Anthony Browne (South Cambridgeshire) (Con) I beg to move, That
this House recognises the importance of financial services to the
UK economy; and calls on the Government to provide adequate support
to help create the right regulatory and operational environment for
that industry to ensure that the UK is able to retain its
competitiveness on the world stage. It is a pleasure to lead this
debate on the future of the UK’s leading industry: financial
services. The...Request free trial
(South Cambridgeshire)
(Con)
I beg to move,
That this House recognises the importance of financial services
to the UK economy; and calls on the Government to provide
adequate support to help create the right regulatory and
operational environment for that industry to ensure that the UK
is able to retain its competitiveness on the world stage.
It is a pleasure to lead this debate on the future of the UK’s
leading industry: financial services. The arguments about its
importance are well known and well rehearsed. The financial
services sector is the UK’s biggest export industry by far, with
a £78 billion a year trade surplus. In fact, the UK is the
biggest net exporter of financial services in the world; we
export more financial services than any other country on the
planet, including the US, Singapore and all of the EU combined.
That means that, as a country, we can afford to import all the
smartphones, flatscreen TVs and other manufactured goods that we
are so keen on, particularly at this time of year.
The financial services sector adds £194 billion gross value
added—that is, it contributes £10 in every £100 of all the UK’s
economic output. One in 14 UK workers is in financial services.
That is 2.3 million employees, two thirds of whom are outside
London. Indeed, this industry really is spread across the
country. Scotland has less than a tenth of the population of
France, but exports about half the amount of financial services
that France does. The financial services sector pays more tax in
a year than any other sector—£76 billion in the last year. As the
Chancellor pointed out in his Mansion House speech in the summer,
that is enough to pay for the entire national police force and
school system combined.
During this hideous pandemic, I am glad to say that the financial
services sector stepped up to the plate and played a crucial role
in keeping the economy going. It lent more than £75 billion in
emergency finance to nearly 2 million businesses. Indeed, it lent
£101 million to more than 2,000 businesses in my constituency of
South Cambridgeshire. To help homeowners, lenders also gave
nearly 3 million mortgage deferrals during the pandemic. The
financial services sector certainly has played its part in
ensuring that the economy has bounced back so quickly. Now,
guided by the Government, it is also increasingly playing a
critical role in ensuring that we reach net zero carbon dioxide
emissions by 2050. From green bonds to climate-related financial
disclosures to carbon markets, the financial services sector will
help, rather than hinder, in the biggest challenge facing
humankind: stopping climate change.
Although we all recognise the importance of financial services,
it is not a popular sector. A leading German politician once said
to me that it was the great British tragedy—that we do not like
our most successful industry. It has often brought that
unpopularity upon itself; we all know the reasons, so I will not
rehearse them here. It is one of the few industries in which we
are genuinely world leaders, but regular surveys of international
financial centres show that our crown is starting to slip: London
is now usually ranked second to New York; our lead over Singapore
and Hong Kong shows signs of shrinking; and our global market
share in some sectors, such as insurance and bank lending, is
trending down. That is a cause for concern, but not alarm. We can
turn the tide, but we need to have a clear strategic objective
that the UK should be the world’s leading international financial
centre.
The industry is at a major turning point. Financial services
policy in the next decade will be very different from financial
services policy in the last decade. We are at the beginning of a
new era. There are two major reasons for this, and both represent
major opportunities. The first is that the wide-ranging reform
and reconstruction of the industry in the wake of the 2008
financial crisis has, by and large, been completed. Almost the
entire regulation of the industry was rewritten in a tsunami of
reforms from both the EU and UK. This absolutely needed to be
done to ensure that the crisis could not happen again—to protect
taxpayers and consumers—but that regulatory repair job is now
largely behind us. We must not forget any of the lessons from it,
but we can now pursue a more forward-looking agenda. The
Government have set this out in their document, “A new chapter
for financial services”, which was published earlier this year
and which I very much welcome. It sets out a vision for the UK as
a leading financial centre that is open, innovative, competitive,
and green.
The second reason that we are at a turning point is that we have
left the EU. Clearly, leaving the single market represented a
major challenge for many financial services companies—and I think
that I am right in saying that not everyone in the industry fully
supported Brexit. But leaving the EU has created opportunities to
ensure that regulation and legislation is tailored to our
national circumstances. We do not have an equivalence deal with
the EU, nor, indeed, that promised memorandum of understanding. I
actually never thought that such a deal or memorandum was that
necessary; it was more a “nice to have”, rather than a “must
have”.
There are many other existing legal routes for UK-based financial
services companies to sell to clients in the EU, as we are
currently seeing. The no-deal scenario that we had in financial
services does have the advantage of giving us full regulatory
control. There are three fundamental problems with the EU
financial services regulation, from a UK perspective. The first
is that the necessity of getting agreement from 27 or 28
countries means that it is very inflexible; once a law is made,
it is very difficult to change it. Secondly, the EU tends to
focus on competition between its members rather than global
competition. It is more worried about competition between London,
Paris and Frankfurt than between London, New York and Singapore.
Thirdly, the EU necessarily assumes a one-size-fits-all approach
even though markets in different EU countries often have
incredibly different dynamics. In contrast, when we had the
chairman and chief executive of the Financial Conduct Authority
in front of the Select Committee yesterday, they talked about how
we can now have a very agile policy regime.
When we left the EU, the Government ensured legal continuity, as
they had to, by incorporating all European financial services
legislation wholesale into UK law. Now, though, we can take our
time to consider what reforms we want both to EU-originated laws
and to laws that we adopted unilaterally when we were part of the
EU. We must of course abide by global regulatory principles, as
set out by international bodies such as the Basel Committee on
Banking Supervision, the Financial Stability Board, the
International Organisation of Securities Commissions, and the
Financial Action Task Force. However, those various principles
are at a high level and below them lies an awful lot of
detail—and we know where the devil lies. We must continue being a
beacon of high regulatory standards and resist any temptation of
a race to the bottom, but we should also get the details right
and ensure that they are appropriate, proportionate, and do not
have unintended consequences. There is no conflict between
abiding by globally high standards and being globally
competitive.
Reform of imported EU legislation will take many years, if not
decades, but the Government have made a start. They have
completed the Lord Hill review of stock market listings and the
Kalifa review of financial technology and adopted their
recommendations, which now need to be implemented. We need to
ensure that the prospectus directive is made more proportionate.
I personally support allowing two classes of shares to encourage
investment in start-up companies. The Government are now
consulting on regulatory reform of wholesale financial markets,
particularly the second markets in financial instruments
directive, MiFID II, and the rules on the capitalisation of the
insurance market—Solvency II. If we get the reforms of Solvency
II right, that promises to unleash productive investment across
the UK, especially in high-growth firms. MiFID II and the
European market infrastructure regulation are extraordinarily
detailed and prescriptive, and could be simplified without harm.
Excessive detail can prevent beneficial innovation. We should
avoid gold-plating international standards, unless there are
clear reasons to do so. Rules on pre-trade transparency can be
counterproductive. The share trading obligation can be safely
removed.
Some retail legislation, such as on PRIIPS—packaged retail
investment and insurance products—is applied to wholesale markets
for little purpose. This week on the Treasury Committee, we heard
from representatives of the commodities exchange, ICE Futures
Europe, that they are required to produce countless retail key
information documents for institutional investors who do not want
them and will never read them. It was, they said, a pointless
waste of time. Retail and wholesale markets are different and
need to be treated differently. We should avoid making our rules
extraterritorial unless there is a clear reason to do so. The EU
often requires all EU-headquartered financial services companies
to abide by EU rules wherever they operate in the world, in a
deliberate attempt to set global regulation, but the UK should
start with the presumption that UK-headquartered financial
institutions need only abide by the rules in the markets where
they are actually operating, as long as those markets operate by
global standards. For example, when trading in the US, the
presumption should be that UK financial services companies just
need to abide by US rules.
The Government should also consider reforms to the capital
requirements directive and regulation. These are the rules that
implement the Basel capital rules for banks into EU and then into
UK law. The Basel rules are designed for international banks
operating across borders, not domestic banks operating just
within one country, but the requirements of the single market
meant that the EU ensured that the same capital rules were
applied to domestic banks operating just in one country as were
applied to international banks operating around the world. The UK
should consider following the US rather than the EU and not
require non-systemically-important domestic banks, such as
challenger banks, to abide by inappropriate global capital rules.
This could improve competition among banks without affecting
prudential stability.
There is also domestic legislation that the UK could usefully
revisit. The Treasury is currently reviewing the ringfencing
rules separating retail and wholesale banks, which, in part,
duplicates imported EU regulation on bank recovery and
resolution. The ringfencing rules can lead to very complex and
inappropriate governance structures for retail banks that do not
have any significant investment banking operations, and it is
certainly worth looking at whether that can be changed.
Critical to the continuing success of financial services will be
the process by which we make new rules, which the Government are
also reviewing. Our financial services rules will no longer go
through the EU policy-making machinery. They will no longer be
scrutinised in extraordinary depth and amended at length by the
European Parliament’s formidable Committee on Economic and
Monetary Affairs, which I wrestled with many times, and which was
once admirably chaired by the UK’s own Baroness Bowles. There is
no way that the UK Parliament has the capacity to replicate that
function. Parliament must set the objectives and principles of
future financial services regulation, but the details should be
determined by the regulators, particularly the FCA and the Bank
of England.
Dame (Wallasey) (Lab)
I agree that, as we are currently set up, the UK Parliament could
not even begin to replicate what the European Parliament did with
regard to oversight of regulation, but surely, if we, as a
Parliament, were properly geared up with appropriate support, we
could.
I basically agree with the hon. Member, a fellow member of the
Treasury Committee.
(Wimbledon) (Con)
This is a really important point that we discussed in the debate
last November prior to the Financial Services Act 2021, which
came into force earlier this year. The key point is that we are
giving the regulator huge increases of power with almost no
appropriate increase in parliamentary scrutiny of those
powers.
I thank my hon. Friend. That is exactly the point I was about to
come to.
This will give the regulators more power, as my hon. Friend said,
over issues that will directly affect the lives of voters. That
means that they must be made more accountable to voters’
representatives—that is, to Parliament. The Government and the
Treasury Committee are considering how that might work, and the
Committee has held various hearings on the issue.
One proposed solution is a stand-alone financial services
committee such as exists in Washington—the US House Committee on
Financial Services, a stand-alone committee that just considers
financial services. However, there is a real risk that that would
tread on the toes of and undermine the existing Treasury
Committee, which must retain oversight of all the Treasury’s
functions. Another alternative is a full Committee of both
Houses—the House of Commons and the House of Lords—but that would
be unmanageable on an ongoing basis. It has worked as a task and
finish group, such as the Parliamentary Commission on Banking
Standards, but it would be very difficult on an ongoing basis. I
am coming to the conclusion that the Treasury Committee needs—I
totally agree with the hon. Member for Wallasey (Dame ) on this—a well-supported
sub-Committee, or secretariat, that can do the work in focusing
on financial services regulation and holding the newly empowered
regulators to account. It could include appointed expert
advisers, as well as members from the House of Lords, on an
appropriate basis.
Obviously, we would need to agree the governance around that. As
the Government have made clear, this is an issue properly for
Parliament itself to decide. The Treasury Committee will make its
own recommendations in due course. Indeed, if any Members here
have other thoughts on it, I would be very interested to hear
them.
The regulators themselves are also changing. The Government have
proposed giving them international competitiveness objectives,
but that must be very much secondary to their principal
objectives of financial stability and consumer protection. They
must not lose focus on their principal objectives.
My hon. Friend is right that we must not move away from the
primary focus, but does he agree—he made the point earlier on the
difference between wholesale and retail—that there ought to be a
more balanced view between wholesale regulation and those two
objectives if we are to remain a global centre
internationally?
I agree. I support having a secondary objective of international
competitiveness and growth. A regulator could decide on policy A
or policy B and, from a UK perspective, it could make no
difference in terms of consumer protection or prudential
stability, but one could mean that we were more able to compete
internationally. We asked the chief executive and chair of the
Financial Conduct Authority about this in the Treasury Committee
yesterday and they went through the details on how that might
affect their thinking. But we absolutely must not lose sight of
prudential stability. We have had a crisis once and we do not
want it again.
We must maintain our support for innovation in financial
services, as long as it brings real consumer and economic
benefits. We must ensure that the fintech sector thrives.
Creating a digital identity ecosystem, which the Government are
looking at, will certainly help. As cryptocurrencies grow, it is
inevitable that they will need some form of regulation to protect
consumers, but it must be done in a proportionate way that
focuses on tackling any harms. It is absolutely right that the
Bank of England is exploring central bank digital currencies. We
do not know whether retail customers want direct access to
central bank funding, but it is absolutely right that we try to
find out.
Finally, I want to cast our eyes across the world, and look at
international partnerships. We are no longer part of the EU, and
we do not know what our future relationship with it will be. As I
said earlier, I consider any memorandum of understanding as a
“nice to have” rather than a “must have”, and it certainly must
not shackle the UK’s new regulatory regime. Any partnership would
require both sides to agree it, and there seems little political
desire for that at the moment on the other side of the channel.
Rather, UK-based banks are worried that the EU is considering
ways deliberately to make it more difficult to offer services to
their EU-based clients, and we have to keep an eye out for that.
That makes it all the more important that the UK forms meaningful
partnerships with other international financial centres. I have
long advocated a close financial services partnership between the
UK and Switzerland, a major financial centre. We share a common
approach, a global outlook and pragmatism.
(Kensington) (Con)
Will my hon. Friend give way?
I am happy to give way to my hon. Friend and current member of
the Treasury Committee.
Does my hon. Friend agree that given their importance to our
economy, both in London and throughout the country, we need to
ensure that financial services are at the front when we are
negotiating trade deals and market access with other
countries?
I very much agree. I was coming to this point. If we can get
those elements into trade agreements, we should aspire to do
that. However, often, regulatory agreements between regulators
are more appropriate.
(Bromley and Chislehurst)
(Con)
Does my hon. Friend agree that in addition to the importance of
financial services in trade deals, it is important that we are
aware of supporting other professional services that go with
them, such as law and accountancy? The legal underpinning and
enforceability of our financial services deals is critical going
forward.
I fully agree with my hon. Friend. I have been focusing obviously
on financial services, but there is the wider concept of
financial and related professional services, including legal
services. As he knows far better than me, London and the UK are a
global centre for legal services. That is a huge export industry
in its own right and we should do what we can to promote that
internationally.
I was just talking about the importance of the relationship
between the UK and Switzerland. We have a lot to gain by working
more closely together. That is why I am delighted that the
Government are working towards an outcomes-based mutual
recognition agreement with Switzerland. I emphasise that it is
outcomes-based because it is pragmatic and we share that
pragmatism. Similarly, we can have an ambitious agreement with
Singapore and other jurisdictions, such as Japan and South
Korea.
I am pleased that the Government are working closely with the
United States to remove barriers to financial services trade
between us. We have some agreements and we could have more. The
Government are doing the same with Australia, Canada and New
Zealand. Coming to the point about trade agreements that my hon.
Friend the Member for Bromley and Chislehurst ( ) raised, I welcome the
agreement in principle on the UK-New Zealand free trade deal,
which facilitates cross-border data transfer and recognises the
importance of allowing firms to offshore back-office functions.
Those are both important for financial services.
We can promote financial services through trade agreements and
mutual recognition agreements between regulators to the benefit
of both sides. The Government must continue to work closely with
our partners through the G7, the G20 and the Financial Stability
Board to ensure consistent international standards. As the most
globalised of all international financial centres, we are more
impacted by global inconsistencies on standards than other
jurisdictions.
My hon. Friend makes an important point about co-operation
between regulators and agreements between regulators. Does he
agree that that is particularly important in the context of
dealing with the United States, where much of the regulation
takes place at the state, rather than federal level? Therefore,
it is not easily embraced in a straightforward, normal type of
free trade agreement.
My hon. Friend makes an incredibly valid point. I know that the
UK Treasury has spent a lot of time wrestling with the
relationships with the United States, which is in many ways
almost unmanageable, because it has 50 different state
regulators, and the federal regulators answer to Congress, rather
than to the Government, so agreements between Governments may not
have an impact on the regulators themselves.
In conclusion, we are at a turning point for Britain’s financial
services industry. In the past decade, we have faced the major
challenges of the global financial crisis and Brexit, and we took
the steps necessary to forge through both of those. We can now
look forward to a new era of financial services, with new
opportunities. We need to make sure that the UK is the undisputed
leading international financial centre, both globally competitive
and serving communities and consumers across our country, and
exporting more, creating more jobs, funding more businesses and
paying more tax. That is something we should all welcome.
13:54:00
Dame (Wallasey) (Lab)
It is a pleasure to follow the hon. Member for South
Cambridgeshire (), who has opened this
Backbench Business debate and is a fellow member of the Treasury
Committee. He has given us a grand tour of a large and diverse
sector of the economy that is, as he pointed out, very important.
He also pointed out that it is affected by a range of issues at
the moment.
The hon. Gentleman gave us some of his ideas on what should be
happening post Brexit with some of the more complex of the EU
directives that have been onshored—in particular, MiFID—which
have been against the grain of how the UK financial services and
insurance industries have always tended to work. He hinted at the
philosophical difference between EU regulation in these areas and
how the UK more traditionally did it; it is the difference
between having principles-based regulation, which is not so
specific, and the EU way of doing regulation, which tends to be
so specific and puts a lot of those specifics in legislation.
When I was in the Treasury and in the Department for Work and
Pensions as Pensions Minister, it was a battle that we constantly
had with the EU in the Council of Ministers and with the
Commission.
The Economic Secretary to the Treasury ()
indicated assent.
Dame
I can see the Minister is nodding, possibly because he recognises
some of those tensions, which always existed when we were in the
EU.
When we were in the EU, because of the size of the influence of
the UK financial services industry as part of that bloc, we had a
very good and effective way of pulling at least a lot of the
regulation that went on more towards our way of doing things. One
of the worries I have post Brexit, which I suppose is a
philosophical and practical worry, is that the EU will now go off
and do a lot more of the things that we were able to persuade it
not to do when we were a member. The divergence between how EU
regulation works and how we may wish our future regulation of
financial services to work is likely to grow larger.
It has not been a very friendly divorce to date, and there may
well be implications to that, too, in terms of competition for
business. We have seen some of that in the wholesale markets for
euros and we will doubtless see more of it. The outcome of our
way of leaving the EU will challenge some of the agreements that
we came to and the influence we were able to have when we were
inside the Council chambers, the European Parliament and the
European Commission, rather than the situation we find ourselves
in now. As the hon. Member for South Cambridgeshire said, that
can be an advantage, but it can also be a disadvantage. It is an
opportunity, but there are also threats and issues that we have
to deal with. We have a sharp disjunction with the recent past,
after 40 years of that kind of influence, that we will have to
deal with in the coming period. We have the inadequacies of the
non-existent deal on financial services, which was part of the
EU-UK so-called trade agreement, and those are already having an
effect.
The hon. Gentleman was right to say that we are in a period of
rapid regulatory change, which would have been the case
regardless of whether we left the European Union. The fact that
we have, and the fact that we have onshored all this regulatory
machinery, means that we now have to start looking at how we wish
to change all of it.
Even thinking about the sheer weight of work and oversight that
will have to be done by the Treasury Committee is quite
overwhelming, as the hon. Gentleman acknowledged in the exchange
we had during his speech. The Minister must go weak at the knees
when he thinks of the detailed work that he will have to put in
to deal with the onshoring in the aftermath of Brexit, and
whether we want to move quickly or slowly to adapt the laws and
regulations that we have imported.
Members of the Treasury Committee have also gone weak at the
knees thinking about how they might have some oversight, because
of the highly technical nature of much of that regulation. We
certainly need to be significantly more tooled up than we have
been if we are to have proper oversight of what the regulators
are tasked with doing, what philosophical direction the
Government wish to go in, and what the practical aspects of that
method will mean for our financial services industry and, of
course—they have not been mentioned much—for consumers in the UK
and for financial stability.
We should not lose sight of those two basic reasons why we have
to get regulation right. Consumer protection is a huge issue in
financial services, as the hon. Gentleman touched on when he said
that financial services are not always the most popular sector of
our economy. Perhaps some of those who supply and form part of
the industry ought to stop and think about why that is they case
and do some self-reflection about it.
Clearly, financial stability is also crucial in an era when
markets are becoming more rapid and more global. In the context
of highly rapid technical change, financial stability becomes
even more important, because innovation outruns the capacity of
many regulators to keep up with what on earth is going on in some
markets. Those two important issues have to underpin all
regulation; the future of the entire financial services industry
rests on them.
Regulatory change in a rapidly evolving situation with a lot of
flux is inevitably difficult for those who participate in the
market and for those who wish to regulate it. It is also
difficult for those such as the Minister who want to see how it
can be properly harnessed and allowed to be beneficial to our
economy while being safe. It is a period of big uncertainty and
flex. New technology has the capacity to change things and lead
to innovation, some of which might be fantastic and some of which
might be awful. That structural issue has hit us greatly through
the innovations of digital currencies.
The systems that control financial services have to deal with the
practical and philosophical issues that arise, such as whether
digital coins are ever stable, what central banks ought to be
doing to deal with that, and whether the wild west of Bitcoin and
the rest should be left as a gambling thing on the side. Those
markets can be volatile—the wild west—but the capacity of
software such as open registers and blockchain, and their
potential for transparency and in-time and open trading of all
sorts of things, could be harnessed for good purposes as well as
for the more nefarious ones that feature on the darker edges of
the net. On top of that, the demands of climate change will cause
a systemic change in the way that things are valued, priced and
assessed for value.
That structural change will completely change the context in
which the financial services industry has to exist. In the UK,
which is one of the most open economies in the world and always
has been, we know how important the financial services sector is,
and not only to London as a global centre. In 2020, it was worth
£164 billion to the UK economy, which is the third-largest sector
by size in the OECD. That is 8.6% of economic output, half of
which is generated in London but half of which is generated
across our regions. Of the 1.1 million jobs, 91,000 are in my
region of the north-west. As the hon. Member for South
Cambridgeshire pointed out, it is one of the few sectors where we
have a healthy trade surplus—£46 billion in 2020. It is the
fifth-largest economic sector in our economy, and all the more
important for that.
As the hon. Gentleman also pointed out, the sector is important
for taxation, with £28.8 billion in tax taken from it. According
to PwC, it makes up £75.6 billion, or 10% of the total receipts.
In the face of such change—technological, structural or the
disjunction of Brexit—any Government would want to see how they
could remake the environment in which the financial sector can
operate and flourish to benefit and protect the sector so that it
can benefit and protect our economy. We certainly all have a
stake in ensuring that that is the case.
In that area of flux, we have to remember that the regulators,
although they could be powerful, are struggling with an
increasingly complex and fast-moving environment that they are
not always geared up to deal with in detail or to keep on top of.
We have seen the travails of the Financial Conduct Authority and
how it manages the perimeter, and philosophically the view of
caveat emptor—that the buyer should beware in all circumstances.
When things go wrong, the reputation of the entire financial
services sector is at stake, so it is a difficult balance.
The Financial Conduct Authority gave evidence to the Treasury
Committee yesterday, some of which reflected how difficult it is
to try to remake a regulator after scandals such as London
Capital & Finance, at the same time as operating within all
the extra complexity and uncertainty. It has a formidable task. I
suspect that being chair of the FCA is one of those jobs where
people are told that, if they do a stint, they will get the
diplomatic equivalent of the Washington embassy as a reward. The
current Governor of the Bank of England is one example of
that.
The FCA needs to be strengthened. We as policy makers, and the
Minister in particular, have to think about how it can
practically do the job. The job cannot be so big and complex that
it is undoable. Sometimes, the way that the FCA has to cope means
it is difficult for it to achieve a balance and be given a job
that it can sensibly do. We know there is a big turnover of staff
at the FCA at the moment, and that there is workplace stress and
unrest. We know that the head of the FCA is trying to transform
that organisation into what he calls a lean organisation that can
respond very quickly to what is going on in the market and in the
areas it has to regulate. I am not convinced that it has that
balance right yet, and I am not even convinced that that job can
sensibly be done without more support.
I want to deal with a couple of areas that the hon. Member for
South Cambridgeshire did not touch on. These are what I would
call threats to the reputation of the financial services industry
in this country. First, I want to talk about economic crime,
which I think poses a threat to the entire sector and its
integrity if it is allowed to get out of hand. We know that there
are rising levels of economic crime, fraud and scams that have
been turbocharged during the lockdown. The sector itself has
survived covid and the lockdown pretty well so far, because it
could manage remotely—it does a lot of its work remotely in the
first place—but one of the things we have all seen,
unfortunately, is the rise in fraud and scams. We have also seen,
and perhaps it is inevitable when it is one of the biggest global
centres of financial services, that London has attracted the
attention of international criminals and fraudsters who wish to
launder their money through cities like London. We know that, as
a major financial centre, it is a target for all of these kinds
of people.
The Intelligence and Security Committee, in its Russia report,
which was suppressed for far too long and was finally published
after the 2019 general election, said that London is considered
the “laundromat” for corrupt money. We have seen that kind of
magnet effect, which is extremely disturbing, and I do not think
that we have yet really got a handle on it. There are regulatory
failings, there are legislative failings with the structures we
have to try to deal with this, and there are certainly
enforcement failings of the laws that we do have.
The hon. Lady makes some very important points, particularly that
last one. Does she agree that now we have left the EU and
therefore, regrettably, left some of the justice co-operation
measures we had, it is all the more important that we seek,
bilaterally and in a broader sphere, to improve and strengthen
international judicial and legal co-operation on the
admissibility of evidence, rendering of suspects and, above all,
dealing with digital evidence being obtained in other
jurisdictions and then made available to prosecutors and the
courts in the United Kingdom?
Dame
I could not agree more with the hon. Gentleman, who is a
distinguished Chair of the Select Committee on Justice. He is
also a practitioner himself, so he knows about the practicalities
of these issues. It is hard, in contemplating the extra work that
has to be done because of Brexit, to know quite where one starts,
but if we do not get it right and if we do not get on with it,
this terrible reputation of London having become a laundromat for
dirty money will only persist and perhaps get stronger, which
will do us untold damage. I urge the Minister responding to this
debate to give us some words of comfort that he is getting on
with the economic crime strategy. We have an economic crime
strategy—
Madam Deputy Speaker ( )
Order. I hesitate to interrupt the hon. Lady, but I have been
very lenient on timekeeping this afternoon because we have plenty
of time and not very many speakers, and I have been particularly
lenient because she is the only representative of the Opposition
Back Benches. However, she is in danger of taking a very large
chunk of time: she has spoken for about 20 minutes, which is
longer than the person who introduced the debate. I wanted to
keep such a balance, so I am not stopping her, but I am hoping,
in the interests of being fair to everyone, that she will soon
draw her remarks to a close.
Dame
Madam Deputy Speaker, I am delighted to do so. I suppose that,
when one gets let off the leash away from debates with
three-minute limits, all the words just come tumbling out, but I
would not want to take more than my allotted time.
I hope the Minister will be able to give us some words of
comfort, particularly that he will be taking fast action to
establish a beneficial ownership register and bring some
transparency to what is going on in respect of financial
crime.
Finally, I want to mention the issue of the model all too often
pursued by some of our financial services, and this is a final
philosophical point perhaps. All too often, complexity is seen as
an end in itself in our financial services, and as a proxy for
competition and a proxy for innovation, when in fact it is merely
an excuse for opaque pricing. That makes it difficult for average
consumers who want to put their money somewhere, make money,
protect their money, or get a reasonable return on their money,
and who find it too complex to do so. I do not believe that this
is serving customers well, catering, as it does increasingly, for
just a few at the top of the earnings distribution rather than
the many who have smaller pots of money. I hope that the Minister
will reflect in his response about what might be done to reverse
that trend. With that final observation, Madam Deputy Speaker, I
am happy to draw my remarks to a close.
Madam Deputy Speaker
Thank you. I hope that we do not have to have a time limit this
afternoon. If everyone takes about eight minutes, there will be
no need for one. If that does not happen, I will have to put on a
time limit.
14:16:00
(Wimbledon) (Con)
It is an honour and a privilege to follow the two speeches from
my hon. Friend the Member for South Cambridgeshire () and the hon. Member for
Wallasey (Dame ). Both of them gave us
philosophical, intelligent and really interesting speeches, and I
noted that both of them made the point that financial services as
an industry perhaps do not get the respect or the renown they
probably should have.
I was reflecting on that when I heard the remark my hon. Friend
the Member for South Cambridgeshire made about the German who
said financial services are not recognised. Why is that? I think
it is probably for three particular reasons, yet when we look at
the contribution to the UK economy, we should really be shouting
out against that. The first point is that, for all too many, when
we say financial services, they think of banking. They forget all
the related professional services, notwithstanding the
subdivisions—indeed, financial services themselves are more
tightly defined—and just concentrate on banking. They think back
to the financial crisis and all the attendant problems that my
hon. Friend so rightly pointed out.
The second point is that, when we say financial services, people
may expect the hon. Member for Wimbledon to stand up, but they
should expect the hon. Member for Wallasey to stand up as well.
Although, understandably, financial services account for 16% of
London’s total gross value added, the reality is that in the
north-west the industry is 6% of the regional economy, in the
south-west it is 6%, in the west midlands it is 6% and in
Yorkshire and Humberside it is 6%. The smallest contribution of
financial services anywhere in the country is actually the east
midlands, and that is 3%, but it is none the less 3% of that
regional economy. So we should be standing up and saying that
this is a UK-wide industry.
The third point—with complete respect to my hon. Friend on the
Front Bench, who is establishing his reputation for being perhaps
the best City Minister we have ever had—is that there are one or
two at the top of this Government who have occasionally thought
that fishing was more important than financial services. If one
says that the total contribution to the UK economy of financial
services was £67.4 billion last year, and for fishing the number
is so small it is not worth talking about, correcting that and
looking to that in the future would underline the point about the
power of financial services. As has already been stated, there is
a huge trade surplus.
My hon. Friend the Member for South Cambridgeshire talked about
the opportunities and the hon. Member for Wallasey talked about
the threats from the EU. It is none the less true that during our
membership of the EU we established ourselves as the world’s
global financial centre, and whether we like it or not 40% of UK
financial services exports still go there. So my hon. Friend the
Economic Secretary to the Treasury will know that in those very
complex negotiations—I will not repeat what has already been said
about them—we must have a sensible, diplomatic and economically
viable dialogue with our nearest and dearest neighbours.
The tax contribution has already been mentioned several times,
and the hon. Lady made the point that PwC estimates that £75.5
billion, or 11% of Government receipts, come from the wider
financial and associated professional services sector, including
insurance and legal. So there cannot be any doubt that this is a
hugely important industry and a powerful industry for the UK, and
if we want a globally successful Britain we need a globally
successful, renowned and well-regulated industry. It is
noticeable that in the last few years we have very slightly
slipped in the global financial centres index to second place and
we must recognise that there are threats as well as opportunities
from leaving the EU. It is of significance that on the first
trading day of this year we lost £6 billion of activity out of
London, and that is a continual threat. So I say yet again not
only that we need those important negotiations to be conducted in
a manner that is to London’s benefit but that we equally need to
recognise of course that the threat is also now once again from
New York, Switzerland, Singapore and Hong Kong. In the global
alliances that we strike in financial services it is perfectly
possible to recognise that, with some economic diplomacy put into
deepening regulatory engagement, we could find ourselves in a
powerful international regulatory alliance with the Americans,
the Swiss and some of the far-east countries. Andrew Bailey some
years ago when I was serving on the Treasury Committee raised
this as an opportunity we should consider. Building those new
trade and investment ties, and underpinning international
agreements with financial services, is key to a globally
successful Britain.
I want to briefly talk about two other points. First, as has been
said, there is a difference between wholesale regulation and
retail regulation. The Financial Services Act 2021 says that the
Financial Conduct Authority must have regard to the relevant
international standards and the effect of the rules on the UK’s
international standing. That is hugely important, particularly in
wholesale regulation where we hope to ensure that the UK is an
international powerhouse. I accept that that will always be a
secondary objective of the rules and the obligations on the
regulator, but it must not be deviated from. I hope that my hon.
Friend the Economic Secretary will set that in place. In terms of
the history of regulation in the UK, a large number of people
think the system, while rightly seeking to ensure extensive
consumer protection, has come at the cost of overspecification
for the wholesale markets to no benefit at all and to the
diminution of our standing.
The other point has also been raised, but it is important. The
2021 Act has given a huge increase in power to the regulators in
a way that we have seen with very few other regulators, by which
I mean the lack of scrutiny in this House. I note that the
financial services document “Future Regulatory Framework (FRP)
review” has come out and it talks about this, and my hon. Friend
the Member for South Cambridgeshire referred to evidence to the
Treasury Committee. Because of the importance of this industry to
the country, I urge the House to consider very carefully
establishing a Select Committee of both Houses or indeed a
standing sub-committee of the Treasury Committee. I do not accept
the argument that several have put that there is not the
expertise or capability within this House, or that this House is
not able to get the necessary resources and capability brought
into it to undertake that proper and appropriate parliamentary
scrutiny.
Finally, in the last minute of my speech I want to talk about two
other matters. We have talked a lot about the past and what
financial services has done, but it could do a lot more to help
in what this Government and this country want to achieve. If
levelling up means anything, it means bringing opportunity to the
regions of this country. Financial services is already a powerful
industry in the regions of this country, and bringing in those
high-paid, high-value jobs also brings in skills. We should be
doing all sorts of things to encourage that, not necessarily just
within Government; universities should specialise in master’s
degrees in financial capabilities and regulation. We should be
focusing heavily on developing the UK as a centre of financial
skills. That way we would not only drive UK levelling up but
bring the talent to make London and the other global centres of
this country into the powerhouse of financial services.
Finally, the Government have done a huge amount of good work
already in delivering the net-zero economy from financial
services. Financial services can do much more in that area; all
sorts of things, particularly using the tax system, have been
done already, but we can do much more, and the financial services
sector must play its role to deliver that objective.
14:26:00
(Rutherglen and Hamilton
West) (Ind)
It is a pleasure to follow the hon. Member for Wimbledon ().
I thank the Backbench Business Committee and the three sponsors
of today’s debate for bringing this topic to the House for
discussion. The UK’s financial services are a huge asset and
truly world class. The UK’s sector is the third largest of the
OECD countries in terms of its economic output. Recent rankings
put London’s financial market as the second most competitive in
the world, only narrowly beat out by New York. It is therefore
unsurprising that even within the UK London holds the lion’s
share of the glory. The city’s contribution to the UK economy for
the sector accounts for 50% of the sector’s economic output, but,
interestingly, Scotland ranks just behind London and the
south-east; it is a very well-established financial centre. So
while London might sit firmly centre-stage, contributions from
across the UK should also be celebrated.
In fact, Scotland has a rich history as a thriving financial hub,
one that spans over 300 years. The Institute of Chartered
Accountants of Scotland was the world’s first professional
accounting body, established in 1854. The Chartered Banker
Institute—or as it was originally known the Institute of Bankers
in Scotland—was established in 1875, making it the oldest banking
institute in the world. Today there are around 84,000 jobs in the
sector in Scotland, and around 2,000 businesses. The FinTech
industry is growing too, with many firms looking to establish
homes in Glasgow and Edinburgh. Many cite the excellent provision
of local skill and talent as the reason for wanting to do so. It
is attractive to foreign direct investment, too.
Like so many of the UK’s industries, the financial sector has not
escaped unscathed from the realities of Brexit. Financial
services were largely overlooked in the trade and co-operation
agreement, so provisions are relatively sparse. According to the
Financial Times, there are 90 mentions of financial services in
the agreement, but variations of the word “fish” appear 368
times. In December last year the sector lost passporting rights
and we moved into market access determined through equivalence.
The deal we came away with was not a good one and, as expected,
many businesses moved to other European financial centres where
they have access to the single market. Jobs and business have
been lost and perhaps still will be, but we will not know the
true impact for a long while yet.
The sector’s economic contribution is substantial, as we know. A
recent study showed that Scottish businesses had an average
profit margin of 7.5%, above the UK average and second only to
London. Financial services are a big part of the reason that
average is so high. The sector’s profit margin in Scotland is
13.6%. Its tax contribution is impressive too, at £28.8 billion
in income tax, national insurance, corporation tax, bank payroll
tax and the banking levy last financial year. That is 4.1% of all
taxes collected last year.
What is next? How do we build on what we have and mitigate the
impact of leaving the single market? The Government’s answer
seems to be deregulation, although industry experts seem to be
not wholly in agreement about the impact that will have. I would
be interested to hear what discussions the Minister has had with
the sector about deregulation, and how that has informed the
Government’s strategy. Have the Government considered the
argument for reregulation—a reshaping of the current framework so
that it is more suitable—rather than deregulation?
Financial services policy remains reserved to the UK Government,
and I urge them not to overlook the sector’s prominent Scottish
presence as they review and reform their policies in a
post-Brexit context.
14:30:00
(Hitchin and Harpenden)
(Con)
It is a pleasure to speak in such a well-informed and thoughtful
debate.
First, on the contribution of the financial services sector, I do
not want to repeat what has been said by my hon. Friend the
Member for South Cambridgeshire () and others about the tax
paid, the growth or the jobs, but I want to bring up something
that has not yet been discussed: the contribution during the
acute phase of the covid pandemic in 2020, when about £75 billion
was facilitated through the UK financial services sector. To
illustrate what that means, in my constituency, which does not
have a huge number of businesses compared with many other
constituencies, over £100 million was facilitated through the
financial services sector for businesses. That is a practical
demonstration of the positive impact that the financial services
sector can have on the lives of our constituents.
Competitiveness has been mentioned by many Members. I support
what the Treasury want to do in adding growth and international
competitiveness as a secondary obligation for the FCA and the
Prudential Regulation Authority. I support the action in the
Budget to reduce the bank surcharge on banks in particular. Had
we left the surcharge where it was, from a tax perspective, it
would have made the UK one of the most expensive jurisdictions in
the world in which to operate a bank, and that is not in the UK’s
national interest. I support the work that the Hill review did on
listings, the general approach to public markets, the share
trading obligation and the double volume cap. On a lot of these
technical things, I think the Government are in the right place;
we are going in the right direction, we are doing the right
things and, as many others have said, the Minister is doing a
great job.
On ringfencing, I will make a confession: before I came to this
House, I spent some time at HSBC, where I worked in
restructuring, and I had a lot to do with ringfencing. I can say
from bitter personal experience that it is deeply complicated. It
was well intentioned, but a review is overdue. I am glad that the
Government are going to look at it. I ask them to look not just
at whether ringfencing has done a reasonable job so far, but at
the asymmetry of how it is imposed on UK-domiciled banks compared
with our competitors, including the sheer complexity and cost
associated with it, not just in terms of compliance and what we
think of as regulation, but in terms of the IT systems, where
people are and how the buildings operate. It costs a considerable
amount of money and a huge amount of focus for big banks such as
HSBC, Barclays and others. Without prejudging the outcome, I
think that review is critically important.
Let me pick up something that my hon. Friend the Member for
Kensington () said about trade deals.
The Government, and indeed the country, are right in pursuing our
strategy on trade internationally, looking beyond Europe and
seeking to strike as many good trade deals as we can across the
world. We need to make sure that those trade deals are best in
class. What I think of as a best-in-class trade deal today, in
the modern world, has to include services, and it has to include
financial services and other professional services, not just
because that is a good thing for this country but because the
nature of modern international trade is increasingly moving
towards services rather than goods, particularly for advanced
western economies such as our own.
We have a great opportunity to pioneer that at an international
level. In particular, our regulators must seek to have many more
regulator-to-regulator exchanges across the world as part of
those trade deals. A lot of the regulations that are in place for
financial services often happen at sub-national level, so it is
so important that our regulators do that. I am sure those
regulator-to-regulator exchanges will be very good fun indeed for
all concerned.
My hon. Friend the Member for Wimbledon (), who is very experienced
in these matters, talked about levelling up and about the
positive regional aspect of the financial services sector and the
jobs it creates outside London and the south-east. I completely
agree, but I think of levelling up as not so much about levelling
up places as about levelling up people. It is about people’s
opportunities. Alongside all the technical work that we have
already talked about, with regulations, ringfencing, the double
volume cap, listing, public markets, prospectus directives and
all that stuff, the financial services sector needs to do
more—and I think it can do more—on levelling up in the United
Kingdom.
What does that look like for the financial services sector? It
means the industry doing more on alternative routes into the
sector—apprenticeships and others. It also means the industry
doing more not so much to provide more jobs outside London and
the south-east, although that is always welcome, but to help to
develop regional clusters around Edinburgh, Leeds, Bournemouth
and various other places. There are significant numbers of
financial services jobs in those places, but what more can the
industry do to develop those regional clusters to give more
opportunities to people from all over the country and from
different backgrounds?
Let me briefly mention debt advice for those who have found
themselves in problem debt after the covid pandemic. I think we
all recognise that, for some people, debt has grown
significantly. I think there is more that the industry can do to
work with people with problem debt and help them get out of that
situation, with the help of the legislation that is already in
place.
Finally, if my hon. Friend the Member for Thirsk and Malton
() were here, I am sure he
would talk about small and medium-sized enterprises and access to
finance. I do not want to steal his thunder, but we must think
about SMEs getting access not just to debt but to equity finance,
and about ensuring that underrepresented groups of
entrepreneurs—often ethnic minorities or women—get more and
better opportunities to raise funds for their businesses. That is
the skillset—the core determinant—of a financial services sector:
providing funds for people to realise their aspirations as
individuals or as part of a business.
I will be doing some more work on this in the new year, as the
Minister knows, but I urge the sector to do more on the levelling
up agenda in its broader sense, in addition to working with the
Government, with me and with colleagues, including the people
here, on the technical regulatory aspects that are critical for
our international competitiveness.
14:38:00
(Bromley and Chislehurst)
(Con)
This has been a really valuable debate, and I hope that it gets
as much publicity as it ought to get. I hope, too, that the
sector gets as much publicity—and as much credit—as it ought to
get.
The sector is massively important to my constituents in Bromley
and Chislehurst, as it is in much of outer London. In my
constituency, financial and professional services together
account for over 36% of the workforce. The sector is by far the
largest driver of jobs and of prosperity overall in our area. Of
course, we must consider not just the jobs in the City or
elsewhere in London, but the other jobs that the income from that
work supports elsewhere in the employment chain, and the growth
of other businesses in the area. The sector is critical.
It is also worth stressing, yet again, the diversity of the
sector. We talked in particular about its overall contribution.
As my hon. Friend the Member for Wimbledon () said, we often think of
the sector in terms of banking. Distinctions are rightly made,
which I know the Minister is well seized of, between wholesale
and retail, but other sectors in financial services such as
insurance contribute something like £30 billion to the economy on
their own. The London insurance market is massive, and has a very
high reputation in both insurance itself and in reinsurance. It
is vital that we include access to insurance products in any free
trade deals, and keep regulation appropriate and
proportionate.
London’s other great strength is the nexus of the financial
services sector with other supporting professions, including the
law. I declare an interest here and refer the House to my entry
in the Register of Members’ Financial Interests. Legal services
are themselves worth some £60 billion to the UK economy and are a
net contributor to the UK’s balance of trade. So many of our
financial services instruments, from derivatives right the way
through to other types of contracts down to trading mechanisms,
are underpinned by legal services and by the reputation of the
United Kingdom as a jurisdiction of choice, because of its
reliability, legal certainty and the expertise of its legal
community. That is backed up by the accountancy sector, too.
As we go forward looking at free trade arrangements and
regulatory deals, which I think we will have to have for the
reasons that have been well set out, it is important that we do
not lose sight of the fact that the whole basket comes together
and contributes overall to that cluster of excellence and
critical mass, which so far has given us a great competitive
edge. We cannot take that for granted, and that is why some of us
were troubled at the lack of reference to financial and
professional services generally in the trade and co-operation
agreement. We have to build on what we now have and this is a
very good example of that.
Reference was made to regulatory reform. The opportunity, for
example, that the insurance industry suggested for two specific
reforms to solvency II would be of considerable benefit. I hope
the Minister will be able to update us on progress on that.
Perhaps, too, we can have an update on where we are with the
actual implementation of the outcomes of the Kalifa and Hill
reviews, and where we are, for example, on the movements that are
freeing up and easing listing, to which I know the Government are
already committed, and where we might be on variable classes of
shares to encourage different types of listing on London
markets.
The other point I want to make on legal services and future
co-operation echoes the point made by the hon. Member for
Wallasey (Dame ). In maintaining London’s
reputation as a reliable and honest jurisdiction, it is important
that we bear down on the risk of economic crime. That cannot be
done in isolation. Sovereignty takes us only so far when it comes
to fighting international organised crime, so it is absolutely
critical that, having regrettably lost access to some of the
European Union justice and policing mechanisms, we find ways to
replicate them either bilaterally or perhaps through future
agreements as we, I hope, develop a more constructive
relationship with our European partners than is perhaps the case
at the moment. It is in nobody’s interest that we have a
permanent state of tension between two such significant markets
on the world stage. Including legal co-operation is massively
important, certainly on the justice side and stretching that out
into other jurisdictions, too.
As the Minister has heard me say many times, it is regrettable
that the European Union is taking a needlessly obstructive
approach to the United Kingdom’s application to join the Lugano
convention on the enforcement of civil judgments. It wrongly
argues that it is a single market mechanism. I think the
Government are right in saying that it is not a single market
mechanism. It is entirely separate and this is a regrettable
product of the tensions we have had. I hope the Government will
not give up on that and will also look at workarounds with other,
non-EU countries to maintain high levels of recognition. The
enforceability of any contract, including a contract for
financial services, is absolutely critical to our remaining the
jurisdiction of choice.
My final point is on the contribution the City of London
Corporation makes in areas such as green finance. A huge amount
is being done. The City Corporation, with the Government,
provided the seed funding for the first three years of the Green
Finance Institute. That, of course, has been involved in building
coalitions of private finance actors. The most obvious of those
is the Coalition for the Energy Efficiency of Buildings. The work
of the City Corporation in such areas, and in bringing forward
and helping to promote and organise a bespoke platform, the Green
horizons summit at COP26, shows the innovation of the financial
services sector and the City as its great champion.
It was a pleasure to welcome the current Lord Mayor and the
Remembrancer of the City to this place only last week at the
inaugural reception of the all-party parliamentary group for
London as a global city. That co-operation is as important as the
way the City has sought to champion the bringing together of
professional expertise. The Minister will know, and I hope will
never cease to value, the work of organisations such as the
Financial Markets Law Committee. It probably has more legal and
financial expertise brought together in one room than we will
find anywhere else in any developed economy and perhaps anywhere
on the globe. Its reports are of the highest quality. It is
chaired, as we know, by a former Lord Chief Justice and has a
range of high-ranking professionals. I hope that the Government
will continue to listen carefully to their suggestions on how to
keep regulation proportionate and deal with a system that gives
us good access to markets across the globe, while at the same
time dealing with the necessary prudential measures from the
point of view of the UK economy.
On that note, I hope we can recognise the financial services, and
their allied and supporting professions, as the jewel in the
crown of the British economy and emphasise that repeatedly
whenever we get the chance to promote the UK abroad. We should
also promote them to our own constituents and fellow citizens
because they do not always get the credit that they should.
14:46:00
(Gordon) (SNP)
It is a pleasure to follow the hon. Member for Bromley and
Chislehurst ( ), who speaks with great
knowledge on these matters at all times.
Like the hon. Member for Hitchin and Harpenden (), I started my working life in
financial services. I started out working in the small but
perfectly formed share registrars department of the Bank of
Scotland, which was taken over by Lloyds TSB. I swiftly moved
over to work for Scottish Widows, which, a few months later, was
also taken over by Lloyds TSB. I decided that, since Lloyds TSB
was clearly so keen to have me on its payroll, it would be
churlish not to spend at least the next few years working for
them, so that is what I did.
I started out in what was called the quality assurance
department. We talk about the diversity of jobs in financial
services. In plain English, it would have been better described
as the complaints department because, if you wrote a letter or
phoned up demanding to speak to the chief executive because your
pension fund was not performing quite as well as you anticipated,
you spoke to me, or somebody like me, in that department. I am
not entirely certain whether it was good training or not for
being a Member of Parliament and a councillor, but I have never
felt the worse for the experience.
Each day, my colleagues and I went in to provide products and
services for a wide range of people, at all different ages and
stages of life, as they tried their best to prepare, hedge and
insure for various happy, not so happy and inevitable events that
we all encounter in our lives. We were not alone in that in
Edinburgh because Scottish Widows was one of many life insurance
and pensions firms in the city, a legacy of the more than 300
years of Scotland being recognised as one of the leading, most
innovative financial centres in Europe.
That industry could not, and would not, exist if it was not for
the high quality of life that people can enjoy outside work, for
the quality of the public services that underpin that quality of
life, and, as the hon. Member for Bromley and Chislehurst said,
for the significance and importance of our professional services
that underpin the sector. It could not survive if it was not for
the support of Government and the quality, experience and
adaptability of the workforce. We should not be in the least bit
shy about saying that; we are exceptionally good at this and we
should advertise that and remind ourselves of it regularly.
Scotland is the second largest financial services cluster in the
UK outside London. Financial services are also one of the largest
sectoral contributors to the Scottish economy at 9.4% of gross
value added, which is equivalent to £13 billion. It employs more
than 160,000 people directly in financial services and the
related professional services; that is nearly 6% of Scottish
national employment. Financial services also represent a
disproportionately high share—25%—of UK employment in the life
assurance sector and 13% of all banking employment. Together with
the professional services sector, that accounts for 40% of
Scotland’s services exports. The industry has disproportionate
scale and scope.
Another emerging area is FinTech, in which Scotland is also
emerging as a leader second only in scale and scope to
London—again, we are the second largest outside London. The
Financial Services Advisory Board, chaired by Scotland’s First
Minister, established the need for an independent organisation to
try to maximise the FinTech potential in Scotland. It provided
£250,000 to try to leverage additional business contributions and
academic contributions to achieve the goal of having Scotland in
the world’s top 10 recognised international FinTech clusters.
FinTech is a tremendously exciting development. It is certainly a
disrupter, but it is also an enabler. This is part of a landscape
on which we have trodden with confidence for centuries. We have
centuries of experience and a reputation in this fast-moving
environment for probity, trustworthiness, quality and excellent
performance, but it is all founded on people and their
skills.
In that regard, Scottish Financial Enterprise’s five-year
strategy, launched earlier this year, takes on a particular
importance. It has four key objectives, including leading us on a
journey to net zero, inspiring global leadership in green finance
and supporting the transition to net zero. It sees a role in
supporting our financial recovery post pandemic. It is about
responding to changing customer needs, delivering innovative and,
above all, inclusive products that meet the evolving needs of all
customers. And to go back to the point made well by the hon.
Member for Hitchin and Harpenden, it is also about delivering
skills and inclusion, enabling financial services firms to
recruit, develop and retain that pipeline of talent and
high-performing, diverse skills that we need to continue with a
successful industry.
These are challenging times on a number of fronts for the
financial services sector, whether on an economic level, a
political level or simply a regulatory front. I am reminded,
however, of the history of the organisation that I went to work
for, Scottish Widows, which was founded out of the tumult of the
Napoleonic wars. Although I am sure that we would all very much
prefer never to go back to that sort of degree of conflict and
tumult, nevertheless, financial services have shown themselves to
be remarkably adaptable and able to rise to the challenges that
they face, whether that means meeting their customers’ needs and
expectations or dealing with the world around them.
We may have a head start in financial services, but there is
nothing to guarantee that, unless we continue to invest,
innovate, and above all, talk up the provenance and importance of
this vital industry.
14:52:00
(Hampstead and Kilburn)
(Lab)
I am very grateful to the hon. Member for South Cambridgeshire
(), the hon. and learned
Member for Edinburgh South West (), who is not in her place,
and my hon. Friend the Member for Wallasey (Dame ) for securing this very
important debate. Not for the first time, I agree with the hon.
Member for Bromley and Chislehurst ( ) that this has been a very
valuable debate, and I hope that it gets the exposure that he
mentioned.
Labour wholeheartedly agrees that our financial services are
central to the British economy. Our financial services sector is
a major driver of our country’s growth. It contributed an
incredible £132 billion to the economy in 2019. Financial
services are also the UK’s most successful export and have been
for decades, worth £60 billion in 2019 alone.
The contribution of the sector will be vital to the UK’s future
prosperity. As the OECD recently warned, the UK’s economic
recovery is at risk. Earlier this week, the CBI downgraded growth
forecasts to 5% as we are surrounded by inflation and supply
shortages, with the CBI director general warning that businesses
will face
“a cliff edge in 2023.”
Supporting the financial sector to thrive will be fundamental to
our economic growth after covid-19 and to delivering the higher
growth, jobs and tax receipts that we need to fund public
services. That is why we want the Government to do more to
support the sector to retain its competitiveness on the world
stage. My hon. Friend the Member for Wallasey spoke about how
regulatory stability is the foundation for success and innovation
in the financial sector. I agree wholeheartedly with that point,
which has been made a few times by Members across the
Chamber.
We know that the most serious issue threatening stability for
financial services today is the post-Brexit regulatory
environment. In government, Labour would focus on making Brexit
work for the City as well as for the country. I think everyone in
this Chamber will be pleased to hear that Labour does not want a
rematch—we not do want to reopen negotiations, before any
headlines start to fly—but being outside the EU does not change
the fact that for many firms in finance it remains an important
market. In 2019, an enormous 40% of UK financial exports went to
the EU.
We have heard a lot about getting Brexit done, but what we want
from the Government now is a proper plan for the aftermath.
Regulatory equivalence for the finance sector should have been a
priority in talks with the EU, but the Government have failed to
achieve that. We feel that the sector is in a state of
uncertainty now.
In my role, which I took on recently, I listen to the concerns of
our world-class financial and professional service businesses.
That is why Labour would seek regulatory equivalence with the EU
for financial services and an agreement with the EU on mutual
recognition of professional qualifications and conformity
assessments across the entire sector. A Labour Government will
build on the deal in the national interest through the mutual
recognition of professional qualifications for our service
sectors. We cannot risk our financial firms losing their
competitive edge in the European market.
Labour would protect the UK’s status as one of the most important
global financial centres as we shape a new future outside the EU.
To achieve that, as Members across the Chamber have recognised,
the sector must be ready for the challenges of the future. That
will require the Government to provide the space and regulatory
landscape for financial services to innovate. That is why Labour
wholeheartedly welcomes developments in FinTech, which many hon.
Members have mentioned and which will allow companies to
experiment with new finance models and create high-skilled jobs
for the future across the UK. Deloitte estimates that, with the
right support, FinTech could add £3 billion to the economy and
create more than 50,000 new high-skilled jobs.
The 21st century requires the Government to play an active role
in ensuring that the UK can take advantage of new technologies.
Labour would award far more public contracts to British
businesses, such as a young entrepreneur who has established a
FinTech start-up in Newcastle, as opposed to handing them to
overseas firms.
I agree with the hon. Member for South Cambridgeshire that the
biggest challenge facing the UK is the climate crisis and the
transition to a green economy. I also agree with him that the
Treasury Committee needs proper support, because it is the most
important Committee in the House. Labour has committed to £28
billion a year of capital investment every year until 2030 to
support the green transition.
We believe that the financial sector has a vital role to play in
attracting green investment. Many innovative companies are
already recognising their wider responsibilities. For example,
Lloyds, which has been mentioned, is providing discounted
financial support for investment in dairy farms to reduce their
use of energy. This is a welcome step, but the transformation of
our economy will require radical action from the Government. We
want to see more ambition in the Government’s announcements on
green bonds. Labour would seek to make the UK the green finance
capital of the world. That is why we have called on financial
institutions and FTSE 100 companies to produce credible climate
transition plans by 2023.
The financial sector should serve the people of this country
wherever they happen to live—a point that has been echoed by
Members across the Chamber. My hon. Friend the Member for
Wallasey and the hon. Member for Wimbledon () both spoke about the
importance of recognising the contribution that UK financial
services already make beyond the City of London. The sector in
Leeds, Birmingham, Edinburgh and everywhere else provides a
significant contribution to our national economy.
However, in the past 10 years, regional inequalities have
widened. Growth in the financial sector has not been felt equally
across the country. In 2019, the financial services sector
contributed more than half a million jobs in London and the
south-east. That should be celebrated, but there were only 43,000
jobs in the sector in the east midlands and 24,000 in the
north-east.
We have heard a great deal about levelling up in recent months,
and I think that we can agree with much that has been said about
it today. The hon. Member for Wimbledon talked about the UK being
a centre of financial services. He also talked about a powerhouse
of financial services, and that is what we want to see in this
country. The hon. Member for Hitchin and Harpenden (), who has left the Chamber,
talked about levelling up people, and Labour shares that
ambition.
Our recovery is fragile following the shocks of the pandemic, and
our economy is much in need of a boost after a decade of low
growth. The financial sector will be critical in delivering the
prosperity that we need. I therefore welcome this important
debate about the need for the Government to support financial
services to enable them to retain their competitiveness on the
world stage. I agreed with the hon. Member for Wimbledon when he
said that it should not be just him and me standing up and
speaking about this important topic; Members throughout the House
should be standing up and speaking about it.
Let me end by asking the Minister a couple of questions. Does he
accept that his Government should find an agreement on regulatory
equivalence with the EU for financial services, and does he agree
that UK financial services should be at the heart of all our
future trade negotiations to help build a positive future for
this crucial sector?
15:00:00
The Economic Secretary to the Treasury ()
It is a great pleasure to respond to the debate on behalf of the
Government. It has been an extremely well-informed debate, and I
have enjoyed listening to all the contributions. I particularly
thank my hon. Friend the Member for South Cambridgeshire (), the hon. Member for
Wallasey (Dame ) and the hon. and learned
Member for Edinburgh South West () for sponsoring the debate.
They were absolutely right to point out that the financial
services industry is critically important to the United Kingdom’s
economy, and to champion the UK as an environment that ensures
that the sector is able to retain its competitiveness on the
world stage.
I discerned five themes as I listened to the debate: the response
to the pandemic, the issue of levelling up, green finance, the
context for our international relationships, and regulation,
about which there have been a range of comments across the
wholesale and retail sector.
I have been the Economic Secretary for nearly four years, and in
that time I have come to recognise the vast economic contribution
that the financial services industry makes to this country—we
have heard a great deal about that today—but I have also observed
the many hidden contributions that it has made, which have been
particularly clear during the pandemic. On the frontline, bank
staff have kept branches open and supported vulnerable customers
at times that have been very worrying for them financially. In
the back offices, people have rolled up their shirt sleeves and
worked all hours with us and the regulators to deliver tens of
billions of pounds of emergency loans. I have already thanked the
industry publicly for what it has been doing, and I am delighted
to do so again today at the Dispatch Box.
My hon. Friend the Member for Hitchin and Harpenden () mentioned the £100 million of
loans and other support in his constituency, and that has been
replicated across the country. The bounce back loans, the
coronavirus business interruption loan scheme and the forbearance
measures were critical at what was a critical time for our
country.
I recognise and acknowledge the sentiments about the financial
services industry not always getting a good press. This is not
just about banks, although they are critically important for the
underpinning of lending to our economy. However, I think we
should also recognise, as the Scottish National party speakers
did, that the industry is not just about the square mile but
about the whole United Kingdom. I visited the constituency of the
hon. Member for Rutherglen and Hamilton West () a few weeks ago to see
the bank hub that is active there and informing the industry’s
response to the challenge of access to cash.
In places such as Birmingham, Bristol, Glasgow, Cambridge,
Edinburgh and Merseyside, this industry is critical. There is not
an equitable distribution across every region, but there are hubs
of real significance. Two thirds of people employed in the
industry work outside London: 37,000 in Northern Ireland, 69,000
in Wales, and 153,000 in Scotland. I am proud that the Government
have used that imperative to headquarter our new national
infrastructure bank in Leeds and to establish our new economic
campus in Darlington.
The sector has also made significant progress on diversity and
inclusion, so that the very best people for the job have an equal
opportunity to succeed, no matter what their race, gender or
background might be. There is a lot more work to be done in that
area, and I commend the incoming Lord Mayor of London for his
championing of that agenda during his tenure.
I want to address some of the points raised by Members during the
debate. I thank my hon. Friend the Member for Wimbledon () for his kind words, his
focus on the importance of the regional agenda, and his challenge
to ensure that we have opportunities across the regions. The
opportunity to secure high-paid, high-value jobs beyond Wimbledon
and across the United Kingdom is a real imperative. I draw his
attention to the Kalifa review into FinTech that was published at
the beginning of March, and to the money secured and announced in
the Budget for the centre for financial innovation and
technology, which will be a key driver of that.
My hon. Friend the Member for Hitchin and Harpenden () mentioned levelling up and
also raised some specific concerns about debt advice. I draw his
attention to the work we have done with the breathing space
scheme, which went live in May. I recognise the uncertainty
around the maps and the reprofiling of face-to-face and online
debt advice. I am taking a close interest in that. We are also
trying to innovate when it comes to no-interest loan schemes,
which are at the proof of concept phase and could make a massive
contribution to assisting many vulnerable people.
My hon. Friend the Member for Bromley and Chislehurst ( ) put a stark statistic before
us when he said that more than 36% of his constituents worked in
financial services and the broader legal and professional
services sector. It is a critical sector for our economy. The
financial services sector also has a crucial role to play in our
response to climate change. The ambition is clear: we want the UK
to be the best place in the world for green and sustainable
investment. As a Government we have taken bold action in this
area to transform the UK financial sector. That has involved
introducing new economy-wide sustainability disclosure
requirements for businesses, and the kick-starting of a green
financing programme with two record-breaking sovereign green
bonds: one for around £10 billion on 21 September and a further
£6 billion on 21 October, achieving a “greenium”—a premium on
what we would have gained from a non-green bond—of around 2.5
base points. We will not be complacent about this. We also need
global action on green finance, and the Chancellor recently
hosted the COP26 finance day, which saw financial firms with
assets of over £130 trillion committing to net zero.
My hon. Friend the Member for Bromley and Chislehurst also drew
attention to the role of the City of London Corporation in green
finance, and I absolutely endorse his recognition of its
contribution and in particular that of Catherine McGuinness, who
has been the policy lead through most of my tenure. She has done
an excellent job, and her tenure comes to an end next spring. As
I have said, the Lord Mayor is also committed to taking on his
predecessor’s leadership in that area.
Looking ahead, it is important that we do not rest on our
laurels, as the motion recognises. There are obviously strong
competitive pressures in the industry, and it is my mission to
help to deliver the Chancellor’s vision for an open, green and
technologically advanced financial services sector that is
globally competitive and acts in the interests of communities and
citizens across the UK. In his speech on 1 July, the Chancellor
said that we should be proud that people around the world looked
to this country for leadership, and we should be. We have an
opportunity and a responsibility to lead the world on
international standards, FinTech, green finance and much
more.
When I took on this role in January 2018, the nature of the
international relationship that the UK would have in financial
services was uncertain. We have now left the EU institutional
framework and, where it makes sense to do so, we are taking
advantage of our new freedoms to refresh the UK’s position as the
world’s pre-eminent financial centre. We are not deregulating,
but we are looking at those international relationships. We have
set out a clear, ambitious programme of work to broaden and
deepen those relationships. We have signed trade agreements with
Japan, Singapore, the European economic area and the European
Free Trade Association, and reached agreements in principle on
free trade agreements with Australia and New Zealand.
I recognise that in many of these free trade agreements,
financial services will not be as prominent because the
regulator-to-regulator dialogues that exist on an ongoing basis
are so instrumental in unblocking opportunities on both sides in
financial services. The Swiss mutual recognition agreement, which
we are negotiating at the moment, will be the most ambitious
financial services agreement globally in both breadth and
depth.
I recognise the uncertainty of the EU relationship. We have
co-operated fully, and it will be for the EU to determine what
sort of dynamic it wishes to have. I was pleased to visit my
counterparts in Madrid last week, and I met several bank leaders
over there. The warmth that exists towards the UK in financial
services is clear, and I have recently had conversations with
other bilateral partners.
We need a regulatory framework that is more agile, that avoids
politicisation and that gives decision making to the independent
and expert regulators. I take the point raised by my hon. Friend
the Member for Wimbledon on the need to ensure proper scrutiny of
that autonomy. I recognise and appreciate the support for the
secondary growth and competitiveness objective that we set out in
the consultation, and it is now critical that we clarify in
legislation how the responsibility of scrutinising those
independent regulators will work. It will be for Parliament to
determine how to examine the way in which those regulators meet
the objectives we will set out in primary regulation.
Members mentioned a number of initiatives concerning the
wholesale markets review. I see broad consensus on the vast
majority of issues identified in the consultation document. We
are talking about incremental changes informed by deep dialogue
with industry.
On the prospectus regime review, I am delighted to say there was
extensive support for the proposals in our recent consultation,
and I look forward to pushing ahead with our reforms. We are
taking forward the recommendations of the Kalifa review on
FinTech. We must remain at the cutting edge of technology and
innovation in financial services. I recognise that its
application both to the regulators and to the financial market’s
infrastructure will be significant.
We have responded to the call for evidence on insurance and
Solvency II, and we are now working closely with the PRA to
identify an optimal reform package across both the risk margin
and the matching adjustment. This is complex work, but we are
taking it forward with enthusiasm.
It seems to me that the House is largely in agreement on two
things. The contribution of the financial services sector to the
country is critical, but we cannot take it for granted, and I
will never do so in my role. I am proud to be delivering on the
Government’s vision for an open, green and technologically
advanced financial services sector that is globally competitive
and acts in the interests of communities and citizens across the
United Kingdom.
I welcome the many varied and well-informed contributions this
afternoon. I agree with the motion, and I encourage others to do
the same. It would be remiss of me not to welcome the hon. Member
for Hampstead and Kilburn () to her place as my shadow,
and I look forward to discussing these matters with her in
future.
15:13:00
Madam Deputy Speaker, you were in the Chair on Monday night when
we had a rather fractious debate on a different subject, and I
think we all agree it is a nice contrast to have a debate on
which there is such wide agreement.
To the hon. Member for Hampstead and Kilburn (), you mentioned a couple of
times that you agree with me on a couple of things, and you
almost sounded surprised. To the hon. Member for Wallasey (Dame
), who also sponsored this
debate, I agreed with almost everything you said.
Madam Deputy Speaker ( )
Order. Please say “she said”, not “you said.”
This has been a well-informed, thoughtful and good-natured
debate, and it was great to hear the hon. Member for Gordon
() talk about the importance
of financial services to Scotland—I also made that point.
Many hon. Members raised points that I did not mention in my
opening remarks. The hon. Member for Wallasey mentioned the
importance of financial crime, which I thought about mentioning,
and she is right that it is a big challenge we need to tackle. My
hon. Friend the Member for Bromley and Chislehurst ( ) spoke about the importance of
legal services and related financial services, which are all part
of a package. My hon. Friend the Member for Hitchin and Harpenden
() talked about the importance
of getting the right skills and talent, which I did not address
but is obviously completely true. And my hon. Friend the Member
for Wimbledon () touched on the importance
of access to EU markets, which is critical and unknown at this
point. It was good to hear the remarks from the Minister in
summing up; it is great to hear that the Government are clearly
very supportive of the financial services sector, committed to
getting international agreements and making incremental changes
that we can all agree on.
I have one last observation to make. My hon. Friend the Member
for Wimbledon talked about the Minister being known as the one of
the best City Ministers ever. I agree with that, but it is a
misnomer calling him a City Minister because, as he said, and as
everyone else has said, financial services are important for the
entire country. So perhaps we need to change the informal name
for that job. This has been an important and thoughtful debate,
and it is nice to be part of a debate where there is a large
consensus on the way forward.
Question put and agreed to.
Resolved,
That this House recognises the importance of financial services
to the UK economy; and calls on the Government to provide
adequate support to help create the right regulatory and
operational environment for that industry to ensure that the UK
is able to retain its competitiveness on the world stage.
|