Can I thank the minister for his statement.
Let me start by saying that it is good that the tackling the
climate crisis is a shared national objective across this House
and we want the government to succeed at COP26 in just ten days'
time.
But there are two central questions about the strategy published
today—does it finally close the yawning gap between government
promises and delivery?
And will it make the public investment which is essential to
ensure the green transition is fair and creates jobs?
I am afraid the answer to both questions, despite what the
minister said, is No.
This plan falls short on delivery
And while there is modest short-term investment, there is nothing
like the commitment we believe is required.
And we know why. When asked at the weekend about the Treasury’s
approach to these issues a BEIS source said:
“They are not climate change deniers but they are emphasising the
short-term risks, rather than long-term needs...”
The Chancellor’s fingerprints are all over these documents—and
not in a good way.
We have waited months for the heat and buildings strategy.
It is a massive let down.
We are in the midst of an energy price crisis caused by a decade
of inaction.
Emissions from buildings are higher today than in 2015.
The biggest single programme that could make a difference is a 10
year house by house, street by street plan for insulation to cut
bills, emissions and ensure energy security.
There are 19 million homes below EPC band C that need upgrading.
The best estimates are that the proposals today will help just a
tiny fraction of that number.
Indeed, there is not even a replacement for the ill-fated green
homes Grant for homeowners.
Can the minister explain where the long-term retrofit plan we
need is? Did BEIS argue for it and get turned back by the
Treasury or did he not make the case?
On heat pumps, the government’s own target says we need 600,000
homes a year installing heat pumps by 2028.
But they are funding just 30,000a year, helping just 1 in 250
households on the gas grid.
Why does his plan on heat pumps fall so far short of what is
required?
On transport, we agree with the transition to electric cars but
need to make it fair for consumers.
We should at the very least have had long-term zero interest
loans to cut the costs of purchasing electric cars.
What is the plan to make electric cars accessible to all and not
just the richest
On nuclear, I was surprised given the advance publicity, that he
made literally no mention of the word.
We have seen a decade of inaction on this issue. Why is there
still no decision on new nuclear?
The failure to invest does not just affect whether this
transition is fair for consumers but also workers in existing
industries.
Take steel, it will cost £6 billion for the steel industry to get
to net zero. If we want a steel industry, we will need to
share the costs with the private sector.
A £250 million clean steel fund will simply not secure our
industry’s future.
Can he tell us what his estimates are of the needs of the steel
industry and how he thinks they can be met?
The same is true with investing in new industries like hydrogen.
There is a global race in these areas and the UK is not powering
ahead but is falling behind.
Germany is offering £9bn for a new hydrogen strategy….the UK
£240m.
We see the same pattern across the board, including land use,
industry and transport and because of this failure to invest,
there remains a wide gap between promises and delivery.
And it was very noticeable from the ministers words that he did
not say that this plan meets the target for 2035, the sixth
carbon budget, surely a basic pre-requisite of this strategy to
2050.
Could he tell us whether the policies in this document actually
meet the sixth carbon budget or whether it falls short less than
halfway to net zero?
Isn’t the truth that despite hundreds of pages of plans,
strategies and hot air, there is still a chasm between the
rhetoric and the reality.
This plan will not deliver the fair, prosperous transition we
need equal to the scale of the emergency we face.