The National Education Union has long been concerned that
unnecessary practices surrounding marking, planning, and data
collection in schools, is having a significant impact on teacher
workload. Our latest survey of 11,341 primary and secondary
teachers working in 6,908 schools, shows that we are right to be
concerned.
Unnecessary accountability tasks and measures previously enforced
by Government and Ofsted were one of the biggest contributing
factors to teachers’ excessive workload and a major reason for
many teachers leaving the profession. While Government has
recognised this, with its recommendations of 2016 on reducing
teacher workload, the message to schools has not been clear or
strong enough, with many practices continuing.
- Just a quarter
of primary teachers (25%) and less than one fifth of secondary
teachers (18%) have seen a review in policy and practice in their
school on planning since the publication of the 2016
recommendations. There has been a greater impact in terms of
changes to marking, but still less than half (45% in primary, 44%
in secondary).
- 78% of
secondary teachers and 69% of primary teachers still think that
the volume of marking they undertake is unmanageable.
- 60% of
primary teachers and 54% of secondary teachers say the volume and
type of planning required is unmanageable.
Triple marking – a practice in which teachers mark students’
work, students respond to feedback and then teachers mark it
again, creating a never-ending cycle of meaningless exchanges –
is still being undertaken in 63% of primary schools and 59% of
secondary schools.
Photographing pupils’ practical work, more usually seen in
primary schools, is still being done by 82% of primary teachers.
This is highly impractical when teaching 30 pupils or more. Not
only is it immensely time consuming but also takes time away from
actual teaching. Having to record conversations with pupils and
what the conversations were about – known as ‘oral evidence’ –
continues to occupy the time of 61% of primary teachers.
63% of secondary teachers and 66% of primary teachers believe
data collection is unmanageable with the vast majority (74% in
primary and 82% in secondary) saying that the collection of data
is not streamlined to eliminate duplication.
Kevin Courtney, Joint General Secretary of the National
Education Union, said:
“This September marks the third school year since the final
recommendations of the working groups were first distributed. We
have seen three education secretaries in that time, all of whom
have spoken out against excessive workload. But it is clear from
our survey that their actions are not enough, and that the
Government must step up and make far greater efforts to tackle
workload by giving head teachers the confidence to drop the
accountability work that is now deemed clearly and irrefutably
unnecessary and of no educational value. It is distorting the
curriculum.
“Successive governments created an accountability machine –
through Ofsted, performance targets and league tables – which is
now out of the DfE’s control and extremely hard to stop. So long
as the main drivers of a performance-based system are still in
place, schools will continue to hyper-regulate themselves, out of
a fear of the consequences of failure. In the short-term,
Government and Ofsted have to be more forceful in their
messaging; but there is also an urgent need to remove the drivers
themselves from the system. The clearest signal which Government
could send to schools that they are committed to a new approach,
would be to announce that Ofsted will be replaced by an
organisation dedicated to the support of school improvement.”