Wera Hobhouse (Bath) (LD) I beg to move, That this House has
considered the matter of support for the UK’s transition to
electric vehicles by 2030. It is a pleasure to serve with you in
the Chair, Mr Twigg. I thank the Backbench Business Committee for
granting the debate and all those colleagues across the House who
supported the application for it. The topic has attracted a lot of
interest, as demonstrated by the many emails I have received from a
wide range of...Request free trial
(Bath) (LD)
I beg to move,
That this House has considered the matter of support for the UK’s
transition to electric vehicles by 2030.
It is a pleasure to serve with you in the Chair, Mr Twigg. I
thank the Backbench Business Committee for granting the debate
and all those colleagues across the House who supported the
application for it. The topic has attracted a lot of interest, as
demonstrated by the many emails I have received from a wide range
of organisations, including the Institution of Civil Engineers,
the Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders, Imperial College
London, UKHospitality, Energy UK and the British Vehicle Rental
and Leasing Association. I also place on the record the report of
the Select Committee on Transport, “Zero emission vehicles”, from
July this year, and the Government’s response to it.
I welcome the Government’s deadline for the end of selling new
petrol and diesel vehicles by 2030.
(Richmond Park) (LD)
I congratulate my hon. Friend on securing the debate, and she is
making an excellent speech. Does she agree that, since battery
production is limited by the availability of lithium, the switch
to electric vehicles will not be accessible or affordable to
everyone who owns a petrol or diesel car, and that consequently
the Government need to invest much more in alternatives to
private car use? Does she further agree that, as a start, the
Department for Transport should swiftly agree terms with
Transport for London for a medium to long-term funding solution
that will allow it to be financially self-sufficient?
Today, we are talking about electric vehicles as part of the
transition to net zero, but I totally agree that modal shift to
other and alternative forms of transport is required, including
for public health reasons. During lockdown, many people found
that walking or cycling, if they could, was a far more pleasant
experience than sitting in a car, yet the large number of cars on
our roads makes such modes of transport unsafe and keeps many
people from looking into alternatives.
Imperial College got in touch with me, as I mentioned, to tell me
that it is leading research into alternatives to lithium use in
batteries. I cannot remember what it was—perhaps something like
sodium. I encourage my hon. Friend and any Member interested in
the subject to get in touch with the research team at Imperial
College to find out more.
The cut-off point of 2030 in the UK and countries across Europe
sends an unambiguous signal of change. Petrol and diesel, made
from fossil fuel, are on the way out, for the simple reason that
we must limit global warming to 1.5° C as soon as possible and by
2050 at the latest. There is no plan B. The transition from
petrol and diesel-powered vehicles to vehicles powered by
electricity is already happening. We are here today to raise the
main issues we need to deal with to ensure the success of the
transition. We have nine years from today to complete the
transition—only a short time.
Like other Members present in the Chamber, I have made that leap
and got my first EV. Like others, I believe that I am in a good
place to contribute to the debate and to steer Government into
making good policy choices for the next nine years, rather than
not so good ones. To get the transition right, parliamentarians
and Ministers must make informed choices, anticipating the
consequences of our choices and welcoming scrutiny from outside
and inside Parliament.
In the big debate on how to get to net zero, the Government have
too often defended their inaction by saying that it is for the
markets to make the transition work. I agree that Government do
not have to deliver all the changes and investment, but they do
have a crucial role to play in setting the right policy
frameworks, from which the market and the private sector will
take their cues.
While there is progress in EV uptake, substantial barriers
remain, many of which have already been raised in Parliament.
They include the high purchase price of EVs, the lack of charging
points, and the fear of being caught short while travelling. They
all act as a constraint and delay on the transition, with many
people continuing with petrol and diesel vehicles. However, time
is short, so today I want to dig down to address the structural
problems that result in those barriers and delays.
The UK is actually in a good place to make the transition to net
zero, and the transition to EVs makes sense only if they use
zero-carbon electricity. As long as half of our electricity is
made by burning gas, why should consumers switch to something
that, from their point of view, is expensive, complicated and
full of uncertainties? The consumer association Which? has found
that just two in five drivers currently signal some intent to buy
an EV. That must change. The first principle must be that all our
electric power is made from renewables. That would be a big
incentive to consumers to make the switch and take on the
inconvenience, because they want to know that they are doing the
right thing. It would be a terrible failing of Government if the
people who commit to going electric find that their carbon
footprint is nearly as bad as it was with their petrol or diesel
vehicle.
Compared with many EU countries, Britain is wonderfully placed to
produce power from wind and waves, but we need to upscale those
technologies considerably. In 20 years, all our power—in fact,
more than we need—could and should come from renewable energy.
The Government must make that their first priority—no ifs, no
buts. Renewable energy, and wind power in particular, needs to be
10 times larger by 2030. Will we be able to power all our EVs
from renewables in 2030? The answer is a resounding yes.
Let me move to the challenges. Upscaling renewables has
challenges, not least in upskilling the workforce to take up the
new net zero jobs while those in the fossil fuel industries are
going. That needs forward planning and co-operation with our
higher and further education sectors. The upskilling of the
workforce will include new jobs in the automotive industry and
battery gigafactories. Further education colleges are open to and
ready for the challenge, but the Government need to invest in
vocational training courses at all levels.
The next challenge—it is a big one—is the national electricity
grid. Increased production of electricity—probably at least
threefold—will require power cables big enough to take the
increased load. Our national grid was built decades ago for much
lower electricity usage. Obviously, that problem is now owned by
a private company. I leave solving that problem to the governing
party that privatised it.
The national grid is a strategic network of cables bringing
enough electricity to the edges of cities and towns, and then to
the array of substations that feed streets in each community. A
threefold increase in electricity usage is anticipated, with
domestic demand increasing as gas is replaced by electric heating
and cooking as well as EV charging, if that is done from home. In
most cases, the existing 63 amps and 100 amps ratings should be
sufficient; the real problem is in the grid. Every home will be
using more electricity, but the grid will overload if too many
homes are taking close to the maximum power. There is no hiding
from the reality of the big investment needed in our national
grid for the laying of big, new cables, building new substations
and upgrading existing substations for the increased load.
The wait for grid investment is the single biggest delay factor
in rolling out EV charging. The Society of Motor Manufacturers
and Traders has undertaken analysis showing that between 689,000
and 2.3 million public chargers are required. I will go further.
The Transport Committee has recommended that the planning Bill
should
“make public charge point provision a requirement of local
plans”
and that the electricity network must be assessed for weak spots.
In 10 years, most vehicles on the roads will be EVs, and in 20
years nearly all of them will be, so when we put in new grid
infrastructure, it needs to be enough for every car in the
future, not just for those that are on the road now. It is
disappointing that the Government have only partially accepted
the recommendations of the Transport Committee, meaning that we
will have to fight for every penny, that investment in the grid
will come later rather than sooner, and that we are always going
to be behind the curve. We need to plan ahead.
The biggest concern for current EV owners, some of whom are in
this room, and future owners is how to charge their vehicles. Let
me deal with home or near-home charging first. Imagine two
different homes: the first is a home with its own off-street
parking, and the second is a home with a pavement or more between
it and its parking space, especially terraced housing or flats.
In the first example, the charging can be done by the owner from
their own electric supply; in the second example, the owner needs
to use a supply offered by the local council, which in most cases
owns the pavement and the road. We need a complete solution for
both. It is obvious that for the home with its own off-street
parking, the charging solution is in the hands of the owner: the
Government do not need to get involved unless they want to
subsidise the equipment. However, homes without off-street
parking require Government and especially local government to
play a key role.
As has been said by the Transport Committee and many others, the
variation in EV charging prices is a problem. The price of
electricity is about 20p per kilowatt for charging from the home.
I believe that the price for the second group of owners who need
on-street charging should be almost the same, but the current
prices usually range from 30p to 40p per kilowatt. That is not
acceptable: it is discriminatory against many of the people who
need the most help and encouragement to move to electric
vehicles. For us to achieve 20p per kilowatt for street or car
parking charging, it will need to be run as a not-for-profit
public service. That is the role of the local authority, but it
will need funding, investment, and the full co-operation of
National Grid.
On a positive note, providing that service will bring out the
best in local government through decisions and actions taken in
close consultation with, and with the assent of, the local
communities that they serve. Councils up and down the country
have declared a climate emergency and have committed to net zero
by 2030. My own council of Bath and North East Somerset is fully
committed to deliver a big roll-out of EV charging, but it cannot
because the grid capacity is not there. I am delighted that the
Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders agrees that we
need
“A national strategic plan delivered locally to uplift the number
of chargepoints and ensure the right type of chargers are in the
right places.”
In my own city of Bath, there are cars parked bumper to bumper on
residential streets. In 10 years, every single parking space
should have a charge point, a little bit like the old car parking
meters we once had. There should still be some connections there.
Let us put in this infrastructure all at the same time, at much
better value for the taxpayer, rather than doing it
piecemeal.
The final piece of the jigsaw for EV charging is away-from-home
charging. How easy could it be to convert the current network of
petrol stations to fast-charging hubs? Yes, it takes an hour or
even a bit more to charge fast, but combined with a meal or a
snack, it could be perfect. Once again, there will be the need
for substantial investment in the grid, as fast charging uses a
lot of electricity very quickly. I had a meeting with
representatives of the Highways Agency a couple of years ago when
they were planning for a new highways network. I asked them about
planning for the laying of big cables, but they said that that
was not the Highways Agency’s responsibility. I could not believe
it: if we are planning to build new roads, we should surely bear
in mind the fact that the cars on those roads will be electric
and will need charging. If everyone knew that they could pull up
into what used to be a petrol station and is now a fast EV
charging station, the fear of being on the side of the motorway
with a dead battery would disappear.
The Transport Committee has already begun scrutiny of the
Government’s Project Rapid, their £950 million charging fund for
strategic sites. It is clear that the levels of ambition and
funding are well below what is needed. To use a driving metaphor,
we need to be driving this transition at 70 mph and not going
along at a pedestrian pace. The Liberal Democrats pledged a
financial investment of £100 billion during this Parliament for
the transition to net zero. We are way off that mark.
In conclusion, by 2030 we can become a country where fossil fuels
are no longer used for private transport. To do that requires
political leadership. That we need alternatives to car use, as my
hon. Friend the Member for Richmond Park () points out, and to bring in
modal shifts and societal change away from our dependency on cars
in addition to the EV transition, goes without saying. There is
no planet B. Let us speed up and deliver the change.
13:45:00
(Broxtowe) (Con)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Twigg. I
thank the hon. Member for Bath () for securing this
debate.
I am pleased to be here today to speak on such a crucial and
exciting topic and to see so many other hon. Members here to do
the same. The UK Government have already pledged to ban the sale
of new petrol and diesel cars by 2030 and hybrids by 2035—a
fantastic commitment that will ensure we are striding towards our
net zero targets. It is clear that carbon emissions must fall by
100% by 2050 to meet those targets.
The target for electric vehicles set out by the Government is
ambitious, but ambitious targets will not be achieved without
equally ambitious policies for our infrastructure, green economy
and environment. This is a once-in-a-generation opportunity but
right now we are moving too slowly. At the moment, less than one
in every 100 vehicles is an electric vehicle.
I am co-chair of the midlands engine all-party parliamentary
group. In the midlands, where my Broxtowe constituency is, 39,410
new public electric vehicle charging points must be installed by
the end of the decade. Urgent action is needed to speed up the
installation of electric vehicle charging points across the
midlands. Midlands Connect’s report, “Supercharging the
Midlands”, suggests that electric vehicle use will increase by
more than 3,000% by the end of the decade and that the
installation of public electric vehicle charging points must be
six times as fast to support the growing demand.
At present, 93% of electric vehicle owners have access to
off-street parking and can install an at-home electric charger.
However, one third of midlands households do not have off-street
parking, so would rely solely on public chargers to power their
electric vehicle. At the moment, less than one in every 100
vehicles is an electric vehicle. The action we need to take is to
help local authorities to identify the best place to install new
electric vehicle charging points and work alongside my colleagues
in the Department for Transport to position the midlands as the
best test bed for the accelerated delivery of charging
points.
For constituents, the benefits of purchasing an EV are numerous.
Unlike conventional vehicles, they have no exhaust pipe and emit
no dangerous gases such as carbon dioxide or nitrous oxides,
reducing pollution and improving air quality for local
communities. They are also considerably cheaper to power:
charging an EV in public costs approximately 58% less than
filling a car with petrol, while at-home charging is even more
cost-effective. It is important that those benefits are clear and
are shouted about.
Given the midlands’ reliance on the automotive sector, securing a
successful green transition in the sector is critical to the
region. Electric vehicles represent a significant opportunity
across the supply chain, led by original equipment manufacturers
but supported by the expertise and engineering quality of our
small and medium-sized enterprises. Success could be harnessed by
exploiting the emerging resetting of international supply chains
and encouraging substantial re-shoring. Bringing the manufacture
of batteries firmly to the UK and specifically to the midlands
would also be advantageous in the context of the UK-European
Union rules of origin from 2027.
An integrated supply of battery-electric vehicles, supported by a
gigafactory and local supply chain, would create the most value.
Proposed initiatives include the west midlands gigafactory site
in Coventry and Britishvolt’s facility at MIRA technology park in
Nuneaton. Loughborough University Science and Enterprise Park
also has plans for a gigafactory to be sited in the east
midlands, but much work is still to be done to secure a green
automotive future for the midlands.
Electric battery manufacturing could be worth up to £916 million
gross value added in the midlands, reflecting a £24 billion
electrification opportunity across the UK, and automotive
opportunities across the midlands could be worth £2 billion GVA.
We have significant automotive manufacturing facilities in the
region, including Toyota, Jaguar Land Rover, Aston Martin, BMW
and Tata Motors. The region is home to significant academic
research and innovation in electric vehicles and batteries, and
that includes the UK Battery Industrialisation Centre.
Batteries represent around 40% of an electric vehicle’s value and
half the opportunity value of battery-powered electric vehicles.
Opportunities are available in the components used to make a
battery cell, such as the cathode, anode, electrolyte supply and
final assembly, as well as in the supply of components such as
cases, coves, bracketry and cabling.
It is clear that the potential benefits that lie with the
increase in electric vehicles is huge. The Government have a
fantastic opportunity not just to level up but to clean up by
creating industries and opportunities around the manufacturing of
electric vehicles, as well as ensuring that we reach our net zero
targets.
(in the Chair)
Order. Before I call the next Member to speak, could I ask hon.
Members to keep their speeches to around six minutes so that
everyone will get a chance to have their say? The clock is
working, to help you with that.
13:52:00
(Easington) (Lab)
It is always a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr
Twigg. I congratulate the hon. Members for Bath () and for Richmond Park
() on securing this important
and timely debate.
If the UK is going to meet our legally binding pledge to meet net
zero by 2050, we need to step up the transition to a green
economy and deliver more sustainable transport options. I was
pleased that the hon. Member for Bath mentioned the importance of
the national grid to EV charging. I was reflecting that we were
the victims of the most appalling storm—storm Arwen—two weeks
ago. It showed up a systematic lack of investment in the power
grid system in the north-east, as many thousands of my
constituents were left without the most basic of
utilities—power—for over 10 days. I am trying to understand how
my communities would have survived if we were solely dependent on
electric vehicles. If we are going to facilitate the transition
to a green economy, the Government need to get the basics right
and climate-proof our power grid.
The basic infrastructure required to facilitate electric vehicles
does not exist in communities such as mine in Easington, County
Durham. There is a massive disparity between the capital and the
rest of the country in terms of accessing charging points, with
more public charging points in London and the south-east than in
the rest of England and Wales combined. We also need to advance
technology, because until we have wireless, accessible, on-street
parking charging points, replacing conventional vehicles with EV
vehicles is not a viable option for people living in built-up
areas—in my case, in former colliery terraces or blocks of
flats.
We are potentially falling into a trap when it comes to
infrastructure, so the Government need to change their mindset
and, rather than focusing on the one-to-one replacement of
vehicles, create an affordable, frequent and reliable public
transport network. That should be the foundation for creating a
sustainable green economy.
I frequently complain about the Northern Rail failure on the
Durham coastline that serves my constituency. The service is
unreliable and dangerous, and I can see the potential of improved
public transport. You might be wondering, Mr Twigg, what that has
to do with electric cars, but the subject of the debate is
electric vehicles, and it is important that we consider what the
options are.
Despite often-repeated Government rhetoric about levelling up,
the transport infrastructure gap in the UK is widening. Improved
public transport can deliver employment opportunities. My
constituency is very close to Nissan in Sunderland, and I accept
that there are many jobs in the automotive manufacturing sector
and in the manufacture of EV battery technology. Indeed, Nissan
in Sunderland is Europe’s biggest and most efficient car plant. I
should declare an interest as a member and chair of the Unite
group in Parliament. Nissan provides employment for many
thousands of people, including many in the supply chain in my
constituency.
However, there are other businesses that could benefit from this
technological revolution. Vivarail, for example, is the only
domestically based manufacturer of battery-powered trains in the
UK. It has a production site in my constituency. Its cutting-edge
green technology and innovative, fast-charging battery-electric
train has enormous domestic and, indeed, export potential.
Vivarail showcased its clean, green and reliable service in
Glasgow at COP26, hosting my colleague, the Chair of the
Transport Committee, the hon. Member for Bexhill and Battle
(), who saw the fast-charging battery-powered train
that was on show.
Many people want affordable and reliable green options, but
making the switch to electric vehicles is difficult because of
the up-front cost. We know that the long-term financial benefits
of electric vehicles, which have been pointed out in the debate,
include lower running and servicing costs, but there is an
up-front barrier in making the transition. We need greater
Government incentives until such time as entry costs for new and
used vehicles fall.
One issue, which was highlighted by the Transport Committee, on
which I have the honour to serve, is the cost of VAT. I raised
that with the Minister in the Fourth Delegated Legislation
Committee yesterday, and I am afraid that I did not get an
answer. The current policy on VAT on charging points penalises
electric vehicle owners who do not have access to private parking
and their own charging points. Those without access are forced to
use public charging points and pay four times the VAT. Her
Majesty’s Revenue and Customs says:
“Supplies of electric vehicle charging through charging points in
public places are charged at the standard rate of VAT”,
which is 20%. It goes on:
“There is no exemption or relief that reduces the rate of VAT
charged.”
I know that the Minister is not responsible for tax policy, but
will she raise that issue with Treasury colleagues?
This debate is far from simple, and a comprehensive approach is
required. The transition to electric vehicles is a
once-in-a-generation opportunity to transform public transport
and create a cleaner, greener and stronger economy in places such
as east Durham. If only we had an ambitious Government willing to
seize the opportunity and spread the benefits more equally.
(in the Chair)
I again remind hon. Members that they should keep to around six
minutes. I will call the Front-Bench spokesperson and the
Minister no later than 2.30 pm.
13:59:00
(Rushcliffe) (Con)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Twigg. I
congratulate the hon. Member for Bath () for securing this debate on
such an incredibly important topic. I have to declare an
interest: I am the owner of an electric car. I also called for
the Government to move their target for phasing out petrol and
diesel vehicles forward to 2030, so I was absolutely delighted to
see that in the Prime Minister’s 10-point plan.
As an early voice in favour of bringing the target forward, I
heard many reasons why it would be absolutely impossible to do
so. They ranged from the availability of minerals to the higher
cost of electric cars, the strain on the electricity supply,
range anxiety and the lack of a public charging network. None of
those challenges is insurmountable, although they are certainly
big challenges, as the hon. Members for Bath and for Easington
() and my hon. Friend the
Member for Broxtowe () have set out. We have
innovation in battery technology, and the hon. Member for Bath
mentioned advances using silicon. Different models of car
ownership, the Government’s plug-in car grant and smart charging
regulations such as the ones currently before the House will all
help to support the transition.
Today I want to focus on range anxiety and the public charging
network. We trade a lot of facts and figures in this place, but I
will focus on my own experiences as an electric car driver. I
know that the Minister is an advocate of rolling out our EV
infrastructure as fast as we possibly can, and I might have some
ammunition to help her with that mission. I thought I would
illustrate the issue using the experience of taking our electric
car on holiday to Northumberland in the summer.
The first bit of advice I have for fellow Members, which is
actually nothing to do with the public charging network, is do
not go on holiday in a new car that has only just been delivered
on the morning of your holiday, especially if you are used to
driving a clunky old petrol-powered Land Rover and you have
switched to an automatic electric MG. It does not do wonders for
marital harmony, and nor does it make for a relaxing, stress-free
break.
There were a worrying few moments when we thought we were going
to have to reverse the entire way to Northumberland, which with a
journey time of three and a half hours would have been quite a
feat, but after a few minutes poking around with the controls, we
did actually manage to start going in a forward direction, and we
were off up the A1.
We pulled in at Ferrybridge services, plugged in and went for
lunch feeling smug. This is easy! We can do this! We returned to
find that absolutely no charge had been transferred to the car.
Oh dear! Were we being silly, as the electric car newbies? No,
the gentleman next to us—a veteran electric car user—was also
having difficulty. The chargers were clearly out of order. “Never
mind,” we thought. “Can’t work every time.”
So off we went to the next services at Wetherby. We plugged in to
one of the chargers, and that charger seemed to be broken too. We
phoned the charge point operator’s 24-hour hotline and they reset
the entire system for us. They said, “It should be working now.”
The only problem was that it was not. They said, “There must be a
problem with the car.” Panic! We do not have enough charge to go
forward, we do not have enough charge to go back and, lovely as
Wetherby services is, I did not really want to spend my holiday
there. So we phoned the car dealership, and lots of people were
running round in the dealership in Portsmouth freaking out that
the car they had sold us, which could be charged, now suddenly
could not be charged.
Twenty minutes later, when one of the other chargers came free, I
said to my husband, “Let’s have one more go.” We plugged in and
it worked. So it was not us and it was not the car, but two out
of three electric chargers at motorway service stations did not
work. I just could not believe it—imagine if two thirds of the
petrol pumps we tried to use at a petrol station were not
working.
So off we went. There was not a charger at our hotel, so we tried
to use the one in the local village next morning, except someone
was using it. Our Zap-Map showed that there were three chargers
in Hexham, so off we pootled. We found two charging points, both
of them wrapped in thick black shrink plastic. Had they just
arrived? Were they leaving? Who could tell? But we certainly
could not use them to charge our car. We finally tracked down
another one outside Waitrose, but that was not working either. So
there were three chargers, and not one of them was working. We
managed to find one in the end—the one in the village became
free.
The next day we went up to Hareshaw Linn, with its beautiful
waterfall. We had a lovely walk—I thoroughly recommend it. Waves
of joy and relief broke over us as we arrived in the car park to
find a charger that was free and that appeared to be working—but
how did it work? It looked like a bollard. There were no
instructions on it. I could not work out how to get the plug out
or anything. All that was written on it was, “Please present a
tag to charge.” Hmm, where was I going to find a tag, even if I
had a description of what one was, in the middle of
Northumberland national park?
The name Electro was emblazoned on the side, so we looked it up
and called it on our phone. We gave it the number of the machine,
but the company could not find it on its system, and neither
could the app, so we could not use that one either. We then found
a sticker—maybe it was BP Pulse—but the app would not take our
debit cards so, again, that was a complete write-off. We did
manage to find some charging points throughout Northumberland
that did actually work on our holiday, so we did get around.
Then, on our way back, we stopped off again at Wetherby
services—that place where we nearly spent the entire week. There
was a queue of six cars to use the chargers. Assuming an average
charge time of 20 minutes, we would have had to wait two hours
just to charge the car, so we would have been there for two hours
and 20 minutes or two and a half hours. That is almost as long as
the entire journey, so off we went to the lovely village of
Boston Spa, which I thoroughly recommend, and there we were
confronted with an Engie EV charger. Again, to charge, we had to
give our names, our address and our contact details before we
could register to pay and charge. Can you imagine the chaos if
that happened at the petrol pumps, Mr Twigg?
I do not want to give the impression that the unfortunate set of
circumstances that I have described happens to us every day. We
do manage to get around in the car. We normally charge at home
and we do not have any issues, but as has been pointed out—
(in the Chair)
Order. Can I ask the hon. Member to wind up, please?
As has been pointed out, lots of people do not have the option of
charging at home, so I have three asks: first, more chargers at
key points, such as motorway service stations; secondly, a ban on
using apps to pay for charging—people should be able to pay with
debit cards; and thirdly, on service expectations around
reliability, if people are taking their car out, they have to be
able to have a reasonable level of confidence that they will be
able to drive it home again. Those are my three asks for the
Minister.
14:06:00
(Vauxhall)
(Lab/Co-op)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Twigg. I
pay tribute to the hon. Member for Bath () for calling this important
debate. I also pay tribute to the hon. Member for Rushcliffe
() for outlining her experience
and for her tenacity and determination to keep going. As a
driver, and given some of the days of driving I have had with my
four-year-old and six-year-old, I would have given up, so all
credit to her.
My constituency of Vauxhall, just across the bridge here,
contains some of the busiest and most polluted roads in the
country. That has a massive and devastating impact on our fight
to tackle the climate emergency, but also on the immediate health
of my constituents. Air pollution has been linked to a litany of
health problems, such as asthma and heart disease. Just last
year, air pollution was ruled to be the tragic factor in the
death of nine-year-old Ella Kissi-Debrah. She tragically lost her
life after two years of severe asthma attacks.
Electric vehicles will not eliminate pollution entirely, but they
do have the potential to bring about a sea change in levels of
pollution caused by cars and to make our roads quieter and
healthier. Unfortunately, many of my constituents who are looking
to get an electric car face so many barriers—a significant
roadblock —in their desire to become greener and reduce
emissions. Aside from the high costs associated with electric
vehicles, people looking to switch are definitely let down by the
infrastructure. As the hon. Member for Rushcliffe highlighted,
the standards are simply not up to scratch. One of my
constituents who wants to get an electric car told me that she
fears that travelling a long distance and visiting family would
be nearly impossible because of the current infrastructure. She
told me about a motorway journey that she made and the fact that
the charging points were out of service and she did not have the
right socket for her vehicle.
People who live in a flat, as many of my constituents do, have
concerns about safety and the reliability of charging their car
overnight. Making travelling to and from the car a necessity
excludes so many people who want to switch, such as the elderly,
carers and so many others who would like to make the transition
to cleaner cars. This would also have a big impact on our ability
to meet our targets by 2030. It might be hoped that supply will
meet demand when it comes to the infrastructure, but it is clear
that demand has been hampered by the current unavailability of
electric cars, so many people are not considering switching. If
we are truly to see an electric vehicle revolution among car
owners, we must build that infrastructure to the same standards
that we expect for petrol vehicles, and drive up demand across
the country.
We know that switching to an electric vehicle is not the panacea
for transport’s contribution to the climate emergency or
pollution. Like me, many of my constituents in Vauxhall make
journeys by foot, active travel, bus and local transport. We are
blessed to live in an inner-London constituency where we have
eight tube stations and fantastic bus networks. Transport
provision is not the same for many constituents up and down the
country in rural areas. If we are to see them using public
transport and not relying on petrol cars, we need to ensure that
our public transport is properly funded.
That is the ongoing debate we are having about London’s public
transport, which the hon. Members for Bath and for Richmond Park
() highlighted was about
ensuring that we have secure funding for Transport for London. We
must continue to encourage people to use public transport and
those who rely on petrol cars to use cleaner, greener vehicles,
such as electric cars.
We must enable those who use cars to be at the forefront of a
green transport revolution. So I have just one ask for the
Minister this afternoon: how can she address the concerns of my
constituents and outline measures to ensure that electric
vehicles are more reliable, viable and cheaper, and that the
infrastructure for them is available?
(in the Chair)
Thank you for keeping within six minutes.
14:10:00
(Strangford) (DUP)
First, may I say how pleased I am to speak in this debate? I
thank the hon. Member for Bath () for securing it. I often
take part in her Westminster Hall debates and I congratulate her
on always setting the scene for them so very well. We do not
agree on everything, but we agree on this and other issues. I am
very pleased to participate in the debate.
Many of us are much more aware of our carbon footprint today and
have come to realise that there are steps we can take to lessen
the damage to our environment. One of the most prominent ways in
which we can do this is by using electric vehicles.
My youngest son, Luke, bought a hybrid vehicle. He did not
experience the problems that the hon. Member for Rushcliffe
() has. Thank the Lord for
that; such problems would be entirely depressing. His buying that
hybrid tells me that the next generation are ready to get ahead.
They are thinking ahead about how they can reduce their carbon
footprint and improve their quality of life. I am very pleased to
see that he and many others have grasped that. I think that more
electric cars were sold in Northern Ireland in the last year than
have ever been sold in the past.
I look forward to hearing the Minister’s response to the debate.
I know that in the past the Government have set some funds aside
for electric charging points and I know that local councils in
Northern Ireland now have the responsibility for such charging
points. That being the case, perhaps the Minister can give me
some idea of how that system will work.
As I am sure all Members are aware, the UK has committed to net
zero carbon emissions by 2050. Transport is currently the largest
emitting sector in the UK economy, responsible for some 27% of
total UK greenhouse gas emissions, with cars in particular being
responsible for 55% of transport emissions. However, I do not
believe that there is any logical way that we can expect people
to travel in a greener manner if we do not provide them with the
means to do so. I think that we are all committed to the net zero
target, but we have to make sure that it is achievable, and we
must reduce the angst that many people have—I probably have it
myself, to be fair—that the charging points are in place.
Infrastructure is the key to getting this greener engine going.
For example, in Northern Ireland there are currently 4,000
electric vehicles on the road, but only 337 public charge points.
Some of the shopping centres back home have introduced electric
charging points, but I would like to see charging points in the
centre of towns, because that is where a lot of the vehicular
traffic is. Also, the charging points must work, because that has
been a problem in the past for many of my constituents.
Does the hon. Gentleman agree that ultimately local councils are
best placed to provide that infrastructure and to ensure that it
actually works, because they are the ones who are accountable,
whereas any private companies can just do their own thing? Does
he agree that local authorities should run these charging
points?
I thank her hon. Lady for her intervention and she is absolutely
right. That is what I say when I talk about councils back home.
The responsibility should lie with them, because they can
specifically monitor their own towns and villages, not only
across my constituency of Strangford, but across the whole of
Northern Ireland.
In my constituency, there are only two electric charging points
shown on the charge point map for a constituency of approximately
60,000 people, which is shocking. I know that the Minister back
home, Nichola Mallon, has committed her Department to improving
that situation greatly, and the quicker that happens the better.
If it was not the responsibility of her Department but of the
council, and there was some money for that, we could achieve some
of our goals on electric charging points.
A report undertaken in 2020 by the Department for Infrastructure
back home came to some interesting conclusions regarding people’s
attitudes towards electric vehicles. Of those surveyed, 33% said
they were unlikely to make an electric vehicle their next car buy
and 42% would not even consider it. We have to address these
attitudes. Why are those figures so high? Indeed, 64% of those
surveyed said that they would be discouraged from buying electric
vehicles due to the price and—guess what?—the need to charge
them.
The hon. Member for Rushcliffe told a story about a nightmare
journey from her home to her holiday destination, stopping on
numerous occasions along the way. I agree that the education must
be there for the UK to fully transition to electric vehicles by
2030, especially for the younger generations. Thousands of young
adults and teenagers are doing driving tests and getting their
first vehicle. We want to encourage the new generation to buy the
cars; we have to enable them to feel confident to do so. That is
why I encourage the Minister to engage with the Department for
Education to ensure that the benefits of using electric cars are
taught to young people. I think we can also address the
generational mindset.
I referred to Minister Mallon, the Minister for Infrastructure
back home. She has announced a new electric vehicle
infrastructure taskforce for Northern Ireland. That is a good
step. I welcome it and congratulate the Minister on that. It was
announced at COP26—COP26 achieved many things outside the
headlines. I encourage the Government to follow suit, and put
more responsibility on local councils, as the hon. Member for
Bath said, to be accountable for e-charging in their areas. That
is the secret. That is the key. That is what we need to do.
Having the necessary charging is absolutely essential to progress
in our battle with climate change.
I recently made contact with the Department for Business, Energy
and Industrial Strategy on a new-start logistics business in
Newtownards, which is seeking funding to ensure that its entire
fleet is made up of electric vehicles. I welcome that initiative,
interest and commitment. We need to find funding for
future-looking companies such as that one, and we also need
electric charge points throughout the constituency to charge the
fleets. It is as simple as that. Let us do it.
14:16:00
(Leeds North West)
(Lab/Co-op)
It is a pleasure to serve under you in the Chair, Mr Twigg. I
refer to my entry in the Register of Members’ Financial
Interests. I thank the hon. Member for Bath () for securing this important
debate in our transition to net zero.
I want to start by talking about a significant zero-emissions
capability. When defining that capability, the Government must
look to the spirit of their decision to phase out the sale of new
petrol and diesel vehicles from 2030. Any vehicle that does not
have the ability to run continuously, creating zero emissions,
for a meaningful range is predominantly an internal combustion
engine vehicle. To continue to allow the sale of such vehicles
after 2030 is contrary to the Government’s own decision.
Therefore, only vehicles with a chargeable battery and a plug
should be included, not mild hybrids.
The only suitable metric to measure that is miles of continuous
zero-emission range, which should be set at a minimum of 100
miles, to ensure that consumers realistically make journeys on
electric miles. There is no fundamental technological barrier
that impedes plug-in hybrids from delivering higher ranges today.
It is merely how to optimise the battery size of a plug-in hybrid
electric vehicle—or PHEV—to comply with today’s CO2
regulations.
We also need a zero-emission vehicle mandate, which is a target
placed on car manufacturers to ensure a certain percentage of
vehicles are zero-emission vehicles. Of course, the definition of
that mandate is extremely important. California has had a working
version of such a mandate and has in fact had a ratchet mechanism
to get more lower carbon vehicles on to the road since 1990.
In the pure form of a ZEV, only vehicles capable of zero-tailpipe
emissions should be included, so battery electric or hydrogen
fuel cell vehicles, but, from a more pragmatic standpoint,
plug-in hybrid vehicles could be included, but given a value
reflective of how far they can drive on zero emissions.
California includes BEVs—battery electric vehicles—PHEVs and
hydrogen fuel cell vehicles. If 20% of a vehicle’s stated range
is electric, it should be a awarded a 20% value. That would be a
reasonable level in the mandate.
How should that work in the UK? In simple terms, there is a
crediting system within a ZEV mandate that attributes different
credit values to different types of vehicles and, for the longest
range vehicles, a super credit. The California mandate and the
China mandate offer four times and six times for the longest
range electric vehicles. As the UK looks at the design, we should
learn from the others and not use super credits, as large super
credits just lead to a surplus of credits and a dilution of the
targets and therefore vehicles on the road.
There should, of course, be a reward for innovation that drives
longer range and more efficient vehicles—the hon. Member for
Rushcliffe () explained that better than I
could—and we need to ensure that vehicles produced have a
meaningful range so people will want to replace their diesel or
petrol cars with an electric one. However, we should cap the
maximum credit value at more than one credit but not as high as
two credits. The average EV should receive one credit, which
today is around 250 miles. That average can be recalculated
annually, to reflect the state of the market and to manage
credits.
The Government have announced that the ZEV mandate will start in
2024. Any target will need to be ambitious, yet achievable.
Looking at the industry’s own projections, SMMT figures for its
high uptake scenario for 2024 are around 35% of zero-emissions
vehicle sales in that year. The industry could meet that target,
but it needs incentives. Funnily enough, it happens to roughly
correlate to the Climate Change Committee’s figure for 2024. That
Committee recommends that 50% of new sales should be
zero-emissions vehicles in 2025, meaning a steep gradient in the
Government’s mandate.
A zero-emissions vehicle mandate is a supply-side tool, but a
fleet mandate is the demand-side tool. The Government could look
to create a fleet mandate to ensure that there are targets for
fleet vehicles. The sector is around 55% of the marketplace in
the UK and provides an important feeder to the second and
third-hand market. Given that there is a favourable taxation
treatment for this marketplace, a mandate could help drive
uptake. The fleet mandate would need to be significantly higher
than the zero-emissions vehicle mandate. We need to remember that
fleet vehicles enter the used-vehicle market three to five years
after becoming fleet. It will mean affordable, zero-emissions
vehicles by 2030. My hon. Friend the Member for Vauxhall () touched on
affordability. Everybody should be able to afford a
zero-emissions vehicle by 2030.
On charging infrastructure, the Government have announced some
significant funding to remove the barrier of connection costs.
The charging points all need to work, though. This £950 million
rapid charging fund is for strategic roads and motorway service
stations, but it has yet to be rolled out. Connection costs is an
issue at these locations, but the same issues exist everywhere.
The Government can do more. For example, more can be done with
our existing policy mechanisms without further grants from
Government. One example is the renewable transport fuel
obligation. The UK is falling behind other European nations when
it comes to using this policy to drive down transport
emissions.
The renewable transport fuel obligation seeks to reduce emissions
from transport fuels and many other countries have already
reformed their versions to provide revenue generation for a
struggling charging sector. European nations have their versions
of the RTFO, and California has a similar instrument called the
low carbon fuel standard. The key difference is that Holland,
Germany and soon the whole of Europe allow renewable electricity
use in vehicles to count towards these reduction targets, as does
the low carbon fuel standard. I call for the Minister to look at
changing the RTFO, because it will drive that infrastructure
through to renewable electricity production.
I will finish by talking about plug-in grants. The price gap
between zero-emissions vehicles and internal combustion engines
continues to reduce, but there is still a significant
differential. Many people are asking for an extension to the
plug-in car grant. I would support that, but I ask the Government
to also look at an alternative: the bonus-malus. The operation of
a malus or levy is placed on the purchase of new fossil-fuel
vehicles, and this is used to fund a bonus or grant for
zero-emissions vehicles, meaning that it is neutral for the
Government and does not require state funding.
14:22:00
(Warwick and Leamington)
(Lab)
It is great to see you in the Chair, Mr Twigg. I congratulate the
hon. Member for Bath () on securing this debate.
The UK’s transition to EVs looks like it is about to stall. Those
are not my words, but those of the automotive industry. The
Government have set a clear legal end date for the sale of petrol
and diesel cars and vans by 2030. By 2035, they want to see the
complete switch to zero-emission sales. We have got nine years to
go. We need much more urgent action than we are seeing. We are a
long way from achieving what we need to. On the one hand, we see
car manufacturers and the motor industry right behind the EV
revolution, but the critical infrastructure supporting EV cars
is, I am afraid to say, not as developed as it should be.
I want to look at what the industry has actually achieved and
succeeded in. Against the 188 new plug-in cars registered in
2010, we are up to 300,000 for 2021. There is now the choice of
around 150 zero and ultra-low-emission vehicles available to buy.
That will double by 2025. In terms of production, BEVs are now up
64% to account to for 7% of car output in the UK. There is a
growing urgency to deliver on gigafactories. The one in Coventry
has to be secured, and I hope we will hear an announcement on
that very soon.
While vehicle development and supply is good, it is the
infrastructure system that we need absolute priority on. We talk
about HS2 and the integrated rail plan, but there is nothing like
the scale of ambition that we need for the charge point
infrastructure for this country. We are one of the worst among
the top 10 global electric vehicle markets, at some 16:1 ratio a
year ago. I chair the all-party parliamentary group on electric
vehicles, and the sorts of stories we heard from the hon. Member
for Rushcliffe () are very much the topic of
debate at our meetings.
Between January and September, just 4,000 new standard public
charge points were installed, compared with 212,000 new plug-in
car registrations. That is one new standard charger for every 52
new electric vehicles. As we have heard, there is huge regional
disparity: in the midlands, as cited by the hon. Member for
Broxtowe (), we need to install
something like 11 charge points every day, but we are doing
something like two a day.
So what do we need to do? According to a recent Savanta ComRes
survey, the message is loud and clear from consumers. Some 37% of
those surveyed were optimistic about buying a full EV by 2025.
There is consumer demand, and we are getting many more EVs on our
roads, but the survey also showed that the barriers faced by
consumers are significant. Some 44% said that the lack of local
charging points was significant barrier to buying an EV, while
38% were concerned about fears over charging access on long
journeys, whether to Northumberland or elsewhere.
That is the main issue. The Government need to empower and assist
local authorities and distribution network operators to develop
urgent and comprehensive plans for integrated charging networks.
They need to identify the sites, work with charging providers and
tender for regional networks, ensuring that the mistakes that
were made over mobile phone telephony are not repeated with
vehicle charging infrastructure.
The Minister heard about the most pressing issue loud and clear
from the industry just a couple of weeks ago: there needs to be a
massive focus on infrastructure for charging and for
manufacturing and recycling batteries. The Government’s rapid
charging fund, with £950 million to rapid and ultra-rapid charge
points, is welcome, as is the requirement for all new build homes
to include EV charging points—although we should have been doing
that for the last five years. That is something that the last
Labour Government talked about. Sure, the current investment is
welcome, but it does not go far enough. The SMMT estimates that a
minimum of 689,000 charge points are required, although the real
figure is more like 2.3 million. We need significant expansion in
delivering binding targets and introducing regulation and
enabling support.
One solution is interoperability or roaming platforms, which
would allow the consumers of individual charge point operators to
charge on other networks that are associated with that hub. We
have only to look at the Netherlands, which is leading the way on
that—it is really not rocket science. The Netherlands has been
doing it for years.
Of course, we have heard about smart charging, and I appreciate
that regulations are being proposed by Government. Finally, we
need better battery technology; I just hope that the Government’s
ambition is there to deliver on a gigafactory in Coventry.
We need incentives. While there is a clear appetite from
consumers for EVs, we need to persuade more to get behind this
market. As others have said, the Government should maintain the
plug-in car grant. Lastly, we should also consider tax breaks,
free or reduced costs for parking, generous long-term plug-in
grants and reliable, fast EV charging points on the street.
In conclusion, it is not enough for the Government to simply ban
new petrol and diesel cars from 2030. We have to have the scale
of ambition and—as we are seeing with the rail infrastructure—a
comprehensive plan delivered for EV charging, which needs to be
delivered urgently to get the 2.3 million charging points that
have been identified. Finally, we need to ensure fair pricing for
consumers, so that all can access cheap and clean motoring, not
just those with domestic charge points.
(in the Chair)
I ask Front-Bench Members to keep their speeches to about 10
minutes, so that the hon. Member for Bath () has time to wind up.
14:28:00
(Paisley and Renfrewshire
North) (SNP)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship for the first
time, Mr Twigg. I congratulate the hon. Member for Bath () on securing this important
debate and on starting us off so well. She made many excellent
points throughout her speech and referenced the excellent
recommendations of the Transport Committee. I should say that I
serve on that Committee, although that was not a self-serving
comment.
There have been many fantastic contributions by Members from
across the House and the debate has been, in the main,
consensual. The hon. Member for Broxtowe () said that this is a
once-in-a-generation opportunity, but that we are going too
slowly. My colleague on the Transport Committee, the hon. Member
for Easington (), rightly spoke of the
challenges facing the national grid and charging outside London,
which I will come on to. The hon. Member for Rushcliffe () spoke of a long journey, by
the sounds of it, and the relationship strain of taking an
electric car on holiday. I can certainly relate to that—not so
much the holiday element, but the change in driving style
required by an electric car. Mine has changed, my wife’s has not.
No doubt I will get into trouble for saying that.
The hon. Member for Vauxhall (), a London MP, made
excellent points about range of and the need for greener public
transport, which I will briefly cover. The hon. Member for
Strangford (), who is always here and is always welcome, spoke of
transport being the largest carbon-emitting sector and urged more
urgent action, if I can put it like that. The hon. Member for
Leeds North West () spoke of the ZEV mandate, which
I will probably not have time to cover but which we
wholeheartedly support. The hon. Member for Warwick and
Leamington (), who always takes a keen
interest in these matters, started out pretty starkly by saying
that we have only nine years but also a very long way to go.
I declare an interest as an owner of an electric vehicle. Thanks
in part to the Scottish Government’s electric vehicle loan
scheme, I made the switch from diesel to electric this year. In
fact, my family went from having two diesel cars to one electric.
The bulk of my remarks will cover electric cars, but I will
briefly talk about electric buses. Thus far, the Prime Minister’s
pledge of 4,000 new green buses has been a pretty damp squib, it
has to be said. The three years of the ultra-low emission bus
scheme’s operation up to this year resulted in just 58 such buses
on the road outside London. It will come as no surprise that
London has more ULEBS-funded buses on the road than the rest of
England put together. The successor scheme, ZEBRA—zero-emission
bus regional areas—has not put a single new bus on the road, and
thus far funding has been made available for only 335 electric
buses. ZEBRA has been a total flop. The Prime Minister has zero
chance of getting to his promised 4,000 buses by the end of this
Parliament. In any event, 4,000 buses represents only 10% of the
English bus fleet.
In contrast, the Scottish Government have promised to decarbonise
more than half the Scottish bus fleet in the same timeframe. We
are well into our second Scottish ultra-low emission bus scheme,
which, for comparison, has resulted in the equivalent of more
than 2,700 buses already ordered or on the road. Indeed, thanks
to the Scottish Government’s SULEB schemes and McGill’s Buses, my
own area of Renfrewshire has more electric buses on the road than
anywhere outside London. These buses need passengers to fill
them, and I am glad to say that, by the end of next month, those
aged 21 and under will enjoy free bus travel, hopefully
instilling some public transport habits into the new generation,
helping to reduce car usage by 20% by the end of the decade. We
see day to day what progress has been, and is being, made in
rolling out the infrastructure we need to move to net zero, so
when I look at DFT’s record, I have to say—not for the first
time—that I am glad to live in Scotland under a Government with a
serious agenda to change our transport options for the
better.
Without a mass roll-out of public charging facilities, EVs will
simply never be the choice for people for whom residential
charging points are simply not possible, especially people who
live in flats or multiple-occupancy buildings. The Climate Change
Committee estimates that at least 150,000 charge points are
needed, while others, such as the Society of Motor Manufacturers
and Traders, say that at least 700,000 are needed, but just under
21,000 are currently in use. There has to be a rapid acceleration
of investment and a clear strategy for how that target will be
met. At the moment, there is no sign that the scale of investment
needed matches the reality of what is available. Once again, the
Scottish Government are leading on the roll-out of public
charging infrastructure, and doing so on the scale needed
elsewhere.
According to the UK Government’s own stats, Scotland leads the UK
in public rapid charging points, at around 70% per capita higher
than average, and nearly double even London’s rapid charging
network, and is second only to Greater London in all public
charging points. That was not achieved by accident; it was the
result of policy decisions taken over the last few years in line
with the Scottish Government’s net zero strategy, which aims to
transform the country to net zero by 2045, five years ahead of
the UK’s current plans. That kind of bold investment in
infrastructure needs replicating elsewhere in these isles if we
are to collectively meet the challenges of the transition to net
zero and the ambition set out by COP26. How that infrastructure
is accessed, as has already been referenced, is also a real
concern.
When the Transport Committee took evidence on public charging and
the interoperability of the many different networks—some publicly
run, some delivered by the private sector—the then Minister said
that regulations to enforce interoperability were planned for
before the end of the year. To date, we have not had those
regulations, despite the consultation closing in April and
despite the Minister’s promise to the Committee.
There is no sign of forcing operators to have common systems,
which would give consumers a seamless experience, regardless of
which provider they charge the vehicle with. We do not expect
drivers of diesel or petrol vehicles to have to remember which
card matches which petrol stations, and it should not be any
different for EV drivers. Interoperability is standard in the
Netherlands, as has been said, with a larger installed base of
public charge points. There is no reason whatsoever why that
cannot be implemented here. I hope that the Minister will clarify
that point because, if that is indeed the case, the Government
need to up their game and get those regulations drafted as
quickly as possible.
Just over two years ago, I spoke in a similar debate in this
Chamber and mentioned the success of electric vehicles in Norway.
At that point, just over half of new cars sold there were EVs.
This year, that proportion reached over 77%. So successful has
their transition been that the debate in Norway is now not about
how to get EVs making up the bulk of the new car market, but how
to realistically phase out the remaining petrol and diesel cars
on their roads.
That, it must be said, is in an oil and energy-rich, progressive
and independent northern European country with the power to act
in its own national and international interests without a
Whitehall-type system to battle through. Norway shows that if the
will and investment are there, the marketplace for cars can be
transformed in a relatively short period. Therefore, while I may
despair at much of the UK’s track record, the optimist in
me—there is an optimist in me, somewhere—still believes that it
might be capable of pulling it off, if the political will is
there. Of course, that is a big if.
In yesterday’s debate on rail investment, I made the point that,
compared with the capital, the rest of England was being badly
let down on transport spending year after year. That mistake is
being repeated in the roll-out of a public charging network.
Again, as the hon. Member for Easington said, it is the north of
England losing out, with the north-west and Yorkshire and the
Humber at the bottom of the league table, while London streaks
ahead.
If the Government are serious about a national EV strategy, it
has to be just that: national. If the Scottish Government can
fund and support charge points from Unst—the most northerly
island in these isles—to the Mull of Galloway at the very south
of the country, there should be no reason for English regions to
be left behind in the transition to zero emission vehicles.
Norway has managed it, Scotland is managing it, and I hope that
the Minister will seek advice from her counterparts in those
countries and elsewhere on how to drive forward the
transformational change needed over the coming years.
To conclude, on the vehicles themselves, it again seems that the
UK is in the slow lane while others are powering ahead. If we are
to change historical behaviours, we must have an appropriate
balance between carrot and stick, but the Government keep
shifting that balance before the market is ready for it. The
Transport Scotland-funded low carbon transport loan gives
potential EV customers an interest-free loan of up to £28,000 for
new cars or £20,000 for used ones, and also covers electric
motorcycles and e-bikes. Compared with the UK’s grant-only
scheme, the interest-free loan scheme is delivering affordability
to households who would otherwise be unable to make the switch to
electric vehicles. It is also undoubtedly one of the reasons why
take up of EVs in Scotland over recent years has considerably
outstripped the rest of the UK, outside of London. That loan has
also now been extended to include used EVs, which are now an
important area of growth in the market.
The top three factors holding potential EV buyers back are cost,
access to local charging points, and range anxiety. By rolling
out zero-interest loans, the Scottish Government are addressing
that first factor; by having so many charging points, they are
addressing the second; and by ensuring that no part of the
country is untouched, they are addressing the third.
14:39:00
(Ilford South) (Lab)
It is an honour to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Twigg. I
will briefly touch on some of the useful contributions by many
Members from across the House, who have obviously taken the time
to contribute to this forward-thinking, progressive debate on
such an important subject.
I thank the hon. Member for Bath () for securing the debate and
putting forward so many interesting ideas. I will also briefly
mention my hon. Friends the Members for Vauxhall (), for Leeds North West
()—I hope to be able to go for a
spin in his Tesla at some point soon—and for Warwick and
Leamington (). We also heard about the
meandering experience of the hon. Member for Rushcliffe (). It would be remiss of me
not to mention my former colleague and hon. Friend the Member for
Easington (), who made some important
points, as did the hon. Member for Strangford ().
Surface transport accounted for 24% of emissions in 2019 and
remains the largest contributor to UK emissions to date. After a
decade of failing to reduce the UK’s transport emissions, it is
good that the Government are finally recognising the scale of the
problem. I will touch briefly on the point made by my other
former colleague from the Transport Committee, the hon. Member
for Paisley and Renfrewshire North (), on the 4,000 zero
emission buses that are still missing from action. If we were to
speak to Alexander Dennis in Falkirk or, indeed, Wrightbus in
Ballymena, we would hear that not a single British manufacturer
has an order for those buses on their books, so I want to know
whether those 4,000 buses are apocryphal. We will not let this go
until British manufacturers have those buses on their books. I do
not want to find out that they are suddenly being given to China
or another country when we should be supporting British
manufacturing.
I am glad to hear, though, that the Government have adopted the
Labour policy of phasing out sales of new petrol and diesel
vehicles by 2030. However, why are hybrids allowed to be sold
until 2035? Hybrids are highly polluting when they use their
petrol or diesel engines due to their weight and poor fuel
efficiency. They are, unfortunately, a lifeline to the fossil
fuel industry, and the policy should be reversed immediately.
The Government have also announced that they will help smooth the
transition to zero emission vehicles by introducing a zero
emission vehicle mandate, which will gradually increase the level
of vehicle sales required to be zero emission up to 100% by 2030.
Labour fully supports the move, but when will the legislation
actually be introduced? Will the Minister confirm whether hybrid
electric vehicle sales will be included within that mandate?
Fully electric and hybrid vehicle sales have surged this year,
with over a quarter of new vehicle sales being either hybrid or
fully electric in 2021 so far, according to the SMMT. However,
the UK’s charging infrastructure is falling behind, as we heard
from the hon. Member for Rushcliffe. Overall funding for charging
given out to local authorities has fallen from £15 million in the
previous financial year, 2019-20, to £6.5 million in 2020-21. As
many local authorities are not able to use those funds for the
remaining schemes, it does need to be addressed, and addressed
quickly.
Regional inequalities for charge points are also huge. If the
Government are genuinely committed to levelling up, why are they
doing nothing to address that regional inequality? The Government
have promised a charging strategy by the end of the year, so
where is it? Councils have rightly expressed serious concerns
that there is no coherent Government strategy about what to build
and where. We need urgent action to address regional
inequalities, a quick ramp-up of charging, and making charge
points easier to use and accessible for consumers. Can the
Minister provide an update on this?
The Government have said very little on how the transition to
electric vehicles will impact on fuel duty revenues. Does the
Minister have a plan to mitigate the loss of that revenue?
Furthermore, as the hon. Member for Richmond Park () said, Transport for London
must have a sustainable long-term funding package, so that there
is no delay to extending EV charging across the network in London
as well.
Although it has been great to see surging sales of electric
vehicles, they are still unaffordable for many consumers. Labour
has a plan to fund interest-free loans for electric vehicles for
low-income households and to trial a scrappage scheme for
polluting vehicles. That would ensure that the transition to
clean, green transport is possible for everyone, not just the
privileged few. In contrast, the Government have repeatedly
slashed the plug-in grant for electric vehicles. Again, what are
the Government going to do to address the affordability of
electric vehicles, so that low-income families are not left
behind in the transition?
The transition is also an opportunity to create thousands of
good, green, unionised jobs in the UK. If the UK is going to
remain a hub for automotive manufacturers, we need to ensure that
the components for electric vehicles can be built in the UK.
Labour has committed to part-financing three battery
gigafactories by 2025, but the Government have done little to
encourage investment in UK gigafactories. We welcome some of the
points made by the hon. Member for Broxtowe (): they just need to be
accelerated and extended as quickly as possible. That is
important due to the new rules of origin requirements in the
Government’s Brexit deal. If we want to continue tariff-free
trade in electric vehicles with the EU, we urgently need to
establish manufacturing capacity in the UK.
We also need to avoid a reliance on imported rare metals such as
lithium and cobalt as global demand for them grows. The
environmental implications of mining those critical minerals are
a serious concern. Furthermore, the mining of those rare metals
has highlighted the use of slave labour and the severe abuse of
workers’ rights in countries such as the Democratic Republic of
Congo. That is profoundly tragic, and concrete action must be
taken to address those concerns. We cannot go green while people
are losing their lives to get those materials to us.
We would be able to ease the pressures on supply chains if rare
metals such as lithium and cobalt, of which there is currently
colossal wastage, were recycled quickly. That could be a quick
win for the Government. Significant natural deposits of lithium
in the UK could be utilised by ensuring that electronics can be
easily disassembled and recycling—that needs to be an immediate
Government priority. Unfortunately, there is a wealth of those
materials in UK electronics, but they are not currently being
recycled. That must change, and it must change rapidly. Will the
Government do anything to encourage the urban mining and
recycling of those rare metals? Are they considering new
standards to require that electronics be easier to disassemble
and recycle?
The transition to electric vehicles is a huge opportunity for
cleaner air, lower emissions and thousands of good, green and
unionised jobs, but the Government must think bigger when it
comes to charging infrastructure, affordability and battery
supply chains. The Labour party has serious plans to address
those issues, and it is time that the Government listened. It is
time for a green new deal for the UK—one that is real, supports
the poorest, and boosts British manufacturing.
14:46:00
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Transport ()
It is a pleasure to be part of the debate and to serve under your
chairmanship, Mr Twigg. I thank the hon. Member for Bath () for raising this subject,
and all hon. Members who have spoken for their enthusiastic and
passionate contributions about electric vehicles.
I will outline some of the support that the Government are
providing for electric vehicles, before running through some of
the questions from hon. Members. We have committed £2.5 billion
in funding for vehicle grants and infrastructure to meet a very
ambitious carbon target. We anticipate that up to quarter of the
36 million cars and vans on UK roads will be electric by 2030. As
we can see from the data released by the SMMT recently, the pace
of the transition is really accelerating. Industry data shows
that almost as many battery electric vehicles were sold in
September as in the whole of 2019, and that nearly one in five
new cars sold in November 2021 was fully electric.
The journey is not just about the vehicles, however. As has been
said, drivers will frequently need world-class charging
infrastructure to support the full range of journeys and vehicles
in our electric future. Rather than leaving that to the market,
this Government have intervened: the Prime Minister announced his
10-point plan for net zero, which will phase out the sale of new
petrol and diesel cars and vans in the UK by 2030, as hon.
Members have said. From 2035, all new cars and vans must have
zero emissions at the tailpipe. In response to questions about
the definition of hybrid, that definition is being worked on as I
speak, and we will be able to update Members on those conclusions
very shortly.
In October, the Government announced in our net zero strategy
that we would introduce a zero emission vehicle mandate, which
would come into force from 2024. The idea is to help the
phase-out dates by setting targets for a percentage of a
manufacturer’s annual new car and van sales in the UK to be zero
emissions from 2024. Alongside our ambitious phase-out dates, we
have also announced £1.3 billion to accelerate the roll-out of
charging infrastructure, ensuring that drivers can charge where
they need to and more easily than refilling a petrol or diesel
vehicle. We are doing that through the Office for Zero Emission
Vehicles.
Funding is available to support charge point infrastructure in
homes, at workplaces, on residential streets and across the wider
roads network. We have Homecharge, which provides £350 to
homeowners to install charge points, and we have had about
230,000 householders take advantage of that. We have the
on-street residential charge point scheme, which provides up to
£13,000 per charge point to local authorities to install charging
infrastructure, and the workplace charging scheme, which offers
£350 per charge point. We have the local EV infrastructure fund,
the charging infrastructure fund, the rapid charging fund—the
Government are providing a wealth of support and building on the
£1.9 billion from the spending review 2020, and we have committed
an extra £620 million of this year’s spending review to support
the transition to electric vehicles.
The Minister is being generous in giving way, and I am grateful
for her listing all the investments and so on that have come
through her Department, but has she had a chance to address the
issues that I raised yesterday in a Delegated Legislation
Committee, and indeed that the Transport Committee has raised,
regarding the differential rate of VAT? Not everyone can have
their own personal charging point if they live in a terraced
house or a block of flats.
The hon. Gentleman makes a common-sense point. We are looking at
this, and I will, as he suggests, speak with my colleagues in the
Treasury to see what we can do. I do think that the Treasury is
playing an important part in this transition, but we need to work
more with local authorities. Members across the House should work
with their local authorities and with me, because, with their
leadership and action through local transport and planning
policies, we can really help to support the local zero-emission
vehicle uptake, and make sure that it is integrated with local
transport strategies.
The Government will publish an EV infrastructure strategy
shortly. That strategy will define our vision for the continued
roll-out of a world-leading charging infrastructure network
across the UK, and focus on how we unlock the charge point
roll-out needed to enable the transition from early adoption to
the mass market uptake of EVs.
I thank the Minister for her response. During my contribution, I
asked her to say what relationship she has had with the Northern
Ireland Assembly, Minister Nichola Mallon and the Department for
Infrastructure. I want the funding that came from Westminster to
come again.
I was going to mention this, but I did have the pleasure of
meeting Minister Mallon in Belfast a few weeks ago. I also
visited Wrightbus, not far from Belfast, in Ballymena. We are
having those conversations with the devolved
Administrations—supporting, providing funding and learning how we
can collaborate best to ensure that the roll-out reaches all the
UK.
The Minister mentioned the strategy. Presumably within that
strategy will be interoperability. When is that issue going to be
addressed? We were told it would be at the end of this year.
I will comment on Members’ queries now.
The hon. Member for Bath asked about energy provision. That is a
matter for the Department for Business, Energy and Industrial
Strategy, as I am sure she knows, but making sure we have the
clean electricity is vital. She will know as well that the Prime
Minister’s 10-point plan sets out the commitment towards 40 GW of
wind by 2030 and 5 GW production capacity for hydrogen. We have
also passed the regulated asset base for gigawatt-plus nuclear
power stations, so we are not shy of taking action on energy.
The hon. Member for Bath also referred to fairness. I think that
is really important, because in this transport revolution we have
an opportunity that we perhaps did not have 150 years ago, which
is to ensure that everybody is involved, this time in charging
vehicles. We are working with organisations such as Motability to
make sure that the charging infrastructure can be used by all,
including disabled people. This is about ensuring through the
regulations we are bringing forward that people know where
charging infrastructure is; that they can be sure the
infrastructure will work; that they will not need to use a
selection of apps, but instead can use contactless, for example;
and that we have the interoperability across different providers
to provide a really comprehensive network, as is needed as we
transition from fossil fuel to a decarbonised transport
economy.
Will the Government legislate for interoperability? Will they
publish a plan showing the milestones of how many public charge
points will be built every year between now and 2030?
I will take away that request, but I can tell the hon. Member
that 26,000 public charge points are available and that of those
4,900 are rapid chargers. We also have a plan to install 750 kW
as a minimum in all the 117 motorway service areas—and that
absolutely includes the motorway services on the A1(M) at
Ferrybridge at junction 41 and those at Wetherby at junction
46.
I commend my hon. Friend the Member for Broxtowe (). A couple of weeks ago, I
had the absolute joy of visiting HORIBA MIRA in Nuneaton, where I
saw the technology and innovation that is supporting not just
decarbonisation but the connected and automated vehicles—they
were was abundant with UK content, as the hon. Member for Leeds
North West () said—that the country will need
to be at the forefront. The technology that I saw at Nuneaton
will be critical to the transition, and the midlands engine is at
the forefront of it. I am delighted that my hon. Friend came to
the debate to talk about that.
I am running out of time, but I want to address the lack of
driveways. We want to ensure that no driveway is no problem. We
understand the need to roll out publicly available charge point
infrastructure, and local authorities are key to that. We are
therefore putting together a toolkit with advice and, most
importantly, resources for where local authorities are struggling
to deliver. My message to hon. Members across the House is to
work with me and with local authorities, because they will know
their local areas best. The Department wants to ensure that we
have fair, accessible, affordable, reliable and transparent
charging infrastructure right across the UK.
The Minister is being kind. I am afraid that she has not
addressed the resilience of the national grid and its importance
to charging. The BEIS Committee has just produced an interesting
letter and report.
That is a matter for BEIS, which it is clearly taking seriously.
I work continuously with colleagues in BEIS as well as those in
the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs on clean
air zones. I will leave it there to allow the hon. Member for
Bath to wrap up.
14:58:00
I thank everybody for their contributions to the debate. As has
been said, there is a lot of consensus. We agree with the
Government that the 2030 target to phase out petrol and diesel
vehicles is ambitious, but if we want to see the big take-up of
electric vehicles, the Government need to do more to support
that.
I thank the Minister for addressing some of the points made. What
was missing was the national grid, which, as we have heard, is at
the bottom of problems with charging. The entertainment prize for
a good speech goes to the hon. Member for Rushcliffe (), who described what it is
like for EV owners on the road. The Government must be more
ambitious about these gaps and get to the bottom of why the
network does not work. That will need investment in the national
electricity grid. As I said, the national grid is owned by a
private company and it is for the Government to resolve the
problem of how they work with it. However, that must be done,
because local authorities want to do something—we all agree on
that—but the block is the lack of infrastructure investment.
Finally, it is no use buying electric vehicles if the power that
fuels them is not 100% renewable. The Minister talked about
nuclear, but I believe that this country is well placed to make
all its power from renewables. I hope that the Government will
share that ambition with me.
|