Asked by
To ask His Majesty’s Government what plans they have (1) to
introduce legislation to prohibit the forcible installation of
prepayment energy meters, and (2) to compensate those subjected
to this practice.
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department for Energy
Security and Net Zero () (Con)
It is right that Ofgem has asked suppliers to pause the
installation of prepayment meters under warrant until they have
assured Ofgem that they are compliant with all relevant
regulations. Courts have been instructed not to list warrant
applications, and the Secretary of State has asked energy bosses
to report back on how they will identify consumers who may have
had a prepayment meter installed inappropriately and how they
will put those matters right.
(Lab)
My Lords, I am not really satisfied with the Minister’s
explanation. All the parties that he mentioned are partly
responsible for the current state of affairs. Since 2019, nearly
1 million warrants for the forced fitting of prepayment meters
have been nodded through the courts. The victims have been denied
fair and public hearings, as required by Article 6 of the
European Convention on Human Rights. Will the Minister now commit
to a judicial inquiry into the failure of the whole apparatus and
immediate compensation for those who have suffered?
(Con)
Ofgem is in fact conducting an inquiry into the matter. We were
all appalled to see the activities of British Gas in particular,
which were exposed by the Times newspaper, to which we should be
grateful. However, we should remember that prepayment meters are
a useful tool for some customers to help prevent debt building
up. A complete ban on prepayment meters would likely just see a
move to debt enforcement by the courts and bailiffs, which is not
a desirable outcome either. So none of these policy choices is
easy, but the Secretary of State has written to all energy
suppliers asking them to report back to him urgently on what
steps they are taking to put these matters right.
(Con)
My Lords, is not the problem that people with prepayment meters
are in the main people who are financially stretched, but they
pay a higher rate for their electricity? What is the regulator
doing allowing this to continue?
(Con)
My Lords, my noble friend knows that normally I agree with him,
but in this case he is partly wrong. Yes, there is a slight extra
charge for those on prepayment meters, but actually the highest
rates are paid by those who have traditional standard credit. The
cheapest way of paying is by direct debit. It is also not true
that all customers on prepayment meters are necessarily in
financially straitened circumstances. Some people—students, young
people, people in tenanted accommodation and so on—prefer that
method of payment. If we socialise the costs and equalise them
among everyone, then many poorer people who prefer either
standard credit or direct debit would pay more to take account of
that.
(Lab)
My Lords, on Sunday, as the Minister said, the BEIS Secretary
gave energy bosses until yesterday to report back on what
remedial measures would be taken where prepayment meters were
installed in the homes of vulnerable customers. He also said in
his Statement on Monday that any compensation scheme is a matter
for the regulator, Ofgem, which raises the question: what exactly
are the Government going to do with what the energy suppliers
report back to them?
(Con)
I am told that those letters came in last night, and the
Secretary of State and officials are reviewing those responses.
We will have more to say on this shortly.
(CB)
The Minister must be alive to the prospect that what is happening
here is that the courts system is simply so overrun that the
warrant operation system is not functioning properly. Are the
Government prepared to invest what is needed in the courts system
to overhaul that, if it is indeed found to be one of the causes
of these terrible incidents?
(Con)
The noble Lord makes an important point. The Lord Justice in
charge of it has instructed the courts not to issue any further
warrants in the meantime while these matters are investigated,
but I am sure that is an important thing that we need to look
at.
(Lab)
My Lords, what is the cost of the 1 million warrants issued by
the courts since 2019 for the forced fitting of prepayment
meters? How much of that money has been recovered from energy
companies?
(Con)
I am afraid I did not quite understand the noble Baroness’s
question, as it depends on what she means by the cost. Is it the
cost to suppliers or customers, or the costs through the courts
system? I will ask officials to look at it and perhaps write to
her on that.
(LD)
My Lords, those consumers who are not on direct debit get their
£67 a month back through vouchers. We know that some 18% of those
are not claimed, so who keeps the money? Is it the energy
retailer or the taxpayer?
(Con)
Ultimately, it will be the taxpayer because that is a taxpayer
subsidy, but we want to ensure that everybody gets the money that
they are entitled to. The performance of companies varies widely
in delivering these vouchers. Clearly, if people are on a smart
meter then it is more advantageous because the support can be
delivered easily and directly. We are working with suppliers to
ensure that people get the support that they are entitled to but,
by the very nature of premises with prepayment meters in them, it
is sometimes difficult to get hold of the person paying the
actual bill.
(Con)
My Lords, I accept the basis of what my noble friend is arguing,
but might he see whether we could look again at the real costs of
prepayment meters? It seems that the energy companies get the
money in from them to start with and that normally, if you pay in
advance, you pay less. It seems odd if it is still true that some
of the poorest are paying more. Can we look at that and see
whether the figuring is in fact accurate?
(Con)
Of course, we continue to look at this and I know that Ofgem is
taking a close interest in it at the moment. All that is allowed
under the licensing conditions is that suppliers can cover their
actual costs that are reflective of servicing those different
customers. As I said, the most expensive method for suppliers is
those who pay by standard credit, because they have to send out a
bill then receive the payment in, et cetera, so those people pay
even more than those on prepayment meters do.
(Lab)
My Lords, Lord Justice Edis stopped all of the warrant process on
the basis that the courts had not been considering the
vulnerability of the customers against whom warrants were being
issued. The reason that process exists is to prevent prepayment
meters being forced upon people who are vulnerable and would
maybe therefore not get heat. There is a degree of urgency,
therefore, in sorting out who has prepayment meters and is not
getting access to energy. From the Minister’s answers, I did not
detect when Ofgem is going to report back to him and what steps
he understands either it or he are taking to try to protect those
people who did not get the protection of the courts.
(Con)
The noble and learned Lord is right. The purpose of the Secretary
of State writing to suppliers was to find out what arrangements
would be made to put right matters that went wrong. Clearly, a
number of consumers who are vulnerable have had the meters
fitted, which of course is against Ofgem rules and against the
licence conditions of those suppliers. That is why the courts are
right to stop the issue of these warrants until these matters
have been sorted, but we want Ofgem to report back as quickly as
possible.
(Con)
My Lords, is there not another aspect of this agenda as well?
Ever since the start of the Covid crisis, HMG have been doing all
they can to persuade people to use non-cash payments for items
such as utility bills. Surely it makes no sense whatever to now
force some of the poorest members of the community in this
country to use cash against their will.
(Con)
Of course, you do not have to use cash with a prepayment meter.
You can have a smart prepayment meter, which you can top up using
mobile phones and so on, but overall my noble friend’s point is
valid.
(Non-Afl)
My Lords, the issue of a warrant to forcibly enter a
dwelling-house is a very serious matter. In this case, we have
heard that it has been done in mass numbers, which I suggest is
clearly unacceptable. Would it not be in the interests of justice
for the householder to be given the opportunity to make
representations during the hearing as to the right or wrong of
that procedure being taken?
(Con)
I am not an expert on the system, but my understanding is that
they are able to do exactly that now. The suppliers have to write
to people to say that they are applying for a warrant and anybody
has the right to go along and make representations in response to
that. It is only when the applications are unchallenged that they
are issued en masse.
(Con)
My Lords, there is a degree of urgency to lowering the price of
gas so that the poorest people in greatest difficulty, with or
without meters, can pay. It just so happens that the price of gas
is lower now than before the lockdown two years ago or the
Ukraine invasion. Why is that much lower price not being passed
on now to the poorest so that they can pay, rather than having
their doors knocked in and being forced to take meters?
(Con)
It will be passed on when the price cap is reviewed by Ofgem. It
is worth stating the amount of government support being given to
all consumers. The reality is that over the winter the
Government—the taxpayer—have been paying approximately one-third
overall of people’s energy bills. There is a considerable amount
of government support because of the massive increase in prices
due to Putin’s war. Thankfully, the world has responded, and
prices are coming down. However, many suppliers hedged against
that and bought long-term contracts. As that unwinds into the
energy system, prices will come down and the price cap will
reflect that. Later in the year, we should hopefully see a
reduction in the price cap. At the same time, of course,
government support will begin to be unwound, so we will have to
see how those two factors interact.