BRC: Cost of living drives return to cash

Thursday, 7 December 2023 00:01

Cash usage up as many households used it to help budget Debit and credit cards still accounted for over 85% of all spending Fees paid to banks and card schemes rose by more than a quarter Today, the British Retail Consortium (BRC) published its BRC Payments Survey 2023. UK retail sales rose 4.3% to £439.5bn in 2022, although this was largely due to rising prices resulting from increased costs throughout the supply chain. The number of transactions rose...Request free trial

Cash usage up as many households used it to help budget

Debit and credit cards still accounted for over 85% of all spending

Fees paid to banks and card schemes rose by more than a quarter

Today, the British Retail Consortium (BRC) published its BRC Payments Survey 2023. UK retail sales rose 4.3% to £439.5bn in 2022, although this was largely due to rising prices resulting from increased costs throughout the supply chain. The number of transactions rose from 17.2bn in 2021 (47.2m per day) to 19.6bn in 2022 (53.7m per day).

Average Transaction Value fell from £24.49 to £22.43, as consumers shopped around more and made more regular, but smaller, purchases. This reverses a trend seen during the pandemic, towards less frequent, bigger, shopping trips – as people tried to avoid going out as often.

By Transactions

Cash usage grew for the first time in a decade, rising to 19% of all transactions (from 15% in 2021). This reflects a choice by many households to use cash to budget more carefully during the onset of the cost of living crisis, as well as a natural return to cash usage following the move to contactless during Covid. Card payments were used for 76% of transactions (83% in 2021), with debit cards accounting for four-fifths of these transactions.

By Spending

Cards accounted for the overwhelming proportion (85%) of money spent, with debit cards taking three-quarters of this spending. They are used more often than credit cards but for smaller value transactions. Meanwhile, cash increased to 11% of consumer spend (8% in 2021).

The increase in cash usage – both by spend and transaction numbers – is welcome. BRC members are committed to accepting cash payments, supporting vulnerable groups and those using cash to budget. Government should ensure that cash acceptance is a viable option for merchants and customers across the whole ecosystem.

The dominance of card payments has come at a significant cost to retailers. Retailers spent £1.26 billion on card processing fees; this includes a 27% increase in scheme fees and a 7% increase in interchange fees (as percentages of turnover) in 2022.

Alternative payment methods saw a rise in popularity in 2022, from 2.0% to 4.9% of transactions. Methods such as Open Banking and Buy-Now Pay-Later (BNPL) are starting to offer some competition to card payments.

The BRC is calling for the following actions to reduce costs for hard-pressed retailers:

Reforms in the payment market: The Payment Systems Regulator must implement meaningful reforms to increase competition and reduce costs in the payment market.
Treasury Review: We call on the Treasury to conduct a full review of interchange fees to examine if they are fit for purpose in the UK market.
Open banking: We want to see the growth of Open Banking in the UK, without replicating the existing card system.

Hannah Regan, Payments Policy Advisor, British Retail Consortium said:

“We are now seeing a return to many of the pre-pandemic trends in payments, including smaller but more frequent purchases, and a slight return of cash payments. Unfortunately, what has not changed, is the ever-increasing scale of fees paid by retailers in order to accept card payments. Though alternative payment methods could provide much needed competition to the market, the dominance of card payments means it is essential that action is taken to prevent fees rising further.”

PAYMENT SPLIT BY TRANSACTIONS
Date	Cash	Debit Cards	Credit Cards	Non Card Payments
2013	52.6%	32.4%	9.3%	5.8%
2014	52.1%	31.7%	9.9%	6.3%
2015	47.1%	38.1%	11.1%	3.6%
2016	42.3%	42.6%	11.4%	3.7%
2017	41.8%	43.6%	11.2%	3.4%
2018	38.3%	46.5%	12.8%	2.4%
2019	36.9%	48.2%	12.4%	2.5%
2020	29.9%	53.4%	13.5%	3.2%
2021	15.2%	67.8%	15.0%	2.0%
2022	18.8%	61.4%	14.9%	4.9%

PAYMENT SPLIT BY TURNOVER
Date	Cash	Debit Cards	Credit Cards	Non Card Payments
2013	27.6%	49.6%	21.0%	1.7%
2014	26.4%	49.5%	22.1%	2.0%
2015	23.3%	53.4%	21.5%	1.8%
2016	23.2%	54.0%	20.5%	2.2%
2017	22.0%	54.8%	20.8%	2.3%
2018	20.4%	56.9%	21.5%	1.2%
2019	19.7%	57.8%	20.5%	2.0%
2020	15.1%	59.2%	21.7%	4.0%
2021	8.2%	66.8%	22.5%	2.5%
2022	11.0%	64.0%	21.2%	3.8%

-ENDS-

Notes:

Data for the BRC Payments Survey was gathered in 2023 and covers the 2022 calendar year. Retailers participating in the survey accounted for 35% of all UK retail annual sales turnover.
We have adjusted and improved our methodology this year. We have re-run all previous years’ data so all figures used in this year’s survey account for the new methodology.
Download the BRC Payments Survey 2023: https://www.brc.org.uk/media/683937/payment-survey-2023.pdf
Definitions:

Card Schemes – Payment networks e.g. Visa, Mastercard and American Express
Scheme fees – fees paid by retailers to the card schemes
Interchange fees – fees paid by retailers to the issuing companies e.g. Barclaycard, Santander, Capital One. The rates paid are set by the card schemes.