3. (Highlands and Islands)
(Lab): To ask the Scottish Government what action it plans
to take in light of the Scottish Affairs Committee’s evidence
session on seasonal agricultural workers. (S5O-03224)
The Cabinet Secretary for the Rural Economy (Fergus
Ewing): Seasonal migrant workers make a vital
contribution to farming and food production in Scotland, and we
share the concerns of the
NFU Scotland about the availability of
suitably skilled workers, and the risk that that presents to this
year’s crops and harvests.
The United Kingdom Government’s
future migration proposals do not meet Scotland’s needs. The
evidence that was presented to the Scottish Affairs Committee
highlights serious issues with the pilot scheme, which seeks to
recruit 2,500 workers for the whole of the UK—not enough to
meet the number of current vacancies in the horticulture sector
in Angus alone.
We will continue to monitor the
situation and to work across Government to address skills and
employment needs throughout the rural economy, but it is clear
that one of the key solutions is to fully devolve immigration
powers so that Scotland might develop a tailored migration
policy to meet our needs.
: Seasonal
agricultural workers are often seen as low-paid and low-skilled.
However, all the evidence suggests that many of the jobs that
they do are highly skilled. Losing those workers will not only be
a hard blow to employers and their local economies, but will have
a significant knock-on effect in terms of depopulation of already
fragile remote communities.
Will the cabinet secretary join me
in supporting the workers in Europe and beyond who form a vital
part of the backbone of rural Scotland by providing skilled
labour and injecting a breath of fresh air into our rural
communities?
: I am happy to agree
with and am pleased that he has
made those remarks.
Those workers work extremely hard.
Certainly in berry picking, the day starts very early, the
conditions are tough and the work is hard. We really appreciate
and welcome what those people do and the contribution that they
make to the economy of, and society in, rural Scotland. We
think that they should continue to be welcomed in Scotland.
That is why it is important that freedom of movement continues
to be our policy. I very much hope that the in Scotland will support
freedom of movement, because Mr Corbyn seems not to support
it.
(Uddingston and Bellshill)
(SNP): Will the cabinet
secretary agree that it is scandalous that three years after the
Brexit vote farmers still do not, due to Tory inaction, have any
certainty or clarity about their workforces? Scandalous!
[Laughter.]
: Mr Lyle has made the
point clearly. I see that the Tories are laughing. I do not know
why: this is a serious matter. Just about every employer in the
rural economy has been making the same point for three years now.
In those three years, a solution could have been found that would
enable people from other countries who work hard in rural
communities—whose work is indispensable and is a sine qua non of
the functioning of the rural economy—to continue to do so, but
the Scottish Tories have said nothing about it during that time.
It is an absolute scandal; Mr Lyle is quite right.