-
Increasing pension
charge cap for workplace pensions may not be
necessary to drive pension money into long-term investments
and does not overcome the major
barriers
-
Plans to boost
investments in infrastructure or illiquid projects should focus
more on Defined Benefit schemes which hold over £2trillion
rather than on Defined Contribution which hold around
£200billion
The Chancellor’s announcement
of an increase in the charge cap for auto-enrolment pension
schemes, above the current 0.75% level, has been
well-trailed. The intention to encourage more pension money
to fund future growth projects is laudable. However it is not
clear to me that the Government’s proposals are the best way to
achieve this objective.
Charge cap is not
major barrier to illiquid long-term investments: Higher
charges will dilute long-term returns for investors and risk
lower pensions over time. Of course, if the investments deliver
much better returns, then that will offset the charges to some
degree, but the majority of workplace pensions do not even charge
as much as the 0.75% cap. Indeed, the NEST schemes already
invests in illiquid assets and have a charge of only around 0.3 –
0.5%. Fund managers understandably wish to charge more to
manage long-term illiquid projects as the costs of overseeing and
managing such investments can be higher than for mainstream
market investing. However, it is not clear that the charge
cap has been the main factor deterring pension funds from
supporting infrastructure, housing, private equity and other
potentially higher long-term return investments. Defined
Contribution schemes are significantly hampered by the regulatory
controls requiring daily pricing and quick transferability of
workplace pension schemes if members wish to take their money
out. Increasing the charge cap does nothing to resolve those
problems. This has meant such pensions invest almost nothing in
illiquid or long-term projects and focus almost entirely on
public markets, which may not be optimal for long-term
returns.
DB schemes with over
£2trillion assets could do more to support long-term
projects: Defined Benefit pension schemes, by contrast,
have been investing in alternative assets, infrastructure,
housing, private equity and other higher return funds for many
years. Their trustees do not have to price the funds daily and
are less constrained by liquidity concerns. The larger schemes
are professionally managed and have achieved overall charges far
lower than 0.75%. The Chancellor should work on plans to
use far more of this money, rather than focussing heavily on
modern Defined Contribution schemes in my view. Currently,
those DB schemes are deterred from alternative and illiquid
long-term investments because of regulatory pressure to ‘reduce
risk’. In recent years, the regulatory landscape has driven
trustees further away from such investments, because of fears
about ‘risk’ when schemes are in deficit. Driving funds into
supposedly lower risk assets, also means lower returns, which
places extra burdens on employers and does not utilise the assets
optimally for growth-boosting projects.
Potential for using
DB assets is far greater than for DC: DB schemes are
more than ten times the size of DC. I would recommend that the
Government develops a state guaranteed underpin for long-term
infrastructure or housing projects specifically aimed at pension
schemes, which offer a guaranteed return at least equivalent to
today’s yields on 20 year gilts. This would allow pension
schemes to allocate far more to riskier projects that they expect
to deliver higher returns, while not affecting their risk
rating for regulatory purposes. The likelihood is that these
projects overall would deliver far better returns than today’s
ultra-low gilt yields, so the ‘guarantee’ would not cost the
Treasury much, if anything, while it could bring in billions of
pounds for much-needed investment. At the moment, overseas
pension funds, such as US, Australia and Canada, have invested
much more in infrastructure and promising smaller businesses than
those in the UK. There is a clear opportunity to use more of our
domestic pension asset base for growth projects than might
otherwise be the case.
Raising charge cap is
not really a solution: Rather than asking workers to pay
more for their pension funds, we need to drive greater focus on
the long-term nature of pensions and move away from the daily
pricing and instant liquidity that has hindered many pension
firms from investing with a truly long-term mindset.