– The current concern over freedom of speech and expression is
focused most notably on higher education.
– The problems result not from a lack of intellectual diversity
in individual institutions, but rather from a lack of diversity
in the sector as a whole.
– While there are two competing factions seeking to restrict
freedom of expression – populist conservatives and radical
leftists – it is the so-called ‘woke’ or ‘social justice’ left
that is gaining the most traction in universities. People from
this class of graduate professional are overrepresented in the
media, publishing, academia and politics, and compete for social
status.
– The current system does not encourage the creation of new
institutions that challenge these orthodoxies, because the
dominant role of government funding in HE disincentivises
competition.
– Further, the central purpose of universities has shifted away
from scholarships, research and debate to certifying young people
for the job market.
– The predatory legal culture in the US, where we see free
expression stifled for fear of costly lawsuits, also has an
enormous influence on restricting freedom of expression.
New research from the
Institute of Economic Affairs places freedom of expression on
campus within a historical context, underscores that the current
problem is the lack of intellectual diversity not within any
single university but rather across faculties at a range of
institutions, and notes that higher education (HE) is not at the
centre of this problem. Rather, it is where a wider problem is
manifesting itself most dramatically.
Author Dr Stephen Davies, IEA Head of Education and former Senior
Lecturer in the Department of History and Economic History at
Manchester Metropolitan University, begins by examining progress
made over the past 250 years. As a combination of technological
change and active campaigns for free expression, a principle of
the right to free speech was established.
But this has never been absolute and unlimited, because that
right is always qualified by other ones, such as private
property, freedom of association and freedom of contract. Direct
measures by governments to impose on universities a duty to
provide a platform for speakers are an unwarranted imposition on
private bodies.
Grounds
for debate: The challenges to free speech in
universities argues that the current problems come
primarily from the lack of intellectual diversity in the HE
sector as a whole, and the lack of diversity between
institutions. If the range of views that we find in the press or
think tanks existed in HE, then one institution having 90 per
cent of its faculty with the same kind of political views would
matter vastly less. The real problem is that the ideological
orientation of the whole range of institutions is so similar.
The question Davies therefore poses is: why have new, alternative
institutions not been set up? First, the overwhelmingly dominant
role of government funding in HE disincentivises investors, and
possibly faculty, from eschewing the current orthodoxy. Second,
HE’s role in the contemporary world has shifted. The good or
service provided is no longer scholarship or research or debate
but rather the certifying of young people. It’s the signal that
will enable them to access higher-paid roles. This creates a high
barrier to entry because, without official recognition, creators
of new institutions could not fulfil that duty. That failure
would be reflected in its ability to attract both students and
finance.
This is just one of two wider problems facing free discussion and
expression – the other is the predatory and dysfunctional
American legal system. Many of the actions against freedom of
expression come not from governments but private firms and
institutions such as university administrations. The fear of
costly lawsuits brought in America ripples out to any firm that
trades in the US or has business relations with institutions
there.
Perhaps most importantly, Davies reminds us that this topic is
constantly in the news not because of an overwhelmingly
powerful movement imposing a set of parameters on thought, but
rather the opposite. That we have controversy and debate, that
there are many people and resources challenging any one position,
suggests that no single group will succeed in forcing their
chosen limits.
The likely outcome will be a process of ‘pillarisation’, with the
consolidation of distinct intellectual and cultural cultures.
This might be preferable to outright authoritarian censorship –
but, as Davies warns, it would still be costly in terms of
reducing the amount of cultural and intellectual innovation that
takes place.