The European Commission has opened an in-depth investigation to
assess whether €95 million of public support granted by Poland to
chemical company LG Chem Group (“LG Chem”) for investing in the
expansion of its battery cell production facility for electric
vehicles (EV) in Biskupice Podgórne in the Dolnoślaskie region
(Poland) is in line with EU rules on regional State aid.
Commissioner Margrethe Vestager, in charge of
competition policy, said: "EU State aid rules enable Member
States to foster economic growth in disadvantaged regions in
Europe. At the same time, we need to ensure that the aid is
really needed to attract private investments to the region
concerned, and avoid that the recipient of the aid gains an
unfair advantage over its competitors at the expense of
taxpayers. We will carefully investigate whether Poland's support
was necessary to trigger LG Chem's decision to expand its
existing cell production facility in Poland, is kept to the
minimum necessary and does not distort competition or harm
cohesion in the EU.”
In 2017, LG Chem decided to invest more than €1 billion in the
expansion of its production capacity of lithium-ion cells and
battery modules and packs for electric vehicles in its existing
plant in the Dolnoślaskie region of Poland. In 2019, Poland
notified the Commission of its plans to grant €95 million of
public support for the expansion.
EU State aid rules, in particular the Commission's 2014 Regional State Aid
Guidelines, enable Member States to support economic
development and employment in the EU's disadvantaged regions and
to foster regional cohesion in the Single Market. The measures
need to fulfil certain conditions to make sure that they have the
intended positive effect. This includes that the support must
incentivise private investment, be kept to the minimum necessary,
must not lure away investment from a region in another Member
State which is at least as disadvantaged ("anti-cohesion effect")
and must not be directly causing the relocation of activities
(such as jobs) to the Member State granting the support from
elsewhere in the EU.
At this stage, the Commission has doubts that the planned public
support of €95 million to LG Chem for the expansion of the
Biskupice Podgórne plant complies with all relevant criteria of
the Regional Aid Guidelines. In particular:
- the Commission has doubts about whether the measure has an
“incentive effect”, i.e. whether the decision by LG Chem to
expand its battery production capacity in Poland was directly
triggered by the Polish public support or whether the investment
would have been carried out in Biskupice Podgórne, even absent
the public support;
- the Commission has doubts about the public support's
contribution to regional development and its appropriateness and
proportionality;
- the Commission cannot exclude at this stage that the public
support exceeds the maximum permissible aid intensity for the
project.
The Commission will now investigate further to determine whether
the initial concerns are confirmed. The opening of an in-depth
investigation provides Poland and interested third parties with
an opportunity to comment on the measure. It does not prejudge in
any way the outcome of the investigation.
Background
In 2019, the Commission approved a €36 million investment aid
granted by Poland to support LG Chem's €325 million investment
for the creation of the Biskupice Podgórne in the Dolnoślaskie
region of Poland. The Commission assessed and approved the
measure under the 2014 Regional Aid
Guidelines.
Evidence shows that large companies take decisions to invest in a
given region not only due to State aid, but based on numerous
factors, including the cost and availability of labour and land,
tax legislation, their existing operations in the given region,
proximity to clients, and the business environment. Granting aid
in a context where a large company would have invested in any
event would merely reduce the company's ordinary operating costs,
which its competitors have to meet without aid. This leads to
competition distortions at the expense of taxpayers.
The Commission's 2014 Regional Aid
Guidelines allow Member States to support regional investment
to support economic development and employment in the EU's less
developed regions and to foster cohesion in the Single Market, if
the measure respect a number of conditions:
- The aid must have a real "incentive effect", in other words,
it must effectively encourage the beneficiary to invest in a
specific region;
- The aid must be kept to the minimum necessary to attract the
investment to the disadvantaged region;
- The aid must not have undue negative effects, such as the
creation of excess capacity in a declining market;
- The aid must not exceed the regional aid ceiling applicable
to the region in question;
- The aid must not directly cause the relocation of existing or
closed down activities from elsewhere in the EU to the aided
establishment; and
- The aid must not divert investment away from another region
in the EU, which is at least as economically disadvantaged as the
region where the aided investment takes place.
The non-confidential version of the decision will be made
available under the case number SA.53903 in the State Aid Register on the
competition website once any
confidentiality issues have been resolved. New publications of
state aid decisions on the internet and in the Official Journal
are listed in the State Aid Weekly
e-News.