Geraint Davies (Swansea West) (Lab/Co-op) I beg to move, That this
House has considered transport funding for Wales and HS2. Bore da.
Good morning. It is a pleasure to serve under your chairpersonship,
Sir Edward. I am here to talk about HS2 and particularly funding
for the railways in Wales. We are all aware that tomorrow the
Chancellor has his Budget, that next week is COP26 and that the
Government have been talking about connecting the Union, levelling
up and net...Request free trial
(Swansea West)
(Lab/Co-op)
I beg to move,
That this House has considered transport funding for Wales and
HS2.
Bore da. Good morning. It is a pleasure to serve under your
chairpersonship, Sir Edward. I am here to talk about HS2 and
particularly funding for the railways in Wales. We are all aware
that tomorrow the Chancellor has his Budget, that next week is
COP26 and that the Government have been talking about connecting
the Union, levelling up and net zero. When we think about all
those together, there is a compelling case that the Chancellor
should look to give Wales our fair Barnett consequential, akin to
the Scottish one, so that we can tool up, gear up, connect up and
help move the UK towards net zero with more rail investment.
The Welsh Affairs Committee, on which some of us here serve,
recently recommended that Wales should receive the same Barnett
consequential share as Scotland. Simply put, Scotland gets 91.7%,
as a proportion of population, of its share of the total costs of
HS2. If Wales got 91.7% of our 5% share of HS2, and if for
argument’s sake HS2 cost £100 billion, Wales would get something
in the region of £4.6 billion. If HS2 ended up costing twice
that, we would get something in the region of £9.2 billion. I am
sure that we will hear about this from the Minister soon, but we
have heard that the projected costs have moved from £38 billion
to £100 billion, and now there is talk of costs of £160 billion
to £200 billion.
HS2 is obviously a UK scheme. However, it is a north-south spinal
scheme, so it will clearly benefit Scotland more than Wales. One
could argue that Wales should receive a higher proportionate
share than Scotland, but that is not what I am arguing; I am
simply arguing that we get our fair share.
I know that the Minister is a great expert in HS2. Phase 1 was
originally due to be completed in 2027. That has been kicked
forward to 2033, and the latest news from the hon. Member for
North West Leicestershire () is that we are looking at
something like 2041. Given the timescale for action that is
projected by COP26, we really must get a move on. There is a very
strong case that Wales should have its share of the money to get
on with shovel-ready schemes in both north and south Wales, to
help build productivity and connectivity, to help with levelling
up and to help deliver net zero.
We know that the Leeds section of HS2 has been cancelled. We also
know that, because of the amount of concrete that will be used,
HS2 will take 100 years to become carbon neutral, and that two
thirds of the woodlands cut down will be burned by Drax power
station, which will affect carbon emissions and air quality.
However, let us assume that HS2 is going ahead full
throttle—namely that phase 1 might be over by 2041. We in Wales
then have a case to get moving now and to get schemes delivered
on the ground. I should disclose that, as people may know, a long
time ago I was the leader of Croydon Council. I delivered the
Croydon Tramlink scheme, a light rail electrified orbital tram
system, which is 26 km long and connects Beckenham, Croydon and
Wimbledon. That cost £200 million gross, but £100 million net,
because it was a public-private partnership. That scheme, which
connected three constituencies, cost the Exchequer only £100
million. With HS2, we are talking about £100 billion—a thousand
times that scheme. My point is that there is a lot to be said for
small, cluster-based schemes around the country, particularly on
an east-west basis. I am talking about the northern powerhouse as
well as connectivity to Wales and, very importantly, within
Wales.
The situation in terms of relative competitiveness is that I can
go from London to Manchester in two hours and 10 minutes, and
from London to Swansea in about three hours. With HS2—if it does
happen—we will be able to get to Manchester in one hour, so we
have to ask what investors are going to do. We have already seen
Virgin pull out of Swansea and go to Manchester because of this,
and KPMG did a study some years ago showing that we will lose
tens of thousands of jobs from south Wales unless we get some
investment of our own to connect up, in particular, the clusters
of Swansea and westwards with Cardiff and Bristol, to make that
engine turn faster.
(Dwyfor Meirionnydd)
(PC)
To return to the point the hon. Gentleman made about speeds and
time, what is the rationale for the Severn tunnel being the
dividing line? To the east of the Severn tunnel, a person can
travel at 125 miles an hour, but we are supposed to accept that,
for some reason, to the west of the Severn tunnel, the speed is
100 miles an hour at best. Why should we accept that as a
rationale, when other times for travelling are being so
spectacularly improved?
I completely agree with the right hon. Lady. Obviously, there are
engineering and geographic issues here: Brunel originally had a
straight line going through to Swansea, which would have taken
half an hour—clearly, it used to loop around to pick up coal and
that sort of thing. But one of the things about time, of course,
is that if you increase frequency, you reduce average time. I
appreciate that the Minister may have a different view on HS2,
but I think there is too much focus on gaining a few extra
minutes when what we really need from HS2 is greater capacity:
bigger trains and thicker tracks, or whatever, not necessarily
going faster. If I can go to Edinburgh in three hours, which is
the same time it takes me to get to Swansea, do I really want to
spend £100 billion or £200 billion to gain that extra bit of
time?
In the meantime, although I know Members will talk about the
benefits for Wales, it is sad that the current plan does not
contain the direct link between Crewe and Manchester that would
help Wales. As we know from our own line, after we zoom through
to Bristol and then to Cardiff, there are a number of smaller
stations, and the train has to stop and start and that sort of
thing. If HS2 had lots and lots of different stations, it would
have to stop all the time, so that has been ruled out, but that
means that people have to travel a long way to get to HS2 and
connect with it. If we do not have this Crewe connection—which we
will not—the benefits for Wales will be very small, much less
than for Scotland. My minimum ask is that we agree the Welsh
Affairs Committee’s joint party report that said we should get
the same share as Scotland, as opposed to more, because Scotland
will benefit and we will lose out.
(Montgomeryshire) (Con)
I am sure it was an omission by my hon. Friend—I call him that
because he is Welsh—that he did not mention the Cambrian line,
which goes through the heart of mid-Wales to Birmingham. Will he
reflect on the hub of Birmingham, and how that impacts on Wales
and HS2? He has talked about Crewe, Manchester and Bristol, but
mid-Wales looks east to west, and that Birmingham exchange is
incredibly important to my constituents.
The hon. Member makes an important point. Overall, having a fast
north-to-south link along the spine of the United Kingdom is good
for the UK, and obviously the connections with Birmingham are
important as well. My central point is that we are going to spend
all this money, but Scotland will benefit much more than Wales:
at minimum, we should get our fair share. My secondary point is
that a lot of shovel-ready schemes are available, many of which
have been devised by the Welsh Government and are ready to roll.
If we are serious about being a Union, connecting the Union and
building productivity, we should do just that.
The productivity situation, of course, is that unfortunately the
gross value added in Wales is something like 70%.In other words,
the average wage is about 70% of the UK average. Of course,
productivity is generated by skills, technology, access to
markets and investment, and the productivity of the actual line
is low. Traditionally, the Department for Transport’s formula for
investing money, in terms of its cost-benefit analysis, rewards
previous investment. In the south-east of England people have
expensive houses, and the train network is basically made to
spoke into London more and more so that people can work in London
and live further and further away, with HS2 and other
connectivity. What happens, obviously, is that house prices are
bid up, so no one can afford to live in London. People spend half
their time going back and forth on a train, using a lot of
carbon, and even if the line is electrified the electricity must
be provided somehow or other, and the energy of the world is
being consumed.
We should look at a more regional basis—a cluster basis—that took
advantage of what we all know now about Zoom technology to allow
people to work from home, and that sort of thing. Post-pandemic
and post-Zoom technology, in our new environment, we should look
at how best we can spend money on building localised economies
more quickly, rather than having much more grandiose schemes for
the long term. I am not speaking against those things as such,
but it seems to me that we need to bring forward these other
projects.
On net zero, the Minister will know that in Paris we tried to
deliver a maximum 1.5° C increase, but the latest projections are
that we are already at 1.2° C and that by 2025 we will be at 1.5°
C. In fact, over Europe it is already 2° C and over the Arctic it
is already 3° C, because there is more heat over land than over
sea, which is why 8,500 tonnes of ice are melting every second
that we speak today. So we are running out of time. I am not
pretending that our schemes in Wales can save the world, but we
all need to think about how to do what we can as soon as we
can.
On the investment we have had in Wales, the Minister will know
that, in terms of rail enhancements over the last couple of
decades, we have had only about 1.5% of the UK’s share for 5% of
the population and something like 11% of the rail track. In
recent times, I ran a big campaign, as the MP for Swansea West
since 2010, to get rail electrification to Swansea. said he would deliver it, but
then something happened to him and we didn’t get it. It was then
argued, “Oh, well, there won’t be a very big increase in line
speed,” but what we need of course is frequency and
electrification so that we get a better service and a greener
future. That is something we need to come back to.
We have left the EU, but 60% of exports from Wales are to the EU,
so we need support. In terms of economic clusters, the Swansea,
Cardiff and Bristol city regions combined have 3 million people.
Similarly, Leeds and Manchester have 3 million people. However,
Leeds and Manchester get something like eight services an hour,
whereas we get about one. So the issue, which comes out of the
Hendy review and other things, is that we should be connecting
up—this is not being nationalist in any sense—with Bristol and
the south-west to create economic prosperity for south Wales and
the south-west. We need that investment in railways now.
I know that , the Transport Minister, and Judy James in the Welsh
Assembly have come forward with detailed schemes about how to
provide a south Wales metro in the south-east and central areas,
and moving west. In essence, we are talking about an integrated
transport system that would connect up light rail with electric
buses, electrified trains and even hydrogen-powered trains in a
way that means people can easily get on to public transport and
are not kept waiting for hours because the service is unreliable
and infrequent, so that they will then switch from car usage.
I would be interested to hear what the Minister has to say about
that. It is all very well saying that people must go on public
transport but if we are serious about net zero public transport
needs to be close to home, frequent, affordable and comfortable.
People will make that shift if the fiscal strategy is there. I
urge the Minister to urge the Chancellor to address that issue,
and I am happy to work with them on that with colleagues.
I know that other Members want to speak, so I will shortly wind
up—I am sure you will be thankful to hear that, Sir Edward.
However, the Minister may or may not be aware of the Blue Eden
project coming out of Swansea. That innovative project combines
tidal energy with floating eco-houses—believe it or not—solar
energy and capturing batteries’ energy. My point is that there is
a great appetite for creative innovation to deliver net zero in
Swansea, Wales and beyond. Part of that must be the investment in
rail infrastructure and public transport that are environmentally
friendly, people friendly and affordable and in building
productivity to help Britain to deliver net zero, higher
productivity and better prosperity for all.
09:46:00
(Montgomeryshire) (Con)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Sir Edward. I
want to make a couple of political points and to reflect on what
my hon. Friend the Member for Swansea West () said—I will continue using
“Friends”, as we are mostly Welsh in the Chamber.
This debate starts from the premise that HS2 is not good for
Wales and I completely dispute that. On the political map of
Wales, above the Brecon Beacons, we find one Labour MP. I think
that is a reflection of the political circumstances of Wales. To
put in a nutshell what is being alleged today, the political
reality of the Labour party in Wales is that it is in south
Wales, and only south Wales, so anything that matters to any one
above the Brecon Beacons is not Welsh and not helpful for
Wales.
In my intervention, I alluded to the Cambrian line. The
Montgomeryshire economy looks east and west. It looks to
Birmingham. Our railway line goes straight into Birmingham. Our
international airport for mid-Wales is Birmingham International
airport. In terms of a political ideological point about the
Welsh nation, I get why people go on about north-south links, but
the reality of our economy and transport is that we look to
Birmingham. That is just a day-to-day part of life.
I am sure the hon. Gentleman shares with me the concerns that
historically there were north-south links. There is a deep irony
that anyone who wants to use a train for a north-south link now,
even in my constituency, has to use a steam train, which is very
effective, but not indicative of a country in the 21st century or
of our needs. We need these links in Wales, to build the nation
of Wales, alongside all the talk of building the Union.
I agree to a point, but it is ironic that since the creation of
devolution we have seen the public transport network in Wales
deteriorate. I speak as somebody who served as a director of a
bus company. The funding to our bus companies in Wales and to a
lot of things in devolved areas has completely wiped away
capacity in the nation of Wales. I would reflect on what our
Welsh Parliament has done to those north-south connections.
I occasionally commute to my constituency office by steam
train—the right hon. Lady has been on the line from Llanfair
Caereinion to Welshpool—and it does not reflect the modern,
dynamic Wales we want, but the heritage railways are incredibly
important.
rose—
I want to come back to my main point before the hon. Member
intervenes. I will, of course, give way; he was very kind. The
premise of this debate does not reflect mid Wales. It does not
reflect north Wales, our priorities and the fact that we fall
back on the spine of the UK railway network. I put it to Members
that HS2 is as much about capacity as it is speed. In
Montgomeryshire we look to London as much as we look to Cardiff,
and anyone in my constituency who uses the UK network could see
that it had huge capacity problems, pre covid. In
Montgomeryshire, we can see the need to invest in that spine. We
can see as businesses and constituents that we need additional
capacity.
The hon. Member for Swansea West mentioned COP26 and the modal
shift; if we are going to have those kind of shifts to public
transport, we need the capacity. If we are going to have the
capacity for mid-Wales, and the UK, we need new lines. I will
give way if the hon. Member for Swansea West wants to intervene,
and then the right hon. Member for Dwyfor Meirionnydd—why not two
at once?
Because it is impermissible.
I have been arguing that we need more connectivity within
Wales—in south Wales and north Wales—but also between south Wales
and the south-west, between north Wales and Liverpool and
Manchester, and mid-Wales and Birmingham. We need connectivity to
connect the Union, but to do that we need our fair share of
investment. That is my simple point; I am not trying to cut off
Wales, and I am certainly not saying that south Wales is the be
all and end all. However, it is the case, as my father found when
he was in charge of economic development in the Welsh Office,
that the connectivity between south Wales and the south-west and
between north Wales and the north-west is greater than between
north and south Wales.
Before I give way to the right hon. Member for Dwyfor
Meirionnydd, I will reflect on the fact that this debate is very
premature. The Union connectivity review is yet to come out, and
those are the exact issues that Peter Hendy has been looking at.
The review is the vehicle for delivering this. There is a
pressure, at times, that unless we give money to the Welsh
Government we are not giving money to Wales—that is not true at
all. The UK Government invest in Wales as well as the Welsh
Government. We have two Governments that look after Wales; the UK
Government, in terms of strategic assets such as transport links,
and the Welsh Government in terms of devolved responsibilities. I
was in Machynlleth, at the black bridge, with Peter Hendy some
months ago; as the hon. Gentleman and I have neighbouring
constituencies, we know that that was a multi-million pound
investment to sort out the Cambrian line by Network Rail and the
UK Government. That should be the UK Government’s role, and I
expect that after the publication of the Union connectivity
review there will be a significant investment into Wales.
Of course, we do share the Cambrian coast line that runs through
Montgomeryshire; it serves Ceredigion and Gwynedd as well. One of
the issues that has arisen from HS2 is the way that it distracts
from other possible places of investment. I would argue that for
many of the hon. Gentleman’s constituents, as with mine, that
improvements at Shrewsbury would make a far greater difference to
connectivity in the immediate term than improvements to
Birmingham.
I agree on that point. That is under the franchise of Transport
for Wales; although it is an English station it comes under the
Welsh franchise and they operate it. My hon. Friend the Member
for Shrewsbury and Atcham () and I are campaigning,
along with other Shropshire MPs, to get direct services from
Shrewsbury to London, and improve the connectivity across the UK
in terms of the Cambrian line. I will give way once more, and
then I will make some other cheap political points before I shut
up.
(Strangford) (DUP)
This is very much a debate about Wales, transport and HS2, but
the hon. Gentleman has referred to Union connectivity. I would
ask if it is possible to consider us in Northern Ireland, who
travel from Belfast to Liverpool to Wales, or go down south to
come across on the ferry to Holyhead. When it comes to
connectivity, we must improve everything within Wales, but we
must do that for the benefit of the whole of the United Kingdom
of Great Britain and Northern Ireland—including for us in
Northern Ireland who wish to travel to Wales.
(in the Chair)
Order. As a general rule, if you want to make an intervention,
you should be here at the start of the debate.
I will remember that for the future, Sir Edward. The hon. Member
for Strangford () makes an incredibly important point, and it is one
that I hope the Union connectivity review does look into. While I
am not suggesting a bridge or a tunnel from Holyhead over to
Northern Ireland or the Republic, I am suggesting that we need to
look at the importance of Holyhead as a UK strategic port, and
some better way of connecting into the UK rail network. That is
exactly where I want to see the investment from the UK Government
going—into our Welsh railway network. The north Wales coast line
is an incredibly important strategic railway for the whole of the
United Kingdom, not just Wales. I am delighted that that
remains—and long may it—the competence of the UK Government,
because that is the only way we will see real investment.
I return to the opening speech by the hon. Member for Swansea
West and the south Wales orientation of Welsh Labour, be it at
parliamentary level or at that of the Welsh Government. On behalf
of my constituents, I feel that especially with the Cambrian
line. I know from north Wales Members that there is a strong
feeling in communities of neglect by the Welsh Government and a
complete orientation to Cardiff and south Wales.
Will the hon. Gentleman give way?
I said I would not give way anymore. I am sure the hon. Gentleman
can use his closing remarks to come back on me. Before I sit
down, I would reflect again on the importance of looking east to
west in terms of connectivity, and the importance of building
additional capacity into our UK network. On behalf of my
constituents, I welcome the Birmingham hub. I know that, for
north Wales Members, the Crewe interchange, and how it builds
into the north Wales coastline, will be incredibly important.
Although I recognise the passion and the sometimes cheeky ask for
additional money, I expect that mid-Wales will require additional
investment in its railway network from the UK Government, through
the Union Connectivity Review. I hope that there is no push by
anybody suggesting that the easiest way to solve any problem in
Wales is to give more money, either through Barnett or directly
to the Welsh Government. If we are going to level up and make a
huge investment in our network in Wales, that has to come from
the UK Government. Otherwise, as I alluded to, I fear it will be
a complete south Wales monopoly on developments.
09:57:00
(Dwyfor Meirionnydd)
(PC)
Diolch yn fawr iawn , Sir Edward. It is a pleasure to serve under
your chairmanship. I congratulate the hon. Member for Swansea
West () on securing the debate. It
is delightful to follow the hon. Member for Montgomeryshire
().
HS2 is a symbol of many things, but for many people it is the
example of a monumental Government white elephant. Justified on
the basis of shaky calculations, which are almost 10 years old
now, supported for the sake of political face-saving, and
adjusted for political purposes rather than transport need, it
has become for many people a political and economic catastrophe.
It is certainly a highly political matter, of which the
Conservative party will be aware, given recent by-elections.
That we press on with a project, originally costed at £32.2
billion in 2012 but now, scarcely nine years later, nearing £108
billion, is a testament to the failure of this Government to
deliver. It is an example of the Westminster Government having
their English cake and eating it, while telling the other nations
to stump up for the ingredients. For Wales, it leaves an
especially bitter taste.
HS2 has become a catchphrase for constitutional injustice, the
high-handed mistreatment of Wales by Westminster, and the lack of
fair play, let alone a level playing field. It reveals the
reality of this Union of inequality. The consequences of HS2 for
Wales are best seen when viewed, as two Members have already
said, through the lens of the levelling-up agenda.
The Government have made much of their proposals for
infrastructure investment, as part of the long overdue
levelling-up agenda. Yet in the previous spending review, the
Chancellor pummelled down rather than levelled up, by reducing
the amount Wales will receive, when compared to UK Government
transport investment in England. Wales was reduced from 80.9% in
2015 to just 36.6% in 2020. There is not much levelling up by the
look of it. That represents a collapse of 44.3 percentage points,
nearly half of what the Welsh Government will receive from every
pound of UK taxpayers’ money, as spent by the English Department
for Transport in England.
Why is that? Since 2015, Plaid Cymru has been arguing that Wales,
like Scotland, should receive a full Barnett consequential from
HS2 on the basis that it is a railway solely for England. Not an
inch of its track will be laid in Wales. With the project
currently expected to cost approximately £108 billion, Wales
would receive roughly £5 billion based on our population share,
if only we could apply the same formula with which all other
England-only expenditure is treated. These are significant
amounts of money, are they not?
That injustice was made worse by the Government’s project
calculating that HS2 would cast a blight on the south Wales
corridor. This region, of course, includes many of Wales’s
valleys communities that are most desperately underinvested, and
I am sure that it also includes the constituency of the hon.
Member for Bridgend (Dr Wallis). The south Wales region is set to
lose out to the tune of approximately £100 million a year because
of the economic blight that HS2 will impose on the south Wales
region.
This is where the situation becomes incomprehensible. Labour
voted, against Plaid Cymru’s efforts, for Westminster to classify
HS2 as an England and Wales project, arguing that both will
benefit. That needs to be on the record. Even yesterday, the
shadow Secretary of State for Transport, the hon. Member for
Oldham West and Royton (), said that Labour is fully
“committed” to the delivery of HS2 and described changes to the
proposed route as a “betrayal”. I beg to differ. The significant
betrayal is Westminster’s treatment of Wales and it is frankly
incomprehensible to witness Labour’s collusion in that.
Tomorrow, the Chancellor must make good his mistake, and he has
an opportunity to do that. We have heard an awful lot about
levelling up. This is an opportunity to give Wales, like
Scotland, what would surely seem obvious to any reasonable person
outside this place—a full Barnett consequential from HS2, as
Scotland has. This is a glaring injustice, made worse by the fact
that despite having 11% of the UK’s rail track, Wales has
received only 1.5% of the money that UK Ministers spent on rail
improvements. Yes, there is spend on maintenance, but when it
comes to improvements in the 21st century for a public rail
transport system that we desperately need, that money is not
being spent in any measure of equivalence in Wales. Correcting
the Treasury’s treatment of HS2 and its Barnett consequential for
Wales is the right thing to do, and that would fast-track our
benefit from levelling up. That is, of course, if levelling up is
ever to be anything more than a catchphrase for Wales.
10:02:00
(Bridgend) (Con)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Sir Edward. I
congratulate the hon. Member for Swansea West () on securing this debate. He
and I serve on the Welsh Affairs Committee and he alluded to its
recent report on rail investment in Wales, which had a section on
HS2. He will remember, from the fierce debates that we had during
those private meetings, that he and I disagree very much on the
essence of HS2 and its benefits to the people and the economy of
Wales, but I admire his passion and I believe that we as Welsh
MPs should fight for as much money for Wales as possible. There
is absolutely nothing wrong with that.
I firmly believe that HS2 presents an opportunity for us to build
back better not just for England, but for the United Kingdom as a
whole. I welcome the hon. Member’s comments that investment in
the main spine down the United Kingdom benefits the whole United
Kingdom. My hon. Friend the Member for Montgomeryshire () highlighted how his
constituents and those in north Wales will benefit with respect
to the east-west nature of their day-to-day travel, with journey
times to London from Birmingham, their closest main hub, being
significantly reduced. This investment will therefore benefit
them.
To turn to areas such as my Bridgend constituency, in the past
20-odd months of being an MP, I have seen a huge number of small
and medium-sized enterprises that are heavily involved in
Government infrastructure projects, whether that is Hinkley Point
C or HS2. I actually surveyed all of the businesses on one of our
industrial estates. There were only a few dozen and not all of
them replied, but over half of them were currently either
servicing or considering tendering for a UK Government
infrastructure project, most notably Hinkley Point C and HS2.
There are currently 2,000 businesses involved in the development
of HS2, with 9,000 people working on the line, and many of those
businesses are based in south Wales. The whole of the United
Kingdom gets to bid and tender for this work. That money and
investment provides job security and opportunities for people
across the whole of the UK.
The Select Committee report was slightly unfair and contains some
inaccuracies. It suggested that the Welsh Government had not
received a single penny from the Department for Transport
spending on HS2. I would like to highlight that between 2015 and
2019 the Welsh Government received about £755 million in Barnett
consequentials. I appreciate that the hon. Member for Swansea
West is referring to future Barnett consequentials, but it is not
the case that the Welsh Government have received nothing. They
have received Barnett consequentials to date.
(Carmarthen East and
Dinefwr) (Ind)
I do not think anybody is discounting the fact that increasing
Department for Transport expenditure leads to overall
consequentials for Wales. The question is on the impact of the
HS2 element. Having mentioned the £755 million for Wales, what
are the figures for Scotland and Northern Ireland, considering
that they get 100% Barnett consequentials? That is the issue at
hand.
Dr Wallis
I thank the hon. Member for his intervention. I represent a
constituency in south Wales. Much has been made of the benefit to
mid and north Wales, and I am trying to highlight some of the
benefits to south Wales. If there is a benefit to people and
businesses in Wales, with investment in infrastructure in the
United Kingdom benefiting the UK and Welsh economy, surely we
have to accept that to ask for 100% Barnett consequentials on the
project is simply not right. We have to accept that Wales will
get a benefit, so asking for a 100% comparison is simply not
right.
Many of my constituents are very concerned about environmental
factors, and achieving net zero is important.
I am listening carefully to the hon. Member’s comments, and I
respect the fact that we have genuine differences. Will he accept
that, if Scotland gets 91.7% of Barnett consequentials from HS2
and Wales gets zero, even if there are some benefits to Wales
from HS2, it could be argued that we should get something in the
middle? I know the benefits of people going from Wales to build
HS2 and coming home to Wales, as he is mentioning, but should we
not get a share at least? We need more money in Wales.
Dr Wallis
We have had this debate a lot. There have already been Barnett
consequentials given directly to the Welsh Government. I think I
have already addressed that point.
Coming back to net zero, we should be trying to drive up rail
uptake, and I am very pleased with that. I want to talk about
what the Welsh Government are doing with roads. We are talking
about achieving net zero and the role of rail in that. We cannot
expect net zero to mean zero cars. Passenger cars will be moving
to electric technologies and potentially hydrogen technologies,
and the state of roads is continually a cause of frustration for
my constituents. I picked up three additional cases at my surgery
on Saturday of residents on a street in Porthcawl who are
frustrated and at the point of exasperation because they cannot
get investment in the roads there, and they cannot get what they
need. The Welsh Government’s decision to simply abandon any new
investment in roads and to completely walk away from building the
M4 relief road has done far more to frustrate my constituents
than anything going on with HS2, frankly.
I will finish by saying that the bounce-back impact of HS2 in
Wales cannot be underestimated, not only from additional funding
but by improving transport links from mid and north Wales and
increasing opportunities for all Welsh businesses, including
those in my constituency. HS2 is a British project that seeks to
level up the whole United Kingdom, and I believe it does just
that.
10:10:00
(Carmarthen East and
Dinefwr) (Ind)
Diolch. It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship again,
Sir Edward. I congratulate the hon. Member for Swansea West
() on securing this timely
debate on the eve of the Budget and the comprehensive spending
review.
How Wales has been treated in relation to HS2 is a scandal of
epic proportions, and it highlights why the British state does
not, and never will, work for Wales. HS2 has been funded purely
and totally by public investment, which means that Welsh taxes
that have been paid into the general Treasury pot are being
utilised. That is different from HS1, which was financed
completely via private means. If anyone thinks that I am arguing
against public investment in rail, that is not the case. I am
arguing that if public investment is used to fund a major rail
infrastructure project, the allocation of public funds becomes an
important political topic.
Despite the confusion about future phases of HS2, with news
reports this weekend indicating that future phases might run on
existing routes north of Birmingham, the reality is that the HS2
project dominates UK rail infrastructure spending and will do so
for many years. It is likely that the whole project will not be
completed until the middle of the next decade.
When the last Labour Government promoted HS2, the projected costs
were nearly £40 billion. As my right hon. Friend the Member for
Dwyfor Meirionnydd () said, the costs are
now estimated at well over £100 billion by the independent
Oakervee review, despite the Treasury’s desperate attempts to cut
costs. , the review’s deputy chair,
put the costs at more than £170 billion. Regardless of HS2’s
finished costs, the key question for the debate and for Welsh
transport is its impact on Welsh funding.
Rail infrastructure is not devolved in Wales as it is in Scotland
and Northern Ireland. The cross-party Silk commission, set up by
the Cameron Government in 2010 to look into the constitutional
settlement, advocated equalising railway powers in the Welsh
settlement with those of the other constituent parts of the UK.
Even before HS2 came online, the commission understood full well
the financial implications for Wales of those powers being
retained in Westminster.
My hon. Friend makes an interesting point. There has been one
significant material change since the original costing for HS2,
in that since last year, Transport for Wales—Wales’ transport
network—has been in public ownership under the operator of last
resort. Given that the train system is in public ownership,
surely Network Rail should also be devolved to align public
spending most effectively in Wales, along with the proper
funding. There is a staggeringly obvious discrepancy and
inconsistency between those two things.
As always, my right hon. Friend makes a pertinent point. It does
not make any sense that the responsibility for operating the
railways in Wales is devolved to the Welsh Government but the
responsibility for the infrastructure remains in the hands of
another Government.
To return to my point, the Silk commission recognised that the
devolution of those powers and the equalisation of powers for
Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland, was right not only for
operational reasons, but because of the financial implications
and the historical underfunding of the Welsh railways that
resulted from the powers being retained in Westminster.
The hon. Gentleman is being generous in giving way. Does he agree
that one has to differentiate, as I do not think the hon. Member
for Montgomeryshire () did, between the amount of
money we get for Wales and who spends it? There was a lot of talk
about UK money—“The Government spends this. Don’t give the money
to the Welsh Government.”—but the basic point is that we should
get our fair share. Of the £48 billion that Network Rail spends,
about £1 billion is spent in Wales, which certainly is not the 5%
that we deserve.
Absolutely; that is the financial reality. We do not even get a
population share, which would be 5% of rail investment. People
might argue that 11% of the rail network is in Wales, so we
should be getting more than our population share. Historical
underfunding is a huge problem for us in Wales in terms of
developing our economy and moving our country forward. I will
return to some of those themes later.
The hon. Gentleman is indeed being very generous. Will he reflect
on the fact that a good chunk of the Welsh railway network is in
England? We have already alluded to the fact that Shrewsbury
station, which I can assure the Chamber is in England, is an
important Welsh station. Going from north to south Wales, a large
chunk of that trunk railway is in England.
I listened to the hon. Gentleman’s speech advocating the benefits
of HS2 with great interest, but he needs to reflect on the full
business case for HS2 produced by HS2 Ltd in 2020. According to
Professor Mark Barry’s submission to the Welsh Affairs Committee,
there is no passenger benefit to Wales at all from HS2.
Returning to my point, the political process in Westminster
following the Silk commission was a hatchet job of the worst
kind, in which representatives of the two main Unionist parties
drew red lines through the commission’s recommendations.
Regrettably, the report was torpedoed below the water line. One
recommendation taken out of the report was the devolution of rail
powers, which meant that the Wales Act 2014, which followed that
process, retained the status quo on that vital issue. The
financial implications of that decision are sobering in the
context of a domineering project like HS2, due to its impact on
Welsh Barnett allocations. It has been catastrophic for Welsh
funding.
While Scotland and Northern Ireland get a 100% allocation from
HS2, Wales gets a 0% rating because the British Government deemed
it an England and Wales project. However, the last time I looked
at a map—I made this point in a question to the Prime Minister
some time ago—all the HS2 destinations are in England. It says
everything about how the British state works that a decision of
this nature, with such far-reaching consequences, can be made
without challenge. In this post-Brexit world, due to the inequity
of the financial settlements across the UK, I have advocated the
creation of a body apart from the Treasury to allow the various
Governments of the UK to challenge financial decisions. At the
moment, Westminster is judge and jury; in this case, that is very
much to the loss of Wales. As a result, I have voted against HS2
at every opportunity.
The reality is that as spending on HS2 increases, Welsh Barnett
allocations plummet. Now that construction has begun on phase 1,
the financial impact has become clear. According to the Wales
Governance Centre’s analysis, the statement of funding policy
accompanying the last comprehensive spending review indicated
that Wales would receive 36.6% of its population share of
transport funding, while Scotland and Northern Ireland’s shares
remain above 90% due to their full entitlements from HS2,
compounding the historical underfunding of the Welsh railways. In
2013, the British Government’s own analysis indicated that HS2
would injure the south Wales economy by more than £200 million
per annum; given that that analysis was done eight or nine years
ago, I suspect the injury to the Welsh economy will be far more
severe than what was revealed at the time.
Underfunding has always been a major issue for Wales. In the way
the Department for Transport allocates funding, as our railways
become less efficient the case for investment is undermined;
meanwhile, investment is ploughed into London and the south-east,
leading to a conveyor belt of investment which makes the case for
further investment. Indeed, when the Prime Minister was Mayor of
London, he argued in the Evening Standard that transport spending
in London would need to increase by £1 trillion—if I remember
correctly—once HS2 was completed, due to the extra passengers
arriving from the north of England. Put simply, the current
system does not work for Wales, and we need urgent and rapid
change.
The hon. Member for Swansea West made an important point about
productivity. Even from the Treasury’s perspective, one of the
major issues within the British state is the geographical
imbalance in productivity. Transport infrastructure investment is
a key economic driver, so if all investment is utilised in and
allocated to the most high-performing areas, productivity gaps
are worsened. The simplest way to address productivity gaps is to
invest in the poorer performing parts of the state, as the German
Government realised following reunification—and there was a wall
between East and West Germany for half a century. Alas, in the
UK, all the money is spent in one small corner. Pre-Budget
soundings suggest that an extra £7 billion or so will be
allocated for expenditure outside London and the south-east, but
the key question is how much of that is new money. It may be less
than £2 billion. We wait to hear what the Chancellor has to say
tomorrow.
To emphasise the point I made to the hon. Member for
Montgomeryshire (), in a submission to the
Welsh Affairs Committee’s recent inquiry into this issue,
transport expert Professor Mark Barry stated that the full
business case for HS2 produced in 2020 proved that HS2 had no
transport user benefit for Wales. How the British Government can
maintain that this is an England and Wales project is beyond
rational understanding, so fairness is at the heart of this
debate. Welsh taxes are being used to fund an England-only
project that will also have a negative impact on our economy,
with no recompense via the Barnett formula. Some might say it was
ever thus, but to use the phrase of the moment, this is not
levelling up; this is levelling down.
If Wales received fairness in real investment, we could be
looking at exciting projects such as a comprehensive metro system
for the west based on the one in Swansea—a project that I very
much support—a north-south line along the western seaboard,
opening up the western half of our economy for further economic
development; enhancements across the north Wales and Heart of
Wales lines; and electrification of the main line to Swansea.
Dr Wallis
The hon. Gentleman talks about these fantastic projects, but
given the Welsh Government’s signalling their reluctance to make
significant investment in infrastructure with their recent
decision not to build the M4 relief road, are they not just
further fantasy?
That is a very interesting intervention. I am not defending the
Welsh Government’s policy in its totality, but they want to move
away from road and towards public transport. If we will not be
using road, we have to invest in rail. This is the fundamental
question facing us as Welsh representatives: given that the UK
Government have shown clearly that they have no intention of
investing in Welsh rail transport infrastructure, what are we
going to do about it? The only way to address that is to take
responsibility for ourselves.
Does the hon. Gentleman accept that the Welsh Government are not
abandoning all investment in roads? They are doing a roads
review, looking at how they can balance transport between road,
rail and active transport in a sustainable way, which will
inevitably—hopefully—lead to a bit more public transport and
rail, including electrified buses and public transport on roads.
We will have more roads, but we will not necessarily need the M4
relief road if on one in five days people are on a Zoom call
instead of sitting in their car.
My understanding of the Welsh Government’s policy is no new extra
roads. That does not mean that there will not be investment in
road maintenance. However, the reality is that, if we are going
down that road, there has to be investment in alternative modes
of transport, which again furthers the case for us in Wales to
receive the powers, so that we can get investment and make the
decisions ourselves. That is fundamentally at the heart of this
debate.
On one side of the argument are those of us who argue that
Westminster will never invest in Wales, so we need rail powers in
Wales that will bring the investment and allow the Welsh
Government to make decisions on investing in our own country. On
the other side are those arguing that the UK Government will
eventually come good and start investing in Wales. That will not
happen, so the only solution is for rail powers to be devolved to
Wales and for the Barnett consequentials to flow to Wales from
England-only projects, as happens in Scotland and Northern
Ireland, which will enable Welsh Government Ministers to pursue
the transport priorities of our own country.
10:24:00
(Slough) (Lab)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship once again, Sir
Edward. I congratulate my hon. Friend the Member for Swansea West
() on securing the debate. He
is more often in the Chair than addressing it, so it is great to
see him in his place. He made a compelling case for a
redesignation of the funding formula so that HS2 is considered
England-only. As right hon. and hon. Members have heard, that
would mean that under the Barnett formula, up to £5 billion more
could flow into Wales’s rail infrastructure and put Wales on the
same basis as Scotland and Northern Ireland when it comes to the
formula’s consequentials.
My hon. Friend makes that argument not only because he is a
doughty and dogged champion for the people of Swansea, and
indeed, the whole of south Wales, but because he rightly
identifies that rail infrastructure in Wales is in pressing need
of investment and modernisation. The redesignation of HS2 as
England-only is a sensible and practical way to release funds to
upgrade the railway in Wales. It was, after all, one of the
recommendations of the cross-party Welsh Affairs Committee. In
its report on 6 July, the Committee concluded:
“There is a strong environmental and economic case for
substantially enhancing the rail infrastructure that serves
Wales, and the passenger experience of slow services and
inadequate stations only underlines the need for an upgraded
network.”
In its conclusions, the Committee reported that:
“Wales will not benefit in the same way as Scotland and Northern
Ireland from Barnett consequentials arising from the HS2 project.
This is despite the fact that UK Government’s own analysis has
concluded that HS2 will produce an economic disbenefit for Wales.
We recommend that HS2 should be reclassified as an England only
project. Using the Barnett formula, Wales’ funding settlement
should be recalculated to apply an additional allocation based on
the funding for HS2 in England. This would help to ensure that
Welsh rail passengers receive the same advantage from investment
in HS2 as those in Scotland and Northern Ireland.”
The case is clear in the Committee’s findings, and it is indeed
compelling. When the Minister responds, I hope he will not merely
dismiss it out of hand, but instead consider carefully the many
expert opinions in favour of such a move, including the
Committee’s recommendations and the thought-provoking speeches of
my hon. Friend the Member for Swansea West and the right hon.
Member for Dwyfor Meirionnydd (), and the invaluable
contribution from the hon. Member for Carmarthen East and Dinefwr
().
The Opposition remain 100% committed to HS2. A Labour Government
would listen carefully to local concerns and place environmental
factors at the heart of the project, but we would get on with the
job at hand. We see new high-speed rail as part of a much larger
modernisation of our railways. We would invest in new lines and
stations and open up all parts of the UK, and therefore the
economy, with affordable, efficient railway services—services
that are accessible to all, including young people, people with
disabilities and people on low incomes; services that are safe
and clean, and services that are integrated across the transport
system of walking, cycling, buses, ferries, light railways, trams
and road systems. A great example would be the electrified metro
for the Swansea Bay city region, which my hon. Friend the Member
for Swansea West so ably championed and which I thoroughly
support.
We want significantly more freight off lorries, off our roads and
on to the railway, and we would accelerate the electrification of
the railway with a rolling programme of upgrades. The
Conservative Government’s decision to cancel the electrification
of the Great Western main line from Cardiff to Swansea was
short-sighted and bad for the environment, and it should now be
reversed. It is absurd that the Great Western Railway’s Hitachi
bi-mode trains run on diesel mode between Cardiff and Swansea and
switch to the less polluting and more efficient electric mode on
the rest of the route in England, including as it goes through
the wonderful town of Slough.
As the right hon. Member for Dwyfor Meirionnydd rightly noted, in
England trains can reach the magic inter-city speed of 125 mph,
but once on the Welsh side of the Severn tunnel, they slow to
average speeds well below 100 mph—not so much levelling up as
slowing down. Will the Minister update us on the Department for
Transport’s stalled plans for the electrification of the railway
in Wales? The last Labour Government rightly prioritised and
invested billions of pounds in modernising our old, inefficient
rolling stock. Having achieved that, the priority of the last
decade should have been the electrification of our rail
lines.
We heard from the hon. Member for Montgomeryshire () about the significance of
the line from Holyhead into England. There has been no mention in
the slightest of that being electrified. Those lines have some of
the most polluting rolling stock, and we have no alternative in
many cases but to use it. That is not the transport
infrastructure of the 21st century, which, just days before
COP26, is what we should be discussing.
Mr Dhesi
The right hon. Lady is absolutely right. I recently visited my
family and saw the wonders of north Wales, and, although it was
lovely to see the scenic countryside on steam railways and the
like, what was sorely missing was an electrified rail network.
That would greatly benefit the good people of Wales, and that is
why there needs to be greater investment in Wales, and in
particular in electrification.
Dr Wallis
The hon. Gentleman said that electrification would benefit the
people of Wales. My constituents already benefit from the
electrification of the line to Cardiff. I have regularly
travelled into London, both before and after I was elected as a
Member of this House. The train journey times into Paddington
from the main station in my constituency are already about 18
minutes shorter. The decision that electrification would not go
as far as Swansea, although disappointing, did allow for
immediate investment in new, more comfortable and more
environmentally friendly trains. Does the hon. Gentleman agree
with me that people in my constituency in south Wales do
currently benefit from electrification?
Mr Dhesi
I thank the hon. Gentleman for that intervention. However,
although his constituents in Bridgend, in south-east Wales, may
benefit from the electrified railways towards Bridgend and
Cardiff, it is absolutely absurd that people in south-west Wales
and beyond are missing out.
It is also absurd that the hon. Member for Montgomeryshire
(), who is no longer in his
place, and the hon. Member for Bridgend (Dr Wallis) are arguing
against more money for Wales. If people in Slough felt that they
were missing out on resources and funding, they would be up in
arms. The hon. Member can bet his bottom dollar that, if the
route through the wonderful town of Slough was not electrified,
the likes of me would be constantly arguing that we needed more
investment in Slough and more electrification of our rail lines.
That is the way we are going to tackle the climate crisis.
Dr Wallis
I thank the hon. Gentleman for giving way again. As the Member of
Parliament for Bridgend, I am certainly not arguing for less
money for Wales, and, were my hon. Friend the Member for
Montgomeryshire () still here, he would be
able, as Parliamentary Private Secretary to the Chief Secretary
to the Treasury, to tell the hon. Gentleman just how many bids
had gone in and just how much money we wanted. It is not fair to
say that I and my hon. Friend the Member for Montgomeryshire, who
is no longer here to defend himself, are arguing for less money
for our constituents. Our point is that HS2 does benefit the
people of Wales, particularly those in mid and north Wales. It
benefits the entire economy of the United Kingdom. It is a
British project, and therefore the assumption that it should be
fully Barnettised is simply not right.
Mr Dhesi
I thank the hon. Gentleman, but Wales is missing out. Some £5
billion of Barnett consequentials is not an insignificant sum. As
I have pointed out before, the good people of Scotland and
Northern Ireland benefit from Barnett consequentials, and none of
the track actually goes through Wales. As has been argued, there
is a need to increase the links between mid or north Wales and
Birmingham, Liverpool and Manchester, but as has been pointed
out, north to south there is still reliance on steam trains. If
that were the situation in Slough, rest assured we would not
settle for that. We would ask for more money and our share of
resources.
The people of Wales are missing out. That is why the Labour party
supports the proposal. It is clear that railway must drive the
green revolution, just as it once powered the industrial
revolution. Electrification is key. The old fragmented franchise
model is dead. The modern railway is still waiting to emerge.
Properly funded, publicly owned and strategically led, the
railway can become the clean, green, affordable and efficient
pride of Great Britain. It can boost our economic recovery after
covid-19. It can transport us into the low-carbon and post-carbon
economy and it can be a vital part of economic and social
renaissance in Wales, but not without the investment we know is
needed.
My hon. Friend is making an excellent speech. He may already know
that between Cardiff and Swansea, where the electrification
stops, the air quality deteriorates because of the diesel fumes.
I chair the all-party parliamentary group on air pollution, and I
have measured it—it is up to 5 micrograms per cubic metre in the
carriage. People are being exposed to pollution unnecessarily. He
will also be aware that Transport for Wales now has the skills
infrastructure to deliver on the ground speedily while the
Department for Transport has multiple priorities and is focused
on HS2. We have the skills, but we need the money. Let us get the
job done.
Mr Dhesi
My hon. Friend makes a powerful point. He has contributed a great
deal to the debate on pollution as the chair of the all-party
parliamentary group on air pollution, of which I am a member. I
am fully aware of the impact on communities of not having
electrified rail infrastructure. I am also aware of the review
that the Welsh Government is undertaking on investment in rail
across south Wales and beyond, so my hon. Friend makes some apt
points.
It is surely wrong that HS2 will reduce the London to Manchester
journey time to one hour and 10 minutes but London to Swansea
will still take three hours. We must invest in and upgrade the
Ebbw valley, the Maesteg lines, the Welsh Marshes line, Cardiff
Crossrail and more. Levelling up must be for every part of our
United Kingdom: not just Manchester but Milford Haven and Merthyr
Tydfil; not just Leeds but Llanelli and Llandudno; not just
Birmingham but Bangor and Bridgend. The £5 billion from Barnett
consequentials would be a good start. I hope the Minister will
give us good news.
10:38:00
The Minister of State, Department for Transport ()
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Sir Edward. I
thank the hon. Member for Swansea West () and right hon. and hon.
Members for their contributions. We all understand the great
importance of transport and levelling up the United Kingdom. All
the Members spoke eloquently about the need for more transport
investment in Wales, an issue that the Welsh Affairs Committee
looked at recently.
Let me assure Members that a key focus of the Government is to
ensure we have a transport network that is not only fit for
purpose but, above all, able to deliver a better and more
prosperous future for all those we represent. HS2 is one of the
many schemes that the Department for Transport is pursuing. It
will free up capacity on the conventional rail network and
support a shift of passengers and freight from road to rail. I
stand here as the HS2 Minister, convinced that HS2 will play a
vital role in levelling up all parts of the United Kingdom.
However, as we have heard, HS2 is not the only matter at hand, so
I will first focus on rail funding more generally in Wales and
other points raised, before turning the HS2.
Let me be clear: we are investing in Wales. The current control
period has seen a record £2 billion revenue settlement for
Network Rail in Wales. Of that settlement, almost £1 billion will
be spent on renewing and upgrading infrastructure to meet the
current and future needs of all passengers, such as the complete
restoration of the iconic Barmouth viaduct in Gwynedd.
Investments in new stations are being made apace, such as at Bow
Street in Ceredigion; line enhancements are being made in north,
south and mid-Wales; major upgrades are being made to Cardiff
Central station; and level crossing upgrades are being made to
the Wrexham-Bidston line. That work is happening now, but a lot
more is coming down the pipeline, including the opening-up of
opportunities for work, travel and leisure for Wales and across
the UK.
Members will of course be aware that the interim report of Sir
Peter Hendy’s Union connectivity review was published earlier
this year. It identified that rail capacity and connectivity
issues need to be addressed in north and south Wales. In
response, the Prime Minister made £20 million available to assess
options on the road and rail schemes, which the review has
identified as crucial for cross-border connectivity. I am glad to
say that my officials are working closely and collaboratively
with the Welsh Government and delivery bodies to identify
potential projects to be supported, in line with our continued
support for the Welsh Government in their ambition to have
greater control over Welsh rail infrastructure. That is evident
in our collaborative approach to working with our partners to
divest the core valley lines to the Welsh Government. We expect
the final Union connectivity review report to be published in the
autumn, when the Government will consider Sir Peter’s
recommendations to improve connectivity across the UK.
I will touch on a few of the investments that are currently under
way. As we speak, important work is going on to transform Cardiff
Central station. The rail network enhancements pipeline has
allocated funding of £5.8 million to Transport for Wales for that
work, supported by funding of £4 million from the Cardiff city
deal. The design and business case work is expected to be
completed next year, and it is an example of the strong
collaboration in place between the UK and Welsh Governments.
The Cambrian line upgrade will bring the line’s digital
signalling up to date. That much-needed upgrade will in turn
enable the introduction of new trains and allow the system to
work seamlessly with other digital signalling schemes. Further
funding for that upgrade has been allocated to deliver the work
by May 2022. A third example of a recent project is the Conwy
valley line, which includes the longest single-track railway
tunnel in the UK. Some £17 million was spent to repair and
restore it, making it fit for passengers again after multiple
floods in the past five years.
Such projects have an enormous effect on communities, and I know
that there will be many more enhancements in the years to come.
The north Wales metro strategy board has been established by
Transport for Wales to integrate the proposals for transport
improvements in the region, building on the exciting
opportunities highlighted by those at Growth Track 360, for
example, whom my hon. Friend the Member for Vale of Clwyd (Dr
Davies) and I met last year, to transform north Wales and deliver
70,000 new jobs over the next 20 years.
The Department for Transport and Network rail are supporting the
work of the board in providing advice on progression of the
programme. There are plans to reduce journey times on the north
Wales coastline between Crewe and Holyhead. The outline business
case proposes an increase in line speeds, with the goal of
improving journey times between north Wales, the north-west of
England and other major UK centres.
Transport for Wales has recently commissioned a further strategic
study into timetable optimisation and connectivity into northern
powerhouse rail and HS2. It will also consider the case for
further infrastructure enhancements including decarbonisation
options for the line. Finally, in March, the Chancellor of the
Exchequer confirmed funding of £30 million for the establishment
of a global centre for rail excellence in Wales.
All the schemes that the Minister has mentioned are extremely
noble, but what is the total percentage allocated to Wales in the
control period? Is the reality not that, compared with
investments across the rest of the UK, especially in HS2, Wales
is being offered crumbs under the table?
I thank the hon. Gentleman for bringing me to that point.
[Interruption.] I have a nosebleed; I will try to power through,
but I apologise for any sniffing, Sir Edward.
(in the Chair)
If you wish to sit down and speak, you may.
It is fine. The Network Rail regulatory financial statements and
expenditure breakdowns show that Wales received around 4% of all
Network Rail spending in 2011-12 to 2015-16, and 6% in 2016-17 to
2018-19. In 2018-19, the spend on Wales was 6.1% of the England
and Wales figure, or 5.4% of the England, Wales and Scotland
figure. The figures include Network Rail’s spending on
operations, maintenance, renewals and enhancements. Does that
clarify the hon. Gentleman’s point?
We understand that to be the total spend, but we also understand
that the spend on investments, development and improvements is
where the spend in Wales is so much spectacularly lower than we
would expect, in terms of the 11% of the rail infrastructure that
we have and in comparison with the conventional Barnett formula
of per head of population.
I thank the right hon. Lady for her point. The UK Government work
collaboratively with the Welsh Government on putting forward
business cases. As she will be aware, we do not allocate set
proportions by region across the United Kingdom; we work on where
the enhancements deliver the best possible value. We have worked
collaboratively with the Welsh Government to bring forward a
number of business cases for further investments. We hope to
continue to do so. The figures I have just outlined show that an
increasing proportion of the Network Rail budget is spent in
Wales—something I am sure the right hon. Lady would welcome.
I want to be clear on this, because that, of course, includes
Barmouth Bridge in my constituency, which is more than 150 years
old. We will have to do work on it, if it is to be maintained as
a line. I take issue with the Minister on levelling up. I rarely
find myself trying to argue the Union point, as I do here, but if
we are talking about levelling up, those areas of the United
Kingdom that most need infrastructure will not receive it unless
it is given by central Government. Wales is a classic example of
this, yet we see that infrastructure investment in railway, the
electricity grid and all the infrastructure needs we will have in
the future to change to net zero—those are the areas where Wales
is lacking. I would welcome the Minister showing us his future
intentions on these arguments.
On this point we are going to have to agree to some extent to
disagree. Through the Union connectivity review, the Government
are demonstrating their real desire to invest more. We are
investing record sums in rail across the whole United Kingdom.
The £4.8 billion levelling up fund, of which at least £800
million will be allocated to projects in Scotland, Wales and
Northern Ireland underlines the Government’s commitment. Changes
to the Green Book will directly help projects in Wales in the way
that I hope they will help projects in the north of England,
where my constituency of Pendle is located.
I think we all share a desire for projects to be moved forward at
pace. As a Rail Minister, I will not argue against even more
investment in rail, but the statistics I have put on record today
show that we are working collaboratively with the Welsh
Government in order to deliver significant projects that the
right hon. Lady’s constituents and other constituents want to see
across Wales.
The Minister will know that, having left the European Union,
Wales will no longer benefit from convergence funding of the
order of billions of pounds and that the UK shared prosperity
fund has not kicked in to do anything about that. He will also
know that convergence funding is focused on alleviating poverty
through building skills and productivity and employment
opportunities. He has also mentioned that the Department for
Transport reaches its criteria on the basis of best value, as
opposed to the criteria for convergence funding. Therefore, will
he look again at those criteria, given that we are losing
convergence funding based on poverty and building productivity,
as opposed to best value, which just rewards existing
productivity? In particular, given that his list of projects
seems to end at Cardiff and, of course, west of Cardiff, there is
a lot of Wales with a lot of needs. As has been pointed out, if
we had had our fair share of HS2, we would have had another £5
billion, which is a lot more than the totality of what he is
talking about.
The hon. Gentleman tempts me to go on to matters that may be
covered in the spending review or the Budget on convergence
funding and other issues. I do not wish to tempt fate by
speculating about what may be announced later this week.
I will just return to the points that were made by several
Members in relation to the Welsh Affairs Committee’s report on
rail infrastructure in Wales. The report emphasised that it is
clear that a joined-up approach to Welsh infrastructure needs is
required in order to unlock investment. Therefore, we have
responded positively to the Committee’s recommendation for a
Wales rail board and are currently working with the Welsh
Government to establish that. The board will build on the
excellent collaborative arrangements in place between the two
Governments to address the effects of the pandemic on transport
in Wales and across the border.
I have tried to cover in detail some of the rail projects and
proposals that are in the pipeline; there are many more that I
could mention. I wanted to do that to give right hon. and hon.
Members a sense of the momentum that is building behind this
work. We all want the same thing: for Wales to benefit from
improved transport infrastructure that will increase productivity
and give people a greener way to travel, leading in many cases to
a better quality of life.
My Department has also been working closely with the Welsh
Government on identifying road investment priorities along the
border between Wales and England. This work has secured joint
funding from both Administrations for National Highways to
develop the long-mooted A483 Pant-Llanymynech bypass. We hope
that further joint funding will be made available for its
construction and to examine the options for other priority
cross-border links. Also, the UK-wide levelling-up fund, which I
mentioned before, will invest £4.8 billion in local
infrastructure, including local transport, regeneration and
culture, over the four years between 2021 and 2025, and at least
£800 million of that will go to Scotland, Wales and Northern
Ireland.
Finally, I turn to HS2. HS2 is a low-carbon transport system for
the future. It will take lorries off the road, benefiting the
whole of the UK in the future and playing a role in achieving our
transition to a carbon net zero future by 2050. HS2 will also
contribute to sustainable growth in towns, cities and regions
across the country, spreading prosperity and opportunity more
evenly.
Let me start by saying something about the costs of HS2, because
they were mentioned by the hon. Member for Swansea West and other
Members. The phase 1 full business case, published in April 2020,
set out the full cost of the HS2 network at £98 billion—a figure
that is, of course, subject to decisions that will be made
shortly in the integrated rail plan. Phase 1 has a target cost of
£40.3 billion, and my parliamentary report last week showed that,
despite covid, delivery remains on track and within budget. The
project also retains cross-party support from the three main UK
political parties.
I recognise that there is some concern, which we have heard again
in this debate from several hon. Members, that Wales may not
benefit from HS2, with the recent Welsh Affairs Committee report
recommending that HS2 be reclassified as an England-only project.
However, the regenerative effects of HS2 will be felt across the
whole of the UK and not just along the line of route. As the
Welsh Affairs Committee report acknowledged, the project has
several thousand jobs as part of its supply chain that span the
UK, including Wales. More than 20 businesses in numerous Welsh
constituencies have already won work for HS2, including
businesses in Bridgend, Montgomeryshire and Swansea West. For
example, I understand that Wernick Buildings, a business based in
Port Talbot, has already worked on HS2. Hon. Members can review
the HS2 supply chain map to see the geographical spread of the
businesses that have delivered work on HS2, including in their
own constituencies.
On the services side, HS2 will enable quicker and more train
services to north Wales. The HS2 route to Crewe, for which the
west midlands-Crewe section gained Royal Assent in February, will
provide shorter journey times for passengers, benefiting those
who are interchanging at Crewe. Such shorter journey times are
currently possible on the west coast main line to Holyhead. HS2
will also free up capacity on the existing west coast main line,
which could of course be used for additional services, including
for rail freight, which will remove lorries from the UK road
network.
Also, as has been pointed out by my hon. Friend the Member for
Montgomeryshire (), HS2 will dramatically
increase capacity for Birmingham, which of course will free up
capacity on the existing lines. That will benefit my hon.
Friend’s constituency.
Turning to the Barnett point made by several right hon. and hon.
Members, the fundamental difference with Scotland is that the
Department for Transport has responsibility for heavy rail
infrastructure policy across England and Wales and therefore
spends money on heavy rail infrastructure in Wales, rather than
providing Barnett-based funding to the Welsh Government in
relation to heavy rail spending in England. That is consistent
with the funding arrangements for all of the reserved UK
Government responsibilities and within the statement of funding
policy.
However, due to the use of departmental comparability factors in
the Barnett formula spending reviews, the Welsh Government have
actually received a significant uplift in their Barnett-based
funding due to the UK Government spending on HS2. I hope that
reassures Members as to why there is a difference. I have set out
how we are expanding the amount of network rail funding that is
going into Wales. On top of that, there have been significant
Barnett consequentials provided to the Welsh Government.
To conclude and to reiterate, investing in Welsh transport
infrastructure is an investment in future generations. Ensuring
that our transport capability matches our great ambitions for our
constituents’ prosperity and wellbeing is a priority for the
Government, and one that I know all Members across the House
share. We owe it to our hard-working constituents to invest in
the most sustainable forms of transport for the future,
delivering both on the green industrial revolution and on our
pledge to build back better from the events of the past two
years.
10:56:00
This has been a very good debate. The Minister hit the nail on
the head when he spoke of the structural difference in
responsibility between Scotland and Wales. The Scottish
Government have got responsibility for heavy investment. If we
had that in the Welsh Government, we would have our £5 billion.
It is still technically possible that if the comparability
factors were changed in the formula to be an England-only
project, which it could be, we would also have the £5 billion
there. Nobody is saying that we are getting no investment in
Wales, but we are trying to head towards net zero, deliver higher
productivity and level up. I ask the Minister and his Department
to think again, to lobby the Chancellor to change the formula and
to give Wales the tools to do the job, getting us on the rails to
a higher, more prosperous future. I thank all Members and you,
Sir Edward, for chairing the debate. It will continue, because we
are simply not getting our fair share, and we need it in order to
succeed.
Question put and agreed to.
Resolved,
That this House has considered transport funding for Wales and
HS2.
|