Asked by
To ask Her Majesty’s Government what support they are providing
to universities to assist them in dealing with the impact of the
COVID-19 pandemic.
(LD) [V]
I beg leave to ask the Question standing in my name on the Order
Paper, and in doing so I declare an interest as Chancellor of
Cardiff University.
(Con)
My Lords, in May we announced a package of stabilisation measures
to ensure that we continue to look after the best interests of
students, as well as supporting our world-class higher education
system. We are bringing forward £2.6 billion of forecast tuition
fee payments to help universities manage cash flow and provide
support to students, and £100 million to help protect vital
university research activities in England. We have also
established a ministerial task force on research stabilisation.
[V]
My Lords, the Government’s recent announcement provides little
new money, and 75% of that will be in loans. Universities’
research is heavily subsidised by international student fee
income, which is predicted to drop by £2 billion this year. Many
universities have made massive contributions of equipment,
research and staffing to the fight against coronavirus. Does the
Minister accept that they now need a much more ambitious package
of support, because they are making research and staff cutbacks
at this moment?
The noble Baroness is absolutely right to point out the vital
contribution that universities are making to solving the
pandemic, which is putting pressures on them as well as on
everybody else. She referred to the further package of support
which the Government announced this weekend. In addition to
bringing forward the tuition fee payments which I mentioned in my
Answer, the Government are providing a package of support to
universities to continue research and innovation. That includes
£280 million of taxpayer funding available to sustain UK Research
and Innovation and national academy grant-funded research, which
is available immediately. From the autumn, there is a further
package consisting of low-interest loans with long payback
periods and supplemented by a further amount of government
grants. I am therefore not sure that I accept what she says about
the Government’s response being inadequate.
[V]
My Lords, universities make a significant contribution to their
local communities and economies, particularly smaller
institutions that attract a larger proportion of students from
disadvantaged backgrounds. These make a significant contribution
to their local context, particularly in this pandemic. In
particular, several Cathedrals Group universities during the
2018-19 academic year had 20% undergraduate students from
low-participation—POLAR4—backgrounds. How will the Government
work with higher education institutions to maintain the widening
of access and retention of students, especially those preparing
for key public service roles that have been so important during
this pandemic crisis?
The right reverend Prelate is absolutely right to point out the
vital contribution made by smaller and specialist higher
education providers; I know there are a number in his own
diocese, as there are around the country. He is right too to
point out the importance of encouraging people from all
backgrounds to continue to go to university and to avail
themselves of the benefits that it can bring. That is why I am
pleased that higher education providers can draw on existing
funding, which is worth around £23 million a month at the moment,
to provide hardship funds and support for disadvantaged students
who are particularly affected by Covid-19.
(Con) [V]
My Lords, I declare my interest as chairman of the Royal College
of Music. Music conservatoires have been particularly seriously
impacted by the emergency. As small institutions, they do not
have the scale, financial headroom or borrowing capacity of the
large universities, or significant research income, and are
highly dependent on tuition fees, including from a high
proportion of international students. As the future on that front
is so uncertain, does my noble friend agree that there is an
overwhelming case for a temporary increase in the specialist
institutional funding which is essential to their sustainability?
That would be a clear sign of the Government’s commitment to
music and the wider creative economy.
My noble friend is absolutely right to draw your Lordships’
attention to the huge value of small and specialist providers
such as music conservatoires, which have such benefits for
society, our culture and indeed our economy. As chairman of the
Royal College of Music, he is a redoubtable champion for such
institutions. Like all higher education providers, these
institutions are eligible for the business support schemes, like
any other business. However, I hope I can reassure him that the
Government are working closely with higher education providers of
all shapes and sizes to make sure that things such as our visa
regulations are as flexible as possible for international
students in these unprecedented circumstances.
(CB) [V]
My Lords, many university students in England have been missing
tuition and access to libraries, laboratories and other
university facilities, and may face financial hardship. The
Minister says that the Government will not cut the amount paid to
universities in tuition fees, but will they reduce sums to be
recovered from formerly affected students in later life?
The noble and gallant Lord is right to point out some of the many
ways in which the university experience is being affected by this
pandemic with regard to access to libraries, laboratories and so
on. I am pleased that universities across the sector have
responded swiftly and creatively to ensure that they remain open
and that students can continue to avail themselves of
high-quality education. Universities are autonomous and
responsible for setting their own fees, and of course, as they
approach the forthcoming academic year, if they decide to charge
full fees, they will want to ensure that they can continue to
deliver courses which are fit for purpose and which help students
to progress their qualifications. However, any matter regarding
the level of those fees and refunds is first and foremost for the
providers and those who apply to them.
(Lab) [V]
My Lords, I declare my interest as a trustee of LAMDA. In the
absence of more appropriate emergency grant funding to compensate
for irrecoverable loss of revenues, the Government have
encouraged universities to apply for business interruption loans.
How does the Minister think these loans, designed for
profit-making companies, can be repaid by non-profit HE
institutions, other than at the expense of the quality of courses
for future generations of students?
The noble Viscount rightly points out that universities, like
other businesses, whether they make profits or not, are eligible
to apply to the Government’s business support schemes. However,
he is also right to point out the wider societal benefits that
universities bring, which is why the Government brought forward
the additional package of measures which I outlined in my Answer.
(LD)
My Lords, what plans do the Government have to reform student and
university funding to enable a greater number of people,
especially mature learners, to undertake short higher education
courses and build up to a full degree in a way that suits them?
That will be increasingly important as individuals reskill post
Covid.
The noble Baroness is absolutely right that many mature students
and others may wish to consider courses of different lengths and
varieties, and the Government are glad to see that wide range of
courses offered. As she says, that will be particularly important
over the coming months. The package of support which the
Government have announced is of course available to providers
irrespective of the length and format of the courses they offer.
(Con) [V]
My Lords, I declare an interest as an academic at the University
of Hull and as chair of the Higher Education Commission, which
produced a report on the value to the United Kingdom of the
export of higher education. Given how crucial that export is and
that from next year EU students will no longer be subject to home
fees, will the Government consider extending the new graduate
route post-study work visa to three or four years to ensure that
the United Kingdom has a competitive offer to international
students?
My noble friend draws attention to the new graduate route which
comes into effect from next summer, which allows people
graduating from UK universities to stay here in work of any level
and any remuneration for up to two years—an increased and very
generous offer. That is part of the Government’s ambition to
increase the number of international students coming to study
here in the United Kingdom.