Moved by Lord Ponsonby of Shulbrede That this House regrets that in
laying the Sentencing Act 2020 (Magistrates’ Court Sentencing
Powers) (Amendment) Regulations 2023 (SI 2023/298) His Majesty’s
Government have not yet published the evidence to justify this
change of policy, which has potential ramifications for slowing
down the justice system for victims, witnesses and defendants;
further regrets that sitting magistrates have spent thousands of
hours cumulatively on...Request free
trial
Moved by
That this House regrets that in laying the Sentencing Act 2020
(Magistrates’ Court Sentencing Powers) (Amendment) Regulations
2023 (SI 2023/298) His Majesty’s Government have not yet
published the evidence to justify this change of policy, which
has potential ramifications for slowing down the justice system
for victims, witnesses and defendants; further regrets that
sitting magistrates have spent thousands of hours cumulatively on
training to properly sentence using the 12 months training pack;
and calls on His Majesty’s Government to announce the expected
date for the review of the effect of reducing sentencing powers
to six months.
Relevant document: 35th Report from the Secondary Legislation
Scrutiny Committee (special attention drawn to the
instrument)
(Lab)
My Lords, in moving this regret Motion, I remind the House that I
am a sitting magistrate in London. I thank the Magistrates’
Association for the briefing that it has provided, as well as the
Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee for its work in asking,
the Minister, , to flesh out the reasons for
this change to magistrates’ sentencing powers.
The instrument that is the subject of this regret Motion reduces
the maximum custodial sentence that magistrates’ courts can
impose for a single either way offence from 12 to six months,
reversing a change put in place in May 2022. The higher
sentencing powers had been in place for only 10 months when they
were reversed. The May 2022 change did not alter the maximum
sentence for any given offence; it simply changed which court
might try cases expected to have a maximum sentence of between
six and 12 months.
The justification given by the Lord Chief Justice was that, since
magistrates’ courts work faster than Crown Courts, the increase
sentencing powers had led to an increase in the prison population
that needed to be addressed, and that going back to the previous
sentencing powers would slow down the increase in the prison
population. The Ministry of Justice is also running Operation
Safeguard, which is designed to create a vacancy contingency in
the male prison estate. Minister Freer has also said that that
would be part of a raft of measures to decrease the prison
population. We do not yet know what the other measures will be. I
want to put on record that the Minister has said that there will
be a six-month review on this change in policy.
In his response to the SLSC letter, Minister Freer spoke of
downstream pressures on the prison population, namely the
recruitment of extra police officers, tougher sentences, more
recalls of prisoners on licence, working through the Covid
backlog and the Criminal Bar Association’s strike. All these
factors have contributed to the growth in the prison
population—about 4,000 prisoners in the past year. We do not know
how that figure is broken down between these various pressures.
In my view, it is unlikely that the change in sentencing powers
has played a significant part in the overall increase.
I shall go through the objections to and the questions raised by
this change in sentencing powers, first made by the SLSC and then
by the Magistrates’ Association. First, when considering the
numbers in custody and on bail, those waiting for their trial in
custody will have to wait longer because of the far longer
backlog in the Crown Courts. When Mr Freer, the Minister, was
asked about the increased risk of reoffending of those who are on
bail to Crown Courts, he said there was no available data. The
SLSC commented that this was indeed a relevant factor and should
have been assessed as part of the policy-making process.
On the costs of the two systems, Mr Freer asserted that the
change does not give rise to any direct financial pressure
because it does not introduce any new demand into the system but
simply transfers some cases to the Crown Court. The SLSC was
unimpressed by that point and pointed out that Crown Courts take
longer to hear cases, involve juries and are very likely to be
more expensive.
An analysis of the May 2022 change was promised by the noble
Lord, of Tredegar, on Report of the
Judicial Review and Courts Bill. The SLSC pointed out that no
data had been published and called on the Ministry of Justice to
complete and publish its review so that a more informed decision
could be taken when considering the effect of changing maximum
sentencing powers in magistrates’ courts. It also inquired
whether more research could be done to see whether sentence
lengths vary between similar cases in magistrates’ courts and
Crown Courts.
In conclusion, the SLSC said that using the maximum sentence
available to magistrates’ courts as a sort of valve that could be
opened and closed in response to wider developments that affected
the prison population was not an optimum way of making policy, as
it failed to consider other potentially important factors. The
SLSC said that maximum sentences in magistrates’ courts should be
determined by the overall outcomes for society and should be
evidence-based, and it believed that this was not the case with
the Government’s decision.
Turning to the Magistrates’ Association, I can do no better than
refer to what Mark Beattie, the current chairman of the
association, has said: “The reaction of magistrates has been very
negative. Magistrates each spent three hours completing a
mandatory training pack, totalling over 30,000 hours of our own
time on our own equipment. Chairs of training committees
personally chased up people who had not done the training so they
could complete the training before they sat in court. These
chairs are feeling particularly aggrieved, both because of the
many extra hours they have spent at this task and because they
fear that this sudden reversal will have damaged their ability to
persuade people the next time they ask them to undertake extra
training. They feel personally undermined, and as this is an
essential statutory role, it is especially bad if they feel that
their ability to perform their duties has been impacted. ‘Why do
the training if the rules can be changed so easily?’ is a message
that we are hearing. We know, because we have been told, that
magistrates are resigning over this matter, although we don’t
know the numbers or the locations.”
Of course magistrates will work conscientiously to deal with the
cases put in front of them and fulfil the judicial oath they have
all taken. However, it is incumbent on the Government, through
the Ministry of Justice, to ensure that the decisions taken are
properly evidenced-based and that court users can understand the
rationale behind those decisions.
I would be grateful if the Minister could give any indication of
a timetable for a review of the current sentencing arrangements,
and whether that review will take into account the additional
factors highlighted by the SLSC and the Magistrates’ Association.
I beg to move.
(LD)
My Lords, I am sorry to hear that the magistrates were upset by
the introduction of this change.
I was articled as a solicitor in the office of the clerk to the
magistrates of the Ruabon Bench in north-east Wales. The chairman
of the Bench was Lord Maelor, formerly TW Jones, the Labour MP
for Merioneth. He had gone down the pit at the age of 14 for 12
shillings a week and later served time in Wormwood Scrubs and
Dartmoor as a conscientious objector, which is an unusual
beginning for the chairman of the Magistrate’s Bench. He is noted
for being the first and perhaps the last noble Lord to burst into
song in the middle of a speech in this Chamber. Once when Mormon
missionaries called at his terrace house in Rhosllanerchrugog and
asked, “Is the Lord within?”, his wife replied, “No, he’s just
gone for his cigarettes.”
8.15pm
To me, TW was the essence of a good magistrate. He was totally
involved in the community, sometimes uncomfortably so. If a
miscreant came from Rhos, his home village, he would not rest
until he had identified his father, his mother, his chapel and
his home. I cut my teeth in prosecuting, in front of that Bench,
those who had trespassed in pursuit of conies or, worse, poached
a pheasant on local estates.
I have always valued the commitment and dedication of lay
magistrates and their desire to do justice, whatever the clerk
may advise them about the law. I know that they regard
imprisonment as a last resort. I must also pay tribute to their
work in family courts. Friends of mine who have been or are
magistrates have found that area of law to be most rewarding.
What the magistracy has gained, therefore, is not just acceptance
but trust in dealing with the 95% of criminal cases which come
before magistrates. I have less trust in the motivation of the
Ministry of Justice, which is promoting a now traditional
Conservative U-turn in policy in the record time of 19 months. So
far as I am aware, this is not based on research into the
outcomes of the policy announced by . His expressed purpose in
January 2022 was to reduce the backlog of Crown Court cases by
1,700 either-way cases—a reduction of 2% to 3% of what was then a
backlog of 60,000 cases and is now said to be 61,000.
I struggle to find any reason in the Explanatory Memorandum for
the reversal of the policy. For me, it explains nothing. It
says
“we are currently experiencing downstream pressures in the
criminal justice system as, for example, manifested in Operation
Safeguard and it is important that the government ensures a
cohesive cross-system response to this growing pressure. Whilst
increased MSPs is not the only factor behind this pressure and
the data on the impact of MSPs is still limited, it is safest to
temporarily reduce MSPs to 6 months so that the Crown Court
retains power over decisions in respect of longer sentences”.
I do not know what that means. What are “downstream pressures”?
What are the other terms that are used in that particular
context? I would be grateful if the Minister could address those
problems.
Your Lordships might observe that my iPad has gone blank, so I am
a little bit lost at this stage. Suffice it to say that we need
some justification—some research —to find out what has happened
in the last 19 months. Why is the policy now being reversed? Is
it simply that magistrates are sentencing for too long a period,
or what? What the ministry needs to bear in mind is that they may
be passing sentences of between six and 12 months —the short
sentences, which, unhappily, do not resolve the problems of the
individual. There is no way in which he can be rehabilitated in
that time; nor do those problems get dealt with. I therefore look
forward to an explanation from the Minister, and I apologise that
my script has disappeared.
(Con)
My Lords, I share the anxieties and concerns of the noble Lord,
Lord Ponsonby. I declare my interests as set out in the register,
including as a former magistrate and, at present, a life member
of the Magistrates’ Association.
I appreciate that the criminal justice system is currently
experiencing—as the noble Lord mentioned—“downstream pressures”,
as manifested in Operation Safeguard. Indeed, as has already been
said, Ministers have said that this pause gives them time to
review this measure, assessing relevant data across the CJS, with
a view to reinstating powers should this be supported by the
evidence. Ministers, however, have also been clear that the
increase to sentencing powers is not the only factor behind this
pressure, and that the data on the impact is still limited. In
the light of this, therefore, I question whether it can be
justified for this change to be made, given the impact it will
have on magistrates delivering speedier justice. Surely it would
be better to make this change only if the data clearly suggested
that it was a significant factor behind the increased pressure we
have seen.
As the noble Lord, Lord Ponsonby, has stated, this change has
ramifications for slowing down the justice system for victims,
witnesses and defendants, not to mention the hours of training by
sitting magistrates. I would be grateful to hear from my noble
and learned friend the Minister more on this, specifically
regarding the process, what evidence and data are needed and when
this review will be concluded.
(GP)
My Lords, considering that we deal with a lot of very big Bills
here in your Lordships’ House, this is quite a small issue, but
for me, it encapsulates the panicky and misguided way in which
the Government constantly tackle big problems such as our prison
population and the justice system. It is an example of their
wanting a quick fix for something that they have damaged over the
last 13 years of austerity and incompetence.
I cannot comment on whether six months or 12 months is right—I do
not have a magistrate’s training—but I can say that we have too
many people in prison and we have to stop sending so many people
to prison, particularly women. We also have to be clear, of
course, that people coming out of prison need help if they are
not going to reoffend. You cannot fix these big problems with
tiny little tweaks such as this.
I do not understand why such knee-jerk reactions happen all the
time with this Government. Where is the overview or the long-term
planning? Where is the coherence for dealing with these big
problems? This Government have tried to fix the whole justice
system on the cheap. It has not in fact been cheap, of course,
because it is very expensive to keep people in prison and train
magistrates, while not giving people the support they need when
they come out of prison, so they go on to offend again. Why not
have a longer-term plan?
This Government have got, one supposes, another year. Please
could they get some expert advice on this sort of thing and not
keep flailing around? One minute it is six months, the next it is
12 months and then it is back to six months again. This is not
good government; it just does not make any sense to do things
like this. The court system is at breaking point and the prisons
are way over full, so the Government should really now be
thinking about how to solve these two problems. This, I would
argue, is not the way to do it. The Government have broken our
justice system and are now doing tiny little tweaks to try to fix
it, which simply will not work.
(Lab)
My Lords, the House is fortunate in having my colleague and noble
friend Lord Ponsonby, and with some reason because he has sat for
many years on the magistrates’ courts and has enormous experience
of their functioning. We are also lucky to have the noble Lord,
Lord Thomas, whose memory stretches back—I dare not ask him how
many years—to his early days when embarking upon a career at the
Bar, and to a certain magistrate whom he much respected in Wales.
We are fortunate, too, to have the noble Baroness, Lady Sater,
who is behind the Minister, and who also clearly has much
experience as a magistrate, although I think she has ceased to be
one.
In my experience, and this goes a long way back, magistrates are
on the whole sensible people—after all, having been magistrates
for 10, 15 or 20 years, they have become very experienced—and are
not great senders to prison. Magistrates are actually reluctant
to send people to prison, particularly for the reason that the
noble Lord, Lord Thomas, presented. It does not do much good to
have somebody in prison for three or six months to set a kind of
an example. It does not work, or did not in my experience, for
the normal kind of criminal offences involving theft and
violence. But it was quite good for motoring offences, because it
set a rather good example to all motorists. If the driver of a
motor car who is otherwise without conviction misbehaves really
badly in driving their car—these are normally citizens who have
not had previous convictions —and they are sentenced to prison
for a short time, that is a very big shock.
The central issue has been rightly raised by my noble friend Lord
Ponsonby and by the noble Lord, Lord Thomas. There should be
proper research on the figures to see whether the basis of this
is right, because magistrates across the board do not have a
record of imprisoning the people who appear in front of them. It
seems to me that to change the sentencing policy down from 12
months, which is only a moderate period, to six months is
complete nonsense. Magistrates should have that freedom. All that
happens is that the appeals go up—in my day—from the magistrates’
sessions to quarter sessions, and, for many years now, to the
Crown Court. One of the things that magistrates were able to do—I
am sure this remains the position—was that, if they considered
that they did not have sufficient powers to sentence the offender
for a period of more than 12 months, they could send the case to
the higher court and it could be dealt with there.
In summary, we are very spoilt by the presence of those who have
experience in magistrates’ courts in this House. There should be
proper research and I welcome all of those suggestions.
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Ministry of Justice
() (Con)
My Lords, I am very grateful to all noble Lords who have
contributed to this debate, in particular the noble Lord, Lord
Ponsonby, whose Motion this is. I also thank the noble Lord,
, and his colleagues in
the Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee for their report.
Their comments are understandable; I will say more about the
background to this in a moment.
I would first like to make one overarching point. I would like to
reassure the House, and through the House the magistracy in
general and the Magistrates’ Association, that this change is no
reflection whatever on the magistracy or its use of the extended
powers. The Government place immense value on the continuing and
outstanding contribution of magistrates in the justice system. I
believe everyone in this House is very aware of the exceptional
work that magistrates do. This has already been mentioned by the
noble Lords, Lord Thomas and , and by other noble
Lords.
8.30pm
I most warmly thank the magistrates, including the noble Lord,
Lord Ponsonby—who is a distinguished magistrate, if I may say
so—for their service to the justice system. I have obviously seen
magistrates in action at first hand. I greatly regret that I
never had the opportunity to appear before the TW to whom the
noble Lord, Lord Thomas, referred. The dedication and principles
explained by my noble friend Lady Sater are alive and well in the
magistracy. We rely heavily on them in the justice system and
they make a vital contribution. I hope I have clarified that as
the most important point to arise from this debate.
That takes me to the question of the three hours of training the
magistrates did. The Government’s hope and expectation is that
this training is not wasted and, as soon as it is possible to
revert to the underlying purpose of the previous legislation and
system, that training will come in again extremely usefully.
That takes me on to explain a little more on the background, and
I will do my best to explain the circumstances in which the
statutory instrument we are discussing came to be made. As your
Lordships are aware, in the Judicial Review and Courts Act 2022
the Government took a variable power to alter magistrates’
sentencing limits. It was deliberately a variable power and
therefore a cautious approach to enable the Government to deal
with unforeseen circumstances in the criminal justice system and
to be able to adjust the sentencing powers according to
circumstances.
As the House is aware, we are currently experiencing downstream
pressures in the criminal justice system. I entirely accept the
comment from the noble Lord, Lord Thomas, that this is a somewhat
elliptical phrase, but what it means is that currently prison
capacity is hovering around 99%. It is quite tight. That is the
background to the introduction of Operation Safeguard, which we
debated in this House in December 2022. Operation Safeguard is
part of a package to manage prison capacity. This statutory
instrument takes effect against that background.
Operation Safeguard was announced in November 2022. Meanwhile,
the new sentencing powers under this legislation came into force
in May 2022. Information available to the ministry in November
2022, six months after the new magistrates’ courts powers came
into force, showed that sentences in the six to 12 months bracket
had increased by some 35%. In other words, in that period there
had been quite a sharp increase in percentage terms, which
produced an unexpected and accelerated increase of 500 prisoners
coming into the system in that six-month period and the
possibility of that trend line continuing.
It may sound a small number, but if you are already bumping right
up against capacity you have to step back and consider measures
to deal with the risk that is emerging. At that point, I think it
may be fairly clear that the department finds itself effectively
between the devil and the deep. On the one hand, as has been
pointed out, the purpose of the reform in the first place was to
try to reduce the pressure on the Crown Court by processing cases
more efficiently in the magistrates’ court. That is a perfectly
sensible measure. It is the Government’s policy and remains our
hope to revert to that policy. On the other hand, as it turned
out, with various factors in play, including the distortions
caused by the barristers’ strike, the new situation was posing
risks to the prison system’s ability to deal with this change in
flow, as it were.
It is perfectly true that in a perfect world one would have
perfect information, one would be able to do research and one
would have all the time one wished to have. Sometimes, however,
if I may respectfully say so, Governments are faced with
unexpected circumstances, imperfect information and the need to
take a decision without delay, and sometimes they have to decide
between very unpalatable options. The options here were extremely
unpalatable, but the Government decided that they had to do
everything possible to avoid running out of prison capacity,
albeit at the expense of some increased pressures in the Crown
Court. I venture respectfully to suggest that that was a
responsible decision that any responsible Government would take
in the circumstances I have outlined.
With regard to some of the observations that were made by the
scrutiny committee, and have also been made this evening, I
respectfully point out that the effect of the statutory
instrument we are discussing is simply to revert to the status
quo that existed at the time of TW and the other experiences
mentioned, namely that magistrates still enjoy the powers that
they have enjoyed for decades. That has been a successful system.
All we have done is temporarily, we hope, modify the change that
was introduced only in May last year.
As to the general comments from the noble Baroness, Lady Jones,
which of course I completely understand, that we have too many in
prison and what are the long-term plans and so forth, the
management of the prison estate and the whole sentencing policy
is somewhat outside the scope of our debate this evening.
However, the Government are taking, with at least some modest
success, quite extensive efforts to reduce reoffending rates and
make prison a more effective regime, particularly in relation to
prison education, employment and other matters. Indeed, the noble
Lord, Lord Thomas, on a recent occasion in this Chamber, praised
Berwyn prison in particular for the success that was being
achieved there. So we have some encouraging—if only modestly
encouraging—and at least positive signs in the system that the
Government are beginning to tackle successfully these very
difficult issues.
I will briefly mention the somewhat limited effect of this
change, in the following respects. First, whether we have the
statutory instrument or not, as far as we know, there is no
change in the proportion of cases electing for trial in the Crown
Court—it has stayed the same. People still have confidence in the
magistrates, and some—around 17%—elect for trial. So whether the
statutory instrument is there or not, there is no change
there.
Secondly, as far as we know, there has been no change in the
number of appeals from the magistrates’ court to the Crown
Court—that is neutral.
Thirdly, whether the statutory instrument is there or not, there
is no effect on the overall length of sentences: there has been
no suggestion that magistrates are mis-sentencing or that one
does better on sentence in either the Crown Court or the
magistrates’ court. As far as we know, it is the same. Therefore,
whether the statutory instrument is there or not, there is no
effect on the time one actually spends in custody; it is simply a
question of which court deals with the sentence.
Fourthly, on the question of the trial, as far as we know—the
noble Lord, Lord Thomas, or perhaps the noble Lord, , made this point—the vast
majority of defendants do not elect for trial in the Crown Court;
they are content to be tried in the magistrates’ court. They are
tried there because, as was pointed out, they have confidence in
the magistrates’ court system.
Therefore, the Government’s understanding is that whether we have
this recent statutory instrument or the old system, that does not
affect trials in the magistrates’ court: you can still have a
trial, with the witnesses, the victim and everything as normal.
The only difference is the process by which you sentence. So this
is a slight change in the process, and more sentencing is being
done in the Crown Court. The Government’s view is that, in the
very unfortunate circumstances with which they were faced, that
was the lesser of two evils, to put it bluntly. That is the
explanation.
I hope I have dealt with the various questions, and, in the
circumstances, I invite the noble Lord, Lord Ponsonby, not to
proceed with the Motion.
(Lab)
Before the Minister sits down, has he any figures for the
occasions when the magistrates do not consider that they have
sufficient powers under the current regime and therefore send the
accused to the Crown Court for sentencing?
(Con)
I do not have that figure with me, but I will write to the noble
Lord, , with it.
(Lab)
I thank all noble Lords who took part in this interesting and
short debate. I query one statistic that the Minister used: he
spoke about a 35% increase in sentences between six and 12 months
during the six-month period after the introduction of the
increased sentencing powers for magistrates’ courts. That seems a
high figure. The SLSC report projected an increase of perhaps 500
prisoners over a two-year period because of that increase in
sentencing. To me, that sounds a lot less than 35%, but,
nevertheless, I take the Minister’s broader point.
In the Minister’s conclusion, he described the Government’s
course of action as the lesser of two evils, but there are many
more than just two evils. A number of evils leading to the
increase in the prison population have been identified in this
debate. The whole point of the debate is that we do not know the
proportion of those evils which are leading to the increase in
the prison population by 4,000. The Minister has not given any
extra information so that we can judge whether the course of
action taken by the Government has addressed the more serious of
the various evils leading to the increase in the prison
population. The point of the SLSC report was that the Government
used a cruder mechanism when using the sentencing powers of the
magistrates’ courts as a sort of valve for regulating this, when
so many other factors are leading to the increase in the prison
population. Nevertheless, it has been an interesting debate, and
I hope that the Government will look at the data in the round and
review this decision again in the coming months. I beg leave to
withdraw my Motion.
Motion withdrawn.
|