While improvements have been made to the system for parliamentary
scrutiny of treaties over the last twelve months, much more needs
to be done to ensure the system for scrutiny is robust and
effective, according to the House of Lords International
Agreements Committee.
In the Committee’s second report on Working
Practices, published today, it asks the Government to sign up to
a Concordat to consolidate commitments made so far in relation to
the parliamentary scrutiny of free trade agreements. The
commitments made to date are welcome, but have been subject to
frequent and iterative change. A Concordat would demonstrate that
these are minimum requirements, that they are fixed and certain,
and that they should be respected by this Government and any
future administrations.
The Committee says that for scrutiny of trade
agreements to be meaningful, it must not be a rubber stamp at the
end of the process to convey simple approval. Instead, the
Committee should be consulted on a draft negotiating mandate, so
that the process can be informed by Parliament, with dialogue
continuing throughout the negotiations.
The Committee regrets that progress on the scrutiny
of non-trade agreements has been more limited. In too many
instances over the last year, the Committee was not made aware
when such agreements were being finalised, and was only notified
when they were formally laid in Parliament. This reduced its
ability to seek expert input and report within the 21-day
scrutiny window set by Constitutional Reform and Governance Act
2010 (CRAG). It is therefore asking for a formal Ministerial
undertaking that, in future, the Committee will receive advance
notice of all treaties.
It has also put forward a series of further
recommendations to help improve the scrutiny system, including on
when amendments to treaties ought to be referred to the
Committee. Ultimately, however, it concludes that, even with the
improvements called for in the report, CRAG 2010 is insufficient
to facilitate real and meaningful scrutiny. It has therefore put
forward three improvements that should be prioritised: (i)
ensuring that Parliament has a formal role earlier in the
process; (ii) that Parliament is provided with treaty text in
advance of signature; (iii) that Parliament’s consent be required
for all significant treaties, including trade agreements, which
the Committee has drawn to the special attention of the
House.
, Chair of the
International Agreements Committee said:
“We welcome the steps the Government has taken
towards greater transparency of new trade agreements, including
commitments to publish objectives ahead of the start of
negotiations and to parliamentary debates. But more needs to be
done to make scrutiny robust.
“As a first step, the Government should consolidate
the commitments it has made on trade agreements in an iterative
fashion over the last nine months in a Concordat to signal their
importance.
“A key issue of concern is that the formal points for
committee engagement are always in response to a fait
accompli: we may have parliamentary debates on negotiating
objectives of trade agreements, but by then the mandate will
already have been set; we can have advance sight of the text, but
only after it has been signed and agreed.
“Parliamentary scrutiny should not be a rubber stamp
at the end of the process that conveys simple approval. For the
system to function effectively, there must be meaningful
consultation between the Government and Parliament. In
particular, for agreements that have significant implications for
the UK's domestic policy and regulatory framework, such as trade
agreements, it is important that this consultation and dialogue
takes place before a mandate is established, so the final mandate
can be informed by Parliament, and continues throughout the
negotiation process. This engagement with Parliament is a key
part of engaging also with civil society and taking into account
citizens’ rights and interests.
“The International Agreements Committee will continue
to work hard to emphasise the importance and benefits of
parliamentary scrutiny to Government.”
The full report is available to read on the
committee’s website.