Facebook has wrongfully removed and suppressed content by
Palestinians and their supporters, including about human
rights abuses carried out in Israel and Palestine during the May
2021 hostilities, Human Rights Watch said today. The company’s
acknowledgment of errors and attempts to correct some of them are
insufficient and do not address the scale and scope of reported
content restrictions, or adequately explain why they occurred in
the first place....Request free trial
Facebook has wrongfully removed and suppressed content by
Palestinians and their
supporters, including about human rights abuses carried out in
Israel and Palestine during the May 2021 hostilities, Human
Rights Watch said today.
The company’s acknowledgment of errors and attempts to correct
some of them are insufficient and do not address the scale and
scope of reported content restrictions, or adequately explain why
they occurred in the first place.
Facebook should take up the Facebook Oversight
Board’s recommendation on
September 14, 2021, to commission an independent investigation
into content moderation regarding Israel and Palestine,
particularly in relation to any bias or discrimination in its
policies, enforcement, or systems, and to publish the
investigation’s findings. Facebook has 30 days from the day the
decision was issued to respond to the board’s
recommendations.
“Facebook has suppressed content posted by Palestinians and their
supporters speaking out about human rights issues in Israel and
Palestine,” said Deborah Brown, senior
digital rights researcher and advocate at Human Rights Watch.
“With the space for such advocacy under threat in many parts of
the world, Facebook censorship threatens to restrict a critical
platform for learning and engaging on these issues.”
An escalation in
violence in parts of Israel and the Occupied Palestinian
Territory (OPT) during May led people to turn to social media to
document, raise awareness, and condemn the latest cycle of human
rights abuses. There were efforts to force Palestinians out of
their homes, brutal suppression of demonstrators, assaults on
places of worship, communal violence, indiscriminate rocket
attacks, and airstrikes that killed civilians.
Human Rights Watch documented that Instagram, which is owned by
Facebook, removed posts, including reposts of content from
mainstream news organizations. In one instance, Instagram removed
a screenshot of headlines and photos from three New York Times
opinion articles for which the Instagram user added commentary
that urged Palestinians to “never concede” their rights. The post
did not transform the material in any way that could reasonably
be construed as incitement to violence or hatred.
In another instance, Instagram removed a photograph of a building
with a caption that read, “This is a photo of my family’s
building before it was struck by Israeli missiles on Saturday May
15, 2021. We have three apartments in this building.” The company
also removed the reposting of a political cartoon whose message
was that Palestinians are oppressed and not fighting a religious
war with Israel.
All of these posts were removed for containing “hate speech or
symbols” according to Instagram. These removals suggest that
Instagram is restricting freedom of expression on matters of
public interest. The fact that these three posts were reinstated
after complaints suggests that Instagram’s detection or reporting
mechanisms are flawed and result in false positives. Even when
social media companies reinstate wrongly suppressed material, the
error impedes the flow of information concerning human rights at
critical moments, Human Rights Watch said.
Users and digital rights
organizations also reported hundreds of
deleted posts, suspended or restricted
accounts, disabled
groups, reduced visibility, lower
engagement with content, and blocked hashtags. Human
Rights Watch reviewed screenshots from people who were sharing
content about the escalating violence and who reported
restrictions on their accounts, including not being able to post
content, livestream videos on Instagram, post videos on Facebook,
or even like a post.
Human Rights Watch was not able to verify or determine that each
case constituted an unjustified restriction due to lack of access
to the underlying data needed for verification, and because
Facebook refused to comment on specific details of various cases
and accounts citing privacy obligations. The range and volume of
restrictions reported warrant an independent investigation.
The Oversight Board recommended that Facebook engage an external,
independent entity to conduct a thorough examination to determine
whether Facebook has applied its content moderation in Arabic and
Hebrew without bias, and that the report and its conclusions
should be made public. This recommendation echoes
multiple calls from human rights and digital rights
organizations for a public audit.
In addition to removing content based on its own policies,
Facebook often does so at the behest of governments. The Israeli
government has been aggressive in seeking to remove content from
social media. The Israeli Cyber Unit, based within the State
Attorney’s Office, flags and
submits requests to social media companies to
“voluntarily” remove content. Instead of going through the legal
process of filing a court order based on Israeli criminal law to
take down online content, the Cyber Unit makes appeals directly
to platforms based on their own terms of service. A 2018 report by Israel’s State
Attorney's office notes an extremely high compliance
rate with these voluntary requests, 90 percent across all
platforms.
Human Rights Watch is not aware that Facebook has ever disputed
this claim. In a letter to Human Rights Watch, the company stated
that it has “one single global process for handling government
requests for content removal.” Facebook also
provided a link to its process
for assessing content that violates local law, but that does not
address voluntary requests from governments to remove content
based on the company’s terms of service.
Noting the role of governments in content removal, the Oversight
Board recommended that Facebook make this process transparent and
distinguish between government requests that led to global
removals based on violations of the company’s Community Standards
and requests that led to removal or geo-blocking based on
violations of local law. Facebook should implement this
recommendation, and in particular disclose the number and nature
of requests for content removal by the Israeli Government’s Cyber
Unit and how it responded to them, Human Rights Watch said.
Protecting free expression on issues related to Israel and
Palestine is especially important in light of shrinking space for
discussion. In addition to Israeli authorities, Palestinian
authorities in the West Bank and Gaza have
systematically clamped down on free
expression, while in several other countries,
including the
US and Germany, steps have been
taken to restrict the space for some forms of pro-Palestine
advocacy.
Human Rights Watch wrote to Facebook in June
2021 to seek the company’s comment and to inquire about
temporary measures and longstanding practices around the
moderation of content concerning Israel and
Palestine. The company
responded by acknowledging that it had already
apologized for “the impact these actions have had on their
community in Israel and Palestine and on those speaking about
Palestinian matters globally,” and provided further information
on its policies and practices. However, the company did not
answer any of the specific questions from Human Rights Watch or
meaningfully address any of the issues raised.
“Facebook provides a particularly critical platform in the
Israeli and Palestinian context, where Israeli authorities are
committing crimes against humanity of apartheid and persecution
against millions, and Palestinians and Israelis have committed
war crimes,” Brown said. “Instead of respecting people’s right to
speak out, Facebook is silencing many people arbitrarily and
without explanation, replicating online some of the same power
imbalances and rights abuses we see on the ground.”
For additional details and examples, please see
below.
For more Human Rights Watch reporting
on Israel and Palestine, please
visit:
https://www.hrw.org/middle-east/n-africa/israel/palestine
For more Human Rights Watch reporting on technology and
rights, please visit:
https://www.hrw.org/topic/technology-and-rights
For more information, please contact:
In New York, Deborah Brown (English):
+1-347-920-8978; or brownd@hrw.org. Twitter:
@deblebrown
In Amman, Omar Shakir (English, Arabic): +1-646-725-8650; or
+970-59-850-4903 (mobile); or shakiro@hrw.org. Twitter:
@omarsshakir
In Washington, DC, Eric Goldstein (English, French):
+1-917-519-4736 (mobile); or goldstr@hrw.org. Twitter:
@goldsteinricky
In Washington, DC, Arvind Ganesan (English):
+1-202-255-8305 (mobile); or ganesaa@hrw.org.
Note: A member of Human Rights Watch staff is on the Facebook
Oversight Board in his personal capacity. The staff member does
not work on issues related to human rights and technology at
Human Rights Watch. Any position Human Rights Watch takes on the
Facebook Oversight Board is independent and is not informed or
influenced by his membership on it.
Removal and Suppression of Human Rights and Other
Content
In May, the escalating tensions between Israel and Palestinians
culminated in 11 days of fighting between Israeli forces and
Palestinian armed groups based in the Gaza Strip. From May 6 to
19, 7amleh, the Arab Center for the Advancement of Social Media
(pronounced, “hamla” in Arabic, meaning “campaign”),
reported documenting “a dramatic
increase of censorship of Palestinian political speech
online.”
In the two-week period alone, 7amleh said it documented 500 cases
of what it described as content being taken down, accounts
closed, hashtags hidden, the reach of specific content reduced,
archived content deleted, and access to accounts restricted.
Facebook and Instagram accounted for 85 percent of those
restrictions.
The digital rights group Sada Social says it documented more
than 700 instances of social media networks restricting access to
or removing Palestinian content in May alone. On May 7, a group
of 30 human rights and digital rights organizations denounced social media
companies for “systematically silencing users protesting and
documenting the evictions of Palestinian families from their
homes in the neighborhood of Sheikh Jarrah in Jerusalem.”
In addition to removing content, Facebook affixed a sensitive
warning label to some posts requiring users to click through a
screen that says that the content might be “upsetting.” Human
Rights Watch found evidence that Facebook affixed such warnings
to posts that raised awareness about human rights issues without
exposing the viewer to upsetting content such as graphic violence
or racial epithets.
For example, on May 24, Instagram affixed such a label to
multiple stories posted by Mohammed el-Kurd, a Palestinian
activist and resident of Sheikh Jarrah, including a story that
contained a reposted image from another user’s Instagram feed of
an Israeli police truck and another truck with Hebrew writing on
it. The image raised awareness about a high court ruling and the
presence of soldiers in the Sheikh Jarrah neighborhood. As of
September 30 this image remains on the other user’s Instagram
feed, without a sensitive warning label.
In a July letter to Human Rights Watch, Facebook said that it
uses warnings to accommodate for “different sensitivities about
graphic and violent content” among people who use their
platforms. For that reason, they add a warning label to
“incredibly graphic or violent content so that it is not
available to people under the age of 18,” and so that users are
“aware of the graphic or violent nature of the content before
they click to see it.” The post in question does not include
content that could be considered “graphic or violent,” based on
Facebook’s standard.
Facebook said that “some labels would apply to entire carousels
of images even if only one is violating.” Hiding content behind a
label that prevents it from being viewed by default restricts
access to that content. This may be an appropriate step for
certain types of graphic and violent content, but labeling all
photos when only a subset of them deserves a label is an
arbitrary restriction on expression, Human Rights Watch said.
Human Rights Watch cannot confirm what other images were in the
carousel.
According to 7amleh, 46
percent of content that it documented as taken down from
Instagram occurred without the company providing the user a prior
warning or notice. In an additional 20 percent of the cases,
Instagram notified the user but did not provide a specific
justification for restricting the content.
Human Rights Watch also reviewed screenshots from social media
users who reported that their posts had less engagement and fewer
views from other users than they typically do, or that content
from their accounts was not showing up in feeds of other users, a
sign that Facebook and Instagram may have made adjustments to
their recommendation algorithm to demote certain content.
The Oversight
Board investigated one instance of content concerning
the escalation in violence in May being removed and, on September
15, issued a decision finding that Facebook acted wrongfully. The
user had on May 10 shared a news article reporting on a threat by
Izz al-Din al-Qassam Brigades, the military wing of the
Palestinian group Hamas, to fire rockets in response to a
flare-up in Israel’s repression of Palestinians in occupied East
Jerusalem. The Board recognized that re-publication of a news
item on a matter of urgent public concern is protected expression
and that removing the post restricted such expression without
reducing offline harm.
The Board acknowledged receiving public comments from
various parties alleging that Facebook has disproportionately
removed or demoted content from Palestinian users and content in
Arabic, especially in comparison to its treatment of posts
threatening anti-Arab or anti-Palestinian violence within Israel.
The Board also said it received public comments alleging that
Facebook had not done enough to remove content that incites
violence against Israeli civilians.
Designating Organizations as “Dangerous:” A Danger to
Free Expression
In some cases, Facebook removed the content under
its Dangerous Individuals and
Organizations Community Standard, which does “not allow
organizations or individuals that proclaim a violent mission or
are engaged in violence to have a presence on Facebook.” This was
the basis for removing the post with a news article about the Izz
al-Din al-Qassam Brigades. The Oversight Board criticized the
“vagueness” of this policy in its decision.
Facebook relies on the list of
organizations that the US has designated as a “foreign
terrorist organization,” among other lists. That list includes
political movements that also have armed wings, such as the
Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine and Hamas. By
deferring to the broad and sweeping US designations, Facebook
prohibits leaders, founders, or prominent members of major
Palestinian political movements from using its platform. It does
this even though, as far as is publicly known, US
law does not prohibit
groups on the list from using free and freely available platforms
like Facebook, and does not consider allowing groups on the list
to use platforms tantamount to “providing material support” in
violation of US law.
Facebook’s policy also calls for removing praise or support for
major Palestinian political movements, even when those
expressions of support contain no explicit advocacy of
violence.
Facebook should make its list of Dangerous
Individuals and Organizations public. It should ensure that
the related policy and enforcement do not restrict protected
expression, including about terrorism, human rights abuses, and
political movements, consistent with international human rights
standards, in line with the Oversight Board’s recommendations. In
particular, it should clarify which of the organizations banned
by Israeli authorities are included under its Dangerous
Individuals and Organizations policy.
Reliance on Automation
The audit to determine whether Facebook’s content moderation has
been applied without bias should include an examination of the
use of automated content moderation. According to Facebook’s
periodic transparency reporting on how it enforces its policies,
for the period of April to June 2021, Facebook and Instagram indicated
that through the use of its automated tools it had detected 99.7
percent of the content it deemed to potentially violate its
Dangerous Individuals and Organizations policy before a human
flagged it. For hate speech, the percentage is 97.6 percent for
Facebook and 95.1 percent for
Instagram for the same period.
Automated content moderation is notoriously poor at interpreting
contextual factors that can be key to determining whether a post
constitutes support for or glorification of
terrorism. This can lead
to overbroad limits on speech and inaccurate labeling of
speakers as violent, criminal, or abusive. Automated content
moderation of content that platforms consider to be “terrorist
and violent extremist” has in other contexts led to
the removal of evidence of war
crimes and human rights
atrocities from social media platforms, in some cases
before investigators know that the potential evidence exists.
Processes intended to remove extremist content, in particular
the use of automated tools, have
sometimes perversely led to removing speech opposed to
terrorism, including satire, journalistic material, and other
content that would, under rights-respecting legal frameworks, be
considered protected speech. For example, Facebook’s
algorithms reportedly misinterpreted
a post from an independent journalist who once headed the BBC’s
Arabic News service that condemned Osama bin Laden as
constituting support for him. As a result, the journalist was
blocked from livestreaming a video of himself shortly before a
public appearance. This kind of automatic content removal hampers
journalism and other writing, and jeopardizes the future ability
of judicial mechanisms to provide remedy for victims and
accountability for perpetrators of serious crimes.
The audit of Facebook’s practices should investigate the role
that designating a group as terrorist plays in automated content
moderation. In one incident, Instagram restricted the hashtag
#AlAqsa (#الاقصى or #الأقصى) and removed posts about Israeli
police violence at the al-Aqsa mosque in Jerusalem, before
Facebook acknowledged an error and reportedly reinstated some of
the content.
Buzzfeed News reported
that an internal Facebook post noted that the content had been
taken down because al-Aqsa “is also the name of an organization sanctioned by the
United States Government,” Al-Aqsa Martyrs’ Brigades. Human
Rights Watch reviewed four screenshots that documented that
Instagram had limited posts using the #AlAqsa hashtag and posts
about Palestinian demonstrations at al-Aqsa. Israeli
forces responded to
demonstrations at the al-Aqsa mosque by firing teargas, stun
grenades, and rubber-coated steel bullets, including inside the
mosque. The Israeli response left 1,000 Palestinians
injured between May 7 and May 10. At least 32 Israeli
officers were also injured.
The use of automated tools to moderate content has accelerated
due to the ever-expanding growth of user-generated content
online. It is important for companies like Facebook to recognize
the limitations of such
tools and increase their investment in people to review
content to avoid, or at least more quickly correct, enforcement
errors, in particular in sensitive situations.
In a letter to Human Rights Watch, Facebook referred to the
incident as “an error that temporarily restricted content.” The
audit should investigate how automation may have played a role in
this erroneous enforcement of Facebook policies.
Lack of Transparency Around Government
Requests
An independent audit should also evaluate Facebook’s relationship
with the Israeli government’s Cyber Unit, which creates a
parallel enforcement system for the government to seek to censor
content without official legal orders. While
Facebook regularly reports
on legal orders, it does not report on government
requests based on alleged violations of its community
standards.
This process may result in circumventing judicial processes for
addressing illegal speech, and government-initiated restrictions
on legal speech without informing targeted social media users.
The result denies them the due process rights they would have if
the government sought to restrict the content through legal
processes. On April 12 the Israeli Supreme Court
rejected a petition filed by Adalah and the
Association for Civil Rights in Israel seeking to stop the Cyber
Unit’s operations.
Facebook declined to answer the Oversight Board’s questions about
the number of requests the Israeli government made to remove
content during the May 2021 hostilities. The company only said,
in relation to the case that the Board ruled on, “Facebook has
not received a valid legal request from a government authority
related to the content the user posted in this case.”
Acceding to Israeli governmental requests raises concern, since
Israeli authorities criminalize political activity in the West
Bank using draconian laws to restrict peaceful speech and to ban
more than 430 organizations, including all the major Palestinian
political movements, as Human Rights Watch has documented. These
sweeping restrictions on civil rights are part of the Israeli
government’s crimes against humanity of
apartheid and persecution against millions of
Palestinians.
Technical Glitches Don’t Explain the Full
Picture
Facebook has acknowledged several issues affecting Palestinians
and their content, some of which it attributed to “technical
glitches” and human error. However, these explanations do not
explain the range of restrictions and suppression of content
observed.
In other situations of political crisis or public emergencies,
Facebook has announced so-called “break glass” measures. These
include restricting the spread of live video on its platforms and
adjustments to its algorithms that classify and rank content to
reduce the likelihood that users will see content that
potentially violates its policies. Facebook has reportedly
deployed such measures in Ethiopia, Myanmar, Sri Lanka, and the
US. Facebook has not publicly acknowledged any special measures
it has taken in the context of content about Israel and
Palestine, aside from setting up a “special
operations center” to monitor content on its platforms regarding
the May 2021 escalation in Israel and Palestine. Human Rights
Watch requested information about the “special operations
center,” but Facebook did not respond.
This latest spate of content takedowns is part of a wider pattern
of reported censorship of Palestinians and their supporters by
social media companies, which civil
society organizations have documented for years. These restrictions
highlight the need to commission a comprehensive, independent
audit that examines Facebook’s underlying policies and
enforcement of those policies for bias.
Social Media Companies’ Responsibilities
Businesses have a responsibility to respect human
rights by identifying and addressing the human rights
impacts of their operations, and providing meaningful access to a
remedy. For social media companies, this responsibility includes
being transparent and accountable in their moderation of content
to ensure that decisions to take content down are not overly
broad or biased.
The Santa Clara
Principles on Transparency and Accountability in Content
Moderation provide important guidance for how companies should
carry out their responsibilities in upholding freedom of
expression. Based on those principles, companies should clearly
explain to users why their content or their account has been
taken down, including the specific clause of the Community
Standards that the content was found to violate.
Companies should also explain how the content was detected,
evaluated, and removed – for example, by users, automation, or
human content moderators – and provide a meaningful opportunity
for timely appeal of any content removal or account suspension.
Facebook has endorsed the Santa
Clara Principles, but hasn’t fully applied them.
Need for an Independent Investigation
Facebook should ensure that investigators closely consult with
civil society at the outset of the investigation, so that the
investigation reflects the most pressing human rights concerns
from those affected by its policies. It should make the outcome
of the independent investigation public, as it did with
its human rights impact
assessment on Myanmar and civil rights audit in the
US, and present its findings to Facebook’s executive
leadership. Facebook should continuously consult with civil
society about how its recommendations are being carried out.
Human Rights Watch raised several questions in the letter to
Facebook to which the company did not respond. The investigation
should address these questions in connection with the May
hostilities, and more generally, including:
- What changes did Facebook make to its algorithms to demote or
reduce the spread of speech that it determined most likely
violates policies on hate speech, violence and incitement, or
dangerous individuals and organizations?
- What automated detection methods were used, including what
terms and classifiers were being used to flag content for
potential hate speech or violence and incitement allowing them to
be flagged automatically for demotion and/or removal?
- What error rates for enforcement were deemed to be
acceptable?
- What policies were applied to content concerning Israel and
Palestine that are not public?
- Does Facebook have any firewalls in place to prevent undue
influence of its public policy staff, including former Israeli
and other government officials, over content moderation decisions
with regard to Israel and Palestine?
|