Asked by
To ask His Majesty’s Government what assessment they have made of
the report by the Energy and Climate Intelligence Unit Cost of
Not Zero in 2022, published on 30 December 2022; and in
particular, the finding that the delay in switching to renewables
and improving energy efficiency resulted in some households
paying around £1,750 extra on their bills last year.
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department for Energy
Security and Net Zero () (Con)
My Lords, the Government remain committed to deploying renewables
and energy efficiency measures. Renewable electricity generation
has more than quadrupled since 2010, and will be supported
further by the annual contracts for difference scheme. For energy
efficiency, the Autumn Statement committed a further £6 billion
until 2028, in addition to the £6.6 billion committed over this
Parliament. This is alongside the £4 billion expanded ECO4 scheme
and the additional £1 billion ECO+ scheme, launching in the
spring.
(GP)
I thank the Minister for his response, but it was not really an
answer to my Question. The delay in going to renewables will be
made even worse now by the Government handing out gas and oil
licences, which completely goes against all common sense. If we
rush to renewables, which is possible, we can stimulate jobs and
make sure that consumers do not carry on shivering in their
homes. So will the Government commit to moving faster on this and
perhaps bring the deadline down to 2035, which is long enough
away anyway, rather than 2050?
(Con)
I actually do not fundamentally disagree with the noble Baroness,
but we are rushing out renewables deployment. We already have one
of the largest deployments of offshore renewables in the world.
We even have one of the largest solar capacities in Europe: we
have more solar generation than France. I agree that we need to
try to go faster. We are doing that—we have increased targets for
2030—but it takes time to roll these out. I disagree with the
noble Baroness about there being no requirement for oil and gas;
there will be during the transition, and we should get as much of
that as possible from domestic sources.
(LD)
My Lords, I congratulate the Minister on his appointment to the
new Department for Energy Security and Net Zero. I personally was
very pleased to hear of the establishment of that department,
because energy security comes about by net zero, renewables and
all those technologies. If that is the case, how come the
Government have approved a coal mine—fossil fuels—in Cumbria?
That clearly has trashed part of the UK’s reputation globally in
terms of the net-zero objective.
(Con)
I thank the noble Lord for his congratulations and I look forward
to working with him. My responsibilities will be pretty similar
to what they were before, but I accept the point he makes. I
refer him to the answer I gave to the noble Baroness, Lady Jones,
on renewables deployment. I do not want to get into the issue of
the coal mine, but, as he well knows, that is not to do with
power generation: we are phasing out coal for power generation
facilities.
(Con)
My Lords, I echo the words of the noble Lord, , about the restoration of a
department for energy, among other things. I declare an interest
as once having been Secretary of State at the Department of
Energy. I also congratulate my noble friend on his appointment.
Although we know that the long-term decline will be in oil, gas
and fossil fuels, which we want, the delay that caused such a
violent increase in oil and gas prices last year and the year
before was simply because we had failed to manage that decline
and to match supply with demand. As supply was outpaced by
demand—and the world has an excessive demand for oil and gas—the
result was a tenfold increase in gas prices, huge suffering, vast
instability, political concern about cuts in real wages and a
great deal of damage for millions of people. That is something
those pushing for renewables should keep firmly in their
minds.
(Con)
I know that my noble friend speaks with great authority on this
matter, given his background, but of course there are many
different aspects to the equation. Of course we need to expand
supply in renewables, which we are doing, but we also need to
reduce demand where we possibly can. That is where our various
energy-efficiency campaigns come in. We had a big public
relations campaign over the last few months, which has been
extremely successful in rolling out energy-efficiency
measures.
(Lab)
My Lords, the report makes it clear that the insulation of homes
was increasing until 2013, when government grants were cut. This
was followed by a 90% decline in rates of insulation, leaving us
with the least efficient homes in western Europe, with 12 million
in band D or below. The Government’s plans for this Parliament
and the next fall well short of what is needed, so will they
urgently review these plans to increase insulation rates much
faster?
(Con)
The noble Baroness is right that we need to do more on
insulation, but she is wrong about the progress. I will give her
the statistics: 47% of homes in England have now reached band C.
That is up from 14% in 2010. So we are making very rapid progress
in increasing the EPC rating. Of course, there is always more
that we can do, and I outlined some of the vast sums of money
that we are spending to the noble Baroness, Lady Jones.
(Non-Afl)
My Lords, have the Government yet read the World Climate
Declaration, which is supported by some 1,400 scientists and
professionals worldwide and finds that our climate is changing as
it always has and that man is not responsible, so really there is
nothing useful we can do about it? Why do the Government want to
go on wasting billions of pounds by running with the climate
scare lemmings who pretend otherwise?
(Con)
Well, I am not going to get into a debate with the noble Lord
about his statements. Let me perhaps give him another
perspective. Even somebody like him, a great British patriot,
should surely accept that, even he does not believe in the
net-zero target, that it makes sense to develop more renewable
sources of electricity in this country, so that we are not
dependent on unstable parts of the world for our oil and gas.
Despite what I said earlier about needing to expand production as
much as we can from the North Sea, it is a declining asset that
we will not have in future. Therefore, even in his world, it
surely makes sense to develop our energy supply locally in the
UK.
(LD)
My Lords, the Minister has just told your Lordships that we are
making rapid progress on energy efficiency. He will be aware that
back in September 2020 the Government consulted on raising energy
performance in the privately rented sector. If he looks at the
government website today, he will see that it says:
“Visit this page again soon to download the outcome to this
public feedback.”
How much longer must landlords wait to know exactly what the
Government want them to do to improve the energy efficiency of
the privately rented sector?
(Con)
Of course, landlords can voluntarily take action if they wish to
improve the performance of their buildings. We are looking at the
consultation responses at the moment. However, nobody should
pretend that these policy decisions are easy. It is simple and
straightforward to just pass a regulation saying that we have to
improve the performance, but if the net result of that is a net
loss of privately rented accommodation, particularly in poorer
parts of the country, there are many people who want that
accommodation and we will not have gained anything. So these
decisions are not easy, but we are looking at this.
(Lab)
My Lords, the report from the Energy and Climate Intelligence
Unit makes the cost of inaction and delay for households
abundantly clear. We also know how important it is for the
planet. I add my congratulations on the Minister’s role in the
new Department for Energy Security and Net Zero in the reshuffle
yesterday. Can I ask that this new department take its remit
seriously by urgently prioritising the relatively cheap and quick
options of renewable energy, onshore wind and solar, and making a
statement to that effect?
(Con)
I thank the noble Baroness for her congratulations, but her
question implies that we are not doing anything in this space at
the moment. Since 2010 the UK has seen a more than 500% increase
in the amount of renewable electricity. The UK continues to break
records in renewable electricity, which has more than quadrupled
since 2010, while low-carbon electricity overall now gives us
around 50% of our total generation. Of course we need to do more
and do it faster—we are doing that—but let us not try to pretend
that we have not made fantastic progress in this area.
(Con)
My Lords, my noble friend said the issue of solar power is of
great importance. While we are in favour of his policy in
general, many people, in rural areas in particular, are deeply
concerned about the way in which good agricultural land is
apparently now vulnerable to massive solar farms. This destroys
our countryside and is quite unnecessary. Does my noble friend
not agree?
(Con)
I do not agree with the noble Lord, actually. Only a relatively
small—in fact, tiny—proportion of land is taken up with solar
power generation, but of course we always have to make sure we
get the balance right. We need agricultural land, but we also
need more solar generation.
(CB)
My Lords, I declare my interests. Given the Minister’s compelling
argument for increasing home-grown renewable energy, can he
update the House on how the Government’s consultations on getting
a sensible planning regime for increasing onshore wind are
progressing?
(Con)
We already have considerable quantities of onshore wind, but I
know the noble Baroness’s commitment to seeing that rolled out
even further. As she will be aware, onshore wind will be eligible
for contracts for difference in the next allocation round
commencing in March, and we will consult shortly on developing
local partnerships for a number of supportive communities that
wish to host new onshore wind infrastructure in return for the
benefits that can then flow to those communities.