Alex Davies-Jones (Pontypridd) (Lab) I thank Mr Speaker for
granting this debate. I am pleased to see my good friend the shadow
Minister, my hon. Friend the Member for Portsmouth South (Stephen
Morgan), and the Minister of State, Department for Education, the
right hon. Member for Bognor Regis and Littlehampton (Nick Gibb),
in their places. I thank the Minister for being here to respond to
a cross-cutting issue that many hon. Members feel passionately
about. I also place on...Request free
trial
(Pontypridd) (Lab)
I thank Mr Speaker for granting this debate. I am pleased to see
my good friend the shadow Minister, my hon. Friend the Member for
Portsmouth South (), and the Minister of State,
Department for Education, the right hon. Member for Bognor Regis
and Littlehampton (), in their places. I thank the
Minister for being here to respond to a cross-cutting issue that
many hon. Members feel passionately about. I also place on record
my thanks to the range of organisations that have supported me
and my team in preparing for the debate, including Welsh Women’s
Aid, Girlguiding, HOPE not hate, the Sex Education Forum and my
brilliant colleagues in the Welsh Government.
This is only my second Adjournment debate and, remarkably, the
previous one also focused on misogyny, albeit in the context of
sport. They say that persistence is key to making progress, so I
am grateful for the opportunity to again raise some broad
concerns about the damaging impact that misogyny can have on all
our lives, and the work that must be done to reduce that impact
for future generations. It is a frustrating reality that the
debate feels more timely than ever. The impact that so-called
social media influencers are having on perpetuating vile misogyny
online and offline is undoubtedly enormous. Misogyny is
developing at a rapid rate in our classrooms, so it is a growing
concern that I regularly hear about when speaking with teachers
in my constituency.
At this point, I must thank the team at Pontypridd High School.
Despite the name, it is just across the border in the
constituency of my hon. Friend the Member for Cynon Valley
(), but it is a key school for
many people living in Pontypridd. Led by the brilliant deputy
headteacher, Kayleigh Oliver, the school has taken it upon itself
to make tackling violence against women and girls a core feature
of the education that pupils receive there. It was great to
welcome a group of pupils to Westminster just before Christmas to
discuss these issues in person. The school is doing some
fantastic work, but it should not have to be that way.
Since being appointed a shadow Digital, Culture, Media and Sport
Minister, a key priority for me has been carefully considering
the Government’s approach to tackling online safety. Of course,
that is another topic that we have discussed repeatedly, and that
we can discuss again on a different day, but we cannot and should
not underestimate the influence that key figures in the online
space are having on young people. Indeed, I am not the only one
to have raised these concerns: just a few weeks ago, The Times
led with a feature entitled, “How teachers are re-educating boys
brainwashed by Andrew Tate”.
For those lucky enough to still be unaware of Andrew Tate, I am
happy to provide a brief education—pun somewhat intended. He is a
classic social media influencer. He has amassed millions of
followers on YouTube, Instagram and TikTok, and is often reported
to be—and proudly boasts of being—the king of misogyny. He is
well known for his ultra-macho lifestyle. He has claimed in
videos that women are a man’s property, that they cannot do jobs
as well as men, and that ultimately, they belong at home. He may
market himself as a businessman or a social media personality,
but really, he is a sad, pathetic individual with a platform who
clearly enjoys spreading hate.
Having spoken to teachers in my constituency, it is clear that it
would be wrong to underestimate the hold that so-called
influencers have on young people. Indeed, I recently spoke to a
GCSE-level teacher, who spoke about the issues in their
classrooms. She said:
“It is impossible for teachers to constantly keep up with the
latest trends or fads on social media, but the hold that Andrew
Tate specifically has over boys in my school is unlike anything I
have seen before. This isn’t happening overnight. We have slowly
seen a change in what were well-behaved boys, often around the
age of 11-16, who have now begun to adopt and exhibit his
alpha-male attitudes and behaviours themselves. This can range
from seemingly harmless remarks about women belonging in the
kitchen, to direct and very public comments on female pupils’
appearance and sexual behaviours.”
This first-hand account points to the heart of the issue: many
schools want to tackle misogyny and teach their pupils about the
harm it can cause, but they lack direction and consistency.
Although the issue has received some recent press coverage, the
concerns and experiences of teachers are certainly not new. Last
year, a survey by NASUWT found that most female staff faced
misogyny in the classroom. Incidents included harassment, sexist
comments and assault, but teachers also specifically highlighted
the growing incel movement as a cause for concern. For colleagues
who are unaware, “incel” is commonly known as short for
involuntary celibate. An incel is often defined as someone who
has defined themselves as unable to meet a romantic or sexual
partner, despite desiring one. Incels often feel that they have
the right to be desired by women, and that women are to blame
when this is not the case. I am sure I speak on behalf of us all
when I say that it is absolutely shocking that rising interest
and support for incel culture is an issue that we are facing in
modern day Britain. It is an even more damning indictment that
female pupils across the country are reporting growing
harassment, sexist comments, assaults, and an overarching culture
of misogyny and disrespect from their male counterparts. Let us
be clear: what can begin as seemingly harmless so-called
classroom banter can often develop into dangerous attitudes and
ultimately behaviour that can all too often put people in genuine
harm.
More broadly, it is clear that schools play an important role in
educating young people in social issues that go far beyond the
standard curriculum, and we pay tribute to all the teachers up
and down the country doing just that day in and day out. Indeed,
teaching young people about the concept of masculinity without
confusing it with so-called macho swagger is, as I am sure we can
all agree, a really vital but difficult challenge. However, there
is some really positive work taking place across the UK, notably
in Wales, which I am keen to draw attention to and which I hope
the Minister will address in his responding remarks.
In December 2021, Estyn, which is the education and training
inspectorate for Wales, published a report about the experiences
of peer-on-peer sexual harassment among secondary school pupils
in Wales. In response to that, the Welsh Labour Government have
taken decisive action, and are currently developing an action
plan that will outline the actions they will take with their
partners to prevent and respond to the issue of peer-on-peer
sexual harassment in education settings. Importantly, this action
plan will also link to and complement sister plans—including the
national action plan on preventing child abuse, the digital
resilience in education action plan, and the violence against
women, domestic abuse and sexual violence strategy—all in order
to aid understanding of the work and support available to empower
children and young people.
The Welsh Labour Government are committed to ensuring that
education settings are safe, supportive, inclusive and engaging
environments for children to speak out and share what matters to
them, because we all have a responsibility to ensure that respect
and tolerance form part of our school communities and cultures.
Ultimately, this is key to creating an inclusive and engaging
environment where everyone’s wellbeing is considered and everyone
feels accepted, safe and ready to learn. Indeed, the Welsh
Government have developed a dedicated online hub, with a range of
classroom resources to support discussions with pupils about the
issue of toxic masculinity and the role this plays in driving
misogyny more widely. There are also a number of resources that
explore harmful online behaviours and issues that are often
connected, such as extremist views, inciting hate, grooming and
misinformation.
It is these kinds of tools that teachers across the UK are crying
out for as they seek to prevent misogynistic attitudes from
developing or being widely shared within school settings. I want
to see parity for children and teachers across the UK, because of
course misogyny knows no boundaries. While we can all understand
how local authorities and schools across the country are
stretched, given the significant financial pressures they are
under, it is vital that future generations are safeguarded
against these dangerous attitudes, which can cause damage to both
themselves and others. I would therefore very much welcome the
Minister’s comments on what the UK Government are doing to
support schools across England in tackling these widespread
harms. We know that his Government have some work to do in this
area and on media literacy and digital resilience, because
provisions in the Department for Education’s general curriculum
are, sadly, seriously lacking.
Yet the Welsh Government have designed a specific programme that
provides safeguarding leads with training to identify, prevent
and respond to incidents of online sexual harassment. They have
also committed to publishing a new online training module to
support all school staff in tackling this issue. In Wales, we are
fortunate to have a Government who really understand and care
about the damage that misogyny can do to communities, big and
small, if it is allowed to perpetuate. They have made it a
priority to get this right and to support teachers wherever
possible, so I want to press the Minister: why cannot the same be
said for England?
I have a huge amount of respect for the Minister, who is
obviously passionate about his brief and comes to this
afternoon’s debate with a huge amount of knowledge and
experience. He, too, must know that misogyny does not exist in a
vacuum, and that it can often be tied to far-right ideology and
the worldview of the so-called manosphere. This often exists
online as a loose collection of forums, blogs, vlogs and
organisations concerned with men’s issues and masculinity that
are oriented around opposition to feminism.
It is thanks to HOPE not hate, which does some incredibly
important work in this area, that we know for certain that parts
of this manosphere are highly misogynistic and have, in recent
years, grown increasingly extreme and close to the far right,
utilising racist conspiracy theories to explain perceived
societal issues.
It is a frustrating reality that charities including HOPE not
hate and Women’s Aid have had to step in in the absence of any
real leadership or Government action. HOPE not hate first began
speaking to teachers about the manosphere back in 2018 and
misogyny in the classroom has been a constant topic in its work
and the work of teachers ever since. Ultimately teachers do not
have the training to deal with the problem, and I have genuine
concerns that some might instead treat it as general behaviour
and are likely to ignore the situation for fear of saying the
wrong thing.
It is important to stress that misogyny is not a school-specific
problem; it is a societal one being played out in the education
system. We must do more to promote our positive male role models
and the brilliant organisations doing transformative work in this
space, including Mentivity, Beyond Equality, Progressive
Masculinity, and the ManKind Project. All of them are stepping in
to take vital action in this area.
In the last year alone HOPE not hate has delivered training to
more than 2,000 teachers across England and Wales as part of its
mission to challenge hate and discrimination. Welsh Women’s Aid
offers a bystander training programme which aims to empower
communities to intervene proactively to stop violence and abuse
wherever and whenever possible. I am proud that this training has
been delivered in all Welsh universities and has also been
delivered in many schools at sixth-form level.
Teachers should not be left to try and tackle this endemic
situation alone. They need the support and tools to tackle the
issue at its root. Teachers are already being given a huge amount
of training on a vast range of topics, but this problem is not
going away without clear attention and interventions.
I am conscious of time so the final points I shall highlight are
findings from the Sex Education Forum’s recent poll around
relationships and sex education in schools in England. It
surveyed 1,000 young people aged 16 and 17 and, shockingly, 37%
reported learning nothing about power imbalances in relationships
as part of their education at school, more than a quarter had
learnt nothing about the attitudes and behaviour of men and boys
towards women and girls, and 28% of young people had not learnt
about how to tell if a relationship is healthy, including online.
That is truly shocking. These numbers are simply too high, and I
look forward to the Minister’s remarks, which I hope will give me
some confidence that he is aware of, and prepared to act on, this
incredibly important issue.
5.12pm
The Minister of State, Department for Education ()
I congratulate the hon. Member for Pontypridd () on securing this
important, albeit brief, debate and on her excellent speech. It
is with dismay that I share her view that we have all seen the
growing prominence of a social media influencer who has gained
status and attention through the use of inflammatory and hateful
comments. While we recognise that schools should not bear all the
burden of responding to misogyny and other forms of prejudice—as
she said, this is a societal issue—education is our key tool in
creating the respectful society we all want to see and inhabit.
Teachers might therefore need additional support in addressing
these issues with pupils and in holding all pupils to the highest
standards of behaviour. Schools must be places in which
inappropriate language or behaviour is always challenged, never
normalised, and never treated as merely banter or harmless
fun.
In September 2020, we made relationships and sex education
compulsory for the first time in all schools in England, and we
published guidance which states that schools should be aware of
issues such as everyday sexism, misogyny, homophobia and gender
stereotypes, and that schools should take steps to build a
culture where these are not tolerated.
Following the shocking murder of Sarah Everard in March 2021,
thousands of testimonies of abuse and harassment suffered by
pupils in schools were posted on the Everyone’s Invited website.
The Government asked Ofsted to carry out a review, and in 2021
Ofsted published a review of sexual abuse in schools and colleges
which made clear recommendations for Government.
The response from this Government has been concerted and
comprehensive. The tackling violence against women and girls
strategy sets out further actions we are taking and the progress
we have made so far, including the Domestic Abuse Act 2021, the
“Enough” communications campaign, and changes to the law to
introduce new criminal offences including upskirting and revenge
porn.
The Department for Education provided additional support for
RSHE, opening an additional round of the RSHE “train the trainer”
programme in 2021 and hosting webinars on hard-to-teach subjects.
We will also be publishing non-statutory guidance specifically
focused on teaching about sexual harassment and sexual violence.
We have updated our behaviour guidance, which now includes advice
on handling sexual harassment and sexual violence in schools. We
have updated our safeguarding guidance, which is now clear about
schools’ duties in relation to equality, harassment and
victimisation as well as prejudice.
Relationships education equips young people with the knowledge
and values they need to combat the prejudiced views expressed by
some social media influencers. Since relationships education
became a compulsory subject in 2020, all primary schools should
learn to identify stereotypes and understand why stereotypes can
be unfair and destructive. Primary pupils should be taught about
the importance of respect and how to build healthy friendships
and relationships, which the hon. Member specifically referred
to. All secondary school pupils should learn about consent and
about what constitutes sexual harassment and sexual violence, and
why that type of behaviour is wrong.
We invested £3 million to support teachers to deliver the new
curriculum, and about 5,000 teachers have received training in a
cascade model in which teachers pass on their training to others.
We have strongly encouraged schools to dedicate time from inset
days for relationships, sex and health education training,
especially in the light of Ofsted’s review.
Ofsted’s review gave us a sense of the scale of sexual harassment
and violence in schools, which is predominantly directed against
girls. In its survey, 92% of 13-year-old girls said that sexist
name-calling happened a lot or sometimes between people their
age, and 79% of girls said that sexual assault happened a lot or
sometimes between people their age. Those statistics are deeply
concerning, and the prejudiced and often violent language that
can be found on social media clearly fosters a culture of
disrespect and abuse. Schools have a challenging task in
addressing the root causes of prejudice, including misogyny,
starting in primary. I express my gratitude to the many teachers
who are working hard to teach about equality, stereotypes and
respect.
In the past year, we have produced webinars to support teachers
to address key topics related to violence against women and
girls, including pornography, child sexual exploitation and
domestic abuse. We will be publishing new non- statutory guidance
later this year providing practical advice to teachers and
teaching about sexual harassment, sexual violence, and violence
against women and girls. That will support schools to take a
whole-school approach to combating prejudice and building a
culture of respect. A whole-school approach includes not only
preventive education but a zero-tolerance approach to abusive
behaviour in schools and a robust approach to safeguarding.
Good behaviour in schools is absolutely essential to a good
education. Our recently updated “Behaviour in schools” guidance
advises schools on how to develop calm, safe and supportive
environments where pupils and staff feel safe and respected.
Schools should be clear in every aspect of their culture that
sexual violence and sexual harassment are never acceptable and
will not be tolerated. Pupils should be taught how to behave
appropriately and to meet the high standards expected of them,
and staff should respond assertively and challenge all sexually
inappropriate language and behaviour between pupils. Those
interventions are necessary to prevent abusive or violent
behaviour in the future and to make clear that sexually abusive
language or behaviour is never acceptable.
It is particularly important that headteachers lead the creation
and reinforcement of a respectful school culture, ensuring that
it permeates through every aspect of school life. Pupils who fall
short of those expectations should and can be sanctioned
appropriately, in accordance with their school’s behaviour
policy.
We have strengthened the “Keeping children safe in education”
guidance. On the back of Ofsted’s review, it now includes
specific advice on sexual violence and sexual harassment, and
puts it on a statutory footing, recognising the importance of
supporting schools and colleges in what is an extremely difficult
role. We are clear that safeguarding is everyone’s
responsibility. However, the role of schools and colleges is
critical. We remain committed to ensuring that they have the
tools and support to carry out their responsibilities.
Although education is a key tool in combating prejudice and
creating a culture of respect, we recognise that, as the hon.
Member for Pontypridd said, misogyny is a societal problem that
arises partly from the harmful content that pupils might access
online. The online world should not be a refuge for violent
misogyny, and the Government are committed to ensuring that there
are sufficient protections for women and girls online.
The Online Safety Bill contains strong protections for women and
girls, who face disproportionate abuse online. The strongest
protections in the Bill, of course, are for children. The Bill
will make the UK the safest place to be a child online. As well
as protecting children from illegal material, all services likely
to be accessed by children will need to provide additional
protection for those children. Those safety measures will need to
protect children from harmful content and behaviours such as
bullying, abuse and harassment, as well as content depicting or
promoting violence.
Finally, I reiterate our commitment to supporting schools in
their work to educate young people about prejudice of all forms
and to protect them from harmful behaviour. We know that this
work can be challenging and that many schools are doing it to a
very high standard. Some schools are struggling, but all pupils
in our schools deserve to grow up in a culture of respect and
kindness. This Government are committed to ensuring that they
do.
Question put and agreed to.
|