Asked by
To ask Her Majesty’s Government when they next intend to review
the adequacy of the contributions made by the Crown dependencies
towards the cost of their access to the United Kingdom’s (1)
public services, (2) provision of security, and (3) international
representation.
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Ministry of Justice
() (Con)
My Lords, the Crown dependencies are responsible for their own
domestic affairs, although islanders sometimes make use of UK
public services such as health or education, for which payment is
made according to bespoke arrangements. The UK is responsible for
the Crown dependencies’ defence and international relations, in
recognition of which they each make a voluntary contribution. The
Government are content with the present arrangements.
(LD)
My Lords, it is general government policy to recover costs
through charges for services provided, particularly for those who
do not pay taxes in the UK. It seems odd that the wealthy Crown
dependencies are exempt from this, particularly given that Brexit
imposes extra costs, as we have seen in fisheries protection and
certainly representation overseas.
I was interested to hear that educational charges are going to be
extended. Is the Minister aware that the one announcement made by
the Department for Education since January has been the extension
of home student fees to all students from the Crown dependencies?
I am amazed that, in his letter to me of 10 May, he repeated the
absurd suggestion that Guernsey’s contribution to the defence of
the UK is
“the cost of maintenance of the breakwater in Alderney.”
Has the Ministry of Defence not told the Ministry of Justice that
the Alderney breakwater, which was built in the 1860s to provide
an anchorage for the British fleet in the event of a French
threat, ceased to be of interest to our defence before the Second
World War?
(Con)
My Lords, I hope I would never make an absurd point, either to
the noble Lord or anybody else. I am certainly aware that there
is no current or perceived future requirement to use the Alderney
breakwater for operational military purposes, but it still needs
to be maintained to preserve the facilities in Alderney’s only
serviceable harbour. The Government previously retained
responsibility for maintaining the breakwater because it was
built by the UK for naval purposes and the Bailiwick of Guernsey
could not be expected to subsidise the cost at the time.
When we requested that the Crown dependencies start making
contributions towards the cost of defence in 1987, Guernsey
assumed responsibility for maintaining the breakwater alongside
remitting passport fees for British passports issued in the
bailiwick. Irrespective of whether the breakwater serves any
defensive purpose, by meeting the maintenance cost that would
otherwise fall on the Government, Guernsey contributes to the
cost of its defence and international relations.
(Lab)
My Lords, the UK is formally responsible for representing the
Crown dependencies in the United Nations Framework Convention on
Climate Change, including during the COP negotiations. Given that
small islands are particularly vulnerable to the impacts of
climate change, can the Minister confirm how Her Majesty’s
Government are engaging with the Crown dependencies in the lead
up to the COP 26 summit?
(Con)
The noble Lord raises an important point. My role in the Ministry
of Justice is essentially to be the point Minister for the Crown
dependencies regarding the Government. Just as I make sure that
the Crown dependencies’ relations with, for example, the
Department for International Trade, are secure when we talk about
international treaties, I also make sure that discussions on
environmental and climate issues are close between the Crown
dependencies and the relevant government departments.
(Con)
My Lords, I recognise that this is a matter for the Crown rather
than Parliament, but can my noble friend tell this House what the
actual costs of defence and international representation for the
Crown dependencies have been over the last few years?
(Con)
My Lords, the UK has a constitutional responsibility to represent
the Crown dependencies internationally. We discharge that
responsibility irrespective of cost. As I said, however, the
Crown dependencies have been making voluntary contributions since
1987. As these are general contributions in recognition of our
overall responsibilities and it is in our interest to represent
the whole British family internationally, they are not intended
to reflect the exact costs of defending the Crown dependencies or
representing them internationally. We are satisfied with the
current arrangements.
(Lab)
My Lords, during the debate on sanctions regulations in February
I asked how we would ensure that sanctions apply in full to the
Crown dependencies and overseas territories. The Minister’s
response was that the Government were
“lending technical support to the overseas
territories”.—[Official Report, 8/2/21; col GC 22.]
What has the outcome of that “technical support” been? Is the
Minister in a position to confirm the full application of
sanctions within the Crown dependencies?
(Con)
My Lords, as sanctions are a tool of foreign policy, it is
government policy for UK sanctions measures to be given effect in
the Crown dependencies to make those sanctions as effective as
possible. The Crown dependencies apply UK sanctions, including,
for example, the Global Human Rights Sanctions Regulations 2020
and the Global Anti-Corruption Sanctions Regulations 2021. The
FCDO and Her Majesty’s Treasury ensure robust implementation of
sanctions. There is considerable sanctions-related engagement
with the Crown dependencies, including meetings and webinars, to
make sure that all the sanctions legislation is properly applied
throughout the Crown dependencies.
(Lab)
My Lords, a voluntary contribution is unusual and presumably
could be withdrawn unilaterally; it depends wholly on good will.
Does the Minister agree that transparency is important to allay
any UK taxpayer concerns that these overseas tax havens are being
treated unfairly? How regularly is there an audit of that
financial relationship? Presumably, that also contains any
contingent liabilities.
(Con)
My Lords, I take issue with the reference to tax havens. That is
a tendentious term and we can perhaps debate it on another
occasion. The Crown dependencies have a long-standing
relationship with the UK via the Crown; it is not a quid pro quo
relationship—using “quid” in both the Latin and the colloquial
sense. It is a relationship based on constitutional convention
and respect for domestic autonomy. We reiterated in the recent
integrated review of security, defence, development and foreign
policy that we will continue to defend and represent
internationally the three Crown dependencies.
(Lab Co-op)
My Lords, is it not clear from the answers we have just heard,
that the Crown dependencies are getting an increasingly good
deal, but it is a bit of a one-way street? Is it not time to
discuss with them their constitutional relationship with the
United Kingdom?
(Con)
My Lords, the Crown dependencies have a long-standing
relationship with the UK via the Crown, and the Government
currently have no intention of reviewing their constitutional
position. They are self-governing jurisdictions with
democratically elected Governments. They are responsible for
fiscal matters and set their own policies to support their
economies, but they do so within international standards. It is
in that context that they determine their own tax rates. They
co-operate with us on taxation, fighting financial crime and
countering terrorist finance, and they are committed to meeting
international standards on tax transparency, illicit finance and
anti-money laundering.