Asked by
To ask Her Majesty’s Government what assessment they have made of
the report by the Care Quality Commission The state of health
care and adult social care in England 2020/21, published on 21
October, and in particular the concerns about staff shortages
this winter.
A noble Lord
Round three!
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department of Health
and Social Care () (Con)
I am on a hat trick. The department welcomes the report by the
CQC and recognises the challenges that providers and local
authorities are currently experiencing in recruiting and
retaining staff, especially social care staff. While local
government has a key role to play in tackling staff shortages,
the department has been monitoring the situation closely. We have
already put in place a range of measures, including funding to
help local authorities and care providers address workforce
capacity pressures.
(Lab)
My Lords, the CQC’s concern about the desperate social care staff
shortages this winter and warning about a tsunami of unmet need
unless urgent action is taken is very worrying. It is clear that
the health and social care levy will not provide any real means
of dealing with chronic staff shortages for at least two years.
The recent £162.5 million for the workforce retention and
recruitment fund gives less than £100 per social care worker,
according to this week’s analysis from the Homecare Association
of care providers. The CQC has echoed the Commons Health and
Social Care Committee’s call in May for an urgent total
overhaul of workforce planning in light of workforce burnout
after dealing with Covid; a people plan for social care; and an
annual independent report with workforce projections. Can the
Minister tell the House what progress is being made on this and
when we can expect a fully costed and funded workforce plan for
this key sector?
(Con)
I thank the noble Baroness for her reference to the £162.5
million of funding for social care through the workforce
retention and recruitment fund to help boost staff numbers and
support existing care workers through the winter. This is on top
of the third infection control and testing fund, introduced in
October 2021, which is providing a further £388.3 million of
adult social care Covid-19 support until March 2022. This means
that, during the pandemic, we have made available more than £2.5
billion in funding specifically for adult social care. We are
also taking action to support adult social care providers through
a national recruitment campaign.
(Con)
My Lords, this important report is challenging reading for all
those who worked on the front line of the pandemic. Its most
challenging section is undoubtedly the part on the recovery of
services; in particular, as the noble Baroness, Lady Wheeler,
said, the importance of
“investment in workforce development and formal changes in
service specifications.”
Can the Minister give us some more precise details on how that
budget will be spent?
(Con)
I thank my noble friend for his question and for the advice he
has given me to date. Even though I have size 11 feet, I am
finding it rather difficult to fill his large shoes. On the
funding announced, local authorities have a key role in
supporting recruitment and retention in their local areas. We are
working with them to make sure that they support local providers
by identifying workforce shortages, developing workforce plans
and encouraging joined-up services. We also continue to work
closely with providers, councils and our partners to assess the
situation and consider what further action may be necessary.
(Lab)
My Lords, the CQC’s annual report highlights the challenges faced
by people with learning difficulties, their families and their
informal carers. Does the Minister acknowledge this problem? The
CQC accepts that its inspection procedures require more emphasis
on the knowledge and experience of family and informal carers,
following Professor Murphy’s report on the failures and abuse in
Whorlton Hall. How can we hope that the CQC and other agencies in
health and social care will give priority to the role of family
and informal carers when the Government’s main policy statements
and papers still virtually ignore their existence?
(Con)
The Government recognise the valuable role that paid and unpaid
carers play in social care. We are looking at how we can make
sure that we recruit and retain staff. We understand the
challenges that many care homes, quite often those in the private
sector, face when trying to recruit and retain staff, given the
competitive pressures around the jobs market. The Government
certainly take seriously the role of unpaid and paid carers.
(LD) [V]
My Lords, in addition to the winter’s and next year’s workforce
plan, the CQC reports that providers of residential care showed
the vacancy rate rising month on month from 6% in April to 10.2%
in September. Some care homes whose attempts at recruitment have
failed are now having to cancel their registration to provide
nursing care, leaving residents looking for new homes in local
areas that already are at, or close to, capacity. In recent
weeks, two homes in York have announced that they are closing. I
appreciate the discussion about planning for the workforce but
this is a current crisis. What is the Minister going to do as
councils are overwhelmed trying to find beds for patients when
there are none?
(Con)
I am grateful to the noble Baroness for the specific examples
that she gave. The department is constantly monitoring the
workforce capacity pressures. We are continuing to gather a range
of qualitative and quantitative intelligence in order to have a
strong and live picture of how the risk is developing and
emerging. In more detail, this includes drawing on evidence
gathered by a regional assurance team and regular engagement with
key stakeholders, including the Association of Directors of Adult
Social Services in England, local authorities and care provider
representatives. We are also monitoring data from the capacity
tracker, Skills for Care’s monthly workforce reporting and wider
market data. To ensure that we are aware of any emerging
workforce capacity pressures, we are strongly encouraging
providers to continue sharing available capacity and completing
the capacity tracker.
(Lab)
My Lords, I conveyed my commiserations to the Minister last week.
As he said, he is on a hat trick today, but he is no Salah just
yet. The noble Lord is obviously not a Liverpool fan. As the
report says, over the past year the pandemic has further exposed
and exacerbated health inequalities. Case rates and mortality
rates were higher in deprived areas—2.4 times higher than in the
least deprived areas for mortality. The report stated that
“strategies to identify and tackle health inequalities were not
yet well established.”
What is the Government’s strategy for this, given that deprived
areas, such as those in London, are often next to the
wealthiest?
(Con)
The noble Baroness raises an important point but before I answer
that specifically, I reassure her that I am a Liverpool fan, as
well as an Enfield Town fan. It so happens that my middle name is
Salah. I think that I can wear that name on the back of my shirt
with pride. I assure noble Lords that I did not line that
question up. One reason why the Office for Health Improvement and
Disparities was set up in the first place was to look at
disparities across a wide range of issues, not only in social
care but in relation to gender inequalities, ethnic minority
inequalities and some of the other inequalities and disparities
between various areas. As the noble Baroness rightly says,
sometimes one can find some of the poorest communities right next
to the some of the wealthiest. We are hoping to address those
issues through the work of the Office for Health Improvement and
Disparities, by first identifying where disparities are and then
addressing them.
(LD)
My Lords, with more than 105,000 vacancies in social care, we
have a bit of a crisis. Which job would the Minister advise a
low-paid worker to take when offered one of these three full-time
jobs, all advertised today: a delivery driver at £11 an hour, a
supermarket shelf stacker at £10 an hour or a senior care
assistant at £9.25 an hour?
(Con)
I do not see myself as someone who is able to offer jobs advice
or careers advice. But the points made by the noble Lord help to
explain in many ways some of the pressures that care home
providers are facing when recruiting in a competitive market. The
Government have looked at funding and how we can work with care
providers, particularly as many are in the private sector, as I
said earlier. They are not directly controlled by the Government
and we can therefore work with local authorities and care
providers on how to make sure that they pay a competitive salary
to attract care workers to work in the social care system, as
opposed to some of the more competitive sectors that the noble
Lord mentioned.
(Lab)
My Lords, one of the areas where there is most pressure has been
that of unpaid carers. Not only are they having to take on a much
greater load but for a long period they could not even visit
their loved ones in care homes. In all the programmes that the
Government are taking on, can the Minister say explicitly what is
going to be done to support carers in their invaluable role?
(Con)
I think that all noble Lords will agree with the point made by
the noble Lord about the importance of unpaid carers and also
paid carers. In relation to unpaid carers, we hope that as the
social care reforms, in particular, come through, patients will
be able to take advantage of social care. That will remove some
of the burden from unpaid carers and free up their time. We are,
however, looking closely at the implications and consequences of
some of the proposed reforms.