Under the Facilitated Customs Arrangement (FCA) proposed in the
Government’s Chequers White Paper, UK importers would face an
administration cost of £700 million per year – a fraction
of the annual £18 billion ‘no deal’ cost to UK traders. However,
the FCA raises a number of significant questions that need to be
resolved for it to be workable and acceptable to the EU.
This is one of the key conclusions of
the House of Lords EU External Affairs
Sub-Committee’s Brexit: the customs
challenge report, published
today.
Other report findings and recommendations
include:
-
The Government has not yet made clear how goods
under the FCA could be reliably tracked and who would carry
liability for keeping EU and UK-destined goods separate. The
UK's proposal to collect revenue on behalf of the EU makes
agreement difficult as the EU’s chief Brexit negotiator has
stressed that the EU will not delegate duty collection to a
non-Member State.
-
The FCA's repayment mechanism is untested and will
take several years to be developed and
implemented.
-
Part of the implementation of the FCA relies on the
establishment of new trusted trader schemes and maximising
their take-up. The Committee recommends simplifying the
application process to facilitate access for small and
medium-sized enterprises and newly established businesses. It
welcomes the Government’s intention to negotiate mutual
recognition of any new schemes with the EU.
-
In the case of 'no deal', trading with the EU under
WTO rules would be disruptive and costly. Tariffs would apply
and the agricultural and automotive sectors would be
disproportionately affected.
-
An estimated 145,000 VAT-registered UK businesses,
and potentially a further 100,000 under the VAT threshold,
currently trade exclusively with the EU and would have to gain
expertise in complex customs procedures, which they do not yet
have. They could choose to outsource part of the customs
procedure, but at a cost.
-
Roll-on/roll-off ports process the majority of
trade in goods between the UK and the EU. In the case of 'no
deal', customs paperwork would need to be checked and some
goods would be subject to additional time-consuming regulatory
checks. This would cause delays and disrupt highly integrated
supply chains.
-
The Government would face a ‘trilemma’ between
keeping trade moving, ensuring security of the border, and the
collection of revenue. Its position that, in the event of ‘no
deal’, customs checks of EU goods could be unilaterally
suspended may be in breach of WTO rules. The Committee calls on
the Government to set out its plans to ensure fair and equal
treatment of all imported goods coming in on most-favoured
nation terms.
-
Technological solutions will not wholly remove the
need for checks on some goods at the border, which is of
particular relevance to the Northern Ireland/Ireland border,
where ‘no deal’ risks re-introducing a hard
border.
Commenting on the report, , Chair of the EU
External Affairs Sub-Committee, said:
“The Government must, as a matter of urgency, provide
answers to questions on the Facilitated Customs Arrangement, such
as how goods would be tracked, how revenue would be collected and
how the repayment mechanism would work.
“With only six months to go until Brexit the clock
really is ticking on a mutually acceptable customs
agreement.
“A ‘no deal’ Brexit will cause disruption –
mitigation options are limited and no technology currently
exists, which would eliminate border checks completely. Even if
the UK waived customs checks on goods arriving from the EU, the
EU has said that it will not reciprocate.”