Long-term failures in the disclosure of evidence have gone
unresolved, in part, because of the insufficient focus and
leadership, says the Justice
Committee in a new report published today. The
Attorney General superintends the Crown Prosecution Service, but
the Committee states ownership of performance rests with the
Director of Public Prosecutions, who did not sufficiently
recognise the extent and seriousness of failures. The report
concludes that this was not aided by data collected by the Crown
Prosecution Service which may have underestimated the number of
cases which were stopped with disclosure errors by around 90%.
Problems with disclosure came into sharp focus
following the high-profile collapse
of a number of cases between December 2017 and Spring
2018. In the immediate aftermath, the Prime Minister announced
that the Attorney General would conduct a review of disclosure
which the Committee hopes today’s report will feed in to.
MPs do not recommend any changes to the principles of disclosure,
but find that failings have arisen in the application of
disclosure by police officers and prosecutors on the ground. The
Committee states there should be a shift in culture towards
viewing disclosure as a core justice duty, and not an
administrative add-on. There needs to be the right skills and
technology to review large volumes of material that are now
routinely collected by the police and clear guidelines on
handling sensitive material.
The report concludes that the Government must consider whether
funding across the system is sufficient to ensure a good
disclosure regime. Delayed and collapsed trials that result from
disclosure errors only service to put a further strain on already
tight resources.
Chair of the Justice Committee, MP, said:
“Correct disclosure of evidence by the Police and CPS to the
defence is fundamental to ensuring a fair trial – but is too
often regarded as just an administrative headache. This is not
acceptable. As we’ve seen in high profile cases since last year -
disclosure failings are extremely damaging for those concerned
and can have a permanent life-long impact. These failings have
caused miscarriages of justice and – as the Director of Public
Prosecutions even admitted to us – some people have gone to
prison as a result.
“The proliferation of electronic evidence makes disclosure
ever more challenging, and we need the right skills, technology,
resources and guidelines, to resolve this once and for all. The
failings are symptomatic of a system under immense strain:
without change, we cannot expect the public to have confidence in
the criminal justice system.
“We welcome the National Disclosure Improvement Plan, and
particularly the commitment of senior police officers we spoke
to, and we look forward to reading the Attorney General’s review,
but these must deliver much needed improvement. There have been
too many reviews of disclosure that have not resulted in real
change.”
ENDS
BACKGROUND INFORMATION
Disclosure is the process by which material collected by the
police during an investigation is made available, first to
prosecutors and subsequently, and subject to certain rules, to
defence teams. Prosecution and defence may make use of this
material in preparation for and during a trial where it is
potentially relevant to an issue, or issues, in a case.
When it works properly, the disclosure process enables judges and
magistrates to have all the relevant evidence before them when
deciding on guilt of an accused person and in the event of
conviction it may be used in deciding an appropriate
sentence.
Disclosure is, as the then Attorney General told the Committee, a
"fundamental question of fairness in criminal proceedings." When
the disclosure process does not work as it should crucial
evidence might not be heard and miscarriages of justice can
prevail. On 5 June 2018 we asked the Director of Public
Prosecutions if people had been wrongly imprisoned as a result of
disclosure failings and she said "some people have
been".
We launched this inquiry following reports in the press of cases
which had collapsed, or guilty verdicts which had been overturned
on appeal, due to errors in the disclosure process. The most
high-profile case, one of those which Joanna Hardy of Red Lion
Chambers referred to as "firework cases", ended in December 2017
with the acquittal of Liam Allan. In this case, evidence held by
the police had not been disclosed to prosecutors or the defence
until the day of trial, and this evidence undermined the
prosecution case to such an extent that - once it was disclosed -
the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) case collapsed. The CPS
"decided that there was no longer a realistic prospect of
conviction and the case was listed at Court on 14 December 2017
so that it could be stopped."
The case of R v Allan acted
as a catalyst to raise the profile of a number of other cases,
most of which were related to the very serious crimes of rape and
sexual assault. These are charges that, if they lead to
conviction, almost inevitably result in imprisonment. The
Committee heard, however, that disclosure errors happen in all
types of cases, both complex cases in the Crown Court, and volume
Magistrates' Court cases covering, not just rape cases, but all
crime types. And we heard from defence practitioners and victim
representatives that it is not in the interest of anyone,
including complainants, to have a case delayed, disrupted or
collapse due to disclosure failings.