The Augar Review did not take a holistic approach to the funding of
universities and made no attempt to assess the potential impact of
its recommended changes on the funding of research in
universities. The result is a distorted assessment of the
sector's financial health as a whole, the House of
Lords Science and Technology Committee warn its report.
The Augar Review recommended reducing the tuition fee cap in
England to £7,500 but unless this loss is fully compensated by
increasing the teaching grant to individual institutions, it will
result in significant financial consequences for universities.
Any loss in funding would require universities to divert other
income streams to support teaching, reducing the resources
available to support research. The panel made no attempt to
assess the potential impact of its recommended reductions in
student fees on the funding of research.
The inquiry also found that Quality-Related (QR) funding,
a significant element of the funding provided to universities to
support research, has fallen 12.8% in real terms since 2010,
adding increased pressure to the ability of universities to
conduct high-quality scientific research.
If the Government is to follow any of the recommendations
of the Augar Review relating to tuition fees, it must implement
them as a full financial package, including increasing the
teaching grant to cover the loss of tuition fees, to ensure that
universities are no worse off than they are now. The Government
should also address the deficit in QR funding, and should commit
to increasing QR funding at least in line with the rate of
inflation.
, Chair of the Committee,
said:
“The Augar Review has completely missed the mark by not
considering research funding in its review. By ignoring research
and cross-subsidies, it has made recommendations which, if
implemented, could prove harmful to the already challenging
ecosystem of university funding.
“We heard evidence that a university’s core
operational activities of teaching and research are both
loss-making activities already and any shortfall in funding would
become unmanageable. The immediate casualties will likely be
widening-participation programmes, student experience,
infrastructure maintenance and repair, and the hands-on elements
of courses.
“Without adequate research funding, the consequences for the UK
will be devastating and the UK risks falling behind other
countries. The Government intends to spend 2.4% GDP on research
and development by 2027, but we conclude that it will be
extremely difficult to meet this target unless funding for
research in universities is secured and the UK can attract
researchers from overseas.”
The Committee also address further issues facing science
research funding in universities including:
-
Brexit - Retaining the mobility of
researchers after Brexit is vital to ensuring the UK can
continue to attract the best researchers and meet its research
and development goals. The Government must ensure post-Brexit
immigration laws do not hinder the ability of UK universities
to recruit and retain the scientific staff they require,
including technicians earning below the recommended salary
threshold.
-
Loss of EU funding - The Government
should ensure that once the UK has left the EU the level of
funding the UK currently receives from the EU for research is
matched in full. As the UK is a net beneficiary of EU research
funding this amount will be greater than the amount the UK
currently contributes to the EU research pot.