Strikes (Minimum Service Levels) Bill Third Reading The Schedule
Amendment 1 Moved by Lord Collins of Highbury 1: The Schedule, page
7, leave out lines 13 and 14 Lord Collins of Highbury (Lab) My
Lords, I will not detain the House for too long. I am very grateful
to the Public Bill Office and the clerks for advising me on these
consequential amendments which arise from the amendments carried by
the House on Report. I am grateful for these...Request free trial
Strikes (Minimum
Service Levels) Bill
Third Reading
The Schedule
Amendment 1
Moved by
1: The Schedule, page 7, leave out lines 13 and 14
(Lab)
My Lords, I will not detain the House for too long. I am very
grateful to the Public Bill Office and the clerks for advising me
on these consequential amendments which arise from the amendments
carried by the House on Report. I am grateful for these technical
amendments to be approved by the House. It does not particularly
change my view on the overall impact of the Bill, but I am
hopeful that the Government will focus on achieving settlements,
particularly in the health service, where we have seen some
progress. I do not see that the Bill, even as amended, will
improve the situation but I hope noble Lords will consider these
technical amendments and send the Bill back as speedily as
possible. I beg to move.
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department for Energy
Security and Net Zero () (Con)
My Lords, these amendments are intended to tidy the Bill,
following the votes to amend the Bill on Report. They intend to
remove from the Bill references to Section 234E, which was
removed due to the passing of Amendment 5.
By convention, the Government do not oppose these amendments as
we have a duty to send to the other place Bills that are
internally consistent. However, I make it clear that the
Government fully expect these topics to be revisited following
the consideration of these amendments in the other place, which
would result ultimately in them being reconsidered here also.
(Lab)
I note the Minister’s comments. I hope that when they return
here, we will have the same level of scrutiny, because this is a
bad Bill with certain consequences which will not improve
industrial relations in this country—in fact, it will make them
worse. It will not achieve the objectives the Government set out;
it will have the completely opposite effect. Bearing those
comments in mind, I welcome the Minister’s commitment to agree to
these amendments.
Amendment 1 agreed.
Amendment 2
Moved by
2: The Schedule, page 8, line 21, leave out “, 234A and [section
removed]” and insert “and 234A”
Amendment 2 agreed.
Motion
Moved by
That the Bill do now pass.
(Con)
My Lords, I thank all noble Lords who have contributed to the
scrutiny of the Bill. We had an extremely thorough and, perhaps
at times, slightly repetitive debate, but that is the nature of
the parliamentary process. I am grateful to everyone who engaged
in that process. In particular, I thank my Whip, my noble friend
Lady Bloomfield, who, as usual, has kept us all in order.
Thankfully, nobody fell asleep during this one, so we were all
spared her wrath on this occasion.
3.30pm
I thank the Opposition Members who contributed and, from the
Government, the noble Baroness, Lady Barran, and the noble Lords,
and , who also contributed to
taking through various clauses. I thank my noble friend Lady
Noakes, who is not in her place, for her support. There were
thoughtful and considered contributions from Opposition and
Liberal Democrat Front-Benchers, as well as various
Cross-Benchers. As is the nature of things, I did not agree with
all the contributions, but nevertheless everybody approached it
in a consistent frame of mind.
I am disappointed that the Bill leaves this House in a condition
which is not as the Government would have preferred. I hope that
the upcoming consideration of the amendments in the other place
will present an opportunity for the elected House to reconsider
the Bill and its contents following the modifications. The
Government fully expect many of the matters in the Bill to be
reconsidered in this House.
The Bill comes at a critical time for our country, where
continued industrial action is having a real, material impact on
the public up and down the country. That is why the Bill was
introduced. The Government still believe that the Bill gets the
balance right between the right to strike and the rights of the
public to go about their daily lives unencumbered by industrial
action.
(CB)
My Lords, I will make two points. First, I thank the Minister and
his colleague for their great courtesy in discussing various
points. Secondly, I hope we learn something from this Bill. It is
a simple lesson: this is not the way to legislate.
(LD)
My Lords, as the noble and learned Lord has just said, this Bill
arrived in your Lordships’ House in a flawed state. It sought to
bypass Parliament and the devolved legislatures, with the aim of
implementing a system where the Secretary of State—they
alone—could implement service levels that, in effect, make
strikes illegal, exposing individuals to the risk of being fired
for striking. Thanks to the hard work of your Lordships’ House,
it goes back to the other end somewhat improved.
I thank the Minister for his tolerant acceptance of the debate,
which I know at times he found difficult. Thanks go to the noble
Baroness, Lady Bloomfield, and the Bill team, who have had to sit
through all of this. A number of Cross-Benchers spoke in the
debates. I pick out particularly the noble and learned Lords,
and Lord Thomas, the noble Lord,
Lord Kerr, the noble and right reverend Lord, , and the noble Baroness, Lady
Meacher, and thank them for their commitment. On the Bishops’
Bench, I thank the right reverend Prelate the . His contribution was
very important, as were those from the noble Lord, , and the noble Baroness, Lady
Jones.
I thank His Majesty’s loyal Opposition for their contribution. I
think we worked together very well, particularly with the noble
Baroness, Lady O’Grady, and the noble Lord, Lord Collins, but I
thank all who spoke. On these Benches, our team, including the
noble Lord, Lord Allan, and the noble Baroness, Lady Randerson,
gave fantastic support. They gave your Lordships very strong
reasons as to why the Bill has to change. I thank Sarah Pughe in
our Whips’ Office for the hard work she is doing.
When the Bill comes back, I am sure we will re-engage. I hope the
team I have just listed, and others, will reconvene in the event
that the Government do not see the wisdom of their ways.
(CB)
My Lords, I was not going to speak, but the noble Lord was very
gracious in his speech. It is true that the House of Commons, as
the elected House, in the end determines and fixes the law. In
the light of what the noble and learned Lord, Lord Thomas, has
just said, if you legislate in a bad way, the lesson you learn is
to not go back to your bad ways by taking out amendments that
have actually improved the legislation.
The devolved Governments not being consulted before the
Government legislate will harm this United Kingdom, over which
King Charles is the Head of State. I beg the other place not to
take the amendments out because it is the elected House; I ask it
to take them out because it thinks that that would improve the
legislation. If it does not think that, please do not make us
look like unruly people.
(Lab)
My Lords, I add my thanks to the Minister for the way he has
conducted himself, and I thank others who supported him. I thank
the Bill team, which has been forthcoming about what it thinks
the Bill means. I also thank my noble friend Lady O’Grady, who
was thrown in at the deep end, as it were, having just arrived in
this House; she acquitted herself brilliantly and made some
forceful arguments. I thank all noble Lords who contributed to
the debate, particularly those on the Lib Dem Benches, who played
an active role, and those on the Bishops’ Benches, who played a
positive role in highlighting the evidence about what the Bill
could lead to.
On the point of the noble and learned Lord, Lord Thomas, this is
a skeleton Bill, and we do not really know what it means
legislatively. The remarks of the Minister’s friend, , sum it up: MPs will have
no idea about the practical implications of the implementation of
the powers that will be granted, not to the other House but to
Ministers. There is no proper scrutiny.
Nevertheless, we have done a very good job and have amended the
Bill. I hope that those amendments will be considered positively
down the other end, but, as I have said at every stage of the
Bill, when Labour returns to government fairly shortly, we will
repeal this legislation.
Bill passed and returned to the Commons with amendments.
|