Asked by
To ask His Majesty’s Government what representations they have
received from organisations representing disabled people about
the widespread introduction of Driver Only Operated trains on the
rail network.
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department for
Transport () (Con)
My Lords, the Government regularly receive ideas and feedback
from the public and passenger bodies, including the Disabled
Persons Transport Advisory Committee. The proposed modernisation
reforms are intended to provide greater flexibility for operators
to deploy staff in multi-skilled customer-facing roles that are
able to deliver more assistance for disabled passengers and those
with additional needs.
(Lab)
My Lords, given that 45% of Network Rail stations are unstaffed
and that a similar number are only partially staffed, does the
Minister accept that that response does not reflect experiences
in the real world? The addition of driver-only operation to
unstaffed stations means that travel for the disabled,
particularly those in wheelchairs, becomes virtually impossible.
The Government’s attitude may well contravene both equalities and
disability discrimination legislation.
(Con)
The noble Lord makes an important point. Many factors feed into
the accessibility of our rail network, and that is why in the
Plan for Rail we committed to a national rail accessibility
strategy. This will take a system-wide approach and ensure that
we can make as many routes as possible accessible to all.
(Con)
I confess to my noble friend that I am a cynical old politician.
Recently, there has been the practice of split ticketing. It
takes me two hours to come here and now I get two tickets, one
for the first hour and one for the second hour. I do not need to
change trains; the price is the same. Can she reassure me that
this is not some device to show that more people take short
journeys and therefore need fewer people on board the train to
look after them, as opposed to people who take longer journeys,
which might merit a guard?
(Con)
My Lords, such cynicism! I will certainly take that away and
establish why it might be the case, but my noble friend makes a
very important point: our fares are too complicated and there are
simply too many. That is why, when the Secretary of State spoke
at the George Bradshaw address yesterday, he talked about what we
are doing to simplify fares by extending the single-fare pilot
and by piloting demand-based pricing, as there is in aviation.
Some tickets could be substantially cheaper when the demand is
less.
(CB)
My Lords, driver-only trains will be accompanied by the closure
of ticket offices and no platform staff in rural areas. Is the
Minister concerned that these measures will discriminate against
groups such as people with learning disabilities, who may often
need reassurance, have difficulty buying tickets from machines or
worry about last-minute changes to train times, and so on?
(Con)
The key to the ticket office issue is not that they will close
and the people staffing them will disappear; rather, they will
come out from behind the Perspex. In the example given by the
noble Baroness, somebody with learning difficulties could be
assisted to use a ticket machine. Perhaps in time, they would
feel more confident using the ticket machine with the assistance
of somebody who can leave the ticket office. Any changes to
ticket offices are set out in the ticketing and settlement
agreement and are subject to local consultation.
(LD)
My Lords, I have absolutely no doubt that the Minister puts
disability and disabled passengers at the heart of her views, but
for some years now she has been talking at the Dispatch Box about
this strategy and how access will improve. I find that, at least
once a week, the person I am expecting to get me off my train at
my home station has not been alerted by the station I departed
from. Without a conductor on the train, I have to go on to the
next station, or even the one after that, and then try to get a
train back—assuming I can. When will the system work for disabled
people, whether they are in wheelchairs, are visually impaired or
have learning difficulties?
(Con)
I am appalled at the circumstances the noble Baroness faces. The
system is in place but clearly is not working, and that is what
we have to fix. We have to go through every element of our
railway system, modernise it, and make it more accessible,
reliable, punctual and affordable.
(Lab)
My Lords, may I table the idea of level boarding for trains,
possibly with retracting ramps at each door? It would obviate the
need for people always to be at the station if wheelchair
operators could get on and off without anybody being there. It is
not a total solution, but it is a solution.
(Con)
The noble Lord raises an important point. There are many
solutions to improve accessibility for wheelchair users and other
people with reduced mobility. That is why the Access for All
scheme was launched back in 2006, and it has made huge strides to
improve the number of accessible routes into stations. Between
2019 and 2024, we are spending £383 million to add more
accessible routes. When we built the railways centuries ago, they
were not built to be accessible. I accept that it will take time
to make them 100% accessible, but that is where we want to
be.
(Con)
My Lords, do I take it from the answer my noble friend gave to
the noble Baroness, Lady Hollins, that it will be possible to
purchase a physical ticket at every mainline station?
(Con)
It will be possible to purchase a physical ticket in the vast
majority of cases, but I do not know about every single mainline
station, as there are many hundreds of them. We have seen over
time that people are not using physical tickets as much any more.
We have to take into account the multiverse of different needs of
the ticket-buying public to ensure that people can use the sorts
of tickets that they want to.
(Lab)
My Lords, building on the testimony of the noble Baroness, Lady
Brinton, the difference between disabled passengers who have a
problem and ordinary passengers that have a problem is that in
the case of the disabled passenger, the impact is almost
catastrophic. Whereas occasional things going wrong are tolerable
in a mainline system, for disabled passengers it must be 100%.
The noble Baroness’s experience is not a singular one: the Office
of Rail and Road did a survey of passenger assisting in July
2022. Almost a quarter—23%—of all the assistance that they booked
was not received. 11% of passengers are not met by staff and a
further 7% have to wait too long. And there is the emotional side
of it: there is still concern that 28% do not feel confident that
all the elements of the assistance they have booked will be
delivered on the day of travel. The question is quite
straightforward: is that acceptable? We do not want to hear about
input; we want to hear about output.
(Con)
Well, I do not think that anybody would say that that is
acceptable and that is why we are actually doing things about it.
Part of the reforms we want to introduce is to have
multi-skilled, passenger-facing roles whereby people are trained
to deal with passengers with reduced mobility and those with
learning difficulties to help them use the railways, so that the
railways work for them.
(Con)
My Lords, do these important questions that have been raised
today not raise the very clear point that the rail strikes are a
battle, not simply against ordinary people who want to go to
work, children who want to go to school and elderly people who
want to visit their families, but most of all against perhaps the
most disadvantaged category: the disabled? This is a strike which
hits the disabled. Would my noble friend agree with that
characterisation?
(Con)
I agree with my noble friend that the strikes do indeed hit every
single passenger who uses our railways. What worries me the most
is that some of those passengers will not come back. We need a
collaborative and constructive relationship with the unions,
because things have to change. Our railways must change; we must
see reform so that they work for disabled passengers and indeed
all passengers.
(Lab)
My Lords, I travel to your Lordships’ House on the train most
days. Not so long ago, I was travelling on a very crowded train
when the young woman next to me completely passed out. We were
crowded shoulder to shoulder. I did not know whether she had had
some sort of attack or simply fainted. There was no means of
getting the guard’s attention—there was no guard. Now, the young
woman concerned may or may not have been in dire difficulty, but
the fact is that all trains now tell you that you cannot pull a
communication cord but must wait until the next station.
Supposing she had had some sort of heart attack, and there was no
guard there to help her. It is a terrible experience to have gone
through, and what the Minister has said does not reassure me at
all that she understands the predicament of disabled people or
people in the position I was in.
(Con)
What we are looking at is not necessarily taking people off
trains but ensuring that the people who are on the trains are
able to provide precisely the sort of assistance that that person
may have needed. The reality is that if one is on a train which
stops fairly frequently, the best option, if it is
driver-only-operated and there is no guard, is to wait until the
next station, because such trains tend to be on routes where the
stations very close together. On longer routes, where the
stations are far apart, there are other people on the train
looking after passengers, and in those circumstances that person
would have been able to help.