
Walmsley, asked about green jobs and job opportunities. Last May,
the Government established the Green Jobs Delivery Group,
bringing together Ministers from BEIS, Defra and the Department
for Education with leaders from the green economy, skills
sectors, academia and trade unions to ensure that the UK has the
pipeline of people needed to deliver our climate and environment
ambitions. The new Environmental Improvement Plan 2023 reaffirms
our commitment to this continued joint working to address skills
needs in priority sectors, including sustainable land use and
nature.
Advancing our research and skills allows us to develop and
deliver targeted policies to support our key sectors in taking
collective action. We recently set out plans for the
environmental land management schemes designed to support the
nation’s farming sector to be profitable and resilient as it
produces food sustainably while protecting nature and enhancing
the environment. Key announcements to support our ambitious
nature targets covered the following.
The first is accelerating the rollout of the Sustainable Farming
Incentive, with six new sets of paid actions for 2023, adding to
the three already in place. This will provide farmers with a
range of paid actions to manage hedgerows for wildlife, plant
nectar-rich wildflowers and manage crop pests without the use of
insecticides. The SFI application window is continuously open,
and applications continue to be received. This point was raised
by the noble Baroness, Lady Brown of Cambridge. It has always
been the intention to add more elements to SFI as funding is
released from BPS reductions.
Secondly, expanding our popular Countryside Stewardship Scheme to
reward farmers for action to support climate and nature will see
around 30 additional actions available to farmers by the end of
2024.
Thirdly and lastly, applications for further rounds of the
landscape recovery scheme will open in spring and in 2024. Round
2 will focus on net zero, protected sites and habitat creation,
including landscape-scale projects creating and enhancing
woodland, peatland, nature reserves and protected sites such as
ancient woodlands, wetlands and salt marshes.
My noble friend raised the issue of tax
around assets focused on natural capital rather than agriculture
or forestry. HMRC and Defra are considering the evidence that
inheritance tax might be a potential barrier to the conversion of
land from agricultural to environmental use in some situations.
HRMC recently updated its IHT manual to help clarify the
position, and further updates will follow in due course.
Analysis, including discussions with external stakeholders, is
taking place, and the Government are looking carefully at what
changes may be required.
The noble Baroness, Lady Walmsley, raised the issue of landowner
engagement. Agroforestry is an innovative practice that has a
significant role to play in achieving the Government’s commitment
to increased tree planting across the UK. Therefore, Defra is
introducing agroforestry as part of ELMS; it will play a key role
in increasing tree cover on farms. Agroforestry can provide a
source of income to the farmer from both the marketable
agricultural enterprise and forestry-generated products. This
diversity will help reduce the risks from fluctuating
agricultural markets and help stimulate and build resilience into
the rural economy, without compromising the ability to produce
food.
We know we will need to continue to develop our schemes, based on
the learnings from our pilots, tests and trials and early
rollouts. We will work with stakeholders across the whole sector
to achieve this. There are many benefits to delivering
nature-based solutions and they play a key role in our efforts to
adapt to climate change. Defra is working across government to
develop a third national adaptation programme for publication in
2023. This will include key actions for restoring nature and
enhancing its ability to adapt to climate change risks, as well
as maximising the benefits for communities.
As emphasised in the committee report, and by the noble Baroness,
Lady Brown, finance is a key enabler for meeting our climate
targets. Nature-based projects need to be financially attractive
to landowners and investors. The noble Baronesses, Lady Warwick
of Undercliffe and Lady Walmsley, both raised the subject of
investment. The Government have committed to maintain the farming
budget for England at £2.4 billion per year throughout this
Parliament, and I have outlined how we are repurposing funding
for farmers and land managers as part of the agricultural
transition.
We are already seeing progress. Currently, there are around
40,000 agreements in our countryside and environmental schemes,
covering about 34% of agricultural land. There are 94% more
countryside stewardship agreements now than in January 2020. By
2028 we plan to increase the number of agreements to at least
70,000 in our environmental land management schemes, covering 70%
of farmed land and 70% of all farms, so that farmers and land
managers can collectively deliver our ambitious targets for the
environment, climate and food production. We are committed to
being transparent about the budget and how it will be spent. We
included in the Agriculture Act a requirement for government to
publish an annual report about the budget, and we did this for
the first time in 2022.
Alongside publicly funded schemes, the Government have set a
target to raise at least £500 million in private finance to
support nature’s recovery every year by 2027 in England, rising
to more than £1 billion per year in 2030. To set the conditions
to achieve this, we are taking a number of actions, including
supporting the development of nature projects that can attract
private capital through our £10 million Natural Environment
Investment Readiness Fund and accelerating the natural capital
investment market by investing £30 million in a new, blended
finance vehicle for nature: the Big Nature Impact Fund.
We continue supporting the Woodland Carbon Code and the Peatland
Code to encourage private investment, with registrations
continuing to increase. I am grateful to my noble friend for his recognition of
these as world-leading certification standards.
Both my noble friend and the noble Baroness, Lady Brown,
highlighted the importance of strong governance and standards in
the current markets for nature-based solutions. The UK has
championed initiatives to strengthen and scale up high-integrity
voluntary carbon markets, including under our COP 26
presidency.
The noble Baroness, Lady Worthington, raised the issue of high
integrity in carbon markets. We have launched multi-stakeholder
initiatives such the Integrity Council on Voluntary Carbon
Markets, and the Voluntary Carbon Markets Integrity Initiative,
to establish the very highest standards.
We are developing plans to put in place a comprehensive suite of
domestic standards for nature markets to provide assurances of
high integrity, create confidence in the market and allow
investment to flow at scale into a much wider range of ecosystem
services and habitats. We will ensure that, as we develop new
domestic standards, we draw on relevant international best
practice.
Several noble Lords raised competing demands on land. It is vital
that we make the most productive use of our land and strike the
right balance between the many priorities that place a demand on
land, including food security, sustainable development, action on
climate mitigation and adaptation, and promoting nature’s
recovery. The noble Baronesses, Lady Brown, Lady Walmsley and
Lady Blake, the noble Viscount, Lord Stansgate, and my noble
friend Lord Holmes all mentioned the need for a clear land use
strategy, as did the committee’s report. The Government recognise
the importance of this and of managing these trade-offs, and we
have therefore committed to publishing a land use framework in
2023 to bring greater alignment in policies affecting land.
I thank all noble Lords here for taking part in this crucial
debate and for raising many important points that I will take
back to Defra and colleagues across Whitehall. I will look at
Hansard and write to noble Lords to follow up on any questions
that I have been unable to answer. The Government have committed
to leaving the environment in a better place than we found it.
There is no doubt that nature-based solutions play a vital part
in achieving our ambitions, and, although we recognise that there
is work to do, we are confident that we have a strong foundation
to build on. With our recent announcements and ongoing commitment
to action, we will continue working with key stakeholders in the
sector and our delivery partners to deploy nature-based solutions
to improve our natural environment and support the climate
agenda.
2.46pm
(CB)
I thank the Minister for his extensive response. I was pleased
that he mentioned a lot of numbers and actions, and I too will
study Hansard carefully—I will take them away and think about
them further. At the moment, however, I fear I am still not
convinced that they add up to an integrated solution to this
issue.
I too thank all who have spoken in this debate—I will not repeat
what noble Lords said so eloquently. I thank the noble
Baronesses, Lady Worthington and Lady Bennett, for reminding us
of what I will call the “zeroth” law of nature-based solutions,
which is that they cannot be used as an excuse for not
decarbonising rapidly. In that vein, the first law is that
nature-based solutions are critical for achieving net zero for
our residual emissions, as the noble Baroness, Lady Worthington,
reminded us. The second law is that more research and training
are needed. The third is that they will not work without robust
monitoring and verification. The fourth is that this is not just
a Defra issue; it needs the cross-government approach that the
Minister mentioned. The fifth is that we must establish robust
ways to fund them and we must have offsets that we can trust. The
sixth is that our farmers are critical and need our help.
I hope that, as a result of today’s debate, the Government will
reflect further—I think I heard the Minister say this, which
pleased me—on whether the scale and pace of their current and
proposed actions add up to a solution to the challenge of
effective implementation and use of nature-based solutions in
helping us reach net zero.
Motion agreed.
|