Asked by
To ask Her Majesty’s Government what plans they have to ensure
music and the arts are prioritised in schools and other
educational settings in England.
(Lab)
My Lords, we have seen a 50% reduction—Oh, sorry! I beg leave to
ask the Question in my name.
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department for
Education () (Con)
My Lords, it is an exciting and important subject. The Government
have committed to high-quality music and arts education from an
early age. All state-funded schools and early-years providers are
required to teach a broad and balanced curriculum, including the
arts and music, which promotes pupils’ cultural development. The
department funds a range of related programmes, including music
hubs. We recently published the Model Music Curriculum to support
teachers and will publish a refreshed national plan for music
education next year.
(Lab)
My Lords, let us try again. I thank the noble Baroness for her
Answer. We have seen a 50% reduction in arts subjects at
universities over recent years. With numbers of pupils studying
drama and music falling by a fifth since 2010, our education
system faces a creative crisis. Even more worryingly, we have
seen a 31% decline in the number of young people taking music
A-levels in England since 2014. Considering that the creative
industries contribute over £11 billion a year to the UK economy,
what plans do Her Majesty’s Government have to ensure that the
number of pupils studying drama and music does not drop any
further? Could I also briefly ask about the arts pupil premium in
the spending review?
(Con)
The noble Lord is right that the number of students doing A-level
arts subjects has dropped, but there are some really encouraging
signs in the data. The number of students doing art and design
GCSE, which could be a precursor to a pick-up in A-levels, has
increased by 18% over the past two years while the cohort has
grown by 7%. The number doing vocational and technical
qualifications in music has risen by 90% between 2017 and
2020.
(Con)
Does my noble friend agree that it is vital for young musicians
to be able to play in orchestras and ensembles? Does she regret,
as I do, that only 12% of state schools now have orchestras, as
opposed to 85% of independent schools? I remind the House of my
registered interest as chairman of the English Schools’
Orchestra.
(Con)
My noble friend is right to raise the important role of
orchestras in schools, but the Government’s focus has been to
ensure that there is a consistent cultural offer, a range of arts
and musical subjects and opportunities for children to play a
musical instrument at school whether it be in an orchestra or in
some other form, maybe a band.
(CB)
My Lords, we heard again this weekend that the Government are
considering further limiting the study of creative arts degrees
because of their lower salary outcomes. Does the Minister agree
that salary data is not the only way to assess value, even
economic value, as it ignores differences in local labour markets
and degrees that lead to low earnings but deliver high social and
cultural value? With almost half of creative businesses reporting
workforce skills gaps, is it not reasonable to assume that
creative graduates will provide tangible fiscal value through
labour in this high-growth sector, not to mention their
contribution of future skills and creativity to the broader
innovation economy?
(Con)
The noble Baroness is right that we need to look at
qualifications more broadly than simply the financial and
earnings potential of those careers. However, I am sure she will
also agree with me that we need to meet a significant skills
shortage in STEM and related subjects. I hope she will be pleased
that the Government are bringing forward a T-level in craft and
design which has been developed with employers.
of Hudnall (Lab)
My Lords, I remind the House of my interests in the register.
There are many ways of learning, but over the past decade
education policy has privileged one kind—the ability to acquire
knowledge by rote and reproduce it under time pressure—over all
others. Your Lordships’ House’s Select Committee on Youth
Unemployment, of which I am a member, has had evidence from many
employers that shows that this is not enough and that they are
looking for people who can also think critically and
independently, communicate clearly and work well with other
people. Does the noble Baroness agree that these are precisely
the attributes that arts-led education encourages?
(Con)
The noble Baroness is right that arts-led education encourages
those traits, but not only arts-led education encourages critical
thinking. I think that she does the teaching profession a
disservice; perhaps she would like to join me on a visit to a
school to see how little is being done by rote.
(LD)
My Lords, the Minister will know from her time at DCMS the
importance of creative and arts subjects and their importance to
the British economy. Is she concerned that there has been a 24%
drop in all six creative subjects over the past five years? How
does she view the EBacc’s responsibility for the demise of all
our creative subjects?
(Con)
The Government do not accept that the EBacc has contributed to a
decline in the adoption of creative subjects. The percentage of
children doing an arts subject to GCSE has remained broadly
stable over the last 10 years. The EBacc mandatory curriculum is
intentionally focused to give space for other subjects.
(CB)
Does the Minister agree that the creative minds of the future
will need a synthesis of the arts and the sciences because that
is the way the world is going? This division between arts and
science will disappear in 50 or 100 years. That is where we need
to go. We need to take the example of, for instance, the Bauhaus
100 years ago or even Professor JD Bernal, who was talking about
this in the 1930s.
(Con)
The creative industries are a great example, as a number of noble
Lords have recognised today, of that fusion of artistic and other
technical and scientific disciplines. That is why the Government
are committed to having a range of arts subjects as a core part
of the curriculum from early years to GCSEs.
(Con)
My Lords, I declare my interest as a trustee of the brilliant
charity Music Masters and welcome my noble friend to her new
portfolio, which I know she will attack with the vigour she
showed when she was in the culture department. I was thrilled to
hear that on the 10th anniversary of music education hubs next
year there will be a refreshed national plan for music education.
Can she assure us that the budget of £75 million a year will at
least be maintained and that we will continue to support the In
Harmony scheme as part of the national plan?
(Con)
My noble friend will understand that I cannot announce the
national plan before it has been published, but I hope that he
will be delighted when he sees the plan in its detail, with its
focus on disadvantaged children.
(CB)
My Lords, arts help to transcend differences and divisions—they
help to unite—but the increased focus on STEM subjects and the
greater value put on the English baccalaureate have led to a
narrowing of the curriculum and disproportionately affected arts
education, particularly in disadvantaged areas. There was a
manifesto commitment to a secondary school arts premium, which
was confirmed in the 2020 Budget. When will the £90 million arts
premium materialise?
(Con)
The noble Baroness will understand that I cannot prejudge the
announcements from the Chancellor on Wednesday. When my noble
friend Lady Berridge was in this role, she was clear that choices
had to be made as a result of the pandemic—hence the delay.
(Lab)
My Lords, the Minister needs to go back to her officials at the
DfE if the figures she has been given suggest that the number of
pupils sitting GCSEs and A-levels in arts subjects has not
dropped in the last decade, because that is very definitely not
the case; it is not what schools report. The English
baccalaureate is definitely to blame, because it has narrowed the
curriculum and does not include creative subjects.
The 2019 Tory manifesto said that
“we will offer an ‘arts premium’ to secondary schools”
to allow them to offer
“enriching activities for all pupils.”
It has not happened, and Covid cannot be blamed because last year
the Chancellor said in his Budget that a £90 million arts premium
would be introduced. That has not happened either. While I know
the Minister cannot predict what will happen on Wednesday, if the
spending review were to announce spending on an arts premium,
should we believe it this time?
(Con)
I apologise to the noble Lord if I was not clear. I hoped I had
acknowledged that A-level numbers have dropped but that GCSE
figures have been broadly stable with around 45% of children in
state-funded schools, both academies and maintained schools,
doing an arts subject.
I cannot add to my earlier answer on the arts premium, but I
remind the noble Lord that we committed £79 million during
2021-22 for music education hubs and during the pandemic
emphasised the importance of continuing with a culturally rich
curriculum.