Extracts from Wales Assembly topical questions: Direct Payments for Farmers - Oct 24
|
Llyr Gruffydd AM: Will the Cabinet Secretary confirm whether
her comments in the Farmers Guardian on 18 October, in which she
stated that she will not consider maintaining some form of direct
payment for farmers, even if the majority of respondents to 'Brexit
and our Land' requested it, is the Welsh Government’s
position? ...Request free trial
Llyr Gruffydd
AM: Will the Cabinet Secretary
confirm whether her comments in the Farmers Guardian on
18 October, in which she stated that she will not
consider maintaining some form of direct payment for
farmers, even if the majority of respondents to 'Brexit
and our Land' requested it, is the Welsh Government’s
position?
Lesley Griffiths AM
(Cabinet Secretary for Energy, Planning and
Rural Affairs): Thank you. Welsh Government
has always been clear the basic payment scheme is
ending. As set out in 'Brexit and our Land', I
propose to replace the common agricultural policy in
its entirety. The consultation is ongoing and I will
consider responses before making decisions. No changes
to farm payments will be made without further
consultation.
Llyr Gruffydd
AM: Well, I have the article here.
You've just told us that you will consider responses,
but here you say,
'Asked whether she would consider maintaining some form of direct payment if the vast majority of respondents to the consultation requested it, she said: “No"'. Now, only last week you were trying to rewrite history about what Sue Hayman had said in comments about payments in England, and today you're trying to maybe rewrite a little history here in terms of what you said as well. You're starting to sound a bit like a Welsh Donald Trump, I venture to say. And it does have the feel of a bad joke about it, doesn't it, really? When is a consultation not a consultation? Well, when the Cabinet Secretary has clearly decided exactly what she's going to do regardless of what anybody says. And that's not a good look, is it? You've really botched this process, I venture to say. First, it was your intervention with your letter midway through the consultation to farmers intervening and influencing the discussion then, and now you're saying that, regardless of what people say, you're not going to listen to their views. So, how can the public have confidence in this process, Cabinet Secretary? Do not your comments undermine the whole validity of your public consultation—or so-called public consultation? And does it not bring into question the integrity of the Welsh Government's engagement with stakeholders on this issue?
Lesley Griffiths
AM: 'Not at all' is the short
answer to your question. Let me put a few of those
points you raised right. As I said, way before the
consultation started, we always said that the basic
payment scheme would end. We believe that it's not the
best design to support our farmers—
[Interruption.] If the Member would like to
listen. [Interruption.]
So if you want to listen, we said before the
consultation started basic payment schemes would end.
I've been clear on numerous occasions—you will have
heard me say it at the Royal Welsh Show, you will have
heard me say it in the Chamber, you may have heard me
say it in committee, and I've certainly said it at my
round-tables, so all the stakeholders were very aware
of that. We have to support farmers in a better way.
So, it is a consultation on the entire common
agricultural policy replacement, as I've said.
We've proposed two large flexible schemes: the economic resilience scheme and the public goods scheme, and that's what we are proposing in relation to income support for our farmers. In relation to Sue Hayman, it might be of interest to you to see the letter that Sue Hayman has sent to the president of NFU Cymru today, which has been copied to me, and then you'll see why I said what I said. So, I think that's a very important point for you also. You also referred to the open letter that I sent to farmers. Brexit is unprecedented. I think that was the word you used—that I had made an unprecedented move. It's perfectly appropriate for Welsh Government to provide further clarity on its proposals. We want an engaged and informed debate. And I have to say, I was really concerned when we brought this very long consultation forward that we'd see a bit of Brexit fatigue. It's great that we haven't. It's really good that we're engaging in a way—. You were at the event, as was I, at lunchtime hosted and sponsored by Paul Davies. I think it's great that we're having this consultation. But it is a meaningful consultation. If anybody's undermining it, it's you. I don't want that taken forward. I want people to understand that those responses that we receive—and we've had thousands, literally, in—. It doesn't close until Tuesday, and I'd be grateful if everybody could bring forward their views.
Paul
Davies AM: Cabinet Secretary,
I was privileged to host the joint briefing session you
referred to earlier with NFU Cymru and the Farmers Union
of Wales, and I was pleased to see you at that
particular event. Now, what I believe came across loud
and clear at the event was that farmers across Wales
are concerned that the Welsh Government is not
listening to them, and this consultation is seen as a
smokescreen for the Welsh Government to plough ahead
and end direct payments regardless of the will of the
agricultural sector or the businesses in the supply
chain that would also be affected indirectly by these
proposals. It's very important that any proposals going
forward give food production the importance that it
rightly deserves, provide parity for Welsh
farmers and recognise the serious implications
that these proposals could have on Wales's rural
economy and, indeed, on our culture. It's crucial that
the right balance is struck between land management and
food production in order to protect the sustainability
of the industry for the future. Therefore, will you now
commit to listening to the views of Welsh farmers after
this consultation closes in order to protect the sector
for the future, and work with the industry to develop
proposals that are fair, appropriate and that genuinely
reflect the views of the farming industry and the wider
rural economy here in Wales?
Lesley Griffiths
AM: I was very pleased to be at
the event at lunchtime; I'm sorry I was not able to
stay for the full hour. I don't know if you were
listening, but what I heard the NFU and the FUW say, when they
were asked the question whether they did feel we were
listening, was 'yes'. Both of those people up on the
stage, both the presidents, are part of my Brexit
round-table. They both said there were no surprises in
that document, because they'd sat round that table. One
of them said to me, 'This is a time for radical
reform', and what we are proposing is radical—I accept
that—but we have to design the best system for farm
support here in Wales, and that's what we are
consulting on.
I absolutely agree with you about food production, and if you look at the four consultations that are being held in the UK on agriculture, I think food production is far more at the heart of those consultations in Wales than in any other of the consultations. I mentioned in my answer to Llyr that we've proposed two schemes. That will offer farmers the opportunity to create more resilient and more diversified businesses. It's absolutely right that we make them as sustainable as possible. We want them to remain on the land. We want them to compete in global markets. There is so much uncertainty around at the moment. We also want them to provide the public goods that we all need as a society which, at the moment, I wouldn't say farmers are being paid for. So, a lot of the public goods at the moment, they're not getting an income for, and that's what the public goods scheme will do.
Neil Hamilton
AM: I think it's quite right
that the Cabinet Secretary should have an open mind
about the future of agricultural policy and the
opportunity that Brexit provides, but I think she has
to recognise that farmers in Wales are far more reliant
upon the common agricultural policy than farmers in
England; it can make up to 80 per cent of farm incomes
in Wales, whereas the average in England is only 55 per
cent. Therefore, it's very important, in my view, that
we should take this step by step, and not rush into
making wholesale changes in too short a time, which
would make it very difficult to manage a transition.
Given that 85 per cent of the farm subsidies that are
paid are under pillar 1 rather than pillar 2, so
therefore they are direct payments rather than for
environmentally related schemes, it's quite difficult
for me to see how we could move very quickly to making
those pillar 2 type of schemes sufficiently robust to
maintain current levels of farm income. Given that farm
incomes are less than £20,000 on average and the amount
of subsidy that is received in direct payment is on
average about £16,000, I'm sure the Cabinet Secretary
will understand why a lot of farmers are very, very
worried that they will lose substantial amounts of
income, which they can ill afford, and tip their
businesses over from small profitability into
loss-making enterprises. That could have devastating
consequences for the countryside in general.
Lesley Griffiths
AM: If I can just pick up on the
two points I think Neil Hamilton was making, I think
that you're right about the 80 per cent of farms and
that being their income, and I think that tells you a
story, and that's exactly what I'm saying: the common
agricultural policy doesn't, I think, encourage or
protect farmers from a lot of, particularly, the
volatility that we've seen. What we want to do is make
them more resilient. I don't think CAP has actually
done that, if we have farms that are 80 per cent
reliant on those schemes.
In relation to taking things step by step, you are absolutely right, and I've made it very clear that no decisions have been taken and neither will they be until we have all the consultation responses in. I've made it very clear there will be further consultation next spring. There will be no changes to payments at all. No schemes will be designed without a proper impact assessment. No old schemes will be removed before the new schemes are ready. So, I've committed to basic payment schemes for 2018-19, and then we'll be looking at this from 2020. I've even said—and I think I said it in the article to which Llyr has referred—that if we think it needs to be another year of transition or another two years of transition, then we will look at that. I'm very flexible around that. We'll see what comes in from the consultation. |
