Gareth Davies (Grantham and Stamford) (Con) I beg to move, That
this House has considered investment industry exposure to modern
slavery. Modern slavery is one of the most prevalent and egregious
violations of human rights in the world today. It is great to see
you in the chair, Mr Robertson, for what is my first ever
Westminster Hall debate. Hopefully my performance will not mean
that it is my last. I welcome the Minister to her new, important
role. I know she...Request free trial
(Grantham and Stamford)
(Con)
I beg to move,
That this House has considered investment industry exposure to
modern slavery.
Modern slavery is one of the most prevalent and egregious
violations of human rights in the world today.
It is great to see you in the chair, Mr Robertson, for what is my
first ever Westminster Hall debate. Hopefully my performance will
not mean that it is my last. I welcome the Minister to her new,
important role. I know she will carry out her brief superbly in
one of the most important jobs in Government—safeguarding our
most vulnerable people.
I think we can all agree that the shameful existence of modern
slavery has no place in a civilised world. It is an issue that
should concern every person who believes in the integrity of
common humanity, and should be a concern for every business,
because it distorts markets and undermines ethical business
practices. As an international community, we have rightly taken
collective responsibility for defending human rights around the
world. Organisations, such as the United Nations working group on
contemporary slavery, have drawn increased attention to the issue
and made significant strides in defining and identifying this
covert and highly complex crime.
That being said, there is a great deal more work to do. Human
exploitation continues to pervade every major nation on earth.
Almost half the countries in the world have yet to criminalise
slavery. In the UK alone, it is estimated that 136,000 people are
currently victims of this awful crime. However, we are here today
to specifically discuss the role that the investment industry can
play in tackling modern slavery because, as it currently stands,
financial services are not considered part of the solution in
public policy. I want to do my little bit to try to change
that.
We must first acknowledge the great work that this Government,
and previous Conservative Governments, have done in tackling this
issue, thanks to the leadership of my right hon. Friend the
Member for Staffordshire Moorlands (), together with, of course,
our late friend and colleague , the Security Minister at
the time, who passed the Modern Slavery Act 2015. The vision for
that legislation was truly world-leading, and the UK became the
first country in the world to require businesses to identify and
address modern slavery risks in their operations and supply
chains. It is an Act that we, in this country, should be
incredibly proud of, for it has highlighted that modern slavery
exists in the private economy. It has also paved the way for
legislation in other countries—in Australia, France and the
Netherlands.
However, while we reflect on what the 2015 Act has achieved, we
must also acknowledge the need for evolution. All legislation
requires continual review to keep pace with developing risks, and
the Government have therefore, rightly, announced that they plan
to strengthen the Act in response to consultation in 2019.
(Strangford) (DUP)
I congratulate the hon. Gentleman on bringing this forward. I
spoke to him outside, so he knows what my thoughts are. Does he
not agree that it is important that for girls in particular, we
need to understand that investment portfolios should show
mindfulness on human slavery? It is not enough to say that if we
do not use modern slavery in our businesses, our hands are clean.
Would the hon. Member agree that we must be cognisant of how
investment portfolios gain interest? This can only be done, as
the hon. Gentleman says, through legislation and legislative
change.
I am grateful to the hon. Gentleman for his intervention, which
is a great honour. That is another first for me, so I feel like I
am really making it now. I completely agree that young girls and
young people—all people, actually—who have investments, savings
or a retirement pot, need to know and have confidence that those
who invest that money on their behalf are doing so prudently and
are putting in place the checks to ensure that there is no
inadvertent risk of modern slavery. The Government should do
everything they can, as I will come on to in a minute.
The Government’s commitment to amend section 54(5) is intended to
make it more prescriptive for investment funds. I completely
agree with that, but even with those changes, that section would
remain entirely focused on internal business structures and
supply chains, not where their investments are made. The good
news is that an increasing number of responsible companies are
holding themselves to a higher standard. Many investors are
already assessing modern slavery risks as part of their robust
environmental, social and governance strategies or choosing to
report their alignment with the United Nations’ guiding
principles on business and human rights.
Yesterday, I met a group of investors, and this year alone, I
have met 24 separate financial services companies in preparation
for today’s debate. I found that they already have robust
measures in place to tackle modern slavery. On the whole,
however, the sector has not integrated modern slavery risks into
investment processes to the same extent that it has adopted
environmental risks. Some 795 financial organisations published
modern slavery statements under the Act last year, but of 79
asset managers who submitted a statement, only 27% disclosed that
they had conducted due diligence on modern slavery risks.
That is clearly a problem, but I believe that there are three
solutions. First, the Government could broaden section 54 of the
Act and consult on including a requirement that investment
portfolios are included, as they are in Australia. Secondly, the
Government could issue specific statutory guidance on how
investors can assess modern slavery risks—again, as they do in
Australia—so they are equipped with knowledge on that assessment.
Thirdly, as it is a global problem that needs a global solution,
we should work with our global allies to establish a taskforce,
modelled on the taskforce on climate-related disclosures.
Although the issue is different, the approach can be the
same.
As it stands, financial services firms are a £9 trillion lever
that we are not yet pulling in our fight against modern slavery.
The UK is the largest net exporter of financial services in the
world and the law change that I have proposed could make a
difference in eradicating that horrendous crime. It would also
protect and promote our democratic values at home and abroad.
British savers and investors should never be used to support
profit from human slavery. It matters for global Britain, as our
leadership in this space will create prosperity at home and help
to promote our values abroad. The situation that we walk past is
the situation that we accept. It is an issue hidden in plain
sight. We need to pull every lever we can to end it once and for
all.
16:09:00
(Totnes) (Con)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Robertson.
I congratulate my hon. Friend the Member for Grantham and
Stamford () on securing the debate. He
and I have been discussing the issue for some time and he has led
admirably on assessing the requirements that are needed to
address it, bringing his background and experience in the private
sector to this place. What a speech that was.
I also thank the Human Trafficking Foundation, with which I
believe my right hon. Friend the Member for Staffordshire
Moorlands () also has a relationship,
whose work has been extraordinary in highlighting and identifying
the issue around modern slavery and human trafficking. My
predecessor played a large role in that
and continues to perform those duties in a meaningful and
effective manner.
I am conscious that there is a limited amount of time, and I do
not want to interrupt those Members who will follow me or the
Minister’s response, but I want to make a few points about what
we understand from the Modern Slavery Act 2015. It was a landmark
piece of legislation. All too often in this place we say that a
Bill is a landmark piece of legislation—this really was. It was
unique in the world, and it has been followed by legislation in
Australia, France and the Netherlands, as has already been said.
In that Act we committed to bring perpetrators to justice, we
ensured that businesses were brought in line with transparency
reports, we enhanced protections for victims, we ensured that
there were supply chain statements and we appointed the
Independent Anti-Slavery Commissioner. Those were all integral
and important points, but we also have to assess their
effectiveness in delivering, and make sure that businesses are
following suit and not just going through the rigamarole of
ticking boxes to say that they have complied with the requirement
to publish statements. The Act has to have teeth. This is where
the opportunity comes. The UK shows global leadership and has
global power in being able to set up initiatives like this.
I will go briefly off topic and talk about the illegal wildlife
trade. In 2013-14 the UK launched a transportation taskforce in
which we brought together private, public and charitable
organisations to disrupt the illegal wildlife trade network. We
then began to bring in financial networks to look at data
analysis and see where we could disrupt those chains across the
world. This is what we should be doing in this area. There is
huge potential for doing it, and there are similar models that we
can replicate in this country.
My last point is what was raised in the Independent Anti-Slavery
Commissioner’s report at the end of this year. It said there were
two points we needed to look at. The first one relates to data
analysis. It is a huge benefit to be able to bring in financial
institutions; to be able to pinpoint and identify beyond the
supply chains and businesses’ internal structures; to look at
where money is being transferred; to look at where money is being
invested and to take account of that; and to make sure that we
can be reassured about where our investments are being put.
Secondly, slavery is generating somewhere in the region of $150
billion a year. The report goes on to encourage the exploration
of opportunities to partner with financial institutions.
We set up the Independent Anti-Slavery Commissioner to make sure
that we listen to these recommendations. These recommendations
have come out in the report; we would do very well to listen to
them. As my hon. Friend the Member for Grantham and Stamford has
said, it is the situation that one walks past and cannot ignore.
We cannot, in this day and age, look at the crisis and the
egregious crime that is human trafficking. We cannot accept it in
the 21st century. We have the opportunity to bring those
financial institutions together—with the City of London and the
power we have as the fifth biggest economy in the world—and it is
time for us to take the action, take the lead and provide that
leadership. I hope the Minister will listen to these words, and
the words of my hon. Friend the Member for Grantham and Stamford,
and take the appropriate action.
16:13:00
(Staffordshire Moorlands)
(Con)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Robertson.
If I can refer to my entry in the register of interests, the
Human Trafficking Foundation appears as I am a trustee. I welcome
the Minister; this is the first time that I have participated in
a debate that she is responding to in her new role. I can assure
her, as someone who fulfilled that role for over two years, that
it is a fantastic place to be; the change you can make to
people’s lives as a Minister in the Home Office with
responsibility for this area is absolutely breath taking. It is a
difficult job, it is a tough job, but it is also one of the most
rewarding jobs in Government. I welcome her to the role and know
she will do a fantastic job. I also congratulate my hon. Friend
the Member for Grantham and Stamford () on securing this debate and
delivering what I know will not be the last contribution he makes
to a Westminster Hall debate. It was an excellent contribution,
and it set out so succinctly and well the point that he is
campaigning hard on. I am also grateful for his willingness to
accept contributions from other Members in this very short,
half-hour debate.
My hon. Friend raised, very well, the risks and the opportunities
there are for investment businesses in ensuring they are making
the ethical investments their customers and consumers want.
People want to know that their money is being invested in a way
that is not funding crime—be that drug crime, gang-related crime
or, in particular, the economic crime against people that is
human trafficking and modern slavery. Let us be clear: this is an
economic crime. It is so often confused with crimes of
immigration, but it is not an immigration crime. It is an
economic crime: one human being is prepared to make financial
gain from another human being. We must all work to stamp that
out.
The numbers are shocking. The latest estimate is that around 40
million people globally are victims of modern slavery, of which
25 million are victims of forced labour and 15 million are
involved in forced marriage or other forms of exploitation. Some
25 million people globally are victims of forced labour. We must
remember that number and work hard to do what we can.
My hon. Friend the Member for Grantham and Stamford is right. My
hon. Friend the Member for Totnes () made the point as well.
My hon. Friend the Member for Totnes has big shoes to fill in
taking over from the wonderful , who is an absolute hero;
without him, we simply would not be where we are today with the
Modern Slavery Act 2015.
When I took the Modern Slavery Bill through Parliament, the hon.
Member for Strangford () was very involved on Report, and tabled amendments
constantly, including on supply chains. Section 54 was not in the
Bill when we started. The Bill had gone through prelegislative
scrutiny by a Committee chaired by , now of the other place. I am
going to call him by name. I know that we would normally refer to
him as the noble Lord Field, but everyone will have seen the news
that he made public last week, and our thoughts go to him. He is
another of the founding fathers of the Act. Without Frank, and
without the noble , , the noble and many others, we simply
would not have achieved it. That prelegislative scrutiny
Committee wanted to see transparency measures for supply chains,
but Government do not always listen to everything that
prelegislative scrutiny Committees or others suggest. A lot of
work was needed to persuade Government of what those of us in the
Home Office could see was a very good idea, but about which
others in Government had not been so convinced.
Section 54 was undoubtedly revolutionary, but that does not mean
that it is not evolutionary. It does need to evolve. Now, six
years along, there are undoubtedly things that can be improved,
and I welcome what the Home Office has said about changes that
must be made. It does need to be strengthened. It must be
expanded to more businesses. The points that my hon. Friend the
Member for Grantham and Stamford made about what we could do on
investments are really interesting, and I urge the Minister to
take those points to her colleagues in Government at the earliest
opportunity so that they can remove their reasons for opposing
them as quickly as possible. This is something that customers
want. Consumers want to know that their money is properly
invested.
I will make two very quick points before I sit down. The first is
that I have tabled a private Member’s Bill that replicates
section 54 on climate change. My hon. Friend the Member for
Grantham and Stamford said that this was something that people
wanted to see. I would like to see that transparency in supply
chains on climate change as well, and I hope that hon. Members
will support the Bill. Second, I join my hon. Friend in pleading
that we ask the United Nations to make human trafficking and
modern slavery a focus of the next General Assembly in September
2022. If we could work together to do that and to get global
recognition of this issue, we would go a long way to tackling
this heinous crime.
16:18:00
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for the Home
Department ()
It is a huge pleasure to be here serving under your chairmanship,
Mr Robertson. I very much thank my hon. Friend the Member for
Grantham and Stamford () for securing this vital
debate and for bringing with him a wealth of experience from his
distinguished career in the investment industry, which informs us
all and helps us all to move further.
I also thank my predecessor, my right hon. Friend the Member for
Staffordshire Moorlands (). I really do feel that I
have very big footsteps to follow in. I thank her for all her
work in bringing the world-leading and groundbreaking Modern
Slavery Act 2015 on to the statue book. Without her work, I
certainly would not be here today talking about this subject, and
it is absolutely right that we are. Thanks to her work, and that
of others, last week we were able to mark Anti-Slavery Day and
reflect on the trauma that victims suffer, the cruelty of those
who exploit them and the bravery of survivors attempting to
rebuild their lives. That was also a moment to reaffirm our
commitment to confronting the evils of modern slavery, wherever
and whenever they occur. They are utterly appalling crimes that
have no place in our society. I very much welcome the interest
shown by my friends today, including the hon. Member for
Strangford (), so that we can stamp out these crimes.
It is nice to pause and reflect on what we have already done as a
Government. We have taken some very important strides forward in
recent years, but of course there is more to do. These crimes
continue to evolve and we must continue to evolve. As my friends
have said, modern slavery is a global problem. We continue to
provide global leadership to tackle it. During our G7 presidency,
G7 members agreed to joint action on forced labour in global
supply chains, and reaffirmed their commitment to upholding human
rights and international labour standards. That is why we
continue to invest heavily in tackling modern slavery. We have
funded a new five-year modern slavery victim care contract to
support victims to rebuild their lives. That new contract is
worth £379 million over five years and will deliver a much-needed
service that is based on need and better aligned to the
requirements of individual victims. As we know, victims present
with incredibly complex needs, and it is right that we have the
support tailored for them.
The Home Office has invested a further £1.4 million this year to
support the police’s response to modern slavery, bringing the
total investment in policing to £15 million since 2016. That
funding in the round has helped us to pursue perpetrators and
drive an increase in modern slavery investigations and
operations. Following our recognition that the nature of modern
slavery has evolved over the years, the Home Secretary announced
a review of the 2014 modern slavery strategy, which builds on the
considerable progress, by adapting our approach and maintaining
our position as an international leader in this area.
We will publish a new strategy next spring, which will set the
strategic direction for years to come. Through the Modern Slavery
Act 2015, the UK became the first country in the world to require
businesses to report on the action they were taking to address
modern slavery risk in their operations and supply chains. That
legislation acts as a call to action for businesses, investors
and the international human rights community—no doubt the
businesses that my hon. Friends were involved in before they
brought their expertise to this place.
Following the recommendations of the independent review of the
Modern Slavery Act and a consultation, the Government committed
to introduce an ambitious package of measures to strengthen our
world-leading legislation on transparency in supply chains. We
will extend the reporting requirements to public bodies, to
leverage public procurement and address risks in public supply
chains.
We will mandate specific reporting topics that statements must
cover, set a single deadline for reporting, require organisations
to publish their statements to a new Government registry for
modern slavery statements, and introduce financial penalties for
organisations that fail to meet their reporting obligations.
Those changes require legislation, but I want to reassure
colleagues that this Government remain committed to legislating
on modern slavery and will implement the measures as soon as
parliamentary time allows.
In addition to the changes we have already committed to make, we
will consider our future approach to transparency in supply
chains, as part of our modern slavery strategy review, including
how we can best utilise the unique power—and pockets—of the
financial sector, to tackle modern slavery.
Let me now turn to some of the specific points referenced in the
debate. Individual organisations must focus on preventing harm in
their practices. We do not believe that physical remoteness or
being several steps away from the supply chain is an excuse.
Investors do need to hold their organisations to account, as my
hon. Friends so eloquently set out. People who are saving for
their pensions or retirement should not be exposed to criminal
activity.
I am grateful for all the work done by my hon. Friends the Member
for Grantham and Stamford and for Totnes (). Through their convening
power, they have brought together financial institutions and
organisations. I am also grateful for the work of the Independent
Anti-slavery Commissioner, highlighting the role that the
financial services sector has to play. It is clear that there is
more to do, but investors can help to drive this change by fully
harnessing their leverage. I highlighted that message this week
at a meeting jointly hosted by the Home Office and CCLA, a fund
manager, to discuss how Government, businesses and investors can
work in partnership to tackle modern slavery. There are some
really good examples of investor-led initiatives, with investors
taking collective action, such as the CCLA-led Find It, Fix It,
Prevent It and Rathbone’s Votes Against Slavery project.
However, we know that there is more to do here. While I am
encouraged by the positive initiatives already under way, we need
to make sure that we continue on the right track and that
investors scrutinise their investment portfolios to engage and
challenge companies on their response to modern slavery.
As hon. Members have said, when it comes to those environmental,
social and governance issues, we know that businesses and
investors have responded well to the environmental challenges
they face. As we look to accelerate progress on tackling modern
slavery, the Home Office is working with investors to understand
what more we can do to encourage and incentivise businesses and
investors to place the same emphasis on social issues. This issue
is now, rightly, rising up the agenda.
I thank the Minister for her excellent response. Minister, last
week in the press over a hundred MPs had signed a petition and a
letter of concern about investment in Chinese companies, some of
which are using Uyghur Muslims as slave labour. Is the hon. Lady
able to give us any guidance on how we can take that further to
try to make that stop?
I thank the hon. Gentleman for that. It is an egregious example
of abuse of human rights; just because it is happening overseas
does not mean that we should turn a blind eye to it. We in the
Home Office are looking closely at all of these issues as part of
our review of the modern slavery strategy. I would be very happy
to continue in discussion with the hon. Gentleman to provide
further reassurances on what can be done. However, I want to make
very clear from this Dispatch Box that companies have a
responsibility to their consumers and shareholders to do the
right thing and not enable slavery in the pursuit of profit.
As we look to accelerate progress on tackling modern slavery, it
does seem very challenging. However, we do know that the business
and investor community has taken huge strides, and it has
succeeded in making better, more informed green choices. We
should hold and demand those same expectations for modern
slavery. We should not walk by. We should not ignore the crimes
that are hiding in plain sight.
My hon. Friend the Member for Grantham and Stamford called for
the legislation to be extended to financial services so that they
address modern slavery in their investment portfolios. I have
taken close note of that. Legislation is important, but it is not
the only factor driving responsible behaviour. Many organisations
already report voluntarily under the Modern Slavery Act and
publish modern slavery statements. I would strongly encourage any
responsible organisation to do the same, and I would encourage
shareholders and consumers to ask those questions about where
they are putting their money and their investment.
I have noted very carefully the points that my right hon. Friend
the Member for Staffordshire Moorlands and my hon. Friend the
Member for Totnes made. I reassure them that we will consider
extending the scope of section 54 as part of our strategy
review.
In closing, let me once again express my thanks to my hon. Friend
the Member for Grantham and Stamford for securing this debate on
such an important subject. It is a real tribute to him to have
brought forward a debate on a topic that is sometimes hidden, but
should not be. I thank him for shining a light on all the work
that the Government, many NGOs, my right hon. Friend the Member
for Staffordshire Moorlands, the Anti-Slavery Commissioner and
many others are doing. Modern slavery is utterly abhorrent, and I
can assure hon. Members that this Government remain steadfast in
our determination to root out such crimes, protect the vulnerable
and support victims.
Question put and agreed to.
|