John McDonnell (Hayes and Harlington) (Lab) I beg to move, That
this House has considered the role of local councils in levelling
up. The debate is about the role of local councils in the
levelling-up strategy that the Government are pursuing. I applied
for it because I had hoped that the Government’s White Paper would
have been published either last week or this week. Unfortunately,
it has been delayed until the new year. Nevertheless, at least the
debate gives us...Request free trial
(Hayes and Harlington)
(Lab)
I beg to move,
That this House has considered the role of local councils in
levelling up.
The debate is about the role of local councils in the
levelling-up strategy that the Government are pursuing. I applied
for it because I had hoped that the Government’s White Paper
would have been published either last week or this week.
Unfortunately, it has been delayed until the new year.
Nevertheless, at least the debate gives us an opportunity to feed
some last thoughts into the pre-White Paper discussions in
Government on the way forward, although the reality is that the
most valuable dialogue will most probably come as the Government
plan the detail of the roll-out and delivery of the policies set
out in the White Paper.
The Government have rightly put great emphasis on levelling up
the country, so much so that we now have a new Department—the
Department for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities. However,
they have not yet defined what achieving levelling up would look
like, what targets they have set themselves to achieve through
that policy programme, or what the timescale for the programme
will be. Hopefully, the White Paper will set out these things
clearly when it is published in the new year.
There is widespread agreement that there is a need for levelling
up. Way back in 2016, at a conference that I convened in
Liverpool, I launched a similar policy with the CBI, using its
regional government investment analysis at that time. That
demonstrated the stark inequalities that exist. The figures are
stark. London receives about twice as much capital investment per
person as the south-west of England and the north-west of England
receives only two thirds of the level that London receives.
Back then, I also used Department of Health statistics to
demonstrate the consequences of inequality, and particularly the
consequences of low incomes and poverty, with a difference in
life expectancy of 20 years between Kensington in Liverpool and
Kensington in London. The Minister may know that we have two
Scousers in Westminster Hall today to evidence that.
The harsh reality, which we have all accepted, is that this
imbalance of investment has meant that too much priority has been
given to investment in parts of London and the south-east, as
well as too many of the best jobs in the country. I speak as a
London MP, because there are also grotesque levels of inequality
within London and the south-east. Over-investment and the heat
that it generates in such an particular economy has a negative
impact on the area, with exorbitant housing costs that leave many
workers priced out of ever owning their own home and paying a
disproportionate amount of their wages in rent.
The other element, which I have drawn attention to in past
debates, is the way that, just to keep a roof over their heads,
families are working every hour God sends, which unfortunately
undermines family life as well. The grotesque imbalances in our
economy are not an accident, or even the invisible hand of the
market. They are a deliberate, ongoing Government policy—one that
has gone on for the last four decades, at least, regardless of
the party in Government.
I looked at the detailed analysis of what the cost of levelling
up would be. To bring every UK nation and region up to London’s
level of funding would require an additional £30 billion in
annual capital investment per year. Even to level up every nation
and region to the current UK average, the capital spend required
would be an additional £6 billion in funding.
To be successful, levelling up has to be about more than capital
spend. It has to be about more than just physical infrastructure,
important though that is. We need a comprehensive and holistic
approach to building both the physical and the social capital of
an area, but that cannot be done when local government funding
from central Government is about £16 billion lower than it was in
2010. There has been a cumulative reduction of more than £100
billion in central Government funding for local councils over the
last decade.
(Liverpool, West Derby)
(Lab)
It is an honour to serve under your chairmanship, Mrs Miller. On
the funding aspect, Liverpool has lost £450 million since 2010,
with further cuts of £32 million expected in April. Levelling up
rings hollow in Liverpool. The sustained attacks that we have
seen, starting with the Conservative and Liberal Democrat
coalition in 2010, have ripped the heart out of the fabric of
Liverpool, so levelling up is hollow rhetoric there. I look
forward to the next Government spending review for local
councils.
The message I am trying to get across is that although the
emphasis in Government announcements has been on capital
spending, levelling up will not become a reality in cities like
Liverpool and elsewhere unless we address the issue of council
funding overall. When we debate the White Paper, I hope that we
can have a serious and sensible debate about how, over time, we
can address what has happened over the last 11 years. We can have
a political knockabout about whether or not it was justified, but
I think we just have to move on and look at how we can address
the situation, perhaps being more creative than we have been in
the past.
The situation is serious in Liverpool, but it is not just
Liverpool. In recent years, we have seen three councils issue
section 114 notices, while another dozen or so have had to call
in exceptional financial support from the Government to avoid the
same fate. I do not know whether the Minister saw the recent
evidence session of the Public Accounts Committee, but we know
that there are possibly dozens more councils in contact with the
Department over their financial situation.
The issue of central Government funding has to be addressed. The
figures are pretty stark. Since the 2015-16 financial year, local
authorities have lost 41% of their central Government
funding—equivalent to the loss of £8.7 billion a year. Although I
accept that some of that has been offset by the retention of
business rates and raising council tax above inflation in recent
years, it has still left councils with significant real-terms
losses in their overall spending power. It has had real
consequences for all parts of the country.
According to the briefing provided by Unison, the local
government union, councils in England have closed more than 859
children’s centres since 2010, although that figure has been
contested—some people think it is actually more. They listed 940
youth centres and 738 libraries that have been closed, while
funding for more than 1,200 bus routes has been withdrawn. That
has an impact on communities across the country that has to be
addressed if we are going to genuinely level up.
I will give an example. It is difficult to see how local
economies can be levelled up if childcare and support for parents
is not available. How can we level up our town centres and high
streets if people do not have a means of transport to get there,
or even just basic public conveniences when they do? My argument
is that, when we debate the levelling-up White Paper—I look
forward to it—we need to debate both the revenue and capital
funding that is needed. Let us look at one region, the north-west
of England; this example will be relevant to my hon. Friend the
Member for Liverpool, West Derby () and it is where I did the most
intensive work on Labour’s policies, talking with local
communities to find out what was needed. Local authorities in the
north-west of England are receiving £1.2 billion less per year in
2021-22 in central Government funding than they did in 2015-16;
that is a 36% cut. The calculation is that the north-west would
need an extra £3.47 billion per year in capital funding just to
reach London’s level. The north-west received nearly £500
less—well, £492 less—per person per year when compared with
London.
We know of some councils that are so depleted by cuts that they
did not have the in-house capacity to even submit bids for the
levelling-up fund. These are funds that were allocated in the
recent Budget, which we welcomed. We cannot have a begging-bowl
approach, with councils fighting over scraps; we need a rising
tide of funding that raises all local authority ships.
I want to talk about power. Levelling up must mean not just an
injection of cash, but a redistribution of power as well.
Councils need more than just greater resources in order to level
up—they need to be given powers to do so. That is the message
from all local authorities controlled by all political parties. I
will watch with interest the Secretary of State’s recently
floated idea for further Mayors—or governors, as he said—covering
more of the country. It will be interesting to see how that can
be rolled out. I am not opposed to it. I am not happy with the
mayoral principle, but it has been established and it seems
anomalous that there are Mayors for cities but not for other
areas.
Let us talk about now. We have devolved Governments in the
nations, and a dozen or so city-region Mayors in England. I hope
the Government will listen to the demands from, for example, the
Mayor of London for more powers. He is asking for more powers to
set rent controls—powers which major cities around the world,
from Berlin to New York, possess. Shelter, the housing charity,
has recently published a report that explains the consequences of
levelling-up infrastructure investment without taking housing
need into account. I will use my area as an example; the Minister
is welcome to come down and visit and we could have a discussion
on site if necessary. In my area, a consequence of the welcome
multi-billion pound investment in Crossrail is that land and
house prices have shot up. Without new council housing or rent
controls, local people are being forced out of the local housing
market. Alongside the building of more council housing, a Mayor
with powers of rent control would really help level up in London
and areas like mine.
I hope the Government are going to listen and back the Mayors who
are seeking to re-regulate the buses in Greater Manchester,
Liverpool city region and West Yorkshire. It is a great policy.
It is about improving infrastructure that will increase private
investment, it is about a modal shift that will improve carbon
emissions and improve air quality, and it is about increasing the
act of travel, which has health benefits as well. I point the
Minister towards the recent reports from Green Alliance, a coming
together of various national environmental groups. They have
pointed out how much more could be done on the Government’s
climate change agenda if the powers and resources were made
available to local government.
When I raised the issue before, Government Ministers have argued
that council spending has been boosted by the retention of
business rates and the ability to raise more through council tax
in recent years. First of all, based on the National Audit
Office’s figures, it is likely that councils’ overall spending
power is now some £5 billion lower in real terms than it was in
2010. The Minister will also know that raising council tax has
very unequal impacts: a 5% increase in Surrey raises about £38
million, while a 5% increase in Blackburn with Darwen raises £2.8
million. It is a similar story with business rate retention:
councils with prosperous commercial centres can raise significant
sums, whereas councils without such areas cannot.
As such, alongside discussing the levelling-up agenda in
investment terms, it is now time to have a serious discussion in
Government about a more radical reform of local government
finance to provide a stable, locally determined income stream
from councils. There have been discussions in all our political
parties about options for doing so, but we need to bring those
options forward more rapidly. For example, I am interested—as are
a number of Conservative MPs—in some version of land value
taxation that might transfer both resources and, more
effectively, power to the local level.
I also want to raise the issue of debt, in the Liverpool context
as well as that of other local authorities. We have a
responsibility here: to be frank, central Government have
encouraged local authorities to borrow, often heavily, to go into
property deals in order to secure much-needed additional revenue
income. The result is that the local government debt burden is
now becoming crippling for some, which is why the Government
should explore new mechanisms for debt relief for local
authorities. I was here during the banking crash, and can
remember when that whole exercise was undertaken and the bad debt
bank was established to sort out the debts of the banks involved.
It may well be that the most responsible thing at the moment is
for the Government to take over some of that debt, and even write
some of it off through a debt jubilee for some local
authorities.
Finally, I am concerned that as the levelling-up policy programme
is developed, it must be seen to be fair. We all have a
responsibility on a cross-party basis to not allow even the
perception of pork barrel politics to take hold in this country,
which is why there must be the fullest openness, transparency,
objectivity, and engagement in decision making about the
distribution of resources. One proposal is to consider a Barnett
formula-type approach, one that would be objectively based on
population, to determine the distribution of capital investment
alongside the local government finance formula. Another is the
establishment of government structures that bring local
government representatives into government more effectively. Some
ideas have been floated on all sides, such as a new Cabinet
sub-committee that invites Mayors and other representatives to
participate, or—as suggested by the Local Government
Association—a national taskforce on levelling up that, again,
rebalances some of the relationship between local and central
Government.
In conclusion, I hope that a central plank of the Government’s
levelling-up White Paper and the subsequent policy direction will
be the empowering of local government to show that councils can
play their role in levelling up our nations and regions. The
Minister and the Government will not find local councils lacking,
either in enthusiasm or in commitment.
17:14:00
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Levelling Up,
Housing and Communities (Neil O'Brien)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mrs Miller. I
congratulate the right hon. Member for Hayes and Harlington
() on securing this very
important debate. I am not sure whether he or I will be more
alarmed to find that we are, as he suggested, in quite strong
agreement on much of this agenda.
I am so convincing, do not worry.
Neil O'Brien
The right hon. Gentleman is always convincing when he talks about
the lost opportunities caused by having parts of the economy
overheating where people cannot afford a house, whereas other
parts of the economy are crying out for investment. I felt that
his was an echo of the Prime Minister’s speech, so we all find
ourselves in at least a pretty high level of agreement on the
challenge.
Does the Minister recognise that the Prime Minister is my
next-door constituency neighbour?
Neil O'Brien
I thank the right hon. Gentleman for that intervention. We are
being run by a west London mafia.
As a lifelong advocate for ending the kinds of regional
disparities that run through the country, I want to reiterate the
importance that I, and the Government, feel about restoring a
sense of local pride right across the country. I will start by
stating a very obvious point, which is that local councils are an
absolutely central part of our levelling-up agenda. They have to
be. They have long been huge parts of the democratic fabric of
this country and I firmly believe that our huge ambitions for
levelling up will not be realised unless local leaders and
communities are properly empowered to deliver for their local
areas.
Levelling up must now go beyond the first stage of devolution. It
must be a mission that gives local leaders and communities the
tools they really need, as the right hon. Gentleman said, to take
control of their own destiny, boost people’s living standards and
spread opportunity. It will not be an exercise in levelling down
London or the south-east in order to lift up other areas; it will
be one with a clear-eyed focus on using local leadership to
spread opportunities to parts of the country that have long felt
that Governments in successive decades have not been interested
in their city or their region.
The levelling-up agenda will recognise that disparities are not
just between everyone who lives north of Watford Gap on the one
hand and everyone else. Cookie-cutter policies are not going to
bridge the divides that exist between Leeds and Bradford, between
Blackpool and Manchester, and between different boroughs in
London. We recognise that there are some of the same issues in
Darlington and in Hayes and Harlington. We also recognise that
levelling up—I agree with the right hon. Gentleman—is a major
challenge that will take some time, but work is well under
way.
Nobody understands the needs of a local area as well as the
people elected to serve as the leadership of that local area in
local councils. We are taking forward several programmes that
will press ahead with meaningful devolution, including the new
county deals that the right hon. Gentleman talked about, to
spread devolution across the whole of England beyond the larger
cities, and new funding streams to give people the financial
firepower to make the changes they want to see in their
communities. For example, we have agreements with 101 towns
across England that have seen £2.4 billion allocated to local
projects through the towns fund and the efforts we are making to
resurrect our high streets as we continue to respond to the
economic headwinds of the pandemic, with £100 million of combined
investment from our welcome back fund and the reopening high
streets safely fund.
Those investments are just the start. My right hon. Friend the
Chancellor and the Treasury have shown that they are foursquare
behind the levelling-up agenda with the recent spending review.
As part of that review, we committed £1.7 billion in the first
round of our flagship £4.8 billion levelling-up fund, backing 105
different initiatives across the country, from the South Derby
growth zone to an upgrade to the ferries to the Isles of Scilly.
Both received nearly £50 million from the fund. Other successful
bids that we have been funding through the levelling-up fund
include the Bolton College of Medical Sciences, the reopening of
the world’s oldest suspension bridge in County Durham, and the
redevelopment of Leicester train station quite near to me. Those
are examples of how the fund is flexible in backing the ambitions
of different local places, whatever they may be. The funding
builds on the foundations laid in the March Budget this year,
with plans to bring regeneration, new prosperity and restored
pride to 10 different places through the new freeports, which are
levelling up in action. In fact, only three weeks ago Teesside
became the first of those amazing freeports to open its doors for
business and future investment from top-end employers.
In the time remaining, I would like to turn to local government
finance. The right hon. Gentleman talked about the need to move
on from the debates we had for a long time at the start of the
2010s. I think that is right. There is no point in re-rehearsing
those arguments. We will not convince each other of our positions
at this point. He talked about a rising tide of funding. We now
have a rising tide of funding. For the last couple of years, our
core spending power in local government has started to go up. At
the spending review, the Treasury backed councils with an average
annual increase in the core spending power of local government of
3% in real-terms per year.
The issue when talking about levelling up and moving on from 2010
is that in 2022 the budget cuts affecting my city once again will
mean that, potentially, four community libraries will be shut
down in some of the poorest wards in the country. Does that
equate to levelling up? Last week, a study by Feeding Liverpool
found that a third of my city are experiencing food insecurity.
Again, how that does chime with levelling up and moving on from
2010, if in 2022 we will still be facing savage austerity?
Austerity kills, and austerity enables poverty.
Neil O'Brien
As I said, the core spending power of local government will be
going up in real terms each year by 3%, on top of all the other
things we are doing through the future high streets fund, the
levelling-up fund and the forthcoming UK shared prosperity fund,
to invest heavily in areas such as Liverpool and the wider
Merseyside area. All those things are, at their heart, about
investing in locally delivered early help for families of the
exact kind that the hon. Gentleman would like.
The example of Liverpool has been given. It would be incredibly
helpful, just to bring the Minister up to speed on a specific
example of what is happening, if he would meet a delegation of
the Liverpool MPs, maybe with the council leader, to talk about
issues there.
Neil O'Brien
I am planning to meet various leaders from Liverpool city region
as part of the Mersey Dee alliance discussions, so I would be
delighted to have that conversation. I am very proud of the
progress we made for that city through the devolution deal,
bringing new powers, new funding and the defragmentation of local
government that I think we all agree on in principle.
In the months ahead we will set out in more detail our plans for
the levelling-up agenda, with the White Paper that will give us
the long-term blueprint, but that is not the end of the story. We
have a levelling up Department that will continue to power ahead
with this agenda over the coming years. The Prime Minister
already gave a clear indication of our position in July when he
said we take a flexible approach to devolution, so local leaders
in our great cities and historic towns have the tools they need
to make things happen for their communities.
Exceptional Mayors are already making a huge difference. If
anyone wants to see levelling up in action, I suggest they take a
trip to Teesside where, during his four years at the helm, has managed to secure a
brand-new economic campus in Darlington with civil servants from
the Treasury, moving the Tees crossing to alleviate congestion
and bringing the Teesside airport into public ownership, on top
of the freeport that I mentioned. That shows that local areas do
not need to be micromanaged out of SW1; they can get ahead if
they are given the financial power and the local powers and
leadership that they need.
There is no reason we cannot bottle and replicate the brand of
leadership embodied in people such as and , our fantastic West Midlands
Mayor, and apply it to other areas of the country, and so use
local leadership and local government to drive forward this
incredibly important levelling-up agenda that we all agree
on.
Question put and agreed to.
|