A charity set up to help people in Gaza may not have conducted
any charitable activity or distributed any humanitarian aid,
according to a highly critical report by the Charity Commission.
The charity regulator has published the findings of its inquiry
into Viva Palestina, and has concluded that its trustees put
publicly donated funds at risk as a result of their mismanagement
and/or misconduct.
The regulator finds that the trustees failed to fulfil their
legal duties including to maintain proper financial records,
safeguard the charity’s assets, provide financial accounts, and
to address concerns raised by the regulator.
Whilst the inquiry saw some evidence that monies had been used to
purchase medical supplies in line with the charity’s objects, the
Commission concludes that the charity’s financial and other
records were so poor that “it was difficult to establish with any
certainty whether any charitable activity had taken place” and
that the inquiry found “little or no evidence that humanitarian
aid was distributed to those in need”.
The Commission did establish, however, that one of the charity’s
former trustees had received payments from the charity and that
mobile phones and radios were purchased with charity funds at
“significant expenditure”. There are no records of where these
assets are now held.
Viva Palestina began in 2009 as a large scale fundraising
campaign to finance aid convoys to Gaza. Its founders did not
originally apply to register the organisation as a charity; the
Commission formed the view that it was a charity and must
therefore be registered.
The Commission says it found a lack of clarity among the former
trustees as to who was responsible for the charity’s day-to-day
running. It concluded that the trustees “failed to act with
reasonable care and skill in the control of their charity’s funds
and the charity’s day-to-day management”, which it says amounts
to misconduct and/or mismanagement.
Michelle Russell, Director of Investigations, Monitoring and
Enforcement at the Charity Commission said:
Our investigation into Viva Palestina found that it was a
wholly inadequately managed charity. A trustee is by its name a
trusted position, acting for the public benefit to help others.
The public has a right to expect that those who serve as
charity trustees take their responsibilities seriously,
properly accounting for the charity’s income, assets,
activities and its expenditure. This didn’t happen in the case
of Viva Palestina. Our inquiry shows that the former trustees
did not pay proper attention to the legal responsibilities
involved in running a charity and handling funds donated by the
public. We found little evidence that the intended
beneficiaries received the support intended, despite the
extensive fundraising by Viva Palestina. The former trustees
thus badly let down the public to whom the charity is
accountable.
Among the issues highlighted in the Commission’s report are:
- unauthorised payments: one former employee claimed that they
had been instructed to make financial transactions by one of the
founders and a former trustee of Viva Palestina, who had no
authority to do so
- lack of proper control over employment: the same individual
also claimed that they had been instructed by the same founder
and former trustee to resign as a trustee and assume duties as a
paid employee. The Commission saw no evidence that the trustees
made such an appointment properly
- lack of oversight over assets
- appoint an Interim Manager (IM) – an IM was appointed in 2014
to take over the management and administration of the charity.
Her role included compiling accounts for years ending 2010, 2011,
2012 and 2013, taking control of the charity’s bank accounts and
examining further the financial management and controls at the
charity
- obtain the charity’s bank records – the inquiry exercised its
formal information gathering powers to obtain the charity’s bank
account records
- freeze bank accounts – the inquiry also used its power to
prevent the charity’s bank from parting with funds without the
Commission’s consent
- direct the trustees to take action – including using its
power to direct the trustees to provide the charity’s overdue
annual accounts and provide documents, records and explanations
about the charity’s expenditure, financial management and
administration of the charity
The Charity Commission’s investigation opened in June 2013, three
years after it published a report on a previous investigation
into the charity. The Commission initially sought to resolve its
regulatory concerns outside of a formal inquiry, but opened a new
inquiry when it was unable to obtain the necessary information.