This would also stop the scandal whereby students are encouraged
to take on debt in return for poor quality, unhelpful university
degree courses.
- The Higher education funding system is failing students and
taxpayers and is not sustainable.
- Public funding is at risk from the large taxpayer losses on
student loans (ca. £10.5 billion per year).
- Meanwhile, the proposed tuition fee freeze until 2024-5, in
the context of high inflation, will put universities under severe
financial stress.
- Universities are paid for enrolling as many students as
possible, rather than on the basis of the outcomes they deliver
for graduates. This has resulted in abuses of the system such as
the mismatch of students and courses, an explosion in the number
of unconditional offers and the launch of courses with poor
academic and economic value.
- Many students are getting a poor deal, and a large proportion
will suffer an effective earnings loss from attending university
due to low earnings and increasing loan costs, with a liability
that can last 40 years and a capital repayment value that grows
with inflation.
- The author’s proposal would allow universities to raise
tuition fees above the frozen levels while requiring them to lend
the difference to their students by means of risk and income
sharing schemes. This would secure the extra resources they need
while creating incentives for institutions to improve graduate
outcomes and ensure courses are relevant.
- This would be a win-win all-round. Freezing the state loan at
current levels could save taxpayers £60bn over twenty years.
Universities new freedom to set tuition fee levels ensures they
have the resources they need to teach and compete
internationally. Students will gain from better courses now the
interests of the institution are aligned with theirs.
The IEA’s new paper, Setting
Universities Free: How to deliver a sustainable student funding
system, by , Managing Director at
Consulting AM and Tom McKenzie, Professor of Economics at CBS
International Business School, argues that the university funding
model is broken and needs fundamental reform.
Students are experiencing a declining earnings premium, higher
borrowing costs and, for many, poor quality courses. Universities
are struggling with reduced revenues while academics complain
about poor pay and working arrangements. The government has
consistently sought to minimise the growing student debt that
will be written off – and essentially funded by the
taxpayer.
The central problem, according to Ainsworth and McKenzie, is that
universities are remunerated on the basis of how many students
they can enrol, rather than on the basis of graduate
outcomes. This incentivises the expansion of
mass-market, low-quality courses that fail to prepare students
for the workforce.
The paper proposes an alternative funding model in which the
university’s income is contingent on future earnings, thus
marrying the long-term interests of students with those of the
university. This will make universities more responsive to
student demands, while forcing them to consider the suitability
of the courses they offer and the students they
enrol.
The authors also propose lifting the tuition fee cap, to help
universities prosper and compete both domestically and
internationally allowing for new investment and higher
productivity to ensure better value for money in the
long-term.
Freezing state support for higher education would also save
taxpayers £60bn over 20 years and slowly phase out universities’
reliance on the state as inflation erodes the government’s
contribution to tuition fee loans.
Overhauling our current system is necessary to ensure that
universities can match their foreign competitors, that they are
accountable to students, that taxpayers are given value for
money, and that universities’ success is tied to the success of
its students rather than the number of students they can recruit.
Implementing Ainsworth and McKenzie’s recommendations would be a
strong first step in such an overhaul.
Commenting on the report, author , said:
“In his first major speech as Chancellor referred to our universities as
one of the country’s great strengths. They will not stay that way
without more money. Our scheme secures for them the extra
resources they need without a single extra penny being required
of the taxpayer. Students gain from the partnership this system
ensures, so the institution will be invested in their success.
It’s good for all parties and is the sustainable funding system
that thus far has eluded the UK.”
Co-author Tom McKenzie, said:
“Discussion of higher-education funding tends to centre
around access to university rather than what a university
education actually does for a student. The system we propose both
encourages access based on merit and incentivises institutions to
consider employability as more than just another league-table
statistic.”