The House of Lords Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee
(SLSC) has today set out how it will approach its role as sifting
committee for regulations introduced under the EU (Withdrawal)
Act 2018.
The Committee will have the power in the Lords to
recommend that instruments proposed by Ministers in the negative
form – which can come into force without a debate in Parliament –
should instead be affirmative instruments, meaning a debate is
required before they could come into force.
In a report published today the Committee says that
its starting point will be to apply an overarching test, based on
its existing ground for reporting regulations that are
“politically or legally important”. In
looking at proposed negative instruments under the 2018 Act, it
will consider whether the subject matter of the instrument and
the scope of any policy change effected by it are of such
significance that the House would expect to debate
it.
The Committee also lists a range of policy matters
which may guide its decision on whether to recommend that an
instrument should be upgraded to the affirmative
procedure.
In setting out its working arrangements, the
Committee stresses the need for Government to manage the flow of
instruments to Parliament, and to provide good explanatory
material alongside them. It endorses the
need for good co-operation with the sifting committee that is
being set up in the Commons, and for external interests to make
their views known to Parliament in good time for the sifting
process.
, Chairman of the
Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee,
said:
“The Committee welcomes this opportunity to
contribute to the important task of scrutinising the secondary
legislation laid under the EU (Withdrawal) Act 2018, whether as
proposed negative instruments or as fully-fledged statutory
instruments. We intend to carry out this
scrutiny to the high standards to which the House has become
accustomed.
“We look to Government to play their part in ensuring
that instruments are presented to Parliament in a well-organised
way, and that the material provided in support gives Parliament
all the information needed to reach expeditious decisions on
those instruments.”
Background on the role of the SLSC
on Statutory Instruments under the EU (Withdrawal) Act
2018
The EU (Withdrawal) Act 2018 gives Ministers the
power to make regulations to ensure that legal provisions
originally based in EU law continue to be effective after the UK
has withdrawn from the EU. In the case of
some of these regulations, the Act allows Ministers to choose
whether they should be “affirmative” instruments – which would
mean that they would have to be debated in Parliament – or
“negative” instruments – which can come into force without being
debated.
The 2018 Act also contains a “Parliamentary sifting
mechanism” for these regulations. This
means that committees in both Houses can make a recommendation
that a proposed negative instrument should be upgraded to an
affirmative instrument.
Ministers will not be obliged to accept such a
recommendation, but the Government have indicated that, if the
sifting committees of both Houses made the same recommendation,
they would expect it to be accepted by the
Minister.
The long-established role of the Secondary
Legislation Scrutiny Committee (SLSC) is to advise the House of
Lords on its scrutiny of all statutory instruments subject to
Parliamentary procedure. The House has
agreed that the SLSC should also take on the role of sifting
committee in relation to instruments under the 2018
Act.
Notes to Editors
1. The
report - Sifting “proposed negative instruments” laid
under the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018: criteria and
working arrangements is available on the
Committee’s website shortly
after publication.
2. For
further information, please call 020 7219
8550.
3. The
Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee was established in 2003
(then as the Select Committee on the Merits of Statutory
Instruments), in order to determine whether or not the special
attention of the House should be drawn to any individual
statutory instrument.
4. The
Committee has 11 members, whose details can be found on
the website.