Asked by
To ask Her Majesty’s Government what proportion of the new Health
and Social Care Levy will be allocated to the provision of social
care.
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department of Health
and Social Care () (Con)
On 7 September, we announced £5.4 billion of new funding for
adult social care over the 2022 to 2025 period. We have also
announced that this includes more than £3.6 billion to reform the
adult social care charging system and to help local authorities
better sustain their markets by moving towards paying providers a
fair rate for care. It also includes more than £1.7 billion for
much-needed wider system reform. Further details will be
announced in a White Paper later this year.
(Lab)
My Lords, the Health Foundation has calculated that, over the
next three years, the funding required just to meet current
social care demand is bigger than the extra money going into
social care from the levy. So this levy will not even start to
address issues such as the need for better pay and conditions for
social care staff, local government’s lack of resources, and the
need for community care, personalisation, et cetera. Could the
Minister explain how he expects the country to believe the
Government’s plan that, after three years of operation, the NHS
portion of the levy, which is currently the majority, will be cut
and transferred to social care? Can he confirm that the plan is
really to cut NHS funding in 2025 in the face of ever rising
demands on its services?
(Con)
The Government have always been clear that the share of the levy
going towards the NHS to tackle the backlog was temporary and
that, in the longer term, we would move to funding social care.
As I am sure the noble Lord is aware, for decades, Governments
have kicked the can down the road and have not tackled this
difficult issue. The Government have been quite firm in
committing money and have been learning, in our constant
discussion with stakeholders, how best to reform the social care
sector.
The Lord
Can the Minister give an assessment of whether the health and
social care levy will enable more people with moderate care needs
to become eligible for social care funding?
(Con)
I thank the right reverend Prelate for that question. I am not
able to answer it directly now, but I will send an answer.
(Con)
My Lords, further to the question from the right reverend
Prelate, I understand the concern that the proceeds from the
ring-fenced levy may not be enough to relieve all the pressure on
social care. So will the Minister encourage the NHS trusts, which
are receiving the bulk of the extra funds, to use Section 75 of
the National Health Service Act 2006 to commission social care,
thereby taking some of the pressure off local authorities?
(Con)
I thank my noble friend for that suggestion, and I will take it
back. What we have to remember about the way social care is
funded is that, in reality, it is mostly private providers that
provide social care, and these are funded by private and
state-funded patients. Quite often, we find it is private
patients who cross-subsidise state-funded patients. I will take
the question from my noble friend back and send an answer.
(CB)
My Lords, the NHS hospital system is the carer of last resort.
When the community’s needs are not being met as they ought to be
by social care or primary healthcare, they go into hospital. This
puts excessive demand on hospital resources, which should be
devoted to dealing with the elective backlog and waiting lists.
Does the Minister recognise that this distortion, with its
damaging effects on the NHS, can be corrected only when the NHS
is partnered by a well-funded and reformed social care
system?
(Con)
It is quite clear that, if we want to make sure that the social
care system is fit for purpose, we have to make sure that, in the
model, enough money is going in to reform the system. Part of the
funding does go to helping local authorities push for reform,
but, at the same time, it is true that some of the additional
productivity as a result of digitisation will help make the NHS
more efficient.
(Lab)
My Lords, is it not an unfortunate fact that not a single penny
from the levy will actually go to the front line of social care
to relieve those overworked and underpaid staff making 15-minute
visits, which is the real urgency? Even when the money does come
to social care, some way down the line, will not much of it be
taken up with bureaucracy, in making assessments and testing
eligibility for the cap that the Government have put into the
system? Surely that is something that we have to look at. How
much of the money is actually going to go to the front line, not
just now but in three or four years’ time.
(Con)
The noble Baroness makes a very important point: we have to see
reforms in the social care sector. The spending of £5.4 billion
includes £1.7 billion for wider system reforms, including at
least £500 million to support the adult social care workforce in
professionalisation and well-being. We are also working closely
with providers of care, local government charities, the unions,
professional bodies, and users of care and their representatives,
and will respond to their views in the forthcoming adult social
care system reform White Paper, later this year.
(LD) [V]
My Lords, so far the Minister has responded only on the issue of
adult social care. Freedom of information requests from every
local authority in England by the Disabled Children’s Partnership
reveal that 40% of authorities cut the respite care for parent
carers during the pandemic. This comes as eight in 10 parent
carers are experiencing some form of anxiety—a rate much higher
than among the general population. Can the Minister outline
specifically how the health and social care levy will help
restore short breaks and respite care for families with disabled
children?
(Con)
The noble Baroness makes an important point that we should
address. In looking at the wider picture, we recognise that
unpaid carers play a vital role in our care system and make a
considerable contribution to society, alongside the paid social
care workforce. The Care Act encourages local authorities to
support unpaid carers and provide preventive care to stop
people’s early care needs escalating. The announcement of the
£5.4 billion funding marks the next step in our transformational
plans for the sector.
(Con)
My Lords, if the care system is to improve, a critical element is
that of a suitably skilled workforce. Can my noble friend tell
the House what plans there are to deliver a new deal for the care
workforce?
(Con)
I thank my noble friend for that important point. We have
listened to the sector and prioritised the adult social care
workforce. The investment of at least £500 million over three
years will deliver new qualifications, progression pathways, and
well-being and mental health support. This workforce package is
unprecedented investment, which will support the development and
well-being of the care workforce. It will enable a fivefold
increase in public spending on the skills and training of our
care workers and registered managers, as well as on their
well-being.
(Lab)
My Lords, the Secretary of State, , has admitted that the
Government cannot commit to clearing the NHS treatment backlog
generated by Covid within three years. This is despite the fact
that £12 billion a year raised from the levy will mostly go to
fund this work and that he is also announcing another £6 billion
in capital funding for the same purpose. Does this recognition of
the scale of the NHS challenge mean that social care will have to
wait even longer than three years for any levy funding? Can the
Minister confirm, as he failed to do last week, that the £162.5
million announced for the social care workforce and recruitment
fund was new money and not part of previous repackaging, as we
have seen with the Chancellor’s pre-spending review announcements
so far?
The funding commits us from 2022 to 2025—it is three years’
funding. The point that the noble Baroness makes is that, of
course, we are hoping that we can clear as much of the elective
backlog as possible. After that, the money will be moved and will
focus on social care reforms. On her specific question, I will
write to the noble Baroness.
(CB)
My Lords, my question builds on that of the noble Lord, . Can the Minister
explain how social care is to cope now, when there is a crisis,
without a larger allocation of the levy in addition to funds
announced, and, in particular, how delayed transfers of care from
acute hospitals may be reduced? Should there be central guidance
to the NHS to commission social care services to assist in safe
rapid discharge?
(Con)
In looking at how we reform the adult social care workforce, we
have consulted a wide range of stakeholders, not only on what we
do from 2022 to 2025 but on what we do in the short term. Further
details will be announced soon.
(LD)
My Lords, £1 in every £12 spent by local authorities on social
care goes towards funding mental health social care, supporting
people of all ages who live with severe mental illness, and their
carers. Can the Minister say what proportion of the planned levy
will be used to fund mental health social care, which provides
such a lifeline to all those affected?
(Con)
The noble Baroness makes a valuable point about the need to look
at mental health and social care. The issue is that, sometimes,
for some of the patients who are being helped, it is not only
mental health that we are looking at; there is a multiplicity of
issues. I will try to get a specific answer and will write to the
noble Baroness.