In response to Energy Security Secretary ' announcements relating to
'Great British Nuclear', Dr Doug Parr, Chief Scientist for
Greenpeace UK, said -
“As the government tries to whip up investment for the latest
generation of reactors, it is striking how many of the nuclear
industry’s speculative claims are being repeated by ministers as
fact. The hype seems to have been enough to convince our
government that nuclear’s last gasp is in fact a new dawn, but at
their radioactive cores SMRs remain the same bad bet. SMRs have
no track record, but initial indications are that the familiar
problems of cost overruns and delays will be repeated, and the
accumulation of unmanageable waste will continue. Maybe the hope
is that splitting one big mistake into several smaller mistakes
means each reactor’s inevitable problems receive less scrutiny?
"By continually obsessing about nuclear the government is taking
its eye off the net zero ball, which will have to be delivered
through a predominantly renewable, modern electricity grid. No
number of SMRs will fix the government’s lacklustre effort to
address issues of delayed connections, smart local grids and home
efficiency. The government may argue that renewables can compete
in the market unaided, while nuclear still needs state support to
survive, but atomic power has been showered with money and
support for the best part of a century without ever working well
enough to pay its way. This is a technology that has gone
straight from adolescence to obsolescence without passing through
maturity.”