Outdated, inefficient, expensive, at constant risk of failure or cyber-attack: complete and co-ordinated overhaul of systems at Defra needed to ensure air quality, safe food and water supply, says PAC
|
- Not enough focus on negative impact or cost to economy of
obsolete, disconnected systems - Defra risks wasting
money due to be spent on IT because it has not yet made key
business transformation decisions Defra systems are used by a
wide range of customers and are critical to the country’s trade,
disease prevention, flood protection, and air quality monitoring.
But in a report today the Public Accounts Committee says for its
customers, that...Request free trial
- Not enough focus on negative impact or cost to economy of obsolete, disconnected systems - Defra risks wasting money due to be spent on IT because it has not yet made key business transformation decisions Defra systems are used by a wide range of customers and are critical to the country’s trade, disease prevention, flood protection, and air quality monitoring. But in a report today the Public Accounts Committee says for its customers, that range from farmers to vets to scientists to traders and beyond, its legacy IT systems feel outdated and difficult to use. Defra and its organisations handle around 14 million transactions per year that still involve paper forms, making them inefficient and expensive. Though it is embarking on a fundamental review and potential restructure of its organisation, Defra does not yet have a concurrent pro-active strategy for the transformation of its digital services, or for challenges like reducing reliance on paper forms and making applications widely available on mobile phones. Defra estimates that it needs to spend £726 million on modernising legacy services between 2021 and 2025, and that fully transforming its digital systems could save £20 million to £25 million every year. But the Committee says the lack of overall vision means any changes made now to its digital systems may not be appropriate in the longer-term and could lead instead to wasted time and money. 80% of Defra’s IT applications remain either in extended support, possibly incurring additional charges for updates, or are completely unsupported by their supplier, and it hasn’t given enough attention to the impact of its poor digital services on its users. It doesn’t measure the cost to users of its unmodernised digital services, so it is not possible to assess the total burden they place on other organisations and the wider economy. For example, previously vets had to buy old laptops to be able to run the programmes they needed to use. Defra is struggling to recruit the digital, data and technology staff it needs, and so it remains over-reliant on contractors which can cost up to twice as much. The Committee is calling on Defra to explain what new approaches it will adopt to recruit staff and reduce its reliance on contractors and temporary staff to provide digital skills. Sir Geoffrey Clifton-Brown, Deputy Chair of the Committee, said: “Defra’s IT systems are so outmoded and disconnected - where they exist at all, instead of paper forms - that in some cases the professionals who keep our food, water and air safe have been forced to buy obsolete equipment just to fill in the forms to fulfil their regulatory responsibilities. We are facing down rapidly spreading animal diseases, maybe the next pandemic, with systems that may rely on moving paper forms around. This cannot continue. “We on the PAC will also not accept a situation where Defra spends hundreds of millions of taxpayers’ money on a disjointed upgrade programme only to find that it no longer fits the structure of new systems of air quality monitoring, food and clean water supply in this country. It’s time for a complete overhaul at Defra, with a concurrent, pro-active digital strategy that matches every step.” PAC report conclusions and recommendations 7. Defra has made good progress in tackling its most urgent legacy issues, though the majority of its applications are still not fully supported. Defra has one of the most significant legacy IT challenges across government, with a proliferation of outdated applications across the Defra Group. Of Defra’s 12 systems with the highest volume of public or business users, two are a mixture of modern and legacy systems and one is an entirely legacy system. Defra has made good progress in tackling its legacy systems so far. It has tackled the most pressing issues first and prioritised work on applications that most need to be stabilised in the short-term. However, 80% of Defra’s applications remain either in extended support, where Defra may have to pay additional charges for updates, or are completely unsupported by their supplier increasing the risk of failure or cyber attacks. Legacy problems have built up in systems related to older legislation, and Defra has tended to focus resources on building IT systems to address newer legislation such as the Future Farming and Countryside programme. Recommendation 1: Defra should, within six months, identify the success factors behind the progress it has made in addressing issues within its legacy IT, and share lessons with CDDO and other departments. 8. Defra does not have a strategy or vision needed for its long-term digital transformation. Defra has so far focused on stabilising its legacy applications by seeking to mitigate the biggest risks of cyber-attack or operational failure and is moving towards enhancing and transforming these applications. But it does not yet have a strategy for the transformation of its digital services and is not taking a proactive approach to challenges, such as reducing reliance on paper forms and making applications available on mobile phones. It has instead tended to be reactive and focus its efforts on areas that need to be addressed more urgently, such as implementing the IT systems needed for EU Exit. We would expect Defra to look at the digital needs across all of the organisations within the Defra Group and consider where it can make savings and improvements. Many different technologies and standards are used across Defra owing to how it has grown and developed over time, and the different approaches to technology adopted by different organisations within Defra. Defra does not yet have agreed standards for IT systems across the Department and its organisation that would ensure they are developed in a more consistent way across the Group. Recommendation 2: Defra should: a. develop its longer-term digital and data strategy, and ensure that this reflects the digital needs of organisations across the Defra Group; b. write to the Committee by the end of March 2024, outlining details of the actions planned in its strategy, including the measures it will use to monitor performance and how it will establish and implement Group-wide standards for technology and architecture. 9. Defra has not given enough attention to the impact of its poor digital services on its users. To users, legacy IT systems feel outdated or lack functionality and they are at higher risk of temporary crashes. Defra has recently upgraded its system that vets and farmers use to record bovine tuberculosis test results. Previously vets had to buy old laptops to be able to run the programme. Many legacy systems still rely heavily on paper forms or documents. Defra and its organisations handle around 14 million paper transactions each year. Defra intends to reduce its reliance on paper forms but is unable to say when this will happen. Despite the advantages of digital forms, there are barriers to increasing the use of digital-based applications and processes which Defra does not yet fully understand. For example, some customers prefer paper-based licenses, and Defra is working to understand and address the barriers to more of its customers using digital solutions. Defra does not measure the costs to its customers of its unmodernised digital services but is now attempting to include these in business cases for specific changes. Recommendation 3: In its Treasury Minute response, Defra should set out how it will identify the problems and costs faced by its service users as a result of unmodernised services, and how it is going to address each of them. 10. Defra is at risk of wasting money on digital services because it has not yet taken decisions on business transformation. In parallel with its work on legacy, Defra is embarking on a fundamental review of the structure of its organisation, including potentially major structural changes to the bodies and organisations that form the Defra Group. Some decisions about digital services need to be taken without delay. But without clarity on what the transformed Defra will look like, it is difficult for its digital specialists to prepare. If Defra makes decisions and undertakes work as part of improving its digital services before it has decided the future shape and structure of its business operations or before it has determined what its digital requirements are, it risks limiting the usefulness of the systems and causing future problems. It has assured us that it would not invest in building new digital systems that would have to be rebuilt to fit its new business model. Recommendation 4: As part of the Treasury Minute response, Defra should set out how it will ensure that investment and new digital systems put in place before it has made key decisions about the future shape, structure and digital needs of the Defra Group, will not need not to be rebuilt. 11. Defra is over-reliant on contractors because it struggles to recruit and retain the people with the digital skills it needs. Defra says it has reduced its reliance on contractors and temporary staff over the last year from 30% to 22%, but this is still too high. CDDO tells us that using some contingent labour is good for flexibility but that it can be up to twice as expensive for some roles. In June 2022, CDDO committed to reducing vacancies in the digital community across government departments to less than 10% by 2025. Between October 2021 and October 2022, Defra ran recruitment campaigns for 244 digital, data and technology roles but could not fill 31% of these roles. In October 2022, 14% of roles in the digital and data community were vacant across government. The digital, data and technology pay framework has helped to attract digital staff, and Defra expects forthcoming changes to the framework to help further. Defra has found that being able to offer home- and hybrid-working can make it easier to recruit staff. In addition, people often join Defra because they are committed to improving the environment and we encourage Defra to continue to capitalise on this. Recommendation 5: As part of the Treasury Minute response, Defra should: a. explain what new approaches it will adopt to recruit staff and reduce its reliance on contractors and temporary staff to provide digital skills; b. specify what target it is working towards for the appropriate level of contractors and temporary staff and when it expects to achieve it. 12. Defra does not yet know how it will meet Government’s ambitions for digital change within its existing resources. CDDO has agreed a set of challenging commitments with departments, and Defra is confident it can meet these. However, Defra received only 58% of the funding it bid for in the 2021 Spending Review and cannot deliver all its aspirations with the funding it has available. For example, it aims to digitise all of its 20 most used services but none of this work is yet funded. Defra has taken an ordered approach to prioritising its work, focussing on its riskiest digital systems first, such as those most likely to fail or at most risk of cyber-attack. It says it has saved money by decommissioning services as part of its review of legacy applications, and believes there is scope for it to save £20-£25 million if it modernised all its IT. However, Defra is unlikely to know the full extent of the cost savings and efficiency gains that are possible because it does not know all the additional costs of operating its legacy services, for example because of the need for manual processes. Recommendation 6: Defra should: a. strengthen its case for investment by developing its analysis of the efficiency savings that could be achieved through modernising its systems and processes; b. write to the Committee within a year with the results of this analysis and what action it plans to take as a result. 13. We welcome CDDO’s efforts to establish strong cross-government co-operation and collaboration to identifying and addressing legacy IT issues. Since our December 2021 report on the Challenges in implementing digital change, CDDO has worked with all departments to establish a common methodology across departments for prioritising legacy risk. It has developed a framework to identify vulnerable legacy systems and tested it with six departments including Defra. Covering 105 digital systems across the six departments, this has highlighted those which need immediate work. CDDO intends to use the framework with the remaining departments by the end of 2023. CDDO has worked closely with departments in the development of its Roadmap to identify problem areas that need to be tackled and has introduced a set of commitments that all departments have signed up to and agreed to fund from within their own budget. CDDO is also working with departments to determine how significant the financial benefits from addressing legacy can be, and it expects this will support departments’ bids for funding to HM Treasury. Recommendation 7: As part of the Treasury Minute response, CDDO should set out whether it is getting the traction needed from departments to achieve its missions, and report annually thereafter on its progress and any difficulties in working with departments. |
