Extract from Scottish Parliament Questions: Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform - Dec 4
|
Oil and Gas Industry (Emissions) 3. Liam Kerr (North East Scotland)
(Con): To ask the Scottish Government what its response is to
Oil & Gas UK’s “Environment Report 2018”, which highlights a
commitment to “playing its part in building a sustainable industry
that is progressively lowering its emission intensity”. (S5O-03851)
The Cabinet Secretary for Environment, Climate Change and Land
Reform (Roseanna Cunningham): I...Request free trial
Oil and Gas Industry (Emissions)3. Liam Kerr (North East Scotland) (Con): To ask the Scottish Government what its response is to Oil & Gas UK’s “Environment Report 2018”, which highlights a commitment to “playing its part in building a sustainable industry that is progressively lowering its emission intensity”. (S5O-03851) The Cabinet Secretary for Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform (Roseanna Cunningham): I welcome the industry’s commitment to lowering the industry’s offshore emissions. We are committed to achieving a net zero emissions economy and managing that fairly. North Sea production is highly regulated, with some of the most advanced, and comparatively least polluting, production methods in the world. Maintaining domestic oil and gas production can lead to lower net global emissions. We are supportive of the sector’s plans to decarbonise oil and gas production and we want to engage the industry in embracing and leading deployment of technologies such as floating offshore wind power, Hydrogen production and carbon capture, utilisation and storage. Liam Kerr: Statistics that were published by the Government in September 2019 state that, last year, 82 per cent of all UK oil and gas was produced in Scotland and that production increased by 4.6 per cent. Scotland employs 39 per cent of the oil and gas industry in the UK and the north-east is a focal point for that activity. Will the cabinet secretary rule out supporting any proposals for a windfall tax that would risk 26,000 jobs in Aberdeen alone and potentially reverse the good work on emissions that she mentioned? Roseanna Cunningham: Frankly, I am not sure that it is within my remit to talk about any tax in that regard, and I am sure that proposals for taxes are being looked at very carefully across the board. As Liam Kerr knows, there is no devolved ability for us to do any such thing in Scotland—yet. So, at the moment, his question is somewhat premature. Claudia Beamish (South Scotland) (Lab): Following on from the Offshore Europe conference in September, when the oil and gas industry set out its road map to a more sustainable future, will the cabinet secretary tell us whether—and how—the Scottish Government might be able to advise, monitor and assess the progress of the industry as it shifts towards net zero? Roseanna Cunningham: We have a constant dialogue with the industry, which is clearly a key industry in Scotland. We want to ensure that it is able to continue to operate as effectively as possible while reducing its emissions from production. As Liam Kerr knows, there are two aspects to oil and gas: the consumption side and the production side. On the production side, industries are working very hard to get their carbon emissions down as quickly as possible. They are focused on working towards net zero in terms of production, and we will continue to work directly with them on that. That is important, because it is a key industry. There are a number of aspects of the industry that, for Scotland, go beyond what the member asked about. As she is aware, when we talk about oil and gas in Scotland, there is an issue of just transition. We have to handle the whole industry very carefully. The dialogue is constant. Patrick Harvie (Glasgow) (Green): That measure of carbon intensity tells us nothing at all about the actual impact of the fossil fuel industry and the materials that it extracts from the ground. Given that we are in a climate emergency, when we are talking about carbon extraction we need a response that is more robust than the thin greenwash of talking about net zero. Does the cabinet secretary recognise that more than 5 per cent of the world’s gross domestic product is spent on fossil fuel subsidies? When will the Scottish Government recognise that we need to redirect that vast flow of money into the transition that is needed, instead of keeping business as usual for the lethal fossil fuel industry? Roseanna Cunningham: I do not think that there is anything going on that might be regarded as “business as usual”. The industry is working very hard to reduce its emissions. We are very aware that there will be a continued role for oil and gas, until we are able to move consumption away from fossil fuels completely. Any suggestion that one can switch away from that consumption before we are able to make the handover misunderstands the massive disruption that would take place and the likelihood of importation from other countries, whose industries are not decarbonising in the way that North Sea oil and gas are. It is a complex issue, which we continue to address as carefully as possible, but if Patrick Harvie has seen the evidence at the Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform Committee from Chris Stark and David Joffe from the Committee on Climate Change, he will understand that it is far more complicated than he makes out. Maureen Watt (Aberdeen South and North Kincardine) (SNP): Does the cabinet secretary agree that by ring fencing the current tax revenues from oil and gas and investing in a just transition, we can support long-term investments to tackle the climate crisis and deliver benefits to communities and our environment? Roseanna Cunningham: Most of us in this chamber accept that the oil and gas sector is a key component of our economy and remains integral to a sustainable, secure and inclusive energy transition. The Office for Budget Responsibility estimates that the North Sea will generate further revenues of £8.5 billion over the next five years. Ring fencing those revenues into a net zero fund would indeed unlock significant additional investment into efforts to decarbonise the economy and would also help to deliver a just transition for areas such as Aberdeen and the north-east that currently rely heavily on the oil and gas sector for employment. |
