Scott Benton (Blackpool South) (Con) I beg to move, That the Bill
be now read a Second time. I am pleased that we have time to debate
this important issue in the Chamber. I know that many hon. Members
in the Chamber will have a personal interest in this area and am
grateful for their participation. Zero-hours contracts are an
important part of the UK’s flexible labour market, both for
employers when there is not a constant demand for staff and for
individuals who need to...Request free
trial
(Blackpool South) (Con)
I beg to move, That the Bill be now read a Second time.
I am pleased that we have time to debate this important issue in
the Chamber. I know that many hon. Members in the Chamber will
have a personal interest in this area and am grateful for their
participation. Zero-hours contracts are an important part of the
UK’s flexible labour market, both for employers when there is not
a constant demand for staff and for individuals who need to
balance work around other commitments such as childcare and
study. However, the 2017 Taylor review of modern working
practices found that workers on zero-hours contracts, as well as
agency workers and temporary workers, struggle where flexibility
is “one-sided” in an employer’s favour. Some employers misuse
flexible working arrangements to create unpredictability and
insecurity of income, and there is a reluctance among some
workers to assert basic employment rights. That one-sided
flexibility means that workers need to be available to their
employer with absolutely no guarantee of work. Employers can also
schedule or cancel shifts with little notice, leading to
insecurity of hours and income for workers—or, in the case of
temporary workers, dismissal altogether at short notice.
To address one-sided flexibility, the Taylor review recommended
that the Government should create a new right to request a
contract with guaranteed hours for zero-hours contract workers.
The successful passage of my Bill would create a new right for
eligible workers to request a more predictable working
pattern.
(Cities of London and
Westminster) (Con)
I welcome my hon. Friend’s private Member’s Bill, because it is
incredibly important to give people on zero-hours contracts the
security of knowing that they will have protected hours. Does he
agree that, as we are trying to encourage the over-50s back into
the workplace, the Bill may go some way to giving them security
over their hours and pay for the work that they do?
I thank my hon. Friend for her intervention. She is a brilliant
champion for her constituents in the Cities of London and
Westminster. Of course, the nature of the economy in central
London means that, often, people will be in the retail,
hospitality and the tourism industry with insecure work. I thank
her for championing the Bill. The point that she makes regarding
older people in employment is important. The Government are
actively looking at that. I hope that they continue to press the
issue to ensure that we can address labour shortages by widening
the pool of potential people to take those vacancies.
The new right would give workers who would like more certainty
the ability to request a more predictable work pattern that
reflects the hours or times that they work. A qualifying worker
would be able to make an application to change their existing
work pattern if it lacked predictability in terms of the hours or
times they worked, or if they have a fixed-term contract for less
than 12 months. The Bill would ensure that workers and employers
retain the benefits of zero-hours contracts and other forms of
atypical work. Of course, workers who are content to work more
varied hours will continue to be able to do so.
Many individuals who work unpredictable patterns often experience
an imbalance of power with their employers, which leaves them
afraid to ask for more fixed conditions out of fear of being
dismissed or denied future shifts. The Bill would address that
unfair imbalance of power, empowering and encouraging workers to
talk to their employer about their contract, safe in the
knowledge that starting the conversation would not result in any
detriment whatsoever to the worker. Workers will be better able
to secure employment that suits their individual circumstances,
helping them to be more satisfied at work and less stressed
around the lack of predictability of their hours and income.
(Bristol East) (Lab)
It is good that we have cross-party support on this issue as
well. It is one thing for an employee to have a right, but as we
have seen, quite often employers who do not want to give their
employees those rights and treat them well have ways of getting
around that; they will find an excuse to dismiss the employee and
take on somebody who might be prepared to be more flexible. How
does the hon. Gentleman envisage that the safeguards and rights
under this Bill will be genuinely enforced? I would suggest trade
union membership as a pretty good start.
I thank the hon. Lady for her intervention and I will get to that
section of my speech in a couple of minutes. She does great
justice to the people in her constituency who work on zero-hours
contracts by raising that important point. The Bill introduces a
right to request a more predictable working pattern and the
process employers have to follow is clearly outlined to ensure
that there is some certainty when employees request that their
contract is changed and that their employer deals with them
seriously and appropriately.
The Bill helps to support the income security of workers at a
time when many are feeling increased cost of living pressures. It
will not only benefit workers; businesses will reap the rewards
of having a more engaged and happier workforce. The rights
introduced through my Bill will apply to all eligible workers,
including agency workers, not only those employed on zero-hours
contracts; it will apply to the wide range of workers who have
unpredictable working conditions, including temporary workers,
agency workers and workers with non-guaranteed hours.
Workers must have worked for their employer for a set period of
time before an application can be made. This period will be set
out in regulations; I am sure the Minister will expand on that in
his remarks, but it is expected to be 26 weeks. The worker only
needs to have been employed with their employer at some point
during the month before that period and to be working again for
the employer when the application is made. Given that the Bill
targets workers with unpredictable working patterns, they are not
required to have worked for their employer continuously.
The same criteria will apply to agency workers applying to
temporary work agencies. Agency workers who make applications
directly to hirers will be required to have worked for their
hirer for at least 12 weeks continuously during the 26-week
period. This replicates the provision in the Agency Workers
Regulations 2010 which states that after 12 weeks’ continuous
service an agency worker will gain entitlement to the same set of
employment rights as if they had been recruited directly. It
ensures that workers cannot use the right to request a more
predictable contract to circumvent the agency workers regulations
and gain entitlement to additional employment rights before they
have worked those 12 continuous weeks.
Once a worker has made their request, the employer will be
required to notify them of their decision within one month. An
employer will be able to turn down a request for more predictable
conditions on specific statutory grounds, similar to those
established for the existing right to request flexible working.
That will help to ensure that businesses are not unfairly
burdened by the new right, for example if the costs of providing
a worker with a more predictable pattern would be too burdensome
at the time.
Workers will have the option to complain to an employment
tribunal if their employer does not handle the request in a
reasonable manner, wrongly treats the request as withdrawn,
dismisses or treats the worker poorly because of their request,
or rejects the application on the basis of incorrect facts. We
assume, however, that most declined requests will be handled
informally and will not give rise to an employment tribunal
claim.
I thank officials at the Department for Business, Energy and
Industrial Strategy for their assistance with drafting the Bill
and the arrangements for today. This area has broad cross-party
support: indeed, it was included in the manifesto I stood on and
the Liberal Democrats and Labour made similar commitments on
zero-hours contracts in their manifestos. I hope that Members on
both sides of the House share my desire to ensure that the Bill
succeeds. As you will know, Mr Deputy Speaker, there is a certain
fragility, to say the least, that accompanies the passage of
private Members’ Bills through the House, and I would therefore
like to navigate this process with the support of Members on a
cross-party basis.
This Bill is a golden opportunity to bring about real change on
the pressing issues of atypical contracts and one-sided
flexibility, at a time when insecurity of pay and hours is
particularly pressing. I hope that Members will be able to
support it.
1.50pm
(Devizes) (Con)
I am delighted to support the Bill, and I congratulate my hon.
Friend the Member for Blackpool South () on presenting it and on his
speech. I am pleased that the Government are giving the Bill
their backing. Of course, it was a Conservative-led Government
who banned exclusivity clauses in 2015, which was an important
step towards the system of worker protection that is needed in
the new economy that is unfolding. I am pleased to see that we
are supporting this new measure, which will end the system of
one-sided flexibility that prevails and ensure that workers can
request a predictable pattern of work. It is right that we are
doing that.
The Bill sits in the context of a broader question about the
model of work we want in 2023. One part of the answer to that
question is that we want a model of work that is not fixed or
ossified, as work perhaps was in the industrial age. We cannot
respond to the gig economy by insisting on restrictions and
inflexibilities that are inappropriate to this age. Ultimately,
we will end up destroying jobs if we insist on too much structure
and predictability, but neither can we chase the gig economy down
the plughole of ever greater rights for employers at the expense
of their staff. We cannot let employers dictate terms that
include unacceptably low wages or unacceptable conditions.
One part of the answer, which is not within the scope of the
Bill, is to ensure we have an immigration policy that ends the
economic model of the last 20 years, in which we have imported
foreign labour at the expense of British workers and at the
expense of investment in our own people and in the innovation and
technology that are needed if labour has its real value, which it
does not if our rates of immigration are too high.
We also need to empower workers. My hon. Friend explained the
problem very well. People are not robots that we can just switch
on and off and leave dormant when we are not using them, waiting
for us to switch them on again. We have to respect the human
dignity of staff. As I said in an earlier debate, we need to
recognise that people are not just workers; they have obligations
and relationships outside work that we need to respect.
The question of what model of work we want is part of a broader
question about what type of life we think people should have in
this country. My simple answer is that we want people to have the
conditions for a decent family and community life. An important
measure to achieve that is ensuring we have a model of employment
in which one adult can earn enough wages to support their family.
We need jobs that support whole families, whether that is one
full-time job or two, three or four part-time jobs. If someone
has a partner, they need to be able to share the workload, to
earn enough money to support the family, enabling them to have
time for children or dependent adults and, importantly, to spend
time supporting their community.
This introduction of a right to request a predictable pattern of
work is good, and I applaud it. I like the fact that we are
imposing a duty on employers in terms of what they should do when
a request for a predictable pattern of work is made. I prefer
duties to rights—the language is better, and the implication is
better. We need to beware the wrong enforcement of duties that we
create, but in principle, duties are better than rights because
they imply relationships and obligations. The alternative—a world
in which society is regulated only by individual rights—is one of
eternal competition, a constant contest between individuals each
claiming their due and eternal legal battles over who has broken
which contract and which law.
We need a better culture than that, in which we recognise that we
live under our obligations, not our entitlements, and our
responsibilities matter more than our rights. That starts with
people who have power in society—people with the power to hire
and fire. We are insisting today on the fulfilment of employers’
duty to enable their staff to create the conditions for a decent
family and community life. That is a good use of the power of the
state, and I am delighted to support the Bill.
Mr Deputy Speaker ( )
I call the Opposition spokesperson.
1.54pm
(Bradford East) (Lab)
I congratulate the hon. Member for Blackpool South () on bringing forward this
very important Bill. I apologise: I may have mistakenly referred
to him as the hon. Member for Blackpool North earlier; I know
that can cause serious issues on occasion.
I will endeavour to keep my remarks brief as I am sure that
Members across the House will wish to wrap up this debate and
move the Bill on to the next stage of the legislative process as
soon as possible. This appears to be a welcome piece of
legislation, as measures to give workers the right to request
more predictable terms and conditions of work are long overdue.
Indeed, over the past decade we have seen an explosion in the use
of unpredictable and exploitative zero-hours contracts that fail
to guarantee for working people a set number of hours of work on
set work schedules.
In 2010, just over 150,000 workers were employed on a zero-hours
contract, but that number has risen dramatically, with more than
1 million now employed on such contracts, according to the latest
release from the Office for National Statistics. As the hon.
Member for Blackpool South highlighted, it does not reflect a
rise in the number of people wanting flexible work, as such
contracts offer flexibility only for employers, not for working
people. It is a rise in the number of people who are being
exploited in a dire employment market by bad bosses.
Under these contracts, working people feel pressured into
accepting shifts, knowing that if they turn them down, they may
not get any hours at all in future. Many are given hours at short
notice: a TUC poll found that four in five were offered shifts
with less than 24 hours’ notice, leaving them scrambling for
childcare cover or transport to work, often at great cost. They
are left entirely at the whim of the employer and, as a result,
zero-hours contract workers find it next to impossible to plan
their finances on time, thereby holding them back and holding
back our economy. Is it really any wonder why our productivity is
so poor compared with other countries when working people are
exploited in this way? Women and those from an ethnic minority
background are more likely to be exploited by zero-hours
contracts, entrenching the discrimination they already face in
the workplace.
I was, then, pleased that in their December 2018 good work plan
the Government accepted that this is an issue that faces our
economy in the 21st century and that action is needed to protect
people’s rights in the modern world of work. However, as for many
other pieces of legislation to address the injustices faced by
working people, we have been waiting for far too long to see a
Bill like this on the Floor of the House. published his review of
modern working practices in July 2017 and it took another year
and a half for the Government to publish their good work plan in
December 2018. Although they accepted the recommendation to
create a right to request a contract that guarantees hours for
those on zero-hours contracts, it is not until now—more than four
years later—that we are seeing legislation to give effect to
it.
Why did the Government not include this legislation in the
employment Bill that they have repeatedly promised from the
Dispatch Box but appear now to have dropped? Such a Bill offered
a clear opportunity to introduce the statutory right to request
more predictable terms and conditions, as well as the opportunity
to strengthen protections for pregnant women and new parents, to
introduce a statutory right to carer’s leave and to protect
people from harassment in the workplace—today alone we have
considered Bills on all those things.
I want to be absolutely clear that the next Labour Government
will, within the first 100 days of our taking office, move to put
on the statute book our new deal for working people, which will
ban zero-hours contracts and contracts without a minimum number
of guaranteed hours. It will ensure that everyone working regular
hours for 12 weeks or more will gain a right to a regular
contract that will reflect the hours normally worked. It will
ensure that all workers get reasonable notice of any change in
shifts or working time, with wages for any shift cancelled
without appropriate notice being paid to workers in full.
We will, of course, support this Bill. I look forward to seeing
it progress to Committee very soon, so that we waste no more time
to enhance much-needed rights for working people.
2.00pm
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Business, Energy
and Industrial Strategy ()
I thank my hon. Friend the Member for Blackpool South () for proposing this important
Bill, and I thank all hon. Members who have spoken on this
subject. I am pleased to say that the Government support the Bill
and are committed to ensuring that the UK is the best place in
the world to start and scale a business—a phrase hon. Members
will hear a lot more, after the Business Secretary’s recent
speech from Davos about scale-up Britain, which is music to my
ears. To do that, we need a strong and flexible labour market
that supports participation and economic growth.
I would like to take a little time to talk about the Bill before
addressing some points raised by hon. Members on both sides of
the House. It is good to see cross-party support, for the third
time today. Unlike the shadow Minister, we believe that
zero-hours contracts are an important part of the UK’s flexible
labour market, both for employers that do not have a constant
demand for staff and for individuals who need to balance work
around other commitments such as childcare and study. Around 1
million individuals are on zero-hours contracts—around 3% of the
UK workforce.
The Government are keen to ensure that everybody can enjoy the
benefits of flexible working. We are determined to tackle unfair
working practices, such as the issue of one-sided flexibility
where workers have to be available to their employer, with no
guarantee of work. Employers may schedule or cancel shifts with
little notice, leading to insecurity of work and income. I
declare my interest, because my daughters are in a similar
situation—one is of school age and works at the local pub, and
that has happened to her. To be fair, a zero-hours contract works
for her to provide flexibility from her side, too.
We recognise that receiving unpredictable and varying levels of
income each month can make it difficult for some workers to meet
the cost of rent, mortgage and household bills, especially during
a cost of living crisis. My hon. Friend’s Bill will allow workers
to request more predictable working arrangements, addressing the
issue of one-sided flexibility, while ensuring that workers are
able to continue working on a zero-hours contract or another form
of non-guaranteed hours or temporary contract, if that is the
type of arrangement that works best for them.
(Bath) (LD)
Does the Minister agree that it is important that employers feel
that there is loyalty to their companies and loyalty to the work
that the employee is doing? It should very much be a win-win.
I agree entirely. That is what modern employers are looking for.
One of the biggest pressures that employers are facing is
recruiting and retaining people. This is another measure where
people can demonstrate that the workplace is fairer and more
flexible, which should attract more people back into it.
The Bill will allow individuals and businesses to strike the
right balance between flexibility and job security. Workers will
be empowered and encouraged to start conversations with their
employers about their work patterns, with the confidence that
starting such a conversation will not result in detriment. We
expect that employers will benefit from the new right, too—the
point that the hon. Member for Bath made—through improved worker
satisfaction and productivity. By allowing employers to retain
skilled staff as workers, those workers will not have to look for
a new role in order to secure a working pattern that meets their
needs.
Facilitating higher productivity, both through this measure and
the other five private Members’ Bills that we are supporting,
will help to drive higher employment, wages and economic growth.
As my hon. Friend the Member for Blackpool South has explained,
the right will function in a similar way to the existing right to
request flexible working. An employer will be able to refuse a
request for more predictable working patterns on specific
statutory grounds similar to those established for flexible
working. We know how important it is to balance new workers’
rights with the impact on businesses, and those grounds will
ensure that employers do not experience disproportionate
burdens.
The Government consulted in 2018 on the right to request a more
predictable contract, and the vast majority of respondents agreed
with the creation of a right to request a more predictable
working pattern.
Mr (South West Hertfordshire)
(Con)
I congratulate the Minister on his usual excellent summation of
the legislation. On that final point, does he agree that giving
employers certainty and giving employees the ability to have
flexible working is a win-win and a good thing for both
sides?
I entirely agree. That is why we have carefully struck a balance
so that there will not be too much of a burden on employers. That
would be detrimental to employees, too, because employers would
be less likely to take people on. The right to consider it is
clear, and the process is clear, but if it cannot work for the
business, the process of saying, “I’m sorry, we can’t do that” is
simple and set out in regulations.
The Government consulted in 2018 on the right to request a more
predictable contract, and in response to that consultation we
committed to introducing a right to request a more stable working
pattern for all workers, including those on zero-hours contracts.
Those workers will be able to make a request if their existing
work pattern lacks predictability in terms of the length of their
contract or the days or hours that they are required to work. The
2019 Conservative manifesto contained a commitment to introduce
for workers
“a right to request a more predictable contract”.
I am therefore delighted that the Bill introduced by my hon.
Friend the Member for Blackpool South reflects our previous
commitments on this important issue.
The Bill will also build on the progress that the Government have
already made in bringing forward measures allowing additional
flexibility for workers on zero-hours contracts and those in low
pay. As my hon. Friend the Member for Devizes () pointed out, in 2015 this
Government banned exclusivity clauses in zero-hours contracts,
helping workers on zero-hours contracts to secure additional
employment and boost their incomes. As of December 2022, that ban
has been extended to workers who have a guaranteed weekly income
equivalent to or below the lower earnings limit of £123 per week.
On top of that, on 1 April 2023 the Government will increase the
national living wage for workers aged 23 and over by 9.7%, to
£10.42. That keeps the Government on track to achieve our
manifesto commitment for the national living wage to equal two
thirds of median earnings by 2022 if economic conditions
allow.
This is the sixth private Member’s Bill on employment rights that
the Government are backing. As a package, those Bills will
increase workforce participation, protect vulnerable workers and
level the playing field, ensuring that unscrupulous businesses do
not have a competitive advantage. The Bills build on the
strengths of our flexible and dynamic labour market and give
businesses the confidence to create jobs and invest in their
workforce, allowing them to generate long-term prosperity and
economic growth.
I will address some of the specific points made by colleagues.
This is the Bill of my hon. Friend the Member for Blackpool
South, and I am pleased to be able to explain the Government’s
policy position on any points that he has raised. My hon. Friend
the Member for Cities of London and Westminster (), who is no longer in her
place, made a point about the over-50s. It is important that we
try to attract more over-50s who have left the workforce back
into the workplace. We know that about 575,000 people of working
age have left the workforce since the start of the pandemic. I
joined a cross-ministerial group, put together with business
groups, to look at how we can attract those people back into the
workforce. That body of work is ongoing, and we are very keen to
find solutions, which will be partly about making the workplace
fairer and more flexible, as this legislation will do.
As my hon. Friend the Member for Blackpool South pointed out, the
legislation will lead to a happier and more engaged workforce. He
also mentioned the 26-week qualification period, which aligns
with other, similar measures in employment law. As he points out,
this results from a manifesto commitment, which is why we are
delighted to be able to support his Bill today.
My hon. Friend the Member for Devizes made similar points and
also talked about the balance to be struck between employer and
employee and the other work we are doing and have done to improve
workers’ rights, including that ban on exclusivity clauses. The
shadow Minister, the hon. Member for Bradford East (), said that the Opposition
were considering banning zero-hours contracts and other measures
if they ever got into government—I very much hope that day will
not come. By implementing things like that, there could be some
serious damage to the economy, were that situation to come to
pass. Nevertheless, we will let the electorate decide on
that.
To conclude, this Bill will introduce an important new right that
will help to address the issue of one-sided flexibility and
support those with unpredictable working arrangements to gain
security of hours and income. It has been encouraging to see
support across the House for this Bill, as is evident from
today’s good-natured debate. The Government look forward to
continuing to work closely with my hon. Friend the Member for
Blackpool South to support the passage of these measures, and I
commend the Bill to the House.
2.10pm
With the leave of the House, I thank Members for their
contributions today. In particular, my hon. Friend the Member for
Devizes () as ever made a thoughtful
contribution, and I agree wholeheartedly with his comments about
the need to utilise the experience, skills and potential of
British workers, rather than automatically reaching for this
lever of unskilled immigration and workers from overseas. I thank
the hon. Member for Bradford East () for signalling the support
of the official Opposition for my Bill. There is also the
brilliant support from the Government, particularly the Minister
and his private team, who have been incredibly helpful over the
past few weeks and alleviated some of my stress with their
technical guidance on some of the finer points of the Bill. That
has been greatly appreciated.
I know that my fellow Thatcherite, my hon. Friend the Member for
Christchurch ( ), is keen to introduce
his Bill, so I will keep my remarks short. Suffice it to say, I
hope that Members on both sides of the House can agree that this
important piece of legislation will give workers struggling with
unpredictability in their working lives a way of addressing that,
by empowering them to discuss their working conditions with their
employer to see whether they can gain more predictability in
their hours and income. I commend the Bill to the House.
Question put and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time; to stand committed to a
Public Bill Committee (Standing Order No. 63).
|