Mr Ian Liddell-Grainger (Bridgwater and West Somerset) (Con) I beg
to move, That this House has considered Commonwealth Day. I am
delighted to work under your chairmanship again, Mr Davies. We
have, for many years, worked together on various things, both here
and in Europe. I am delighted also to see so many colleagues
joining us to celebrate the Commonwealth. If I may, Mr Davies, I
will start on a sad note. Emilia Monjowa Lifaka, chair of the
Commonwealth...Request free trial
(Bridgwater and West Somerset) (Con)
I beg to move,
That this House has considered Commonwealth Day.
I am delighted to work under your chairmanship again, Mr Davies.
We have, for many years, worked together on various things, both
here and in Europe. I am delighted also to see so many colleagues
joining us to celebrate the Commonwealth.
If I may, Mr Davies, I will start on a sad note. Emilia Monjowa
Lifaka, chair of the Commonwealth Parliamentary Association,
unfortunately passed away, as you know, in sad circumstances. She
was from Cameroon—a remarkable lady who was one of those people
who go through life setting the room alight. She was absolutely
sweet. Her death caused a vacuum, which has now been filled
temporarily by me.
I am delighted to introduce the debate for a load of reasons.
First, the Commonwealth, as my colleagues know, is 111 years old.
It is one of the oldest—dare I say it?—non-governmental bodies in
the world, and it has enormous respect. For the record, 17,000
parliamentarians, 180 Parliaments, 54 countries and 2.4 billion
people are part of the family that we call the Commonwealth.
This week is very pertinent because yesterday we had the
Commonwealth service in Westminster Abbey, which is always
interesting. I am sitting next to a couple of my friends—my right
hon. Friends the Members for Basingstoke (Mrs Miller) and for
Dumfriesshire, Clydesdale and Tweeddale ()—and we are delighted that
this week we have the Westminster Seminar, which is ongoing, as
we speak, in the Attlee suite. That seminar is 70 years old this
year. The Commonwealth, as a family, has shown time and again
that it breaks every record.
As chairman of the UK branch of the Commonwealth Parliamentary
Association and international vice-chairman, I am always grateful
for the support that the House and the other place give. Every
party in the House, and every Member, is an enormous supporter of
the Commonwealth, and I am grateful for all the work that
colleagues do—not just here in the United Kingdom, but
overseas—in welcoming delegates, wherever they come from across
the Commonwealth, and going on trips, sometimes at short notice,
which can be fairly onerous as we know. You, Mr Davies, have been
involved, and I am grateful for the time and effort you have put
in over the years.
Was yesterday’s Commonwealth Day just a symbol or an annual
occasion? Some people may think it was a bit of both, but let us
put the matter in perspective. The world is watching in horror
and disgust as the tragic death and destruction in Ukraine
unfold. That is why the peaceful symbolism of the Commonwealth
has become more important than ever. For anyone who saw the
moving service in Westminster Abbey yesterday, or was lucky
enough to be present, as I and colleagues here were, the true
meaning and the lasting value of the Commonwealth shone
through.
It was terribly sad for us all that Her Majesty the Queen, in her
70th year on the throne—she has provided enormous support,
stability and guidance over all those years—was not able to
attend the service. We were obviously delighted to see His Royal
Highness the Prince of Wales and Her Royal Highness the Duchess
of Cornwall, and Their Royal Highnesses the Duke and Duchess of
Cambridge. That was very special indeed, but I know that we all
send Her Majesty our heartfelt wishes to get better soon.
In normal circumstances, the Queen is an absolute stickler for
duty. I suspect her doctors probably said, “Look, stay at home,”
but I know one thing: she does not give in easily. However, the
decades of loyal service are catching up with her, and because
she has only recently recovered from covid, I think she has, more
than any other person, an excuse for saying, “I can’t attend.” I
am convinced, however, that she can play, and will continue to
play, a highly influential role in the development and success of
the family that we call the Commonwealth. I hope colleagues will
join me in that, for that is what the Commonwealth really is—a
family. It is no cosy club, let alone, God forbid, a political
movement.
Mr (South West Hertfordshire)
(Con)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Davies. My
hon. and gallant Friend has alluded to the fact that the
Commonwealth can be regarded as a family—I have two brothers, so
I know that, occasionally, there can be tension in a family—and I
applaud him for his excellent work with the Commonwealth
Parliamentary Association, of which I have some direct
experience. I know that people get more out of the Commonwealth
than they put in.
Does my hon. and gallant Friend agree that the jurisdictions that
we are able to help from this place find it immeasurably helpful
to share not only democracy, but also the same values, legal
system and language, to the benefit of what was once the British
empire?
Mr Liddell-Grainger
I would like thank my hon. Friend on three counts: first, for his
courtesy in intervening, as he raises a very important question;
secondly, for all the work he has done on behalf of the
Commonwealth; and thirdly for the overseas trips he has
undertaken very nobly.
The point my hon. Friend makes is absolutely right. There are
hiccups; in any family, there will be hiccups. Hopefully this
year we will welcome back the Maldives and Zimbabwe. We resolved
an issue with Fiji, and they came back into the Commonwealth. We
do not like to exclude anybody, as my hon. Friend alludes to. We
try to work with any country that has an issue to make sure that
they understand what we can do to help them, and maybe how they
can help us. It has been a very successful formula; we have never
completely excluded anybody. Even in the worst days, with some of
the things we have seen over the years—I am a little older than
my hon. Friend—we have never done that. We have kept things
going. Therefore, my hon. Friend is absolutely right that this is
an amazing organisation, based on mutual trust as much as
anything.
The Commonwealth is a genuine association of nations with worthy
aims and the mission to improve the lives of all its members and
their citizens. We are talking about very big numbers across the
world. Commonwealth Day was observed and celebrated by people in
Africa, Asia, the Caribbean, the Americas, the Pacific and, of
course, here in Europe.
The Commonwealth of Nations, which is its proper title, has 54
nations. It is impossible to open an atlas without finding
somewhere the footprint of that extraordinary organisation. On
the continent of Africa are Botswana, Cameroon, The Gambia,
Ghana, Kenya, the Kingdom of Eswatini, Lesotho, Malawi,
Mauritius, Mozambique, Namibia, Nigeria, Rwanda, Seychelles,
Sierra Leone, South Africa, Uganda, the United Republic of
Tanzania, and Zambia. To the east, we have Bangladesh, Brunei,
Malaysia, Maldives, Pakistan, Singapore and Sri Lanka. In the
opposite direction, over the Atlantic, there are Antigua,
Barbuda, the Bahamas, Barbados, Belize, Canada, the Dominican
Republic, Grenada, Guyana, Jamaica, St. Lucia, Saint Kitts and
Nevis, St. Vincent and the Grenadines, not to mention, of course,
Trinidad and Tobago. Across the other way, towards the Pacific,
we have Australia, Fiji, Kiribati, Nauru, New Zealand, Papua New
Guinea, Samoa, Solomon Islands, Tonga, Tuvalu and Vanuatu. It is
a really incredible worldwide membership.
Some of us may be very lucky and hopefully get away to the
beaches of Cyprus and Malta this year, provided there are no
further problems. Both of them, which comes a surprise to some
people, are members of the Commonwealth. The Commonwealth
occupies one quarter of the world’s landmass, and is home to 2.6
billion people. To put that vast figure into perspective, here
are some timely comparisons. Russia has a population of 146
million. Even the former Soviet Union, which Vladimir Putin wants
to put back together, apparently, would only account for 300
million people. The Commonwealth is enormous: big not only in
size but, I am glad to say, big in ideas.
We are committed to the institution of world peace and the
promotion of representative democracy. We stand for individual
liberty, the pursuit of equality and the opposition of racism. We
only fight discrimination, poverty, ignorance and disease—I want
to get that message across. We want a safer planet. A democratic
planet. A free world with free trade and the freedom to express
ideas and the pursuit of common goals.
At this stage I would like to mention my right hon. Friend the
Member for Basingstoke and her phenomenal work with the Women and
Equalities Committee across the world. I am so grateful for all
the work she has done. I have a feeling, if I dare say this, that
the Kremlin would not understand a word of this, and I also have
the feeling that they should learn.
The Commonwealth is far more than a throwback to the days of the
British empire—that is a silly myth. Although it is perfectly
true that many of the great Commonwealth countries were once
British colonies, look at them now: independently governed,
democratically elected, not owing their lifeblood or their
existence to a long-gone empire. Thirty-four of its countries are
republics; 15 others are Commonwealth realms where our Queen, the
Head of the Commonwealth, is also the Head of State; and five
countries—Brunei, Eswatini, Lesotho, Malaysia and Tonga—are
monarchies, with kings and queens in their own right.
My hon. and gallant Friend is making an excellent speech; those
who have heard him speak before will not be surprised by that.
Does he agree that there is quite a young population within the
Commonwealth? From my understanding, about 60% of people in the
Commonwealth are below the age of 29, and therefore the next
generation has seen the benefits of being a partner within the
Commonwealth family.
Mr Liddell-Grainger
I thank my hon. Friend again, because that is a very good
intervention. He is absolutely right: this is a very young
organisation. If we take India, Pakistan, Bangladesh and a lot of
Africa, these are very young people. As you well know, Mr Davies,
the younger you get people, the more you can influence them, and
democracy is something we fight for and live for. We want to
foster that, and it is taught in schools. I have just come back
from Pakistan, where I was with , the secretary-general of the
Commonwealth Parliamentary Association. We went to see schools
where they teach children of six and seven about what it means to
be part of Pakistan, and about democracy and the way it works. We
were surrounded by MPs from Pakistan who came out to talk to the
kids as well. It was a great thing.
Saying that we are a family takes in every age group, ethnicity,
colour, creed and religion, and that is the beauty of the
Commonwealth: it is all-encompassing, and age is just one facet
that we love to deal with. I am very grateful to colleagues that
the Westminster Seminar series is looking at this part of it. We
sit there in the Attlee suite, and one of the things we embrace
is the ability for young people to aspire. Nothing gives me more
pleasure than to find somebody from Tonga who has gone to Canada,
somebody from Canada who has gone to India, somebody from India
who has gone to New Zealand, or somebody from New Zealand who has
gone to South Africa to work within our family. Our scholarship
and fellowship schemes are quite remarkable.
As I say, these countries all do their own thing, but they prefer
to stay signed up to the ideals of the Commonwealth. Any
Commonwealth country can leave. We started with eight countries
when Her Majesty came to the throne; we are 54 now. Nobody
leaves—they join. Why? Because they know what they are getting.
What is on the tin is in the tin, and they understand that. It is
funny how many countries want to join us. Sometimes, like with
Mozambique or Namibia, people might say, “Well, it is a bit
tenuous.” Rubbish! We are delighted for countries to join whose
creation Britain has had a part in—probably not quite the part
they wanted, but we had a part in their creation, and they want
to join us. That is important. There are only two Commonwealth
countries that did not have any connection with the empire.
Namibia is one; the other, of course, is Rwanda, which has gone
through a frightening history and is now an enormously valued
part of the family.
Slowly, patiently and effectively, the family of the Commonwealth
is spreading the doctrine of parliamentary democracy across the
world. It works at different speeds in different places,
understandably, but there is no doubt in my mind—or, I hope, in
the mind of any Member of either House—that it does a good job.
We reject dictatorships. We seek agreement through debate, with
the active participation of the people via the ballot box. That
is what we do as an international parliamentary association and
as its individual nation branches, including the one right here
in Westminster, which is phenomenal: I thank my colleagues and
Members of the other place so much for the work they do. The
network is registered throughout the world, and recognised
throughout the world as an invaluable source. It brings people
together and nurtures co-operation. If it did not exist now, we
would certainly never invent it.
But there is a problem—one that, sad to say, the Government at
the moment have not been able to address or recognise. For
reasons that make little sense to me, the Commonwealth
Parliamentary Association is a registered charity. That goes back
into the mists of time; I do not know why it was set up that way
in the first place. That would be fine if the CPA were purely in
the business of raising funds for worthy causes, but we do not
need the sorts of tax breaks that go with charitable status—it is
not what we do. We are serious players in a serious process of
effective diplomacy across the world. We have something to offer
that is proven, practical and effective. We help all
parliamentarians in the Commonwealth. We aim for best practice;
we teach best practice; we want good governance and know how to
get it. That is our strength. It is surely high time that the CPA
is given the status it richly deserves.
All we are asking for is legal status in the UK similar to that
enjoyed by comparable organisations. We do not want to be any
different from them. We just want it changed so that we are
comparable, for example, with the Parliamentary Assembly of the
Francophonie, a group of parliamentary nations that share the
French language—Belgium, Canada, Belize, Cambodia—in a mini
Gallic commonwealth. Such legal recognition would enable the CPA
to have more positive influence.
I do not think that is much to ask and the time has come. The
former Lord Speaker, Baroness D’Souza, introduced a Bill in the
other place, the Commonwealth Parliamentary Association (Status)
Bill, which is working its way here. A few weeks back, I launched
a ten-minute rule Bill, the Commonwealth Parliamentary
Association (Status) (No. 2) Bill, with exactly the same wording,
to get the legal status recognised. The enthusiasm for change
unites all parties throughout both Houses of this Parliament. Mr
Speaker is an enormous advocate of the Commonwealth, as is the
Lord Speaker, who spoke at the Westminster Seminar yesterday. I
am very grateful to Mr Speaker, who has been incredible in the
past 24 hours, appearing at almost every event. It would be
fitting to pay tribute to the Commonwealth Parliamentary
Association in Her Majesty the Queen’s jubilee year. She has
presided over the incredible growth of the organisation.
I know that Ministers have so far reacted to the idea without
enthusiasm, even though it will not cost a penny. It will make no
fundamental change to this place and no difference to the
Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office. It will make no
difference to the way we operate. We will operate in exactly the
same way, but it will make a massive difference to the way that
we are seen in the world, and the organisations we can become
part of. I say gently to the Minister that I sincerely hope we
can help change the Government’s views on a fairly small but
fundamental change. These are very dangerous days for world
peace. We should show leadership as a nation and support all
efforts to promote democracy, not just in the Commonwealth but
obviously elsewhere. The alternative is as brutal and deadly as
Russia proves hour by hour. That is what we do not want to
see.
The Speaker, for the first time, is leading his own delegation to
India in a couple of weeks, about which we are absolutely
delighted. It is right that the Speaker of the House of Commons
should be able to lead delegations, and I hope colleagues agree
that is a welcome change. I know colleagues will join me in
thanking the CPA team in the House, led by chief executive Jon
Davies and Helen Haywood, which looks after CPA interests in this
country and across the world.
I would also like to thank , who is the secretary-general
of CPA international, based across the road from here, for the
work that he and his team have done. It has not been easy for
either team over the past two years. We have had to keep
everything going and keep in touch with everybody round the
world, when we could not go anywhere. The frustration for me and
Stephen was that we could not send colleagues or get into
delegations, with everything done by Zoom. Last week in Pakistan
we met a female MP who said to Stephen:
“Gosh! You are a lot taller than you look on Zoom.”
That probably summed up the past two years. As my right hon.
Friend the Member for Basingstoke knows, that was Shandana, who
is chair of the women’s caucus and forum, the Commonwealth Women
Parliamentarians.
Lastly, it has been a great privilege to be part of the CPA for a
decade. I follow on from a line of very noble people who have led
the CPA UK branch, and it has been a remarkable experience for us
all. One thing I will never cease to be amazed by is that,
everywhere I go in the Commonwealth, I realise that people are
truly grateful for the work we do on benchmarking, for the way
that we do our academies, and for the way we work with other
Parliaments through Clerks, through Hansard and through all the
other things that we take for granted but which so many other
places do not. It is what gives us our strength. It means never
resting, never stopping, growing the Commonwealth, and making
sure we do it in the name of democracy and in the name of the
people whom we represent: the people of the world.
9.50am
(Strangford) (DUP)
I congratulate the hon. Member for Bridgwater and West Somerset
(Mr Liddell-Grainger) on setting the scene so well. His deep
interest in this subject is apparent from his comments, and I
thank him for all the hard work he does.
The hon. Member referred to the work of the Commonwealth
Parliamentary Association. I endorse his comments about what the
CPA does and the importance of having it in place. He also
referred twice to parliamentary democracy and how important it is
to set an example, which the Commonwealth clearly does. As we are
all reminded every morning and night on our TV screens, some
parts of the world are fighting for their democracy; we think of
Ukraine, as the hon. Member rightly said at the beginning. We
concur with his comments about Russia, but we are greatly
encouraged by the Ukraine military’s spirit and the courage that
people are showing against Russian aggression. We are proud of
that.
We are also very proud to be part of the Commonwealth of 54
nations. The Commonwealth spans 54 independent countries, and
about 2.6 billion people—out of some 7.9 billion globally—live in
the Commonwealth. That tells us about the size and importance of
the Commonwealth, and about what it does. I share people’s
adoration of the Queen, who by her very Christian faith and life
sets an example for us all in this House and across the world.
She is also the Queen of 15 Commonwealth nations, whereas five
other countries have their own monarch and 34 are republics. The
Commonwealth makes up a quarter of the world’s landmass. Such
stats illustrate the importance of the Commonwealth, its size and
the role that it plays across the world.
Along with India and Australia, the giant of the Commonwealth
group is Canada. I well recall emigrating to Canada as an
18-year-old—it was not yesterday. Canada was the country where I
was a landed immigrant for a year. I was a bricklayer there; it
was good to experience, as a young person, what the Commonwealth
has in Canada and what it can offer. One of the great things
about the Commonwealth is being able to enjoy that. Canada is the
world’s second largest country by area, but the beauty of the
Commonwealth is that we also embrace the smaller states to which
the hon. Member for Bridgwater and West Somerset referred— states
such as the Pacific islands of Nauru, Samoa, Tuvalu, Vanuatu, as
well as Dominica, Antigua and Barbados in the Caribbean. This
great Commonwealth represents a cosmopolitan world through
countries large and small.
As a Commonwealth of nations, we believe in democracy, freedom
and a common purpose to extend the arm of friendship to many
countries across the world. It is mutually beneficial to be a
member, and the combined GDP of the 54 countries is some £7.5
trillion—twice the size of Japan’s, but some way behind that of
the US. Trade with the Commonwealth accounted for some 9.1% of
the UK’s total trade in 2019, and UK exports to the Commonwealth
were worth around £65 billion. That tells us that the importance
of the Commonwealth lies in our trade and in nations coming
together. Imports from the Commonwealth were worth around £64
billion, so the value of what we sell them is comparable to the
value of what they sell us.
It is clear that it is a good thing to do business with friendly
neighbours. Although this is not a Brexit debate, it has always
been my hope that we can be separate yet distinct in Europe with
our friendship. The despicable treatment of my country, Northern
Ireland, as a political football has disabused me of that notion.
Were we to treat one of the Commonwealth countries with such
malice and contempt, the world would rightly call us out.
Unfortunately, Northern Ireland’s treatment by Europe has been
widely accepted and continues—but that is a discussion for
another day as it is not the subject of this debate, although it
is important to put it on the record.
Now, more than ever, the arm of friendship should be extended
within our Commonwealth family to ensure that we are getting and
giving the best of those with whom we share the commonality of
the Commonwealth. We share many cultures, much history and even,
in many cases, the same language. We must also use our position
to encourage members that do not allow religious freedom to do
so. The Minister knows that I often speak about that and although
I suspect that she has already prepared the answer to the
question that I will ask, it is important to put it on the
record.
According to the Pew Research Centre, 70% of people who live in
Commonwealth countries face high or extremely high Government
restrictions on their right to freedom of religion or belief.
Worse still, some 88% of those people face high or very high
social hostility simply for holding minority beliefs. I declare
an interest: I am chair of the all-party parliamentary group on
international freedom of religion or belief. As we celebrate the
Commonwealth, will the Minister tell me, the House and those
watching the debate what has been done to address the persecution
of those in this great Commonwealth who have Christian beliefs,
other beliefs and, indeed, no beliefs? I would like there to be
freedom of religion for all—and I know, without even asking, that
the Minister does as well. It is important that one of our pleas
should be for that to be improved, and I hope that it will
be.
I will also make another honest plea. As we approach St Patrick’s
day on Thursday, I am ever mindful that the Republic of Ireland
is not part of the Commonwealth. Would it not be great if they
were? It is not too late to ask them—we ask them regularly. We
want them to consider that gently but honestly, as friends. I see
membership as something that could be advantageous to them and to
us. Their inclusion would make the Commonwealth bigger, greater
and better. I ask the Minister this: has there been any
opportunity to see whether the Republic of Ireland would join the
nations brought together by this great multicultural Commonwealth
and by a common desire?
This great challenge must be met head on. I urge the Minister to
take the baton of that challenge and work sensitively and
effectively with all our Commonwealth brethren to bring about
religious freedom for all. Trade is a wonderful positive point,
but we must all ensure that we exert any positive influence that
we can, at any opportunity, to bring about change.
I am eternally grateful for the leadership of Her Majesty the
Queen in matters of faith—I know that those are a priority for
her. We can and should follow the example of that wonderful lady
by pressing for religious freedom for all. We can do more with
the body and the mechanism of the Commonwealth to improve lives,
but we must also take the opportunity, in this dark world, to
shine a light at any and every opportunity. The goodness of the
Commonwealth, in what it does and what it can do, can help this
country to be a brighter shining light for all.
9.58am
(Stafford) (Con)
It is an honour to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Davies. I am
delighted to have co-sponsored the debate with my hon. Friend the
Member for Bridgwater and West Somerset (Mr Liddell-Grainger),
and I congratulate him on securing it on Commonwealth Day.
As a member of the Commonwealth Parliamentary Association, I
appreciate the importance of the interconnected nature of the
Commonwealth and the need to keep and strengthen the strong
cultural, trade and diplomatic relationships between the
countries of the Commonwealth. I am looking forward to
strengthening our sporting ties this summer, when we will welcome
people from across the Commonwealth to Staffordshire,
particularly the west midlands, for the Commonwealth games. I
welcome the Minister to her place. I know that she shares my
enthusiasm for the games, as the mountain-biking event will take
place in Cannock Chase forest, which borders our two
Staffordshire constituencies.
I am honoured to have been appointed as the Prime Minister’s
trade envoy to Kenya, one of the leading Commonwealth nations in
east Africa. The close Commonwealth connections between the UK
and Kenya mean that it is one of the first countries that the UK
has done a trade deal with in this area following our exit from
the European Union. I was pleased to be at the signing of the
UK-Kenya economic partnership agreement, which I believe will
provide continuity for UK businesses and help to create more
jobs, both at home and abroad. From my recent visits to Kenya to
meet British businesses working in east Africa and Kenyan
Government Ministers, the importance of this trade agreement for
our mutual prosperity is very clear. Such trade deals are being
replicated across the Commonwealth, increasing economic
prosperity for all Commonwealth citizens.
Like my hon. Friend the Member for Bridgwater and West Somerset,
I attended the Commonwealth service at Westminster Abbey
yesterday with the Prime Minister and the royal family. I sat
alongside a number of African MPs who were here this week in
London to attend the Westminster Seminar. I was struck by how
united the Commonwealth is in its aims for the future and how
immense the potential is to tackle the great global challenges we
all face, including one of the biggest threats to our current way
of life: climate change.
I attended the COP26 summit last year in Glasgow to meet with
parliamentarians from around the world who are all so dedicated
to delivering sustainable development goals and looking at ways
to promote international conservation. It was clear from talking
to those MPs that there is international will to tackle climate
change. In particular, there were strong commitments from
Commonwealth nations. I welcomed the Glasgow Climate Pact, which
includes a plan to phase down the use of unabated coal power, as
well as the Global Methane Pledge, which was signed by over 100
countries, committing at the summit to cutting their methane
emissions by 30%. These steps will lower greenhouse gas emissions
and help to reduce the use of fossil fuels, which ultimately will
help us tackle climate change.
As ever, it is vital that these agreements are what make a real
difference on the ground. I note that the COP26 President, my
right hon. Friend the Member for Reading West (), recently said at COP26,
“This is our last hope…Our best chance of building a brighter
future.”
I welcome the fact that he retains the COP presidency until
November this year, so that we can continue to make progress on
tackling climate change. I believe this is a real opportunity to
build on the plans to reach net zero by 2050; as a global
Britain, we should continue to use the COP presidency as a
platform to protect our planet further.
Climate change and damage to the environment are occurring now as
I speak here in Parliament. In the last minute alone, we have
lost 30 football pitches of forest and at present, over 1 million
species are facing extinction. Those are staggering figures. The
reality is that climate change is not just about statistics or
abstract concepts of temperature modelling: it impacts the lives
of people every day living in the Commonwealth. Sadly, it is only
set to get worse in the future if we do not work together to
tackle it.
I am sure that, like me, many Members saw Tuvalu’s Foreign
Minister Simon Kofe’s very emotive speech at COP26. He said, “We
are sinking.” The camera then panned behind him to show that the
island where he was standing was actually under water. As they
say, a picture really does speak a thousand words. Climate change
and rising sea levels are a problem not just for Tuvalu but for
British overseas territories and other countries throughout the
Commonwealth.
Also at COP26, the UK launched the Clean Green initiative to help
developing countries take advantage of green technology and grow
their economies sustainably. That included a doubling of
UK-aid-funded green investments to more than £3 billion over five
years. It provides new guarantees to support clean infrastructure
projects in the Commonwealth and throughout the developing
world.
One of the obvious opportunities for renewable energy is in east
Africa with solar. Let us face it: Africa has a lot more sun than
we do in London. On my first visit to Kenya as trade envoy last
year, I saw first hand the transformative impact that renewables
can have in Africa. I toured east Africa’s largest solar
plant—Malindi—which was built by the British firm Globeleq using
$32 million of financing from CDC Group, now British
International Investment. The plant’s 157 solar panels began
powering a clean energy transition earlier this year. That is a
great example of where the UK-Kenya economic partnership is
already delivering clean, green infrastructure on the ground in
Kenya today and is the type of collaboration I would like to see
replicated across the Commonwealth.
We have also seen deforestation throughout the Commonwealth;
sadly, it is exacerbating climate change. As the chair of the
sub-committee on the work of the Independent Commission for Aid
Impact, I have recently held an inquiry on international climate
finance and how UK aid is used for halting deforestation and
preventing irreversible biodiversity loss. We had a recent oral
evidence session with as the Minister for the
environment at the FCDO. I asked the Minister how the Government
see the role of tackling deforestation and protecting
biodiversity, specifically in relation to reducing poverty. I was
pleased to hear the Minister say that the Government are now
actively looking for nature-based solutions when planning
Official Development Assistance-funded projects.
Tackling deforestation and planting trees is one of the areas
where the Commonwealth is leading the world. The Queen’s
Commonwealth Canopy, launched at the Commonwealth Heads of
Government meeting in 2015, is an excellent example of how all
Commonwealth countries are collaborating to make a difference to
our planet. This is a flagship international conservation project
and comprises millions of trees, from the Maldives to Malawi,
from St Lucia to Singapore. It will eventually link Commonwealth
nations across the globe, which demonstrates the power of the
Commonwealth working together for the common good.
The project is also being replicated here in Great Britain.
Earlier this month, I was delighted to plant my first tree for
the platinum jubilee at Flash Ley Community Primary School in my
Stafford constituency. Not only will that fruit tree teach local
children about caring for the environment, but it also forms part
of the Queen’s Green Canopy, which aims to encourage every
community throughout the United Kingdom to plant trees to mark
Her Majesty’s 70th year on the throne and expand the tree canopy
in the Commonwealth. I encourage all my colleagues to do the same
and especially the Minister, as my next-door neighbour in
Staffordshire.
In conclusion, I applaud the efforts of all countries in the
Commonwealth that are aiming to create a sustainable future that
is more green. The Queen, as the Head of the Commonwealth, said
it best in her recent Commonwealth statement. She said we
must:
“endeavour to ensure the Commonwealth remains an influential
force for good in our world for many generations to come.”
I absolutely agree.
(in the Chair)
I call David Mundell—and not just because he is wearing a
Commonwealth tie.
10.08am
(Dumfriesshire, Clydesdale
and Tweeddale) (Con)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Davies, and
to take part in this debate. I congratulate my hon. Friends the
Members for Stafford () and for Bridgwater and West
Somerset (Mr Liddell-Grainger) on sponsoring the debate. I thank
my hon. Friend the Member for Bridgwater and West Somerset in
particular for the work that he does as chair of the UK branch of
the Commonwealth Parliamentary Association, and for the work that
he is doing on the international front, stepping in, as is his
wont, to challenging situations and carrying that work forward
with his usual good humour and disposition.
Last week, I had the pleasure of taking part in a Commonwealth
day celebration in another Parliament. I was on the steps of the
Lesotho Parliament in Maseru with the Speaker of that Parliament
and the President of the Senate, along with our excellent and
newly established British high commissioner in Lesotho. It was
heartening to see the value placed on the Commonwealth by the
Members of that Parliament and the tributes made, as they have
been this morning, to Her Majesty the Queen and her commitment to
the Commonwealth.
As other Members have referenced, the Commonwealth ranges in
scale from countries the size of India and the geographic size of
Canada to the very small, landlocked Lesotho. People in Lesotho
are clear that their country is as much in the heart of Her
Majesty the Queen as any of the other members of the
Commonwealth, and her 70 years of service were celebrated as much
in Maseru as they are being celebrated here in London and in the
rest of the UK.
That visit—I know you are familiar with Commonwealth
Parliamentary Association work, Mr Davies—was part of a series of
contacts that have taken place between the CPA UK and the Lesotho
Parliament to enable parliamentarians here and the CPA UK to
support the Lesotho Parliament to develop and improve processes,
and to learn from each other. The Lesotho Parliament is facing a
situation that will be new to certainly all Conservative Members:
there is a conflict within the ruling party and apparently a
challenge to the Prime Minister, and there will potentially be a
vote of confidence in Parliament. We were able to have a full
discussion about how such matters are handled in our own
parliamentary system.
I am being slightly flippant, but a serious discussion took place
on how processes in that Parliament can evolve. The CPA UK has
done a great deal of work that has fed into the National Reforms
Authority, which has been established in Lesotho to try to take
forward the omnibus Bill, which will reform that Parliament. That
highlights the very important work that the CPA UK is doing not
just in terms of what my hon. Friend the Member for Bridgwater
and West Somerset does in this Parliament, but in working with
other Parliaments—peer-to-peer working between Members of this
Parliament and other Parliaments, and learning from each other.
There are certainly things that we can learn from what is done in
Lesotho and all the other members of the Commonwealth.
This is an appropriate time to pay tribute, as others have, to
Jon Davies, the chief executive of the CPA UK, and his great
team. We were accompanied on our visit to Lesotho and South
Africa by Felicity Herrmann—she is responsible for many of the
partnerships between this Parliament and other Parliaments—and
others, such as Victoria Bower. They do an excellent job
supporting members in their activities.
I led the delegation, and while we were there we met the Deputy
Speaker of the South African Parliament. He made exactly the same
points that my hon. Friend the Member for Bridgwater and West
Somerset made about the status of the CPA. I want to reinforce to
the Minister that that is a really important issue, particularly
for African members of the Commonwealth, which feel that the
CPA’s charitable status demeans it in terms of the status that it
should be afforded.
It was clear to me—I am sure the Minister and her colleagues are
aware of this—that the position in South Africa vis-à-vis the UK
is not exactly as we would want it to be. For example, the South
African view of the Russian war with Ukraine is not the same as
ours. It is very important that we have good working relations
with South African politicians. South Africa is a hugely
influential country, both in that part of the world and globally,
and therefore we have to take it seriously when its Parliament
says, “We don’t like the way in which the CPA is constituted.” I
would be grateful if the Minister would take on board not only
the point I am making, but the point made by my hon. Friend.
In his intervention, our hon. Friend the Member for South West
Hertfordshire () referred to the Commonwealth as a family, while the
hon. Member for Strangford () used this debate to raise his concern about faith
issues. In my capacity as co-chair of the all-party parliamentary
group on HIV and AIDS, I say to the Minister that we need to use
the fact that we are in the Commonwealth family to put pressure
on other members of the Commonwealth and raise the issue of
HIV/AIDS and their response to it. Some 60% of people living with
HIV live in Commonwealth countries, while one in four men in
Caribbean countries where homosexuality is criminalised has HIV.
There is a great deal to be done.
Thanks to the advances in medicine over the past 40 years, today
there is no reason why anyone with HIV should live a shorter life
than someone without it. Crucially, we have the tools to
radically slow new infections through education and prevention
measures. However, the ability to prevent the spread of HIV is
seriously compromised by punitive laws, discriminatory and brutal
policing, and denial of access to justice for people with and at
risk of acquiring HIV, which is fuelling the epidemic.
The issue at the centre of international efforts to deal with
this pandemic is a crisis of human rights law in many
Commonwealth countries, not the lack of medicines. There is now
overwhelming evidence of the link between the criminalisation of
homosexuality and the rate of HIV infection. To end new diagnoses
of HIV by 2030, which this Government are committed to doing, the
punitive laws against LGBT+ communities in the Commonwealth must
be reformed. We must not be afraid to raise this issue with
Commonwealth family members—being a family is about being able to
raise difficult and challenging issues.
As we have heard this morning, the Commonwealth is a really
positive institution. Countries such as Rwanda and Mozambique
have joined it. However, we must be clear with our friends and
family members that we want to see them reform their own
procedures and customs. On that basis, we can look forward to a
very positive future for the Commonwealth. I certainly want to do
my bit as part of the Commonwealth Parliamentary Association in
the UK. I encourage all my colleagues in this Parliament and the
devolved Parliaments to take part—it is a really worthwhile
opportunity.
(in the Chair)
Last but not least from the Back Benches, I call .
10.18am
(Basingstoke) (Con)
It is a great pleasure to serve under your chairmanship in this
important debate, Mr Davies. It is absolutely right that we
should hold this debate, secured by my hon. Friend the Member for
Bridgwater and West Somerset (Mr Liddell-Grainger), to mark
Commonwealth day. Yesterday, in Westminster Abbey, we celebrated
the rich diversity of the Commonwealth; today, we are hearing
from right hon. and hon. Members from across the House about the
important practical role that the Commonwealth plays. I declare a
slight interest: I am a member of the CPA along with my hon.
Friend, and a trustee of the Westminster Foundation for
Democracy.
My right hon. Friend the Member for Dumfriesshire, Clydesdale and
Tweeddale () set out very clearly that
one of the many values of the Commonwealth, and in particular the
CPA, is in enabling Parliaments to talk to each other and work
together to improve. I say “together” quite pointedly, because we
have as much to learn as we have knowledge to impart, which is
very important.
We live in an increasingly interconnected world. The situation in
Ukraine shows that, as do the pandemic and, as my hon. Friend the
Member for Stafford () said, climate change. Whether
it is equality, opportunity or religious freedom, which the hon.
Member for Strangford () mentioned, so many issues are interconnected, and
organisations such as the Commonwealth, but particularly the
Commonwealth, can play such a powerful role.
The Commonwealth continues to resonate because it reflects that
interconnectivity between 54 equal sovereign nations around the
world—54 nations that share values that are fundamental to our
way of life. We are free, democratic societies that want to live
in peace and to prosper, and we take action to support each other
in achieving those aims. My hon. Friend the Member for Stafford
mentioned the Commonwealth games. Nothing embodies the
Commonwealth more than athletes from across the Commonwealth
coming together, as they will in Birmingham in July this year, to
demonstrate the purposefulness behind the Commonwealth
organisation.
Too often, when we speak about the Commonwealth, we talk about
economic ties. They are important—the Commonwealth provides
significant opportunities for global Britain to trade more
freely, and the Government have been very successful in putting
their words into action with the free trade agreements with
Australia, New Zealand and Singapore and the ongoing negotiations
with India, and by looking to boost ties with countries such as
Canada. That is very real and important. However, for me, it is
the democratic ties that are so important, as my right hon.
Friend the Member for Dumfriesshire, Clydesdale and Tweeddale
said.
We have opportunities to work together to improve our
democracies. It has never been more important in this world for
us to strengthen democracies, and for this Parliament, as well as
Parliaments throughout the United Kingdom and the world, to
understand their role and their obligation to strengthen
democratic ties and, fundamentally, to strengthen our
democracies.
Within the Commonwealth, it is astonishing to see the very
practical ways that countries can work together at parliamentary
and, indeed, Government level. We have 11 member states that are
committed—as, I am proud to say, our own Government are—to 12
years of education for women. We have an alliance of 34
Commonwealth nations that have joined together to look at ways to
reduce plastics in our oceans. Those are practical ways in which
Commonwealth countries can come together on policy issues that
really matter to the future of our world.
Like other Members who have spoken, I want to pay particular
tribute to the Commonwealth Parliamentary Association. When I
joined Parliament, albeit it a number of years ago, I had not
heard of the CPA, but over the ensuing decade and a half I have
got to know it very well. I am deeply impressed by the way in
which the CPA, not just here in Westminster but across the
Commonwealth, is so dedicated to improving our democracy and the
way democracies work, and to enabling us to learn from each
other, as we are in this week’s Westminster Seminar. I am
privileged to be leading a session on Thursday on how we can be
better scrutineers of Governments. Having been a Government
Minister and the Chair of a Select Committee, I am looking
forward not only to talking about my experiences, but to hearing
from other Members about how they effect good scrutiny in their
jurisdictions.
As well as the CPA, Commonwealth Women Parliamentarians has a
crucial role in a world where still only one in every four
parliamentarians elected is a woman. We have a long way to go. In
our own Parliament, there are twice as many men elected to the
House of Commons as women, so anybody who thinks we have got this
right needs to read some of the evidence; we still have a long
way to go ourselves. By working together, Commonwealth women
parliamentarians can share experiences, perhaps hold each other
to account, and scrutinise each other on how we are trying to
increase women’s parliamentary representation.
Across the Commonwealth, we are seeing significant action being
taken. In the CWP Pacific region, women parliamentarians are
using New Zealand as a crucial regional hub to increase women’s
representation, and are highlighting notable role models. The
Canadian region is working with civil society on non-political
training for potential women candidates at provincial and
municipal levels to encourage more women to stand for Parliament.
That is something that our Parliament should be seriously
considering, as we still have a real shortfall in the number of
women who want to stand for election.
Curiously, our own region is called the British Islands and
Mediterranean region. Basically, that is the United Kingdom plus
a number of other quite scattered jurisdictions, as my hon.
Friend the Member for Bridgwater and West Somerset set out. We
are very focused on how we can use an important
tool—gender-sensitive Parliament audits—to look at how good we
are as a region at female representation. The research is clear
that strong Parliaments are representative of their country’s
people and, of course, more than 50% of people in our country are
female. We can use gender-sensitive Parliament audits to identify
how we can improve the way we encourage women to stand for
election and retain them as elected representatives.
The States Assembly of Jersey implemented such an audit in 2018,
and the Scottish Parliament has announced its plan to carry one
out this year. I am hoping that we can do likewise here in the
UK. I pay tribute to the work of the Women and Equalities
Committee, which has looked at these issues in some detail.
Indeed, four out of 13 Parliaments in our region have completed
gender-sensitive Parliament audits.
I reiterate the comments made by my right hon. and hon. Friends
about the status of the CPA. Its charitable status is becoming a
real problem, and the Minister needs to take that on board. It is
seen by many of our members as absolutely inappropriate. It does
not sit well alongside the purpose of the organisation. The CPA
needs to be recognised in the same way that so many other
international organisations are recognised, and charitable status
is not right. It would be such a shame, given the immense support
that Ministers give to the CPA, if we could not resolve this
rather administrative problem. I pay particular tribute to my
hon. Friend the Member for Bridgwater and West Somerset, who is
the chair of the CPA in the UK and, indeed, on a Commonwealth
basis at the moment, for all the work he has done on that. A
number of hon. and right hon. Members have paid tribute to the
staff of the CPA, and I echo that.
In closing, I will make reference to a remark that Her Majesty
made in her message on Commonwealth day. She said that
Commonwealth countries should continue
“to be a point of connection, cooperation and friendship.”
Those words are absolutely right. For me, the Commonwealth is
literally part of my family. Half of my family is Canadian. I am
a proud mother of three Canadian children—joint citizens. It is
those family ties, that connectivity, that binds us together—most
importantly of all, under the leadership of Her Majesty.
10.29am
(Coatbridge, Chryston and
Bellshill) (SNP)
It is good to see you in the Chair, Mr Davies. I too am grateful
to the hon. Member for Bridgwater and West Somerset (Mr
Liddell-Grainger) not only for bringing forward the debate, but
also for speaking with such great authority and knowledge on the
Commonwealth.
As we have heard, the Commonwealth brings together 54 countries
and 2.4 billion people around the world. It is a network
connecting many of the fastest-growing nations on Earth, with
strong ties in language, culture, values and mutual appreciation.
Of course there are also the famous Commonwealth games, which is
one of the few opportunities for athletes in Scotland to
represent Scotland under the Saltire; I am sure that the right
hon. Member for Dumfriesshire, Clydesdale and Tweeddale () enjoys that just as much as
I do.
The Commonwealth also has profound origins in colonialism and can
be seen as a direct descendant of the British empire. Many
critics of the Commonwealth have described it as an institute for
Britain to forget about the British empire’s genocides,
exploitation, dominance and oppression of post-colonial
countries.
Today, Commonwealth countries are still waiting for an official
apology for atrocities committed by Britain during its colonial
rule of those countries. For example, there was the massacre at
Amritsar in northern India in 1919, when British troops fired on
thousands of innocent and unarmed men, women and children during
a peaceful protest. Over 100 years later, Britain has still
refused to offer an official apology, having only acknowledged
that the massacre took place. This Government should offer India
and the people of Amritsar the closure they deserve by issuing a
formal apology—something they have requested for years.
Numerous aspects of the Commonwealth demonstrate it is not the
welcoming body that we all hoped and imagined it to be. For
example, take the Windrush controversy of recent years. Hundreds
of Commonwealth citizens, many of whom were part of the Windrush
generation, were wrongly detained, deported and denied their
legal rights. For years, Caribbean Heads of Government tried to
discuss this issue with this Government, only to be rejected. It
was only when coverage of these individuals’ stories began to
break in mainstream media that the same UK Government decided on
a U-turn and abandoned their “hostile” immigration environment
for the Windrush generation.
The UK has held the position of Commonwealth chair-in-office
since 2018 and will continue to do so until June this year. To be
honest, the UK Government have so far missed an opportunity to
implement fundamental cultural change. In March 2020, my hon.
Friend the Member for Glasgow North East () addressed this issue and
stated that the UK Government must do more, considering the two
years we have lost due to the pandemic, and that time was of the
essence to make a positive impact. Such an impact has not been
made. The Government need to do more to fully understand the
Commonwealth and to ensure that its member states abide by the
shared values of democracy, human rights and the rule of law that
are enshrined in the Commonwealth’s charter.
The Commonwealth has an unimpressive record of not being
sufficiently vocal in enforcing these core values, a situation
which has become more challenging as the organisation has grown
in size. Some members ignore international pressure to promote
democracy and human rights. Also, the Commonwealth family took no
action in January 2021 when Uganda’s President, Yoweri Museveni,
clung to power after a deeply flawed election. Also, in 2013
President Mahinda Rajapaksa of Sri Lanka hosted a Commonwealth
summit at a time when his Government stood accused of presiding
over war crimes. In Nigeria, another Commonwealth member, there
is a 10-year prison sentence for same-sex couples showing
affection in public and a 14-year prison sentence for anybody
having a gay marriage.
Also, the UK is withholding considerable aid funding from
critical Commonwealth states, demonstrating that it is
unconcerned about the Commonwealth. The UK Government have cut £4
billion from its foreign development budget for 2021-22 and
according to Commonwealth Innovation Fund research the number of
people living in extreme poverty in the Commonwealth will
increase from 209 million in 2019 to 237 million by 2025.
Mrs Miller
The hon. Gentleman is making some important points about the
Commonwealth, but will he not join me in paying tribute to the UK
Government during their time as chair-in-office for supporting
six Commonwealth countries to repeal and reform outdated
legislation that discriminates against women, girls or LGBT
communities? Is that not an opportunity that would not exist if
the Commonwealth did not exist?
I thank the right hon. Member for that intervention. She is
absolutely right, and wherever we can pursue openness, democracy,
fairness and equality throughout the world, we should take the
opportunity to do so. I just feel that we have missed an
opportunity to do that while we have been chair-in-office.
Nevertheless, I thank her for her intervention.
In 2019, the UK provided approximately £1.8 billion in bilateral
aid to Commonwealth countries, accounting for over 18% of total
bilateral ODA. In 2021, the then Secretary of State for
International Trade, the right hon. Member for South West Norfolk
()—who now serves as Foreign
Secretary and Minister for Women and Equalities—signed off £183
million of cuts to education, gender and equality spending in the
UK aid budget.
Mr Liddell-Grainger
I gently say to the hon. Gentleman that I think there is a slight
misunderstanding here. The Commonwealth does not deal with aid
budgets; it does not deal with anything to do with Government,
but Governments are part of what we do.
The hon. Gentleman mentioned certain countries that we work with.
He is quite right that there are issues in those countries, but I
was in Abuja in Nigeria recently, and we talked about that as a
family. They understood that there is a great deal of concern
around the world, as does the President of Uganda, whom I met. He
realises that there is an issue. His deputy now is Rebecca
Kadaga, who was formerly Speaker of the House out there, and she
is pretty formidable. I say to the hon. Gentleman that he should
please try not to confuse the two things. We do an enormous
amount of work, but the air of publicity in certain countries
goes against what we are trying to achieve.
I take on board what the hon. Member is saying. I will take the
opportunity to raise the injustices that we see across the world
whenever I can, and if that includes Nigeria or any other
Commonwealth country, I will continue to do so, but I thank him
for his intervention.
The UK cannot claim to have a compassionate, co-operative and
international outlook while simultaneously decreasing its
contributions to lower-income countries, including those within
the Commonwealth. We in the Scottish National party acknowledge
that work needs to be done, and that only by understanding these
little-said truths about the Commonwealth can we understand it in
the present.
10.36am
(Lewisham East) (Lab)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Mr Davies. I
thank the hon. Members for Bridgwater and West Somerset (Mr
Liddell-Grainger) and for Stafford () for co-sponsoring this debate
and bringing it before this House. Many right hon. and hon.
Members from across the Chamber have made significant
contributions on topics including promoting democracy across our
Commonwealth nations, promoting religious freedoms, economic
prosperity, preventing the spread of HIV, and connectivity
between Commonwealth countries.
Commonwealth Day is an opportunity for us to reflect on the
enduring bonds we have with our Commonwealth siblings. Nothing
more effectively reminds us that we are part of a global
Commonwealth family than contact with our constituents. Our
diversity is our strength, and I think we in Lewisham appreciate
that more than most. I have Guyanese Indian and Jamaican descent,
and I am British born and bred, so I am a child of the
Commonwealth through and through. On my trips to both those
countries, I have gained such an appreciation of the culture and
traditions that have developed over centuries from people mixing
together. In Guyana, I love the pepperpot and cook-up rice, just
as in Jamaica I love the saltfish and ackee with green bananas. I
have been to many Commonwealth countries so far in my life—The
Gambia, Barbados, Trinidad and Tobago, Mauritius and Malta—and
hope to visit many more.
We cannot take our Commonwealth family ties for granted: the
strong relationship we have with each other must be constantly
nurtured. The institutions of the Commonwealth help us to do just
that, and find new ways to partner and co-operate to solve our
common challenges. Today, we look forward to the Commonwealth
Heads of Government meeting in Rwanda this June. As we know, the
timetable was delayed by the pandemic; the UK has now held the
chair for four years, and I am sure the Minister will set out
what the Government see as the achievements of our time as
chair.
I also want to hear about the engagement that has been happening
in preparation for June. One of the ways in which the
Commonwealth brings people together is through sport, and we look
forward to the 22nd Commonwealth games in Birmingham later this
year, which will provide another welcome opportunity to renew and
deepen our connections. I would like to take this opportunity to
celebrate the achievements of Birmingham as it prepares to host
the games.
The challenges we face are daunting, but we are stronger together
than apart. Russia’s brutal invasion of Ukraine has far-reaching
impacts. We must be clear that the Russian invasion is a
violation of the Commonwealth values and principles set out
repeatedly in declarations from Singapore, Goa, Harare and
Coolum. Does the Government intend to facilitate any discussion
among Commonwealth partners?
As Commonwealth members, we believe in the notions of peace and
security, and the international rule of law. Both of those
principles have been shattered by the Russian invasion. The
Kenyan ambassador to the United Nations, Martin Kimani, said it
best:
“We must complete our recovery from the embers of dead empires in
a way that does not plunge us back into new forms of domination
and oppression.”
I could not agree more. Those words are another example of how we
have so much to learn from the experiences and histories shared
across our Commonwealth partners. I would like to again put on
the record Labour’s support for improvements to the curriculum so
that a broader range of perspectives can be fully understood.
The Russian invasion will also have economic implications across
the world, including for many Commonwealth countries. Labour
urges the Government to publish assessments of the impact of the
food and energy price rises on developing countries, particularly
the least developed states. I urge the Government to restore
funding to 0.7%, otherwise the humanitarian money that is rightly
being devoted to Ukraine will come at the expense of others. That
will often mean Commonwealth countries whose needs are also
great.
Much of the UK’s time as chair-in-office of the Commonwealth has
been dominated by the covid-19 pandemic. I ask the Minister to
give an update on the number of vaccinations delivered into arms
as a result of UK donations. I also ask the Minister to say
something about any progress that has been made on delivering
those doses earlier and more predictably, because a dose that
arrives just weeks before it goes out of date is not really a
donation at all—it is closer to the dumping of medical waste.
Quite frankly, that is an insult.
To recover from the pandemic, we need education systems to bounce
back quickly and effectively. In many Commonwealth countries, as
in the UK, schools were shut, in some cases for almost two years.
That can have a massively greater impact on girls, particularly
in parts of the Commonwealth affected by poverty. Children who
are not in school are vulnerable to child labour and child
marriage.
Analysis of the 2020 and 2021 aid budget cuts suggests that
together they would result in 700,000 girls losing support from
education programmes. The leaked equalities impact assessment
last week showed a reduction of 75% for programmes to tackle
violence against women and girls, and up to 80% for some sexual
and reproductive health programmes. The focus of this year’s
Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting in Rwanda will be
empowering young people through technology. There are many strong
UK companies and NGOs which could contribute expertise, so I hope
that the Minister will say more about what the Government will be
doing.
The benefits of an inclusive recovery from covid are huge. Girls
and boys who can achieve their potential will build more secure
societies and expand opportunities for trade and investment.
Labour is watching closely to see how the Government live up to
their promise to fully restore funding for women and girls, and I
hope that the Minister will say more about that today.
Democracy and inclusive governance are core Commonwealth values.
This year will see elections in many Commonwealth countries,
including Malta, The Gambia, Papua New Guinea, Australia, Kenya,
Lesotho, and Fiji. We look forward to being able to celebrate the
outcomes of free, fair, and peaceful elections with all of those
Commonwealth siblings in the months to come.
We must do everything we can to support those values through the
Commonwealth Parliamentary Association and Commonwealth
Foundation, and through direct diplomacy by the Government.
However, the funding for the Westminster Foundation for Democracy
remains in doubt. The Government must continue to support its
work.
The protection of human rights is another Commonwealth principle,
and we must continue to raise issues affecting marginalised
people across our sibling countries. As we know, the colonial
legacy includes laws targeting LGBT+ people, and all those
standing up against that legacy today must have our full support.
Likewise, we must work together to end violence against religious
and ethnic minorities, and ensure that journalists and political
activists can operate freely in every Commonwealth country,
including that of the incoming chair-in-office. I hope that the
Government will set out their intentions to do that in their
response.
Having saved the best until last, the Commonwealth must come
together to tackle the climate emergency. There is surely an
opportunity in Kigali to set the stage for COP27 in Egypt and to
announce continued deepening of shared Commonwealth programming.
What are the Government doing to engage with Commonwealth states
in June on the acute needs that many have on climate financing
and on adaptation, mitigation, and loss and damage funds?
The members of our Commonwealth family are bound together by so
much: our histories, our common values, our endeavours and our
shared challenges. The Commonwealth can be a deepening
partnership of equals that helps our world to flourish all the
more. Labour joins in the celebration of Commonwealth Day, and I
with it, as the Commonwealth is special to me. We encourage the
Government to set out the steps they will take to make the
promise of the Commonwealth a reality.
(in the Chair)
To respond to all those points, I call the Minister, .
10.45am
The Minister for Asia and the Middle East ()
Thank you, Mr Davies. It is a pleasure to serve under your
chairmanship, although I think I might struggle to answer every
single point that has been raised in the debate. I have been
furiously writing notes, and I will do what I can.
I am grateful to my hon. Friend the Member for Bridgwater and
West Somerset (Mr Liddell-Grainger) for securing the debate,
which is timely and which gives us an opportunity to mark and to
celebrate Commonwealth Day, and I commend him on his tireless
work and support for the Commonwealth as chair of the CPA. We
deeply appreciate the important work done by the CPA and its UK
branch.
I welcome the commitment to the Commonwealth shown by Members
across the Chamber, and I will do my best to deal with the points
they have made, but I want to begin by mentioning one colleague
who has been sorely missed during today’s debate: our dear
friend, . Sir David was a passionate
advocate for the Commonwealth, and he took part in last year’s
debate with his customary good humour, insight and
conviction.
As Minister for Asia, I had the privilege of working with Sir
David, and have travelled to a number of Commonwealth countries.
Most recently, I visited Singapore, where I advanced our
partnership to create a safer, more prosperous region. Each year,
Commonwealth Day is an occasion on which to celebrate our
connections and the diversity of our 54 nations. The Commonwealth
makes up a third of the world’s population, spanning every
continent and ocean, and every stage of development. It is right
that we use Commonwealth week to reflect on our shared values of
freedom, peace and democracy as enshrined in the Commonwealth
charter. That is a key theme that has come through all the
contributions this morning, and the charter sets out the
commitments of each member state to develop as a free and
democratic society, and to promote peace and prosperity.
The value of those principles has been highlighted over the past
few weeks, and they are completely at odds with Putin’s
unprovoked and illegal invasion of Ukraine. We will continue to
work with our Commonwealth and international partners to ensure
that there is strong political, humanitarian, defence and
economic support for Ukraine.
This year, we celebrate the platinum jubilee of Her Majesty the
Queen to mark her 70 years as monarch and 70 years as Head of the
Commonwealth. Yesterday, the Prime Minister, Lord Ahmad, who is
Minister for the Commonwealth, and members of the royal family
were joined by Commonwealth representatives at Westminster Abbey
for a service that paid tribute to Her Majesty for her tireless
dedication to the Commonwealth. This summer, at the Commonwealth
games in Birmingham, all 72 nations and territories of the
Commonwealth will come together in the spirit of friendly
competition. I am delighted that my constituency neighbour, my
hon. Friend the Member for Stafford (), is in the Chamber today. The
mountain biking event will be held in my constituency —I think
the site is on the border of our constituencies, to be fair—and I
am thrilled that we are hosting that event. I hope that Members
will come to visit Cannock Chase, which is a beautiful part of
the world.
In June, Commonwealth leaders will meet in Kigali for the first
full in-person gathering of Heads of Government since the 2018
London meeting, but let us look at the past four years that we
have been chair-in-office. We have worked hard to deliver the
commitments made in London to build a fairer, more sustainable,
more secure and more prosperous future for the 2.5 billion people
of the Commonwealth. With our Commonwealth partners, we have
built a fairer future. We have honoured our pledge to support
women’s empowerment through trade. A number of Members raised the
topic of women and girls. The SheTrades Commonwealth programme,
which supports female entrepreneurs, has already helped generate
sales of more than £32 million for women-owned businesses in
Nigeria, Kenya, Ghana and Bangladesh. We work with national human
rights institutions across the Commonwealth to strengthen human
rights, and we have ensured that more girls across the
Commonwealth have access to education.
My right hon. Friend the Member for Dumfriesshire, Clydesdale and
Tweeddale () mentioned LGBT rights. We
have delivered programmes worth more than £11 million to support
the promotion and protection of LGBT rights across the
Commonwealth. We look forward to welcoming Commonwealth partners
to the “Safe To Be Me” conference that we will host later this
year.
With our Commonwealth partners, we have built a more sustainable
future. The Government are committed to double our international
climate finance to £11.6 billion by March 2026. Since 2018, we
have co-founded the Commonwealth Climate Finance Access Hub,
which has mobilised more than $45 million to support
climate-vulnerable Commonwealth countries. Colleagues raised the
issue of climate. Through the Commonwealth marine economies
programme, we have helped 17 small island developing states to
build sustainable marine economies that are more resilient to
climate change.
With our Commonwealth partners, we have built a more secure
future. We work with all Commonwealth countries to strengthen
their cyber-security. We continue to support the excellent work
that the UK Commonwealth Parliamentary Association is doing in
strengthening governance, parliamentary oversight and
accountability across the Commonwealth. We welcome the work it is
doing this year on climate change, women, online harms and modern
slavery.
Finally, with our Commonwealth partners, we have been working for
a more prosperous future. We have a network of Commonwealth trade
envoys—it is good to see some here today—in countries such as
South Africa, Nigeria, Kenya, Ghana, Uganda and Rwanda. We have
funded programmes to liberalise global trade. We have made rapid
progress to secure trade agreements with 33 Commonwealth
countries. We recently signed two historic trade deals, with
Australia in December and New Zealand last month. This year we
will launch a new developing countries trading scheme, which will
help countries reduce poverty through trade.
Hon. Friends mentioned the legal status of the CPA. I know that
, the Minister for
the Commonwealth, wrote to my hon. Friend the Member for
Bridgwater and West Somerset earlier this month, and I believe
further conversations are ongoing with officials. We hope to find
a legal route that will give the CPA the recognition it seeks. We
have been proud to work with the CPA UK across a number of
projects during our chair-in-office, which have sought to
strengthen democracy, oversight and accountability throughout the
Commonwealth, and we value that partnership. The CPA UK has put
forward project proposals for the next financial year, and we are
considering those as part of our business planning process.
I might have a couple of minutes to pick up on another couple of
points.
I asked the Minister about the persecution of Christians and how
they are focused on in the Commonwealth. I also asked about the
Republic of Ireland. Will the Minister comment, if she is able
to?
I was just coming to countries re-joining the Commonwealth. The
UK is open to considering new applications for membership on
their merits. The interest of potential new members is a sign of
the Commonwealth’s vitality. Decisions on membership are made by
consensus of all member states. I believe that some of the
countries mentioned earlier were members in the past. Whether
they want to re-join is up to them, but as I say it is by
consensus of member states.
The hon. Member for Strangford () is a passionate champion of freedom of religion or
belief, which is established in the Commonwealth charter. We
would like Commonwealth leaders to recommit to promoting and
protecting those freedoms at CHOGM. He will be aware that the
Prime Minister appointed my hon. Friend the Member for Congleton
() as his special envoy, and will
host an international summit in July. We continue to raise human
rights with countries wherever concerns exist. My hon. Friend the
Member for Stafford, my next-door neighbour, mentioned the
Queen’s Commonwealth Canopy. We hope that all 54 member states
will have committed to participate by the time of CHOGM in
June.
My right hon. Friend the Member for Dumfriesshire, Clydesdale and
Tweeddale mentioned HIV and AIDS. I know that he is a passionate
champion of this issue. The UK’s Global Fund and the Global
Alliance for Vaccines and Immunisation are a really important way
of supporting international progress on HIV and AIDS. There is
strong engagement across Africa, including in many Commonwealth
nations, as this issue is exceptionally important. We have a
global AIDS strategy, which focuses on addressing those
inequalities.
I think I have about one more minute before I must let my hon.
Friend the Member for Bridgwater and West Somerset wind up. I am
sorry that I have not been able to cover all the points made, but
we have been able to get a snapshot of our co-operation with the
Commonwealth and Commonwealth countries. Those partnerships and
today’s debate demonstrate how the Commonwealth brings great
benefits to diverse communities across the globe. As we hand over
the baton of chair- in-office to Rwanda in June, our commitment
to the Commonwealth and the shared values of the Commonwealth
charter will not dim. The pandemic, the growing impacts of
climate change and the rise in global prices make these testing
times for all members of the Commonwealth, but as Her Majesty
said in her Commonwealth Day message yesterday, we can
“draw strength and inspiration from what we share, as we work
together towards a healthy, sustainable and prosperous future for
all.”
10.57am
Mr Liddell-Grainger
I thank the Minister and all Members who have taken part in the
debate. I am grateful for everybody’s insight and to the Minister
for being able to take on the points that have been raised. I
know that the point about the CPA’s status will be taken on
board. The Commonwealth has achieved so many of the aims that it
set out to. I did not mention this, but I am grateful for the
funding that we get from the FCDO. I was not going to bring up
our next funding bid, but I thank the Minister for doing so. I
think she knows—certainly colleagues do—that every penny that we
get from the FCDO is spent on programmes, and we do it well. The
staff of the CPA UK is only 30. The staff of the CPA
internationally is only 20. That a whole organisation can be run
on such small numbers is phenomenal; they are a tremendous
team.
We have praised Her Majesty for her incredible leadership over
the last 70 years. That shows that one person can make a massive
difference, and does so all the time. I say gently to the
Scottish National party spokesman, the hon. Member for
Coatbridge, Chryston and Bellshill (), that any country can leave
the Commonwealth. It is a club. People want to be part of the
Commonwealth because it gives us a shared history, good or bad.
It shows that by working together we can change things. It is not
always easy; it can be difficult, and I take that on the chin,
but our history is one of the things that binds us. Common
adversity can bring commonality. That is what has bound us
together. Dealing with colleagues from around the world—it is
lovely to hear about people’s heritages—shows that that is what
makes this incredible organisation work so well. One can go
anywhere in the world and meet people who say, “I’ve got a
cousin”—or an aunt or whatever—“in the United Kingdom,” and that
is just wonderful.
We do this every year. We do it because it matters to an enormous
organisation that has an enormous heart. We are a democratically
led organisation, and we fight for people and democracy.
Question put and agreed to.
Resolved,
That this House has considered Commonwealth Day.
|