-
Survey finds people believe system is tilted in favour
of wealthy
-
Few have confidence to run cases without a
lawyer
-
Strong support for free legal advice for those on low
incomes
-
Policies to cut justice budgets out of step with public
opinion
Justice is as important to most people as health and education,
according to far-reaching research into public attitudes to the
justice system in England and Wales, but only 20% think
there is sufficient funding in place for those who need legal
advice.
The survey of 2,086 people also revealed an alarmingly widespread
belief that justice favours the wealthy.
The Populus survey was commissioned by the Law Society, Bar
Council and Chartered Institute of Legal Executives (CILEx) to
mark the launch of Justice Week, a week of events and activities
to boost the profile of justice and the rule of law.
The insights into public attitudes come after successive
Governments have restricted access to justice more than at any
time since legal aid was established in 1949, and indicate that
policies to slash Ministry of Justice and legal aid budgets are
in fact out of step with public opinion.
Justice Week will run between Monday 29 October and Friday 2
November.
The survey found that:
- 78% agreed that
‘Justice is just as important as health or education’
- 76% agreed that
‘People on low incomes should be able to get free legal advice’
- 63% said they
would feel uncomfortable dealing with the law and legal processes
themselves if they were accused of a crime for which a judge
could impose a custodial sentence
- Only 13% agreed
that ‘the state should not have to pay for people’s legal
expenses if they are accused of an offence that could earn jail
time’
For all types of legal issues listed by the survey, at least 50%
of respondents said they would feel ‘uncomfortable’ dealing with
them without a lawyer, and for no legal issue did more than 25%
say they would feel ‘comfortable’.
The findings also revealed that 60% of respondents agreed that
‘people on low incomes are more likely to be convicted of crimes
than wealthy people’.
Law Society president Christina Blacklaws said:
“Cuts to legal aid spending over the past five years have denied
justice to the most vulnerable in society, placed a further
burden on the taxpayer and damaged the foundation of our justice
system.
“Since April 2013, hundreds of thousands of people have become
ineligible for legal aid as a result of freezes to means tests as
well as cuts to the scope of legal aid, including victims of
domestic abuse and people under threat of eviction.”
Chair of the Bar, Andrew Walker QC, said: “While
it is increasingly recognised across the world that an effective
and accessible justice system is fundamental to a fair and
peaceful society, a successful economy and a functioning
democracy, many parts of our own justice system have reached
breaking point. Not for over 50 years has there been a more
pressing need to make the case that a properly funded system of
justice is at the core of a democratic government’s obligations
to its own people.
“This survey shows that the public really does care about justice
and thinks that politicians do not prioritise it as they
should. There is now a gulf between what people expect from
our justice system, and what they are getting. We do not
leave the ill to treat themselves without expert medical help, so
nor should we expect people to deal with legal problems and
disputes without expert legal help if they cannot afford
it. As the survey confirms, most of the public do not
expect this, yet increasing numbers are being forced to represent
themselves in court in very serious and complicated matters such
as family separations or disputes with an employer, and far too
many are now having to defend themselves in criminal
proceedings.”
CILEx President, Philip Sherwood said: “These
findings should alarm anyone with an interest in justice. Given
the legal aid cuts, a perception that the system is tilted in
favour of the wealthy may not be surprising, but it is extremely
dangerous and undermines the rule of law. It is incumbent on
lawyers and politicians alike to ensure the system is open and
fair to all.”
A Justice Week petition calling on the Government to
extend the availability of legal aid is now
online: https://chn.ge/2OLpovH